top of page

R. A. Lafferty and Antisemitism

9781501350542.jpg
box 4.png

​​​​​​

​​

​​

​​

​​

​​

"In his novella ‘The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny’ (1977), R. A. Lafferty uses speculative fiction to remove not only the Holocaust but all of the major traumas of the twentieth century including both world wars and the Great Depression. However, in typically elusive fashion, Lafferty finds a way to avoid these traumas yet still experience them."
Glyn Morgan, Imagining the Unimaginable (2020)¹

​​

​"To the second of the beasts they offered the flesh of Gypsies and Jews." 

The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny²

​

​"People are easily fooled. But there are tests for reality. If a thing is burned up, then there will be a residue of ashes and gasses. But if there is not such a residue, and the things appears to be unchanged, then it is not acting as if it were burned up.”

The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny³

​​

"But if indeed six million Jews were killed (between a third and a half of the Jews in the World, and more Jews than were in the maximum area ever controlled by the Germans) then they should have left a big hole in the total Jewish World Population, but they didn't." 

Lafferty to Dan Knight, January 24, 1990⁴

​​

"SWEENY is carefully wrought, and even has diagrams and chronologies. What other work carries a total history of the century with it?"

Lafferty to Sheryl Smith, December 21, 1977⁵

​​​​​Updated November 18, 2026

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

R. A. Lafferty (1914–2002) was a devout Catholic and a writer of genius. Beloved by readers and esteemed by major figures in science fiction, he brought moral vision and imaginative intensity to many subjects. His novel Okla Hannali (1972) recounts the history of the Choctaw people through the life of a fictional patriarch, combining humor, tragedy, and moral witness. It is a neglected but significant work of American literature. Lafferty’s reputation as a writer’s writer is well earned. I need not list the many distinguished writers who loved his work.

​​

Those of us who admire Lafferty’s accomplishments and want to understand them must also confront his antisemitism and Holocaust denial. These beliefs run through his work. The relative obscurity of his archives gives scholars who consult them a particular responsibility to make the relevant evidence known.

​​

Archival evidence shows that Lafferty rejected the reality of the Jewish Holocaust. His letters show his adoption of the claims of Holocaust denial literature and an antisemitic interpretation of Western history extending from antiquity through the Dreyfus Affair to the modern era. In the early 1980s, he discovered The Journal of Historical Review. Initially surprised by its existence, he later endorsed its ideas and cause.⁶

​​

What follows examines failures in fandom and scholarship to address these matters. My purpose is not to elicit declarations of admiration or condemnation for Lafferty. I am writing for the handful of readers who want to understand Lafferty as a whole, including where these views fit in his work. A little time on this blog should make clear that I am not here to tarnish Lafferty. I’ve spent time trying to get him right, and I’m not out to ruin the enjoyment. 

​​​The archival record

I began reading Lafferty closely in October 2024. Several months into writing this blog, I grew aware of the antisemitic inflections in what he said in correspondence and wrote in his fiction. That awareness raised difficult questions: Is knowledge a private possession or a public trust? I chose to withhold public comment until I had examined all the relevant materials in the McFarlin Library’s Special Collections at the University of Tulsa, knowing the subject required deliberate and careful handling, here in the case of a writer I deeply admire (in carefully qualified ways), one whose work gives me immense pleasure. The first stage of that research took place in July 2025.

​​​​

The Tulsa archive makes clear that Lafferty’s antisemitic views became more articulated and deepened over time. He came to believe the arguments he discovered in the Holocaust denial literature he read. But he said he rejected the historical reality of the Holocaust from the start. This is a crucial point. To this degree, one cannot say he merely became embittered. This aspect of his thought intensified alongside his disillusionment with youth culture, Catholic dissent from Humanae Vitae (July 25, 1968),⁷ and his frustration with theological and pastoral Modernism, both in his home parish of Christ the King in Tulsa and in the wider post-Conciliar Catholic Church. These developments coincided with his declining presence in mainstream publishing.

​​

These were also years of physical decline. Yet through the 1970s his mind stayed quick and incisive, and into the early 1980s he produced, in private, some of his best work, much of it still unseen by his core readership. His opinions surface mainly in letters, though a reader who looks closely at the fiction will find traces there too. They were not always the familiar kind of antisemitism. He admired Jewish intellectual achievement, and he argued that the Holocaust was irrational because Europe would not deliberately destroy so much of its own intellectual capital.

