"I Don't Like You"
Updated: 19 hours ago

“We do not even know what his character is,” said Doctor Fell. “Most men who sound vicious take out their viciousness vocally. And all of the sadists I have known, and I have known a great many in thirty years of police work, are mild of talk and appearance and inclined to banter. You will have to admit that Soapy Seeley is not what we might call a sterling character. A man of sterling character is not arrested two hundred plus either thirteen or fourteen times in ten years. And all of the arrests were not for drunkenness. He has gone on any number of violent binges. If he is crossed when he is very drunk he will use any weapon that is handy on anyone who is present. He once inflicted thirty-nine shallow stabs on a poor bum who happened to be drinking with him. He did this with a can opener that fortunately would not stab more than three-eighths of an inch deep. He did it in a sudden fury because the bum was taking too long to open a can of beer with it. He has used jagged wine bottles for weapons. He has used half bricks. He has beat up his last three landladies. Any number of times he has been guilty of breaking and entering. He has not been picked up as a molester, but we do not know that this was primarily a sex crime. And yet in a way I am sure that it was, and that this may be the answer to a line of them that curiously goes back ten years.”¹
This is another prenucleation Lafferty story that uses the police interrogation to pattern its plot. The title alludes to Dr. John Fell (1625–1686), best known now through Tom Brown’s English adaptation of Martial’s Epigram I.32 (“Non amo te, Sabidi, nec possum dicere quare . . .”). The original Latin says, in effect, “I don’t like you, Sabidius, and I can’t say why; I only know I don’t like you.” It was a reworking of Catullus.²
According to legend, the satirical Brown was a student at Christ Church, Oxford, where he faced expulsion by the dean, who was Dr. Fell. Fell offered to remit the punishment if Brown could produce an impromptu translation of a Martial epigram. Brown complied (maliciously) and turned it into a zinger aimed at Fell himself. In the familiar version: “I do not like thee, Doctor Fell, / The reason why I cannot tell; / But this I know, and know full well, / I do not like thee, Doctor Fell.”³
From there, it became a widely quoted piece of light verse, although the famous version differs from the text in Brown’s collected works.⁴ For a long time, “Dr. Fell” was a byword for an unaccountable, instinctive dislike.⁵ In “I Don’t Like You,” Lafferty gives the reader a Dr. Fell far more sinister than the historical figure.

The story’s main character is Soapy Seeley, a likable bum, arrested for the murder of Doris Dark, a crime we would now call overkill. Doris Dark was a young and attractive woman who was strangled. Her name is perhaps a play on Doris Day, a Catholic who swam the other way across the Tiber in the 1940s in becoming a Christian Scientist.⁷ Dark’s neck was broken and then she was stabbed many times. After a preliminary hearing, lawyer Joe Plunkett (who also appears in the unpublished "Milly")⁸ and police physician Dr. Charles Fell talk about the nature of identity and the probability of Seeley's guilt.
The evidence is damning. Soapy was at the victim's apartment after midnight. On his person were found Dark’s precious $100 bill and her key. Even worse, a blood-crusted jackknife with Soapy’s fingerprints is discovered under the victim's sofa.
