top of page
Search

"Phoenic" (1960/1980)

Nov 3, 2025
9 min read

Updated: 1 day ago

Joan de Joanes's Pentecost painting, with a dove radiating light above figures marked by tongues of flame.
Joan de Joanes (Valencia, c. 1505 - Bocairent, 1579), Pentecost.

“I took a live mermaid not far from here one morning,” said John Counts. And then he paused. “That pause, old Wiedervogel,” he said after a bit, “that pause was for you to say ‘Incredible!’ or something similarly apropos.” “Consider it said. Was she real?” “She said that she was. She seemed to be. She was ugly as sin . . . Her skin was green and rough . . . She smelled like a mermaid, or at least like a fish . . . I tried to sell her in England. There is a man there who goes in for such things. ‘But I already have a mermaid,’ this man said. ‘A real one?’ I asked him. ‘No, not a real one, but this is not the first real one that has been offered to me. What I have is better than a real one.’ “It was. What the man had was incomparably better than a real one. She was a beautiful human girl who happened to terminate in a fishtail. But she was no great whiz at swimming or deep diving. She wasn’t a real mermaid. I gave my mermaid back to her husband on my return voyage and paid him for her service. We did not understand the same thing by the term, but she was a real mermaid.”

(Now Hiram the king of Tyre had furnished Solomon with cedar trees and fir trees, and with gold, according to all his desire,) that then king Solomon gave Hiram twenty cities in the land of Galilee. — 1 Kings 9:11

There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day. — Luke 16:19

“Phoenic” is far from being easy Lafferty. It’s more like a pop quiz. For most of its length, Lafferty keeps his hand over the challenge, then in the last few paragraphs, he lifts his hand. He amplifies all the preceding ambiguity and ends with a question: Whence is this newness? There are quite a few rhetorical questions in Lafferty. There is occasional hypophora. This is neither. And given what he constructs in “Phoenic,” it’s a tough quiz. “Phoenic” is also a good lesson in Lafferty's early virtuous antisemitism.

 

Table comparing Petersen’s and Ferguson’s readings of the final question in “Phoenic.”

Ferguson finds his answer in the storyteller’s craft. Petersen sees the same danger I see in the clothes, though he hears genuine renewal in their names. I put more weight on what the Pittsburgh firm is selling.

This story can wrongfoot you. From the outset, there are two main characters in “Phoenic”: the gaunt Phoenician, Wiedervogel, and the florid Jew, John Counts. Wiedervogel is a tall old man with a beak-like nose—predatory in aspect—and a coat-and-suit maker back in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, a place Lafferty calls “farther than Punt, farther than Ophir.” Returning to his home continent, Wiedervogel arrives at the port of Aqaba, where he hires transport from a boat owner, John Counts.


As they travel, Lafferty gives us a mythopoetic dialogue, juxtaposing the tall thing with the small thing—John Counts’s naked commercialism. Counts asks Wiedervogel about his purpose of travel. The Phoenician says he has "an appointment beyond. It was made long ago." He will go to the House of Ashes. When John Counts asks how much time Wiedervogel has left, Wiedervogel says, "Five days."


Their conversation next turns to the supernatural nature of the region as a cauldron of story. Counts says, "The irony of the locale is that all the legends are true," and he recounts his experiences with phantom ships and a man who is repeatedly drowned, perhaps recalling Phlebas the Phoenician. Wiedervogel compares his own going to that of the elephant but adds that "in my case there will be no bones left."


Table analysing the ghost ship, repeatedly drowned passenger, and mermaid encounters in Phoenic.

When the two reach Yenbo, Wiedervogel gets a guide, a boy who might be moulded of clay (distinct from Otto, the steward Wiedervogel suspects is a golem, and perhaps something like the boy Adam in Past Master), who leads him inland to a great flat rock. Following an ancient prescription on the morning of the vernal equinox, the boy builds a fire. He has been told by his father to watch the ritual closely, but the boy turns away for a moment to relieve himself, and Lafferty writes "when he turned back it was finished." After the fire dies down, the young Wiedervogel sweeps the remaining ashes into the small sandalwood box Wiedervogel had been carrying.


The boy and a young man who looks like a young Wiedervogel return to the coast with the box. John Counts, who is not easily perturbed, picks him up. He is unsurprised by the apparent reincarnation. The story ends with a pseudo-digression. The true marvel is not the confirmation of the Phoenix legend, but the creative explosion that followed half a world away. Wiedervogel Coat and Suit Fabrique in Pittsburgh is now producing revolutionary fashion, including Fire-And-Ashes jackets, Resurrection cloaks, and the exclusive I Was Dead And Now I Live Again line. Lafferty asks, “Whence is this newness?”