​​​

Because little correspondence from before the 1960s survives, scholars will inevitably differ in their conclusions about the contours of antisemitism in Lafferty’s early thought. The record presents two figures: the famously reticent, eccentric storyteller and the lifelong contrarian who took a stand on a question of immense historical and moral weight.​​​

​​

In published commentary on Lafferty, I have not found any discussion of this aspect of his thought among editors, critics, science fiction writers, or other influential voices, whether in big media or smaller press venues. Commentators may focus on other aspects of Lafferty’s work, be unfamiliar with the archival record, or avoid the subject for reasons not stated in their work. Whatever the cause, the result is an incomplete public portrayal that leaves this dimension of Lafferty’s intellectual life largely unexplored at a time when a December 2023 poll had raised concerns about Holocaust denial among younger Americans.⁸ 

​​​

Recognizing the flaws of major talents is essential to understanding their creative and intellectual lives, to preserving the historical record, and to confronting the complexity of the human person honestly. Such recognition also shapes how one reads their art. As John Clute has observed, Lafferty “clearly delighted in a vision of the world as being irradiated by conspiracies both godly and devilish.”⁹ 

​Lafferty scholarship

An example in Lafferty’s work is The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny, his deepest fictional exploration of twentieth-century history and a novel concerned with that era’s violence and terror. Its central theme is consensus reality. It tells the story of a man who can alter history through his artistic gifts. Without awareness of Lafferty’s own Holocaust denial, a reader is far less likely to notice—and far less able to grasp—the implications of the novel’s Jewish imagery.​ The alternative, recognizing the equivocal imagery in the work but not knowing about Lafferty’s Holocaust skepticism and Holocaust denial, can be just as intellectually damaging.

​​

Imagine you are an early-career scholar who notices the relative absence of the Holocaust in The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny. You are committed to understanding how the Holocaust is represented in literature and seek to explore the significance of its place in the work of a master of speculative fiction. You aim to situate this literary treatment within the American literary imagination and to contribute meaningfully to both your discipline and the broader intellectual community. You are, above all, struck and perplexed by what you find.

​​​​

In September 2016, Glyn Morgan submitted a PhD dissertation at the University of Liverpool. It was titled “Mapping Planet Auschwitz: Non-Mimetic Writing and the Holocaust in Anglo-American Fiction.” In section 2.2 of chapter 2, “Misremembered Traumas by the Forgotten American Fantasist: R. A. Lafferty’s 'The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny,'” Morgan quotes Andrew Ferguson, researcher and biographer of Lafferty, who has published on the author’s work. (Ferguson himself studied at the University of Liverpool in the years after completing his MA at the University of Tulsa, where he had conducted research in the McFarlin Library’s Special Collections on Lafferty’s correspondence.)¹⁰

​​​

A passage from Morgan’s dissertation:¹¹

​​​

“The problem is amplified with regards to Apocalypses in particular as the book itself occupies a mysterious portion of Lafferty’s life, as Andrew Ferguson, Lafferty’s biographer, tells me: 

​

          '"Even in Lafferty’s correspondence there’s a gap: no record of him talking directly to the press

            at all, which meant his agent Virginia Kidd would have handled all of those discussions. But    

            Lafferty wrote the book between January 22 and February 8, 1976 [. . . ], and then the

           Apocalypses volume was published in 1977, and there’s a gap in Lafferty’s correspondence with

            Kidd that covers the years 1976 and ’77.”

​​

​​​​​At the University of Tulsa archive, within the Dan Knight correspondence, one will find a Lafferty letter dated January 24, 1990, in which Lafferty writes that he "never did accept the idea" of the Jewish Holocaust:¹²

​​​

“I myself never did accept the idea of the Holocaust in the context of The Six Million. As a prophecy it’s been in the Talmudic literature for a couple of thousand years, but it has always been a sort of allegory until the time of WWII. But if indeed six million Jews were killed (between a third and a half of the Jews in the World, and more Jews than were in the maximum area ever controlled by the Germans) then they should have left a big hole in the total Jewish World Population, but they didn’t. By the end of the War (within five years of the end), North America had received more than a million Jews from Europe, so had South America, so had Israel, and the total World Jewish population was up considerably from where it had stood at the beginning [. . .] And when Germany was losing the war for shortage of man-power in the factories, there was no sense in them killing six million of the most intelligent workers in Europe. There were work camps, yes, and likely a lot of cruelty in spots in them, but there weren't extermination camps." 

​​​

​​​I have read Ferguson’s publicly available work on Lafferty, including his blog Continued on Next Rock, his MA thesis, his scholarly apparatus for Past Master, his academic article on Lafferty and mimesis, his Gaiman essay, his unrelated dissertation, and his piece on “Unpublished Lafferty” that presents a comprehensive list of the unpublished fiction at Tulsa.¹³

​​

In a YouTube conversation with Daniel Otto Jack Petersen, who wrote a dissertation on Lafferty and Cormac McCarthy that draws on Andrew Ferguson’s ideas, Ferguson discusses his research on Lafferty’s biography, including how he first came to the subject and his desire to read everything the author ever wrote. [Petersen has now addressed the Holocaust issue on his YouTube channel.] Ferguson says he had most of what he needed for a biography.¹⁴ 

​​

Over the years, Ferguson says that he has continued to add little bits here and there to the biography manuscript, and he reflects on the many places his Lafferty research has taken him. Over a decade ago, he wrote a comment on a blog about Lafferty’s letters, saying, “One of my medium-term projects will be to get a volume of selected correspondence, at least between him and his agent Virginia Kidd.”¹⁵ And there is a YouTube clip titled "A Conversation with Andrew Ferguson at Laffcon1."¹⁶ 

