"Long Teeth" (1959/1960)
Updated: 13 hours ago

“He is fifty-three years, seven months and nine days old. His calculated worth is three hundred and twenty-two thousand dollars (my own calculation but a close one); you are his heir, Clinton. He is moreover highly insured with such a multiplicity of policies that it is almost impossible to tabulate them or even to be sure that I know about them all. He is unsound of heart, liver, lung, kidney, and stomach; has high blood pressure, ulcers, and Evan’s Disease; in short, he is the kind of man who might live forever. I have no faith in the early death of a man with a number of deadly diseases.”¹
In “Long Teeth,” we meet Carla, a designing woman married to a clueless simp named Clinton, who stands to inherit a fortune from his wealthy Uncle Nicholas. Carla grows increasingly impatient for Old Nick to die so that she and Clinton can come into their inheritance, and she justifies her lethal intent with a proverb: “A person can grow a pretty long set of teeth while waiting for a man to die.”²
Clinton is timorous, but Carla takes charge, orchestrating a series of odd events meant to hasten the death of the resilient invalid. Her attempts range from slipping a coral snake into his whisky cabinet to rigging an exploding grandfather clock. Yet, Nicholas survives them all—thanks to his own wits and a succession of food-tasting cats named Amenhotep who perish in succession.³
In the final confrontation, Nicholas ends up thoroughly roasted, and Carla dies from a broken neck after apparently setting herself alight. Clinton inherits the estate and continues caring for his nephew, Walter Jr., in the Old House. But this is a story about the cycle of greed. Years later, Clinton is chilled and saddened to overhear Walter Jr.’s wife, Charlotte, give the proverb a new turn—revealing that Clinton has now become the target.⁴
Andrew Ferguson has written well about this early Lafferty story, situating it within the genre history and the magazine world in which it appeared. He also notes that if Lafferty hadn’t broken into science fiction, this is the kind of genre work he might have written more of—a possibility Lafferty himself mentioned in passing.⁵ Ferguson points readers to Lafferty's great unpublished novel Mantis.⁶
Lafferty doesn’t so much write mysteries as write from mystery. What he produces are puzzles. Conventional mysteries are puzzles, of course. But some puzzles open into further mystery; others do not. One might here think of the difference between conspiracy in Chesterton's The Man Who Was Thursday and conspiracy in Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose.⁷ Lafferty's early stories are tidier puzzles than the later stories because the earlier ones are less open to the puzzlement of mystery itself. There is more rationalization in play. On the question of puzzle and story, Lafferty wrote in a letter to Hiroshi Inoue: “I do not mean to puzzle people with my writings, though any good story is the unraveling of a puzzle.”⁸
Still, picking up on Ferguson's insight, Lafferty wasn’t made for mystery fiction. The genre depends on varieties of closure that don’t suit him; even when Lafferty restores order, he leaves mystery. That’s the irony of the classic whodunit: it works hard to create an initial moment of mystery, then solves it so entirely that the mystery is gone. To see the counter movement in Lafferty, compare any of the early mystery-adjacent pieces like "Long Teeth" to what he does in "The Funny Face Murders."⁹
Since “Long Teeth” is not a mystery, finally, what kind of puzzle is being unraveled? If we aim high, the puzzle is the mapping of a recursive topology, an obsession that Lafferty develops repeatedly throughout his fiction. Consider how The Devil Is Dead, which Lafferty first drafted in 1963,¹⁰ is topologically continuous with Finnegan's blackouts in the earlier Archipelago, such as its memorable 105-hour Finnegan blackout.¹¹
For Gregorio Montejo, Finnegan himself figures as a Klein bottle.¹² Read this way, The Devil Is Dead trilogy, with its rich pattern of incident, has the structure of a Klein bottle, where what looks like a break or crossing in ordinary narrative space is a continuous loop. To return to Finnegan, his blackouts index the bottle’s apparent self-intersection—the point where the same surface crosses itself in projection. We are inside Archipelago, and then we find ourselves inside The Devil Is Dead. Where are we? Inside both.¹³
The mystery is that of form. Lafferty takes Carla’s proverb and shows that it is the formula for a closed loop of greed. It is not a linear vector from non-wealth to wealth, but a Möbius strip: a non-orientable surface along which the hungry mouth moves on a single continuous side, only to arrive as what passes into another mouth, making this yet another of Lafferty’s self-consuming artifacts.¹⁴




Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work-history card bears the date April 3, 1959, beside the title and records submission to Mystery Digest the following day. After further circulation, the card records an acceptance notice from Keyhole Mystery dated April 8, 1960.¹⁹
First published in Keyhole Mystery Magazine, August 1960.²⁰
Notes
1. R. A. Lafferty, “Long Teeth,” Keyhole Mystery Magazine 1, no. 3 (August 1960): 81–82. Carla’s speech ends at the top of p. 82. The magazine omits the additional sentence about Death shaking her head that appears in the longer reading used in the study notes. Back to text
2. “Long Teeth,” 81. Carla’s comparison opens the story. Charlotte varies it on p. 87. The phrase “froggish proverb” in the reading notes does not occur in the magazine. Back to text