Seeley says the knife belongs to him, even offering to identify the prints (he knows his own), but he also says he was drunk and has no memory of the night's events, except for two certitudes: he knows he did not wake up where he fell asleep, and, before that, he knows he cut his hand on his knife while trying to open a wine bottle. He is pretty sure he will be hanged for the crime and makes a bet with Plunkett about the outcome of the case.⁹
The investigation advances. There is more interrogation of Seeley. There are interviews with the victim's acquaintances. Junie Gogarty describes Dark as a young woman who was kind to lowlifes like Seeley. She says that Seeley often slept in Dark's room when intoxicated. Dr. Fell browbeats Seeley at one point, setting up the allusion that gives the story its title:
"You are a sponger and a leacher and a drunkard. You have never had any regard for anyone but yourself. You will take anything from anybody, even a life, to gratify yourself. You are as sane as a Solon and as mean as the devil. You have committed the most dastardly murder I have ever encountered and you will pay for it to the extreme. You are the most despicable criminal I have ever encountered." "Doc, I don't like you either."¹⁰
Dr. Fell has one odd peculiarity, though: a defective left eye that never fully opens or closes, which Seeley sees as a sign of insanity. He knows this because he once enrolled in a correspondence course on medical matters. A witness from across the hall next testifies that she heard the voice of a "smooth-talking dude" in the room that night. Although Lieutenant Rich assumes she has identified Seeley, the witness questions that assumption: are they "talking about the same dude?" It turns out the voice heard was Dr. Fell's.¹¹
The story ends with Dr. Fell confessing to the murder of Doris Dark. He followed her home, found Seeley asleep on her sofa, and pushed Seeley’s knife under the sofa and planted Dark’s key and money on him before carrying the bum to a nearby alley. Fell says that, after returning and sleeping on the sofa, he killed Dark and stabbed her with his own knife after she looked at him with contempt and rejected his advances. The story closes with a dark little coda highlighting the bitter irony of Fell's institutional fate versus Seeley's:
But in a way Soapy did not have the last laugh. For the doctor is still alive and well and minds his pleasant confinement not at all. He writes up notes on fanciful medical and psychiatric cases, and he talks at great length to the other patients; for he is indeed a smooth-talking old dude. And Soapy Seeley suffered an unfortunate hanging two years later when he mistreated unto death with a broken bottle a fellow bum in the after-midnight hours.¹²
Soapy Seeley is one of Lafferty’s more distinctive characters—a man of low character who is at the same time absolutely honest. One of the funnier moments in an unpublished Lafferty story happens when we read about Soapy’s violent past, including his stabbing of another bum. We find Lafferty’s fixation with eyes, before he developed his technique of noetic darkening (no counterfiguration here), in the half-shut left eye of Dr. Fell, which indicates his madness.
As in several of the early mysteries, Lafferty’s murders of women are sexual homicides, but he chose to write around the fact, making it a feature of the deep background that is perhaps difficult to see. It is apparently the case that Dr. Fell is, long before “serial killer” became a familiar term, a serial-killing sexual psychopath who gets soft treatment because he is crazy, while the comparatively mensch-like Soapy Seeley is not.¹³ The suspicion of psychology is a deep theme in the Ghost Story.
In general, Lafferty’s stories treat this as a fundamental suspicion: the profession trades in the same commodity as the confidence trickster. It makes people believe things about themselves. Sometimes this is literal, as when Dr. Steinhard turns out to be a con man named Charley O’Malley running the "Pygmalion Clean-out" ("Johnny Crookedhouse"), or when a psychoanalyst splits fees with a crooked well-driller who creates psychosis by draining buildings of their psychic underlay ("Dig a Crooked Hole").¹⁴
More often, it is a plot device that orders the story. The doctor in "Beautiful Dreamer" defines his role as an enforcer of "careful credulity." The agreed-upon world must be propped up: "The Scatterbrain may be only another name for a wide-ranging intuitive comprehension."¹⁵
Psychologists tend to be bunglers. They misinterpret a science writer working outside his window as suicidal ("Fall of Pebble-Stones"), diagnose in a way that misses the point ("The Hole on the Corner"), and refer endlessly up the professional chain. We get a sequence of analysts who analyze the analysts who analyze the analysts, a loop with no exit to reality ("The Hole on the Corner," "Splinters").¹⁶ Lafferty’s character Joe Spade seems pretty close to Lafferty himself when he talks about a "head-grifter," an "anapsychologist" ("Hog-Belly Honey").¹⁷
At the same time, Lafferty is not completely hostile to psychology. After all, he wants to explore it in his turn-it-inside-out way. There seems to be some respect for practitioners who exceed their profession, who are, in the language of "Make Sure the Eyes Are Big Enough," phenomenal in both senses. The phenomenal psychologists in that story take the perception of other-dimensional beings seriously. They record these observations. Dr. Lollie Lindwurm suggests that some of the entities are "angelic messengers ascending and descending on Jacob's Ladder."¹⁸
Another figure in Lafferty who isn’t treated completely negatively is the trilobal James Riddle in "Dorg," who, half-mad and horn-rimmed, has a third brain lobe and proposes truths normal psychology cannot reach. The five (or six) "psychologs" of "In Outraged Stone" throw themselves into anthropological fieldwork with vigor, even if there is judgment there. The unnamed psychiatrist in "McGonigal's Worm" investigates rather than explains away.¹⁹ Psychologists in Lafferty can get at least partly on the cranky one’s side by being open to life and capable of astonishment.