 

Separately, the University of Tulsa archive holds an extensive collection of Lafferty’s correspondence with Dan Knight and many others. I read through much of this material over the course of a week because most of the boxes are not overstuffed, having become aware of Lafferty’s antisemitism and wanting to understand its depth and nature. Among these letters is the one dated January 24 in which Lafferty explicitly denied the Holocaust.¹⁷

​​​

​In their PhD dissertations, both Petersen and Morgan cite Ferguson as Lafferty’s biographer. Morgan, in particular, draws on Ferguson’s authority regarding Lafferty’s archives and publishing history.¹⁸ 

​​​

One reason to think there might be something like the Holocaust denial letter in the archives is a big clue: another box at McFarlin. It contains Lafferty’s copies of IHR Holocaust-denial journals, as well as Lafferty’s handwritten timeline of Holocaust-denial books (box 4, folder 12). Propaganda pieces are there, with titles such as “The ‘Problem of Gas Chambers’” and “A Prominent False Witness: Elie Wiesel.” Ironically, the same box contains the Neil Gaiman letters. They are in box 4, folder 1.¹⁹ 

​

Many people who visit Tulsa to study Lafferty will want to read the Gaiman letters, because, as Morgan points out in his dissertation, Gaiman has been Lafferty’s advocate for many years. Gaiman wrote a Lafferty pastiche that Ferguson published. Gaiman is probably Lafferty’s best-known fan. Gaiman’s name is on Lafferty books, and it has even drawn attention to the Centipede Press edition of Lafferty’s short stories. Ironically, copies of the letters from the young Jewish aspiring writer and publications from the Institute for Historical Review have been box companions. Gaiman, whose cousin Helen was a Holocaust survivor, once visited Tulsa and was shown around.²⁰ Ferguson writes about this on his blog, but it is not documented whether Gaiman saw box 4 during his visit. I have written to Neil Gaiman about this topic in the hope that he can help get the Holocaust denial materials relabeled at McFarlin’s Special Collections, and I have asked Ferguson to join me. ​​​​​

​​

Morgan cites Ferguson on a gap in Lafferty’s correspondence with Virginia Kidd in 1976 and 1977. Lafferty’s denial in his January 24, 1990, letter to Dan Knight bears directly on Morgan’s argument that the novella finds a way to represent the Holocaust even as it removes it from history.

​​​​​

A clear record of this material is needed. The letter is particularly relevant to Morgan’s study, given that Lafferty modeled the character Enniscorthy partly on himself; that Enniscorthy is the subject of a fictional biography; that The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny depicts Jewish and Roma victims of the second Armageddon without explicitly identifying their destruction as the systematic genocide of European Jewry; and that archival evidence shows Lafferty denying that genocide.

​

Taken together, these facts provide a relevant context for scholarship on Lafferty, particularly in Holocaust-related areas and for understanding how Lafferty reasons about history and human suffering. I have tried to point out elsewhere on this blog some of the ways his fiction codes antisemitic tropes.

​Reading the fiction

At present, a university search for “Lafferty” and “Holocaust” brings up “Mapping Planet Auschwitz: Non-Mimetic Writing and the Holocaust in Anglo-American Fiction,” where one will find Morgan’s conclusion that “Lafferty relativises the Holocaust as one of a series of holocaustic events, a chain of human madness which can be linked from the First World War, to the Second, and to the Third which results in fiery nuclear Armageddon: a literal holocaust”²¹

​

and

​

"Lafferty imagines an Adolf Hitler who pursues art over politics, as referenced by his ‘Brown Danube’ oil painting above. However, unlike Spinrad, Lafferty deemphasises Hitler’s significance in the twentieth-century. He avoids the Second World War and the Holocaust not by making Hitler a better artist, or an emigrant, but by defusing the circumstances that led to his politicisation, rise to power, and the climate in Germany which allowed him to assume the supreme role within the nation. He does this by affecting a greater series of changes stretching back to before the First World War, linking the major conflicts of the twentieth-century into a single timeline of warfare and struggle. In doing so, Lafferty aligns ‘The Three Armageddons’ far more powerfully with a structuralist view of history than Spinrad’s novel is able to, thus reassigning blame for the Holocaust from a single man (Hitler) and onto a wider failing of society which encompasses not just Germany but all of Europe, and indeed the world [emphasis added]".²²

​​

This reading may be moving and persuasive, but it needs to be considered alongside the archival evidence. For Lafferty, there were no six million deaths to relativize: “if indeed six million Jews were killed (between a third and a half of the Jews in the World, and more Jews than were in the maximum area ever controlled by the Germans), then they should have left a big hole in the total Jewish World Population; but they didn't.” In the Second Armageddon, Lafferty singles out Jews and Roma as sacrificial victims. Lafferty could recognize that the Nazis made scapegoats of Jews and Roma and still deny the Holocaust. In his 1990 letter to Dan Knight, he acknowledged that the Nazis ran labor camps and said he believed prisoners had probably suffered cruelty there. Yet he denied both the existence of extermination camps and the systematic murder of six million European Jews.²³