King Solomon receives gifts from Hiram at a waterfront crowded with ships and attendants.
Ships of Tyre bringing Hiram’s gifts to King Solomon

The Phoenician returns from the House of Ashes, and his firm puts the language of resurrection to work selling clothes. Here the Phoenician begins to look like a business-minded Philistine. This is one reason I read “Phoenic” as a story with two protagonists. The pursuit of money forms the general equivalent for John Counts (Jew/Solomon) and the Phoenician (Gentile/Hiram) in the Ophir legend.

Solomon builds the fleet at Ezion-geber. Hiram sends sailors to join Solomon’s men on the voyage to Ophir (1 Kings 9:26–28). Compare verse 26 with Lafferty’s account of the port.


And king Solomon made a navy of ships in Eziongeber, which is beside Eloth, on the shore of the Red sea, in the land of Edom.

On this day [the Phoenician] was in the port town of Ezion-Geber, built by his people for Jedidiah [Solomon] long ago, and now named Aqaba.

Both Jedidiah and John evoke divine favor: Jedidiah means “beloved of Yahweh,” while John means “Yahweh is gracious.”
Why Counts? 2 Chronicles 2:17–18; 1 Kings 5:13–16; 2 Chronicles 8:7–10; 1 Kings 9:23; 1 Kings 10:14; 1 Kings 10:26–27; 2 Chronicles 9:25–27; 1 Kings 4:32; and Ecclesiastes 7:27.


Lafferty turns to Solomon and Hiram several times in his work, and his handwritten notes on both survive. Counts tries to sell the Englishman a working mermaid. The Englishman likes his own better. This is where “Phoenic” touches “The Skinny People of Leptophlebo Street.” The garment trade gives us another version of the same joke. Consider the armor of God in Ephesians 6:10–18. At a fitting in Pittsburgh, a customer can acquire the semblance of a new face and body. The psychic clothes go further. They can make other people love or avoid the wearer. Both John and the Phoenician are money men.


It also looks like Lafferty intended John and the Phoenician to be competing figurations of time. For the Phoenician, this is a given because he is the Phoenix, but John Counts is a little trickier. The exchange contrasts John’s recent encounter with a ghost ship and the Phoenician’s memory of the old ships themselves:


“Not two years ago, I drove right through a grand old sail-ship on just such a night as this. It had no body to it. It must have been made out of fog. The lanterns on it, and the seamen on the deck, and the smells up out of the open hold must have been made out of fog too. But they seemed real enough. It was a great lateen with a high poop from the old Caliphate days of sail. You see cuts of them in old books. They haven't sailed for near five hundred years.” “I remember them a little bit,” Wiedervogel said.

I suspect the steward's name, Otto, is a joke because the Ottoman Empire controlled what had been Phoenicia from 1516 to 1918.


But back to time. One of my favorite discussions of the kind of time John Counts and the Phoenician embody is Stephen Jay Gould’s Time’s Arrow, Time’s Cycle: Myth and Metaphor in the Discovery of Geological Time, a book about deep time and evolution I read in my days as a geologist. As you can guess, Time’s Arrow is linear and directional history. It imagines time as an irreversible sequence of unique, unrepeatable events. This conception of time is rooted in the Judeo-Christian tradition. It emphasizes that each moment holds a distinct place in a narrative of linked events, from the singular creation of the Earth to the specific historical moment of Christ’s death and November 3, 2025.


In contrast, there is Time’s Cycle. It captures the idea of a repeating, timeless order. Fundamental states are always present. Apparent motions are parts of a recurring cycle. Westerners are probably closest to it as inheritors of ancient Greek thought. It imagines time has no inherent direction and is governed by timeless laws. The main challenge to this is exact repetition. It would make events indistinguishable; so what one typically gets is a qualification, the concept of advancing cycles, where repetition happens but with crucial differences, a bit like the wheel of Ages rolling forward or “Been a Long Long Time.”


Gould argued that in thinking about deep time and geology, it is a mistake to treat the two views of time as mutually exclusive. They are partners in any attempt to understand reality more fully. To comprehend history, we need both the uniqueness provided by Time's Arrow, which marks each moment, and the immanent, general principles of order offered by Time's Cycle.


Gould saw the interplay illustrated in evolutionary biology. Lafferty would have held his nose at this, yet its logic can show what lies buried in “Phoenic.” Homology, the retention of features from a common ancestor, is a direct product of Time's Arrow. It records the unique and irreversible pathway of a lineage’s descent, as in the relation between human fingers and the bones of a bat’s wing.


Analogy arises when similar forms evolve in separate lineages. This demonstrates Time's Cycle, showing how immanent principles of function constrain evolution to a limited set of effective solutions to recurring problems, such as the independent evolution of wings in birds and bats. The result is a vision in which every organism is both the product of its history (arrow) and an expression of "timeless" principles (cycle).