Unsurprisingly, at the base is a coherent Catholic anthropology. If everyone is already mad (in Catholic talk, “disordered”)—"I have never known a single human whom I could call unqualifiedly sane" ("Beautiful Dreamer")²⁰—then the profession's claim to define and police disorder is a boondoggle. One thinks here of Albert's credo in "Eurema's Dam": "Were we all well adjusted, we would ossify and die. The world is kept healthy only by some of the unhealthy minds lurking in it."²¹
Lafferty's angriest demonstrations of this principle show entire societies classifying sanity as a disease. These are all those coded traditionalists whose coding points toward the Christian tradition. We see this in “And Mad Undancing Bears” (fish clan, Clovis, Francis, Cluny, Trent).²² Catholic anthropology gets called berserking in a world of noise. Sometimes this shows up in a story as just getting it wrong: automobile drivers are hunted as incurably insane by Lafferty’s trolley utopia in one of his greatest stories, "Interurban Queen.”²³
Lafferty, of course, was much more open to Jung than to Freud, but he is quick to qualify Jung. We are told that Jung’s depth psychology contains "the shadow, but not the substance" of the truth ("The Hole on the Corner").²⁴ Jung is, at best, a door into realities outside his own system ("Episodes of the Argo," "In the Turpentine Trees").²⁵
Freud fares badly. To give two examples, Freud is one of the secular-liberal saints in "The Forty-Seventh Island."²⁶ Edmund Weakfish, in Lafferty’s complicated, very great "Mud Violet," causes the Freudian accidents.²⁷ The implication seems to be that Weakfish, who teaches participation psychology and is an incarnation of the Putty Dwarf (we can argue about this), imposes a counter, half-formed imago Dei on his charges. He is a weak fish (anti-Christos) rather than a strong fish (Christos). His gospel is what the story calls hylicon.
The story shows Lafferty using idioms brilliantly and has some of the best verbal texture of the unpublished short stories. More importantly, perhaps, is that it is an anxiety dream about what alcohol does to selfhood and moral agency. Like Finnegan, Soapy has blackouts, but Soapy's blackouts make him unable to distinguish himself from a murderer:
"I wish I knew, I wish I knew. It's the most damnable thing I ever heard of. She's about the only one in the neighborhood I haven't sometimes wanted to see dead. I hope the rope breaks three times so they can keep hanging me over and over for it."²⁸
He can't account for the blood, the key, the hundred-dollar bill, or his movements. Early in the story, Plunkett outlines a "toy philosophy" of sleep that serves as the perfect metaphor for a drunk's epistemology:
"But when you are asleep or when you are just going to sleep or awakening you do not seem to have any particular identity. It is as though one drop which is you fell into a big bowl of water which is everybody. Then when you awaken it is a drop drawn out again and given back to you. But you cannot be sure it is the same drop. We may in a small measure be different persons every day of our lives. And is anyone entirely responsible for what he did the day before?"²⁹
If you dissolve your identity every night in alcohol, you cannot guarantee what reconstitutes in the morning. Or something like that. This is a serious moment of iconographic insetting from a writer who was obsessed with the nature of memory, amnesia, both retrograde and anterograde; one probably afraid of "wet brain" (we find evidence of this fear of Korsakoff syndrome in Archipelago),³⁰ and one who could imagine a world where he ended up a rummy had he not returned to writing.³¹