​​​​

Without access to, or awareness of, the archival evidence, an academic may quite reasonably produce interpretations that, in hindsight, take on an unintended and jarring quality. For example, Morgan’s observation that “R. A. Lafferty finds a way to avoid all of the major global traumas of the twentieth-century, yet still experience them” reads very differently once Lafferty’s Holocaust denial is known—so differently that it can seem unintentionally grotesque.²⁴

​​

The same applies to the subsection on Lafferty in his dissertation, “Misremembered Traumas by the Forgotten American Fantasist.”²⁵ This is not a criticism of Morgan’s diligence or intentions, but an illustration of how new information can shift the meaning of earlier interpretations. The reason should be apparent: Archival evidence can require us to reconsider what earlier interpretations imply about the author. Few would knowingly set out to write a dissertation on Holocaust trauma in literature, only to later learn that their subject had expressed Holocaust denial.

​​

If you hold a PhD in the humanities, you probably look back on your graduate work with mixed feelings. That is part of the normal growth process. But this situation is different. All academics share one constant: reliance on others’ scholarship. None of us can visit every archive, read every letter, or unearth every document ourselves.

​​

Researchers should be able to recognize the antisemitism in Lafferty’s letters without needing to know the archive thoroughly, and to have the tools to approach it knowledgeably. This includes the Holocaust denial propaganda materials in box 4 of the Lafferty collection, his handwritten timeline of denialist literature, and the ways he refers to Jews when the subject arises. In his letter of January 24, 1990, Lafferty rejects the reality of the Holocaust, explains why he never accepted it, and outlines his decades-long engagement with denialist thought. The letter appears to have been prompted by a story he read titled “The Bigot,” and he seems to have intended it as a statement that he was not one. I have therefore asked the University of Tulsa to label these materials clearly, so that Lafferty’s Holocaust denial is unmistakable and easily verifiable.

​​​

Ferguson’s own commentary shows why such labeling matters. In discussing the character Dotty on his blog, he treats her repeated use of “the Old Jew” and “a debt-caller” as expressions of personal anguish rooted in a specific historical Catholic setting, and he distinguishes them from the author’s views. He writes, "I would balance this carefully against the other treatments of Jewish individuals in his works, and remind again that these are not the words of the author, but of the character he created . . . ."²⁶ Ferguson also recalls Father Coughlin’s antisemitic preaching and questions Dotty’s distinction between good and bad Jews. Read on its own, this interpretation is plausible. However, without archival context (particularly the denialist material), it can insulate Lafferty from his text’s implications. The same correspondent who received the January 24, 1990, letter published Dotty. In this respect, the interpretation risks obscuring rather than illuminating the author’s ideology. Awareness of the denialist material is therefore not a peripheral supplement, but a necessary condition for analysis of this and other conspiratorial themes in Lafferty’s fiction.

​​​

This is an instance where new evidence reframes earlier work. I reached out to share the information with Morgan, and I contacted the Encyclopedia of Science Fiction about the entry cited in Morgan’s dissertation. The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction was co-edited in its second edition by John Clute and Peter Nicholls. Clute’s Encyclopedia of Fantasy, co-edited with John Grant, includes an entry on Lafferty co-signed by John Clute and Neil Gaiman.²⁷ In The Best of R. A. Lafferty (2019), Gaiman wrote, "I did not know that I would one day write with John Clute the entry on Lafferty for the second edition of The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction."²⁸ Clute has told me that this is an error on Gaiman’s part, but neither encyclopedia mentions Lafferty and Holocaust denial, though the Encyclopedia of Science Fiction forcefully emphasizes Lafferty’s preoccupation with conspiracy. Clute characterizes the SFE entries as adopting a textualist approach and suggests that Lafferty’s Holocaust denial belongs in the site’s bibliography under the About the Author section. This seems appropriate to me. Yet Clute’s statement that Lafferty delighted in seeing the world as irradiated with conspiracy is itself a biographical inference, a critical and biographical judgment grounded in textual analysis. It speaks to how Lafferty viewed the world: He took pleasure in the idea of pervasive conspiracy. That inference is, of course, accurate. It appears in Lafferty’s belief that Jews with dual loyalties to nation-states were responsible for real-world conspiracies, including what he regarded as Jewish Holocaust propaganda. Although this requires me to revise parts of the blog, that is a minor task compared with the permanence of having a dissertation on record.​

