Ia. The Myth of the Six Million
Updated: 2 days ago

“People are easily fooled. But there are tests for reality. If a thing is burned up, then there will be a residue of ashes and gasses. But if there is not such a residue, and the things appears to be unchanged, then it is not acting as if it were burned up.” — The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny, p. 357
“But if indeed six million Jews were killed (between a third and a half of the Jews in the World, and more Jews than were in the maximum area ever controlled by the Germans) then they should have left a big hole in the total Jewish World Population; but they didn’t.” — Lafferty, letter to Dan Knight, January 24, 1990
One key to interpreting a segment of Lafferty’s fiction is his longstanding Holocaust denial and his use of Jewish stereotypes. These help explain certain tropes he employs and the treatment of the Jewish Holocaust in The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny. This is a distinct issue from one of many developments of the "new-antisemitism"—specifically, the 1980s IHR-denial version that Lafferty later bought into—though continuities make strategies of secular quarantine impossible.
Lafferty said that, before reading the Journal of Historical Review, he had read The Myth of the Six Million (Noontide Press, 1969). First published anonymously, the pamphlet is generally attributed to David Leslie Hoggan.
Something that would have arrested Lafferty’s attention in The Myth of the Six Million is the discussion of Stephen F. Pinter, a former U.S. War Department attorney who served with the occupation forces in Germany and Austria, and the author’s appeal to the Holy See. In a letter to the popular American Catholic weekly Our Sunday Visitor (June 14, 1959), Pinter said that there were no gas chambers at Dachau or other German camps and minimized the scale of Jewish deaths.
The anonymous author of The Myth of the Six Million uses this letter to say, “It is small wonder, under such considerations, that the Holy See has steadfastly and consistently refused to join those who charge that Germany practiced a deliberate policy of seeking to exterminate the Jewish population of Europe.” The pamphlet invokes Catholic authority to support its denial. A foundational text of modern Holocaust denial quotes from a major Catholic communications organ in the United States, citing a letter published ten years earlier.

Anyone who claims that the mere fact of Lafferty’s Holocaust denial marked a radical break from his earlier Catholicism should examine the Dachau letter in Our Sunday Visitor and flip through the issue. In the year Lafferty wrote “The Six Fingers of Time” and “The Polite People of Pudibundia,” rosaries could coexist with discussion of Holocaust denial in a preeminently mainstream organ of American Catholic communication. Also relevant for understanding Lafferty are the development of the post-Conciliar Church’s social teaching, the Church’s relationship to the State of Israel, and Belloc’s separate influence, topics discussed elsewhere on this blog.
Did Lafferty read The Myth of the Six Million before January 22, 1976, when he completed The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny? I think the textual correspondences point that way. The strongest comparisons involve Brigadier General George Dredgefellow’s fictional article, “A Square-Headed Answer.” His position is unstable: he dismisses memories of his own wounds, and the dialogue eventually makes him concede that the wars may have happened. That framing matters when comparing his rhetoric with the pamphlet.



This convinces me that specific elements of Holocaust denial literature profoundly shaped one of Lafferty’s major artistic works, a book that impresses me. Lafferty himself said that he "never did accept" the reality of the Holocaust.
I take him at his word. His knowledge of history makes this a moral and intellectual failure. The Three Armageddons refers to the burned flesh of Jews and Gypsies. My argument is that its treatment of history nevertheless participates in erasing the Jewish Holocaust.
For Lafferty, "myth" usually does not mean "lie"; in the title The Myth of the Six Million, it does. The following false and misleading claims are reproduced to examine the pamphlet’s Holocaust-denial propaganda.






