top of page
Search

The Sex Life of Melchisedech Duffey

Oct 26, 2025
3 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Painting of an elderly crowned, white-bearded figure holding a stack of round loaves beneath an arch.

This post charts Melchisedech Duffey’s sexual conduct and its connection with antisemitic tropes in More Than Melchisedech. The tables collect the evidence for that reading, distinguishing events from characters’ claims and from the novel’s conflicting accounts of identity and time.


Duffey is blackmailed with photographs of his sexual misconduct with children and his encounters with adult women. He attributes the photographs of the children to Hugo Stone, whom he identifies with Absalom Stein. A later passage also names Hugo as the photographer, but the identification of Hugo with Stein is disputed within the novel.


The bookstore photographs show Duffey with girls from the time they were eight or ten. The later narrator condemns his conduct. Margaret Stone, however, challenges Duffey’s account of the photographer’s identity: she says several of the Stone cousins called themselves Hugo because Duffey could not tell them apart. Duffey insists that Hugo was Stein, and Stein later refers to his former soul as that of Hugo Stone, the Chicago Communist. These accounts do not agree.


Stein is German for “stone.” The names invite the identification, but their correspondence does not resolve the conflicting testimony.


The blackmailers want to enter The Crock and publish their ideas in it. The preceding narration connects attempts to take over the magazine with the Communist politics of the 1930s. Stein’s Jewish characterization, his disputed identity as Hugo, and Shirley Israel’s role give this plot its antisemitic associations. The attempt can thus be read as an effort to infiltrate Duffey’s Catholic political circle, whose aspirations Casey describes in Archipelago.


Of Duffey, Casey Szymansky in Archipelago says,


He is a Centrist. He is the only member of the Catholic Center Party of America. He is the Party. d'Allesandro, Mary Frances, Demetrio Glauch, and myself are his best prospects. If he could fully enlist us he would have a party of five. Smaller parties have done well in Europe. But it is lonesome to be a party of one.

Shirley and Ben Israel belong to the hostile Chicago social circle described before the blackmail. Rollo McSorley’s newspaper article within the novel calls Shirley a “nefarious Jewess.” The portfolio scene describes the photograph of Duffey with her as its only flagrante picture and presents it as an entrapment.


“Well, what are you going to do with them?” Duffey asked stiffly. “Oh, we hope that we will not do anything with them,” the man said. “It is just that some of us want to join with you in the excellent little magazine you are running, and you have not welcomed us with open arms. We do not want to join in from hope of money gain. We will bring in money, not take it out. And we will enlarge the magazine. But it is an idea magazine, and we want our ideas to be in it.” “Who are you going to blackmail me to?” “Oh, to your wife, and to others.” “You're wasting your time,” Duffey said. “My wife can read my mind. She knows the things I have done. These things cannot be held against me, however they may look. I have confessed the few guilty things among them and I have been absolved of them. And any guilt I ever had in them, either in fact or in appearance, is gone now. It is all past.” “Some of these pictures, you must know, are not too old.” “Some of my confessings and absolvings are not too old either.” “Ah, but will your wife absolve you?” “Certainly she will. I will explain to her that I am clear of all these things now, and that she must hold me clear of them.”

Flowchart of the fictional blackmail plot against Melchisedech Duffey, tracing compromising photographs, threatened exposure, and the demand for influence over The Crock.

I. Childhood and Boarding School

Childhood and boarding school, panel 1 of 1.

II. St. Louis (1915–1917) and Early Exploitation of Minors


In his St. Louis years, Duffey pursues Beth Keegan, who is slightly older, while also behaving sexually toward the much younger Gretchen Sisler.


St. Louis years, panel 1 of 2.

St. Louis years, panel 2 of 2.


Duffey’s talismanic creations give him a kind of magical fatherhood. The narrative does not place all these events within seven consecutive calendar years.


The seven hidden years, panel 1 of 1.

IV. Marriage and Chicago Years (1925–1946)


Duffey reappears in 1923 and marries Letitia in 1925. The Chicago years include his abuse of children in the bookstore and the later use of photographs to blackmail him.


Marriage and Chicago, panel 1 of 2.

Marriage and Chicago, panel 2 of 2.

V. After Letitia’s Death and the Later Proposals


After Letitia’s death, several women propose marriage or renewed intimacy. Their visits in New Orleans precede Duffey’s later proposal to Monica in St. Louis.


After Letitia’s death, panel 1 of 1.

VI. Context of Sexual Degradation


Letitia’s scrapbook contains fictional clippings about sexual abuse and educational decline. These passages do not describe Duffey’s own conduct.


Letitia’s scrapbook, panel 1 of 1.

 

VII. The Blackmail Plot and Antisemitic Characterization


Blackmail and antisemitic characterization, panel 1 of 2.

Blackmail and antisemitic characterization, panel 2 of 2.

bottom of page