​​

For example, in a letter to his correspondent Al Doty, Lafferty wrote, "there is a pretty good bunch of Blacks who are competent or better as writers and do not need any reverse discrimination to help them out. Steven Barnes is probably the best of them, or I may think so because I know him the best, but there's a dozen or so who are adequate, and people don't especially think of them as Black." One of the inadequate Blacks for Lafferty was Octavia E. Butler, now in the Library of America, which also issued the edition of Lafferty’s Past Master with an introduction by Andrew Ferguson. Lafferty wrote, "But Blacks in Science Fiction and Fantasy are favored with a sort of reverse discrimination. Octavia Butler has received accolades far beyond what is deserved by her unimpressive work."²⁹ ​​ ​

​​​

Lafferty’s work deserves close study. He was an unrepeatable literary genius, brilliantly original in genre fiction and formidable as a Catholic thinker. Yet this was also a Catholic mind that denied the Jewish Holocaust in the years after Nostra Aetate (October 28, 1965), when the Catholic Church formally repudiated the charge of collective Jewish guilt, but before We Remember: A Reflection on the Shoah (March 16, 1998). In the latter, the Catholic Church acknowledged the failures of its members during the Holocaust, and it called for repentance.³⁰ By this time, as I understand it, Lafferty was incapacitated in a nursing home in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. Had he been able to read We Remember, his reply would almost certainly have been revealing and decisive for his legacy on the Holocaust issue.

​​Two approaches

For those now approaching Lafferty academically, I anticipate two main families of readings:

​

Approach 1) Secular Quarantine: A strategically secular reading says Lafferty’s views soured over time: Late positions diverge sharply from the earlier self. It posits a break between the Catholic-intellectual strain of “traditional” antisemitism and the virulence of Holocaust revisionism, emphasizing (a) no antisemitic content in early correspondence; (b) the year he repeatedly gave as when he stopped writing; (c) the fact that his most troubling statements appear only after that date. By downplaying continuity, this approach lets the “never did accept” in Lafferty’s Holocaust-denying letter to Dan Knight be absorbed gradually. Nasty Lafferty is Late Lafferty. Quarantine the problem for Lafferty Studies.³¹

​

Approach 2) Theological/Continuity Integration: A confessional reading rejects the rupture thesis and asserts continuity: The late statements extend long-standing commitments rather than contradict them. It situates Lafferty’s remarks within Catholic traditionalism (supersessionist motifs if not full supersessionism, anti-modern polemic, typological portrayals of Jews), reads irony and satire as technique rather than disavowal, and treats scattered early cues as seeds that later surface. On this view, Lafferty’s absolute Holocaust denial, preceding his embrace of IHR-style revisionism, expresses a historical skepticism consistent with his later IHR phase. The upshot is to absorb the offense into the unity of the oeuvre and the religion. Lafferty is Always Lafferty: Holocaust denial persists; only the intensity shifts. This sees the REALLY BIG critical problem as Holocaust denial itself, because that is what shapes something like the imagery in his literary work—not the revisionist IHR talk Lafferty learned to articulate by the 1990s, which is a biographical issue relevant primarily to understanding how he came to express his ideas about Jews in personal letters. Reject quarantine and integrate the problem for Lafferty Studies.

​​​​​​​​​​ 

​​Related essays

I. The Myth of the Six Million​

II. The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny

III. Reading Lafferty Through Rosenfeld and Marcus

Lafferty’s Holocaust Denial

"The Skinny People of Leptophlebo Street"

"Phoenic"

Kabbala and "In the Turpentine Trees" (1982/1983)

Conspiracy and "About a Secret Crocodile" (1970)

"Groaning Hinges of the World" (1968-1971)

The Sex Life of Melchisedech Duffey

Julius Brass

Counterargument​

Correspondence​​​​

​​​​​​​

​​

​​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​​

*Photograph of original; carbon archived at McFarlin.³²

​

Hello Dan and Clan:

​

     Dean Swift (of Gulliver’s Travels) once wrote a sharp essay called ON THE PERVERSITY OF INANIMATE OBJECTS, but he was wrong in thinking that any thing at all is inanimate. Certainly the international mails are animated by black-humored unclean spirits. I had just sent yesterday a letter describing the contents of the un-lost package, and this morning I received your January 15 letter.

     THE EPISODES OF THE ARGO with various other things sounds like an attractive package. There is one thing I would like on this one though, a cover that announces itself. A cover is like a road sign, and I never liked a road sign with lettering so small that it can’t be taken in by a swift glance. Bigger letters, louder letters, words that echo like burnished bugles.

     As to your three enclosed stories: SNATCHED is a very good short-short with a snatchy ending. Someone who has just about enough space for a short-short may take it. It’s worth trying around.

FRUITS OF WISDOM is the same sort of story, a turn-about identity thing, and there’s no reason it shouldn’t sell somewhere. I’m a meat-eater too. I’ve seen what looks like hot dogs made out of soy beans for the vegetarians; but why would they like something that looks like mean if they detest meat?

     THE BIGOT. There are difficulties here. This is a horror-irony piece, and the irony must be clear and sudden at the same time. There is a fuzziness about the identities that indicates that you haven’t quite made up your mind about something here. Set it aside, but keep it actively in the back of your mind. There’s a trick in it somewhere that should surface eventually, and it may make quite a striking story when it does.