I remember someone saying online years ago that dissociation in Lafferty is a result of Lafferty’s own alcoholism. That was quickly shot down by a Lafferty apologist, who was right that it was too monocausal. That much conceded, however, the non-apologist had a point. Memory, dissociation, and boozing are cousins in Lafferty, with early examples of the schizo-gash closely linked to alcohol consumption and the tavern. For instance, we see this in 1957’s “Cabrito.”³²
One of the more intense lines of “I Don’t Like You” comes from Plunkett. He says that Soapy is responsible for whatever he bought when he put his dollar on the counter at the Port-In-Any-Storm bar. Soapy himself goes from stabbing a bum who couldn’t get a beer open fast enough to hurting himself with a knife and finally to murdering someone.³³




Bibliographical Note
Unpublished. Written in fall 1957, according to Lafferty’s work card, which gives a length of 5,000 words.³⁴
The card records submission to Scott Meredith on November 23, 1957, and return on December 12. Subsequent entries trace submissions to mystery and general-interest magazines through 1960.³⁵
Notes
1. R. A. Lafferty, “I Don’t Like You,” unpublished story, fall 1957, Fell’s account of Soapy’s arrests. Quotations from this story follow the transcription in my research files. Subsequent references identify the scene. Back to text
2. Martial, Epigrams 1.32, ed. and trans. D. R. Shackleton Bailey, vol. 1 (Harvard University Press, 1993). My paraphrase. For the echo of Catullus, Carmina 85, see Lindsay C. Watson, “Bassa’s Borborysms: On Martial and Catullus,” Antichthon 37 (2003), n. 37. Back to text
3. Patricia Watson, “‘I do not love thee Dr Fell’: Tom Brown’s Reception of Martial,” International Journal of the Classical Tradition 25, no. 4 (2018): 355. The Oxford anecdote is also recorded in the Dictionary of National Biography, s.v. “Brown, Thomas (1663–1704).” Back to text
4. Thomas Brown, The Fourth Volume of the Works of Mr Thomas Brown (London, 1709), 51, cited in Patricia Watson, “Tom Brown’s Reception of Martial,” 355 and n. 1. The collected version uses “love you” and has shorter middle lines. Back to text
5. See Robert Louis Stevenson, Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (Longmans, Green, 1886), 25, where Utterson invokes Dr. Fell after meeting Hyde. Back to text
6. The printed caption credits Photofest (p. 20). Back to text
7. Doris Day, with A. E. Hotchner, Doris Day: Her Own Story (William Morrow, 1976), 87–88. Back to text
8. R. A. Lafferty, “Milly,” unpublished typescript, fall 1957, 10, 18, series 2, box 17, folder 8, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text
9. “I Don’t Like You,” Soapy’s wager with Plunkett and his account of the cut on his hand. Back to text
10. Fell’s accusation and Soapy’s reply. Back to text
11. Soapy’s correspondence course and the witness’s identification of the voice. Back to text
12. Fell’s confession and the final two paragraphs. Back to text
13. On the later currency of “serial killer,” see Phillip L. Simpson, “Serial Killing and Representation,” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice, July 27, 2017. “Sexual psychopath” was already in use when Lafferty wrote. See Deborah W. Denno, “Life Before the Modern Sex Offender Statutes,” Northwestern University Law Review 92, no. 4 (1998), pt. III. Back to text
14. Lafferty, “Johnny Crookedhouse,” unpublished story, fall 1957, the exposure of Dr. Steinhard as Charley O’Malley. See also Lafferty, “Dig a Crooked Hole,” unpublished story, July 1, 1976, the well-driller’s account of the fee arrangement. Back to text
15. Lafferty, “Beautiful Dreamer,” Shock, September 1960, 95 (“careful credulity”), 94 (“Scatterbrain”). Back to text
16. R. A. Lafferty, “Fall of Pebble-Stones” and “The Hole on the Corner,” in Lafferty in Orbit (Broken Mirrors Press, 1991), 169 and 53–54, respectively. For the analysts in “Splinters,” see Shadows, ed. Charles L. Grant (Doubleday, 1978), 63–75. Back to text
