top of page
Search

Counterargument

Oct 12, 2025
2 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Black-and-white historical photograph of children in striped concentration-camp clothing standing behind barbed wire.

“People are easily fooled. But there are tests for reality.” — The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny

This will be the last I have to say about Lafferty’s Holocaust denial for a while, unless it becomes directly relevant to an argument about a specific story.


A counterargument to my account of Lafferty’s beliefs must confront the archival record at the University of Tulsa and explain what it establishes about his history of denial.


Lafferty’s January 24, 1990 letter presents his Holocaust denial as longstanding. A claim that the letter was mere provocation must also account for the IHR Holocaust-denial materials preserved among his papers.


A rebuttal of Lafferty’s history of categorical denial must account for this primary evidence. Ignoring it is evasion.


The literary question is whether the novel’s treatment of the Jewish Holocaust amounts to ideological erasure. A competing reading must explain the passages on which my argument rests.


With The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny, you would need to offer a more compelling and comprehensive account of the novel’s strange architecture than the one I have proposed. You must reckon with the dozen parallel strategies I have identified and explain their role in the novel’s treatment of historical consensus.



Your reading must explain these details with greater coherence than the denialist reading does. I am identifying denialist echoes in a work by a man who denied the Holocaust. Lafferty created it to make his vision of the twentieth century legible to intelligent readers. It was a summa of his century; in his letter to Sheryl Smith, December 21, 1977, he described it as carrying “a total history of the century.”


I call the muting of Lafferty’s extreme views secular quarantine. It distorts the politico-religious ideology that informs his treatment of the Holocaust.


An account of Holocaust denial as a failing confined to Lafferty’s final years must reckon with his retrospective claim: “I myself never did accept.” My reading locates its fictional parallels in Three Armageddons, published in 1977.


My argument is that, in this case, separating the art from the artist is a critical impossibility. The denialism is in the work’s blueprint. To separate the two is to misunderstand what the art does. The Three Armageddons is Lafferty fully in control of his genius, one of his masterpieces, so this is a critical problem.


A serious counterargument must identify errors in my use of the archive or my reading of the fiction. An alternative reading should account for the passages discussed here.


I have yet to receive an answer to these arguments.

bottom of page