     By the way, Canada wasn’t the first with the ‘anti-hate’ laws. They have them in France and in West Germany and I believe in other places. Publishing the opinion that the Holocaust didn’t happen can land one in prison; and there are persons in prison for this offense right now. I myself never did accept the idea of the Holocaust in the context of the Six Million. As a prophecy it’s been in the Talmudic literature for a couple of thousand years, but it has always been a sort of allegory until the time of WW-II. But if indeed six million Jews were killed (between a third and a half of the Jews in the World, and more Jews than were in the maximum area ever controlled by the Germans) then they should have left a big hole in the total Jewish World Population; but they didn’t. By the end of the War (within five years of the end) North America had received more than a million Jews from Europe, so had South America, so had Israel, and the total World Jewish population was up considerably from where it had stood at the beginning of the world. And when Germany was losing the War for shortage of man-power in the factories, there was no sense in them killing six million of the most intelligent workers in Europe. There were work camps, yes, and likely a lot of cruelty in spots in them, but there weren’t extermination camps. But I believe that the only book debunking the Holocaust that I had read before running onto The Journal of Historical Research was THE MYTH OF THE SIX MILLION, Anonymous, published by the Noontide Press in Los Angeles in 1969. Then, probably in about 1982 I found one of the issues of THE JOURNAL FOR HISTORICAL REVIEW at a used book sale. ‘What’s this?’ I asked myself, since my hobby has always been History. ‘Why haven’t I heard of this before?’ The Journal was about two years old and it didn’t seem to have caused a ripple. The Journal did show convincingly (to me at least) that the Holocaust couldn’t have happened. And the only answer that could be given to it was ‘The proof that the Holocaust could have happened is that it did happen.’ And the passing of laws that the Holocaust must be accepted as Historical Fact, and the savage penalties to be assessed against those who claimed that it wasn’t historical fact. And several of the most famous historians in the world being stripped of their degrees by law and forbidden to teach or write. And persons in prison for offences against the Holocaust Laws being murdered there.

     The Journal of Historical Review has been publishing ‘Revisionist’ pieces since 1980, except for a brief while when they were unable to publish because of fire-bombing and arson at their printing plant, and very large numbers of people (especially of college students) have become aware of the Revisionist views and sympathetic to them. In the United States especially, Revisionist Scholars have been debating everyone who would face them at various colleges, and have been winning the debates resoundingly. And the Canadian Trial, despite its outcome, cause many persons to accept the Revisionist credo. This brings us to February of 1989, last year, when the 9th IHR REVISIONIST CONFERENCE was to be held somewhere in Southern California. There was even scheduled a Great Debate between the Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust and the ‘Exterminator of Revisionism’ who were eminent (they said that they were) Jewish Scholars, or Christian Scholars who believed strongly in the Holocaust, Glen Peglau, Hal Lindsey (author of THE LATE, GREAT PLANET EARTH), Tom Anderson, John Warwick who was called the Intellectual of the Exterminator team. But the debate didn’t take place. Within hours, all four members of the touted ‘Exterminator’ team withdrew from the debate. Hal Lindsey remembered that the day of the debate was the same day he was supposed to sign a new $500,000 book contract. Peglau remembered that the day of the debate was the same day he was to be in court to settle a suit for which he would earn $2,225.00 in legal fees (all of these were expensive people). John Montgomery remembered that the day of the debate was the same day he was to be in court on a dispute with his ex-wife. And Peglau claimed that his heart condition (which was real) was getting worse every day as the time of the debate neared. But some of the Revisionists were so crude as to say that the four Exterminators all backed out of the debate when they found that they and their staffs could not find any evidence at all that the Holocaust had really happened. So the NINTH IHR REVISIONIST CONFERENCE was held without the Great Debate. But it was said to be a very interesting and successful Conference even without it.

​

     Sorry, I didn’t mean to take so much space for the Holocaust-that-never-happened affair.

I do believe that you will be able to make a good story (or a better story) out of THE BIGOT. It will take a touch of genius, but everybody has a touch of genius when he reaches deep enough for it.

​

      All good things for all of you.

      (signed) Ray Lafferty
      Tulsa (the Hub of the Universe) OK, USA

 

---

​

​​​May 19, 1989. To Paul de Vinny. "Yes, I am mystified and disgusted by the disproportionate number of "science fiction people" who are atheist, and I don't know how to counteract the tendency. Part of the explanation sounds anti-semitic, but I don't believe it is. Jews do make up a disproportionate number of science fiction people" and "when Jews lose their religion, they commonly become atheists. Catholics, for instance, when they lose their religion, usually become agnostic or indifferentists. Protestants usually become the milder sort of humanists."³³​

​

January 24, 1990. To Dan Knight. Holocaust denial. Says he never accepted that the Jews had been murdered en masse. His Holocaust denial predates his encounter with Holocaust revisionism. Gives personal history. Says his hobby has always been history.³⁴