John Counts and Wiedervogel give us Time’s Arrow and Time’s Cycle. John has something of the Wandering Jew in him. He is a man of events and transactions, this voyage and that cargo. On four separate crossings he collects a fare from the same passenger. For Counts that makes four fares. For the passenger it is the same drowning four times, and each time he hopes to escape it. Counts puts an end even to geography. “Nobody goes beyond Yenbo. That is the end of the World.” Time’s Arrow has an end and a new beginning in Messianic time.


Wiedervogel (“again-bird”) is Time’s Cycle. The rite falls on the vernal equinox. The boy’s father tells him to watch closely. He puts the next opportunity five hundred years off. In “The Day After the World Ended,” Lafferty calls this Toynbee’s Phoenix Syndrome (Feast of Laughter 4, p. 349).


So whence is this newness?


Time’s Arrow (Jew) and Time’s Cycle (Gentile) are necessary but not sufficient to achieve the universal. Old Wiedervogel’s suit was one of his own obsolete models, dead stock. Simple renewal would put that same suit back on the rack. Is the phoenix, that bird of flame, somehow tied to another bird, the Holy Spirit that makes new? Or is it a counterfeit? I think it’s more counterfeit than not.


Lafferty’s Time’s Arrow and Time’s Cycle point to the source. In my way of reading Lafferty, that source is the Logos through the imaginative vision of the Logos I call the oceanic. The Phoenician brings about a not-quite Pentecost. The amazing change results in resurrection cloaks and that exclusive line of haberdashery, I Was Dead And Now I Live Again. Some spirit of creativity is poured out from the ashes.


The fruit of this spirit is commerce: Solomon and Hiram. The end result is the sporty, modish numbers and the fame that reaches New York (Ecclesiastes 2:9–11).


Here I see a joke on Lafferty’s Not to Mention Camels (1976) scripture, Matthew 19:24, in what John Counts/Solomon says to the Phoenician’s sewing trade: “It must be that you have kept your nose too close to the needle.” That is, of course, ironic coming from John, who is another of Lafferty’s ethno-essentialized money-wise Jews. The Holy Spirit is not visible here because we have gone back to a pattern that precedes Pentecost.


The Phoenician looks to me like an apostle of business. He’ll “express” the sacred ashes from Cairo to Heliopolis to save himself a trip. He resembles the Englishman who had a mermaid better than a real one, a personage like Kafka’s Poseidon. His is a Madison Avenue newness. What you can buy in Pittsburgh is a Resurrection cloak.


Lafferty asks, “Whence is this newness?” I hear the voice from the throne in the Apocalypse. “Behold, I make all things new.” In Pittsburgh the risen Christ’s words about his own death and life have become the name of a clothing line (Revelation 1:17–18). Counts might have said as much about newness as he did about the mermaid. “We did not understand the same thing by the term, but she was a real mermaid.”


This is a cynical reading of the story. I can see why Petersen hears a promise of renewal in those clothes. But do you want to sell it? I don’t. The Phoenician is a pneumatic businessman, a dealer in specious pneuma.


Character map of Wiedervogel and the figures he encounters, including the boy who seems moulded of clay.
Numbered outline of the story’s events, including the boy who seems moulded of clay and waits on a board out at sea.
First source sheet for “Phoenic,” pairing passages with the phoenix tradition, biblical navigation and the disputed identification of Ezion-Geber.
Source notes on death mythology, elephant graveyards, the golem, ghost ships, Jonah, and mermaids in Phoenic.
Third source sheet for “Phoenic,” including the garment trade and the appearance of new fashions at the Pittsburgh firm after Wiedervogel’s rebirth.
Four-stage diagram of Wiedervogel’s age, pilgrimage, immolation, and renewed life.
Ancient and Modern comparison, juxtaposing the phoenix and other possible mythic figures with the modern garment trade.
Journey diagram following Wiedervogel to the Red Sea, the ritual fire and the coast, with a Pittsburgh coda showing new fashions at his firm.



Bibliographical Note


Lafferty wrote “Phoenic” in July 1960. I read the handwritten date on his work-history card as July 17. He sent the story to A. L. Fierst on July 23 and got it back on September 26. The card records further submissions in 1962 and 1963.


First published as “Phoenic’” in The Anthology of Speculative Poetry, no. 4 (1980), 6–7. Lafferty also uses the terminal apostrophe in his letters to Dan Knight of December 22, 1987, and January 20, 1988. The story was collected as “Phoenic” in The Back Door of History (United Mythologies Press, 1988).


Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card no. 68 for “Phoenic” and letters to Dan Knight, December 22, 1987, and January 20, 1988, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “Phoenic’,” https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?1292330.

bottom of page