IIIa. Reading Lafferty Through Rosenfeld and Marcus
Updated: 2 days ago

"Rita, did you know that the Jews believe that the Jews are a handsome people," Cecelia Ching Brass jibed. "Really. And how odd it is. I found it out, quite by accident from a chance remark of Julius here. The implications of it open up an entirely new fantasy world, a world in which the Jews really are handsome, and everything likewise is upside-down." "I'm not sure what the Chinese think about the Chinese," Julius said, "but I have heard that the Irish really do believe that the Irish are handsome. But then the Irish have always lived in a fantasy world in which indeed everything is upside-down. But the belief that the Irish are handsome is the origin of the golden lie, that blatant falsehood. Odd, odd, odd, that such a delusion should take hold of a people, and how odd that you should abet it, Rita." In a Green Tree, p. 654

I continue to reflect on Belloc and to think about the nature of Lafferty's antisemitism. Ivan G. Marcus examines the history of Christian hostility to Jews in How the West Became Antisemitic (Princeton UP, 2024). Chapter 9, “Antisemitisms: Medieval and Modern,” is available below:
I outline Marcus’s chapter below.
Also helpful is Deciphering the New Antisemitism, edited by Alvin H. Rosenfeld (Indiana UP, 2015). The following table summarizes categories discussed by its contributors:

Sources: Alvin H. Rosenfeld, ed., Deciphering the New Antisemitism (Indiana UP, 2015): Kenneth L. Marcus, pp. 21–42; Pascal Bruckner, pp. 7–20; Sina Arnold, pp. 375–404; Elhanan Yakira, pp. 77–102; Bernard Harrison, pp. 289–325; David Patterson, pp. 326–349; Aryeh Tuchman, pp. 350–372; Mark Weitzman, pp. 242–286.
I would characterize Belloc’s antisemitism as follows. The religious comparison concerns his early twentieth-century Catholic politics and his insistence on Jewish national separateness.

Source: Hilaire Belloc, The Jews (Constable, 1922), preface, pp. vii–ix; pp. 4–5 (separateness and segregation), 93–96 (finance and racial character), 124 (racial contrast), 178–182 (Bolshevism), 209–210 (the Church and Jewish separateness), and 231–240 (Zionism and nationality).
Lafferty:

Sources: R. A. Lafferty, letter to Dan Knight, January 24, 1990; Institute for Historical Review materials, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979.002, box 4, folder 12, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa; The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny, in Apocalypses (Pinnacle Books, 1977), ch. 10, §2, pp. 354–358. The correspondence and religious context are discussed in “R. A. Lafferty and Antisemitism”; the fictional parallels in “The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny: Ideological Erasure”.
Outline of Ivan G. Marcus’s chapter:

Source: Ivan G. Marcus, “Antisemitisms: Medieval and Modern,” ch. 9 of How the West Became Antisemitic (Princeton UP, 2024), pp. 189–200. Chapter PDF.