​​​​

February 26, 1992. To Stephen Minch. Thoughts on the Dreyfus Affair and antisemitism. Writes, "The fear of being called an anti-Semite was then stronger in both France and England than it is now, if that were possible. And Dreyfus was more puzzled than anybody about the whole thing. He couldn't understand why people considered him Jewish when he hadn't been Jewish for four generations, and was in fact only one-sixteenth Jewish. But he had a smart Jewish lawyer to defend him."³⁵

​​​

February 26, 1992. To the editor of Eastern Oklahoma Catholic. "In recent months several articles and essays have appeared which argue that the Moslems and Jews should be able to live together in peace because they did it once before: in peace, in a golden era, a magic era of high attainment in every field of science and art and intellectuality and understanding. They lived in this golden age for about eight-hundred years in Iberia (Spain and Portugal and a few islands  and scraps. This golden age began around the year 711 and faded away about 1470. But there was an unmentioned missing element in this joyous twosome of Moslems and Jews. With these two it was a two-legged stool. There had to be a third element. And in fact there had to be the Christian populace to be considered. These Christians lived in almost total slavery for eight hundred years," After body, concludes: "In the February 22 issue of the Eastern Oklahoma Catholic, there is a write-up titled 'Reconciliation to Set Right 500-Year Wrong.' The strange argument was that the eight hundred years of slavery had been right, and that the well-handled ending of it was a wrong. And there is a picture of sixteen persons, Catholics, Jews, and miscellaneous who all seem to be under the same delusion. / But all sixteen of them are wrong, some of them innocently wrong, some of them maliciously wrong. Pray for them."³⁶

​

April 9, 1992. To David Jones, Eastern Oklahoma Catholic.  Further interpretation of the history of Spain.  Concludes: "And the Jew now has the right to quote the old verse of Alexander Pope: 'Yes I am proud. I should be proud to see / Men not afraid of God afraid of me."³⁷  ​ 

​

March 24, 1993. To Al Doty. "But blacks in Science Fiction and Fantasy are favored with a sort of reverse discrimination. Octavia Butler has received accolades far beyond what is deserved by her unimpressive work. If she were White she might not have been published at all. Samuel Ray (Chip) Delany on the top of the heap for several years a combination of fancy titles," etc. Lafferty also writes, "On the other hand, there is a pretty good bunch of Blacks who are competent or better as writers and do not need any reverse discrimination to help them out. Steven Barnes is probably the best of them, or I may think so because I know him the best, but there's a dozen or so who are adequate, and people don't especially think of them as Black."³⁸ 

​​​​​

​

dan.png

widgetid

Loading...

Notes

1. Glyn Morgan, Imagining the Unimaginable: Speculative Fiction and the Holocaust (Bloomsbury Academic, 2020), chap. 3, “The Damned and the Saved,” conclusion.

2. R. A. Lafferty, “The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny,” in Apocalypses (Pinnacle Books, 1977), 355.

3. Lafferty, “Three Armageddons,” 357.

4. R. A. Lafferty to Dan Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, R. A. Lafferty Papers, 1979-002, Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.

5. R. A. Lafferty to Sheryl Smith, December 21, 1977, p. 1, scanned letter.

6. Lafferty to Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, Lafferty Papers. “Institute for Historical Review,” box 4, folder 12, Lafferty Papers.

7. Paul VI, Humanae vitae, July 25, 1968.

8. Nick Robertson, “1 in 5 Young Americans Think Holocaust Was a Myth,” The Hill, December 8, 2023.

9. John Clute, “Lafferty, R A,” The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, updated September 14, 2026.

10. Glyn Morgan, “Mapping Planet Auschwitz: Non-Mimetic Writing and the Holocaust in Anglo-American Fiction” (PhD diss., University of Liverpool, September 2016), sec. 2.2, 127–34.

11. Andrew Ferguson, personal communication to Glyn Morgan, September 27, 2014, quoted in Morgan, “Mapping Planet Auschwitz,” 128–29, esp. 129n63.

12. Lafferty to Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, Lafferty Papers.

13. Andrew Ferguson, “R.A. Lafferty’s Escape from Flatland; or, How to Build a World in Three Easy Steps,” Science Fiction Studies 41, no. 3 (November 2014): 543–61. See also Ferguson, “Lafferty and His World” (master’s thesis, PDF created September 14, 2010); “The Order of the Phoenix: Homage, Pastiche, and Neil Gaiman’s ‘Sunbird’” (paper presented at the Thirty-Fourth International Conference on the Fantastic in the Arts, 2013); and “Unpublished Lafferty,” The New York Review of Science Fiction, no. 281 (January 2012).