3. “Long Teeth,” 82–85. The snake is in the whisky cabinet, the grandfather clock is destroyed, and Nicholas keeps replacing his black cat. The narrator numbers the cats Amenhotep I through IX. Back to text
4. “Long Teeth,” 85–87. The narrator leaves the cause of the fire open. Charlotte’s version of the proverb appears on p. 87, followed by Walter’s protest and Clinton’s assessment of it. Back to text
5. Andrew Ferguson, “40. Long Teeth,” Continued on Next Rock, June 27, 2013, https://ralafferty.tumblr.com/post/54070376467/40-long-teeth. Ferguson reports Lafferty’s remark about early mystery sales without identifying the occasion. Back to text
6. Ferguson, “40. Long Teeth,” final paragraph. See also Andrew Ferguson, “Unpublished Lafferty,” The New York Review of Science Fiction, no. 281 (January 2012): 1, 4–6, under “Mantis” in the section on novels. Back to text
7. G. K. Chesterton, The Man Who Was Thursday: A Nightmare (J. W. Arrowsmith, 1908), chaps. 14–15. Umberto Eco, The Name of the Rose, trans. William Weaver (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1983), “Seventh Day, Night” and “Last Page.” Back to text
8. Lafferty to Hiroshi Inoue, May 22, 1993, signed typescript letter, 1, penultimate paragraph. Lafferty has just discussed the relation of ghost stories to what he calls joyful entertainments. Back to text
9. Lafferty, “The Funny Face Murders,” in New Terrors Two, ed. Ramsey Campbell (Pan Books, 1980), 135–64. The comparison turns on Roy and Austro’s investigation and its ending. Back to text
10.Lafferty to Hiroshi Inoue, March 27, 1986, typescript letter, 2. Lafferty dates the writing of Archipelago to 1962 and The Devil Is Dead to 1963 and describes them as simultaneous novels. Back to text
11. Lafferty, Archipelago (Manuscript Press, 1979), 202–4, especially 203. The interval in the Texas chaparral contains dreams and parts of twelve years of another life. See also Lafferty, The Devil Is Dead (Avon Books, 1971), opening chapter, “Seaworthy and the Devil.” Back to text
12. Gregorio Montejo, “‘There Are Three Ways to Open a Secret Door’: R.A. Lafferty’s Bricolage Aesthetic,” in Feast of Laughter, vol. 4 (Ktistec Press, 2017), 106–9, 112. Montejo discusses the topology of the bottle and calls Finnegan an embodiment of it. Back to text
13. Archipelago, 202–4. For Lafferty’s own account of a break between chapters 10 and 11 of the companion novel, see his “Interglossia to The Devil Is Dead,” Is, no. 5 (1972): 16. The identification of the blackout with the crossing of the surface is Nelson’s. Back to text
14. “Long Teeth,” 81, 87. For an earlier use of the Möbius strip to describe narrative recurrence in Lafferty, see Andrew Ferguson, “R.A. Lafferty’s Escape from Flatland; or, How to Build a World in Three Easy Steps,” Science Fiction Studies 41, no. 3 (2014): 555. The application to the two generations of heirs is Nelson’s. Back to text
15. “Long Teeth,” 81–82 (Carla’s calculation), 82–85 (the attempts on Nicholas and the loss of Walter and Velma), 86–87 (the fire and Clinton’s inheritance), and 87 (Charlotte’s speech). The outline and the accompanying reading notes use a longer form of the opening proverb. Back to text
16. “Long Teeth,” 81, 87. Back to text
17. “Long Teeth,” 82, 85–87. The narrator introduces Clinton and Walter as Nicholas’s nephews and later places Walter Jr. in the couple’s care. Back to text
18. “Long Teeth,” 82–86. For Nicholas’s comments, see 83–84. For the investigation of the crash, see 85. For the deaths of Nicholas and Carla, see 86. Back to text
19. Lafferty, work-history card, “Long Teeth,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa, https://utulsa.as.atlas-sys.com/repositories/2/resources/197. The card gives 3,000 words, the April 4, 1959, submission to Mystery Digest, the February 20, 1960, submission to Keyhole, and the April 8 notice. Back to text
20. “Long Teeth,” 81–87. The August issue lists the story on its contents page. The Internet Speculative Fiction Database records reprints in The Early Lafferty (United Mythologies Press, 1988), beginning on p. 18, and The Man Who Never Was (Centipede Press, 2021), beginning on p. 209, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?69663. Back to text
Bibliography
Chesterton, G. K. The Man Who Was Thursday: A Nightmare. J. W. Arrowsmith, 1908.
Eco, Umberto. The Name of the Rose. Translated by William Weaver. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1983.
Ferguson, Andrew. “40. Long Teeth.” Continued on Next Rock, June 27, 2013. https://ralafferty.tumblr.com/post/54070376467/40-long-teeth.
Ferguson, Andrew. “R.A. Lafferty’s Escape from Flatland; or, How to Build a World in Three Easy Steps.” Science Fiction Studies 41, no. 3 (2014): 543–61.
—. “Unpublished Lafferty.” The New York Review of Science Fiction, no. 281 (January 2012): 1, 4–6.
Internet Speculative Fiction Database. “Long Teeth.” Accessed November 19, 2026. https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?69663.
Lafferty, R. A. Archipelago. Manuscript Press, 1979.
—. The Devil Is Dead. Avon Books, 1971.
—. “The Funny Face Murders.” In New Terrors Two, edited by Ramsey Campbell, 135–64. Pan Books, 1980.
—. “Interglossia to The Devil Is Dead.” Is, no. 5 (1972): 16–18.
—. Letters to Hiroshi Inoue. March 27, 1986, and May 22, 1993. Typescripts.
—. “Long Teeth.” Keyhole Mystery Magazine 1, no. 3 (August 1960): 81–87.
—. Work-history card no. 36, “Long Teeth.” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. https://utulsa.as.atlas-sys.com/repositories/2/resources/197.
Montejo, Gregorio. “‘There Are Three Ways to Open a Secret Door’: R.A. Lafferty’s Bricolage Aesthetic.” In Feast of Laughter, vol. 4, 31–135. Ktistec Press, 2017.


