top of page
Search

Lafferty and Magic Realism

Sep 1, 2025
4 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Painting of a black-robed friar levitating with outstretched arms while another friar reaches toward him.

You will hear it said that Lafferty is a bit like magic realism, but isn’t quite magic realism. For a while, I’ve thought this has to do with what Northrop Frye in The Anatomy of Criticism calls the low mimetic mode. The low mimetic mode is the level of literature where the hero is one of us. He isn’t raised above humanity by rank or by power (that is the defining characteristic of the high mimetic). Nor is the hero reduced below it, as in the ironic mode.


The low mimetic is the mode of much ordinary novel-writing, where characters live within the limits of common experience and probability. Lafferty thought the ordinary novel had come to an end. He doesn’t usually give us literary criticism, but he did on this point, and it is instructive:


Prose fiction was a narrow thing. As a valid force it was found only in Structured Western Civilization (Europe and the Levant, and the Americas and other colonies),and for only about three hundred years, from Don Quixote in 1605 to the various ‘last novels’ of the twentieth century. The last British novel may have been Arnold Bennett's Old Wives' Tale in 1908 or Maugham's Of Human Bondage in 1915.Both of them have strong post-fictional elements mixed in. The last Russian novel was probably Gorki's The Bystander in the 1920's, and the last Irish novel may have been O'Flaherty's The Informer about the same time. In Germany, Remarque's All Quiet on the Western Front, published in 1929, was plainly a post-novel in a post-fictional form. But the structured world did not end everywhere at quite the same time. In the United States there was a brilliant ‘last hurrah’ of novels for several decades after the fictional form had disappeared in Europe, and Cozzen's By Love Possessed, published in 1957, might still be considered as a valid fictional work.

What Lafferty means by structured points to how the low mimetic is also the locus of realism, but not identical with realism: realism is a historical style and technique devoted to surface fidelity and psychological detail (a historical and cultural aesthetic effect), while the low mimetic is a structural category based on the hero’s relation to us. While most realist novels are low mimetic, other stylistic forms can also inhabit the low mimetic, and realism itself may appear across other modes.


For Frye, the low mimetic shades into irony as the hero becomes less capable than we are. Irony can then disclose mythic patterns beneath ordinary life. The modes circle back toward myth.


This was how Frye explained something like James Joyce. In the Anatomy, he writes,


“Irony descends from the low mimetic: it begins in realism and dispassionate observation. But as it does so, it moves steadily towards myth, and dim outlines of sacrificial rituals and dying gods begin to reappear in it. Our five modes evidently go around in a circle. This reappearance of myth in the ironic is particularly clear in Kafka and in Joyce.”

Frye’s account suggests one way to read Lafferty’s dislike of Joyce. Lafferty once called Joyce a disgrace to the Irish in a letter. Joyce’s rejection of Catholic communion and his use of irony may help explain the hostility, but this is my inference. Lafferty’s anagogical vision seeks the humor of the Laughing Christ beyond the ironic suspension of myth.


This distinction also helps me locate Lafferty in relation to magical realism.


Much magical realism places marvelous events among ordinary people in recognizable social and historical settings. Ghosts, prophecies, and miracles may be accepted as part of daily life. In Frye’s terms, such works can bring myth into the low mimetic without abandoning it.


Some also place their characters at the mercy of history or politics. Myth and irony can coexist in that setting. This describes one tendency in magical realism, rather than a definition that covers every work.


“Land of the Great Horses” (1967) handles the marvelous differently. Its fantastic premise alone does not settle whether it belongs to magical realism. What matters for my comparison is how the characters respond: the returning land interrupts their understanding of the world.


If you haven’t read it, “Land of the Great Horses” is about an incredible event in which a long-lost piece of land, once thought to be only a mirage in the Thar Desert of India, reappears. Two mineral surveyors stumble upon the lush highland. Seruno Smith realizes he is not who he thought he was, but a Romani (Gypsy) whose people’s ancestral homeland had been taken away a thousand years earlier by alien visitors.


As the land returns, Gypsies from all over the world feel the pull to go home, abandoning their lives and converging from every continent. It turns out the aliens had removed a sliver of Earth for study, leaving behind a mirage and a homing instinct in the displaced people. Now restored, the Romani return, while elsewhere, another sliver of Earth (Los Angeles) is taken away in the same manner, setting up a few classic Lafferty-style jokes.


The return is extraordinary, but the surveyors, mechanics, barmaids, and carnival workers are ordinary people. They are caught in an event beyond their control. This is the story’s low mimetic element: its characters remain recognizably human while their world changes around them.


Lafferty also writes the storyteller’s presence into third-person narration. Connectives, comments, qualifications, and direct questions give the prose its spoken quality. These are not all pragmatic markers in the same linguistic sense: some are frequency adverbs or ordinary uses of modal verbs. Nor does a conversational narrator determine the hero’s mode in Frye’s scheme. But the familiar voice keeps the reader company as the events grow strange. It can say, “And of course Jacob’s pants were back on,” or, “No, no, there was nothing at all notable going on aboard the Argo that morning, except a lot of loud hornpipe music and some carousing and laughter; and Eva and some other girls discovered on the Argo were having lots of fun with fellows of uncertain origin.”


Connectives and narrator’s commentary, panel 1 of 4.

Connectives and narrator’s commentary, panel 2 of 4.

Connectives and narrator’s commentary, panel 3 of 4.

Connectives and narrator’s commentary, panel 4 of 4.

bottom of page