14. Daniel Otto Jack Petersen, “‘You Are the Old Entrapped Dreams of the Coyote’s Brains Oozing Liquid Through the Broken Eye Socket’: Ecomonstrous Poetics and Weird Bioregionalism in the Fiction of R. A. Lafferty (with a Comparative Reading of Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian)” (PhD diss., University of Glasgow, 2020); Petersen, “Discussion with Lafferty Scholar Andrew Ferguson – Part 1 (of 2),” YouTube video, February 9, 2025, at 40:22.

15. Andrew Ferguson, comment on Stephen Reid Case, “Does Anyone Else Have Something Further to Add?,” December 29, 2014, 6:16 a.m.

16. Yakushima, “A Conversation with Andrew Ferguson at Laffcon1,” YouTube video, June 11, 2016.

17. Lafferty to Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, Lafferty Papers.

18. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 10; Morgan, “Mapping Planet Auschwitz,” 128–29.

19. “Institute for Historical Review,” box 4, folder 12, Lafferty Papers. “Gaiman, Neil,” 1986, box 4, folder 1, Lafferty Papers.

20. Andrew Ferguson, “In Tulsa Town,” Continued on Next Rock, March 15, 2015. For Gaiman’s recollection of his cousin, see Stephen Armstrong, “Neil Gaiman: My Cousin Was a Holocaust Survivor — She Knew Good Stories Save Lives,” The Times, November 4, 2021.

21. Morgan, “Mapping Planet Auschwitz,” 132.

22. Morgan, “Mapping Planet Auschwitz,” 134.

23. Lafferty to Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, Lafferty Papers. See also Lafferty, “Three Armageddons,” 355.

24. Morgan, “Mapping Planet Auschwitz,” 127.

25. Morgan, “Mapping Planet Auschwitz,” 127.

26. Andrew Ferguson, “81.5 Dotty,” Continued on Next Rock, November 2, 2020.

27. John Clute and Neil Gaiman, “Lafferty, R A,” in The Encyclopedia of Fantasy, ed. John Clute and John Grant (Orbit, 1997). See also Neil Gaiman, journal entry, March 20, 2002.

28. Neil Gaiman, “Not to Mention R. A. Lafferty: A Personal Introduction,” in The Best of R. A. Lafferty, ed. Jonathan Strahan (Gollancz, 2019). The linked excerpt appears in the 2021 Tor edition.

29. R. A. Lafferty to Al Doty, March 24, 1993. The correspondence section above gives the author’s transcription.

30. Second Vatican Council, Nostra aetate, October 28, 1965, sec. 4; Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, We Remember: A Reflection on the Shoah, March 16, 1998, secs. IV–V.

31. Lafferty to Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, Lafferty Papers.

32. Lafferty to Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, Lafferty Papers. The photograph shows the original letter. Its carbon copy is held at McFarlin Library.

33. R. A. Lafferty to Paul de Vinny, May 19, 1989, box 3, folder 2, Lafferty Papers. Tulsa catalog.

34. Lafferty to Knight, January 24, 1990, box 7, folder 5, Lafferty Papers.

35. R. A. Lafferty to Stephen Minch, February 26, 1992, Hermetic Press correspondence, box 4, folder 9, Lafferty Papers. Tulsa catalog.

36. R. A. Lafferty to the editor of the Eastern Oklahoma Catholic, February 26, 1992, box 3, folder 9, Lafferty Papers. Tulsa catalog.

37. R. A. Lafferty to David Jones, April 9, 1992, Eastern Oklahoma Catholic correspondence, box 3, folder 9, Lafferty Papers. Tulsa catalog.

38. R. A. Lafferty to Al Doty, March 24, 1993, transcribed here by the author.

Selected Bibliography

Clute, John. “Lafferty, R A.” The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction. Updated September 14, 2026.

Clute, John, and Neil Gaiman. “Lafferty, R A.” In The Encyclopedia of Fantasy, edited by John Clute and John Grant. Orbit, 1997.

Ferguson, Andrew. “R.A. Lafferty’s Escape from Flatland; or, How to Build a World in Three Easy Steps.” Science Fiction Studies 41, no. 3 (November 2014): 543–61.

Gaiman, Neil. “Not to Mention R. A. Lafferty: A Personal Introduction.” In The Best of R. A. Lafferty, edited by Jonathan Strahan. Gollancz, 2019.

Lafferty, R. A. Apocalypses. Pinnacle Books, 1977.

Lafferty, R. A. R. A. Lafferty Papers. 1979-002. Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.

Morgan, Glyn. Imagining the Unimaginable: Speculative Fiction and the Holocaust. Bloomsbury Academic, 2020.

Morgan, Glyn. “Mapping Planet Auschwitz: Non-Mimetic Writing and the Holocaust in Anglo-American Fiction.” PhD diss., University of Liverpool, 2016.

Petersen, Daniel Otto Jack. “‘You Are the Old Entrapped Dreams of the Coyote’s Brains Oozing Liquid Through the Broken Eye Socket’: Ecomonstrous Poetics and Weird Bioregionalism in the Fiction of R. A. Lafferty (with a Comparative Reading of Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian).” PhD diss., University of Glasgow, 2020.

bottom of page