17. Lafferty, “Hog-Belly Honey,” The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, September 1965, 95. Back to text
18. Lafferty, “Make Sure the Eyes Are Big Enough,” in Golden Gate and Other Stories (Corroboree Press, 1982), 167–80, Lollie Lindwurm’s exchange with the lizard-faced speaker. For Jacob’s dream, see Genesis 28:12. Back to text
19. Lafferty, “Dorg,” in Lafferty in Orbit, 185–86, 188. For the two investigations, see Lafferty, “In Outraged Stone,” in Frontiers 1: Tomorrow’s Alternatives, ed. Roger Elwood (Collier Books, 1973), 169–89, and “McGonigal’s Worm,” If, November 1960, 60. Back to text
20. “Beautiful Dreamer,” 94. Back to text
21. Lafferty, “Eurema’s Dam,” in New Dimensions II, ed. Robert Silverberg (Doubleday, 1972), 67–81, Albert’s speech at the awards dinner. Back to text
22. R. A. Lafferty, “And Mad Undancing Bears,” in The Berserkers, ed. Roger Elwood (Trident Press, 1974), 92–109, the Catholic names and places in the Bears’ history. Back to text
23. Lafferty, “Interurban Queen,” in Lafferty in Orbit, 207–8. Back to text
24. “The Hole on the Corner,” in Lafferty in Orbit, 56. Back to text
25. Compare Lafferty, “Episodes of the Argo,” in Episodes of the Argo (United Mythologies Press, 1990), 7–43, and “In the Turpentine Trees,” in Four Stories, Drumm Booklet no. 7 (Chris Drumm, 1983), 9–18, the episode with Anima. Back to text
26. R. A. Lafferty, “The Forty-Seventh Island,” in Basilisk, ed. Ellen Kushner (Ace Books, 1980), sec. 5, Frederik’s list of planets. Back to text
27. Lafferty, “Mud Violet,” in Demon Kind, ed. Roger Elwood (Avon, 1973), 17–41, the opening account of hylicon and the deaths of Weakfish’s students. Back to text
28. “I Don’t Like You,” Soapy’s reply when asked why he killed Doris Dark. Back to text
29. Plunkett’s conversation with Fell about sleep and identity, before the first account of the murder hearing. Back to text
30. R. A. Lafferty, Archipelago (Manuscript Press, 1979), chap. 10, “Distressed Merchandise,” sec. 1, 243–44. Finnegan names his condition on 244. Back to text
31. R. A. Lafferty, Past Master (Garland, 1975), unnumbered author’s note following 191. Lafferty recalls taking up writing when he cut down on drinking. Back to text
32. R. A. Lafferty, “Cabrito,” in Funnyfingers & Cabrito (Pendragon Press, 1976), 33–45, the fetches in the taberna. Back to text
33. “I Don’t Like You,” Plunkett’s lunch with his wife, Fell’s account of the can opener, Soapy’s account of his cut hand, and the final paragraph. Back to text
34. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “I Don’t Like You,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. The heading gives the length as 5,000 words and dates composition to fall 1957. Back to text
35. Work card. The Scott Meredith entry runs from November 23 to December 12, 1957. Later entries include Manhunt, March 7–26, 1959, and Tightrope, April 16–July 27, 1960. Back to text
Bibliography
Brown, Thomas. The Fourth Volume of the Works of Mr Thomas Brown. London, 1709. Cited in Patricia Watson, “‘I do not love thee Dr Fell’: Tom Brown’s Reception of Martial,” 355 n. 1.
Catullus, Gaius Valerius. Carmina. Edited by R. A. B. Mynors. Clarendon Press, 1958.
Day, Doris, with A. E. Hotchner. Doris Day: Her Own Story. William Morrow, 1976.
Denno, Deborah W. “Life Before the Modern Sex Offender Statutes.” Northwestern University Law Review 92, no. 4 (1998): 1317–1413.
Dictionary of National Biography. Edited by Leslie Stephen. Vol. 7. Smith, Elder, 1886. S.v. “Brown, Thomas (1663–1704).”
Lafferty, R. A. “And Mad Undancing Bears.” In The Berserkers, edited by Roger Elwood, 92–109. Trident Press, 1974.
Lafferty, R. A. Archipelago. Manuscript Press, 1979.
Lafferty, R. A. “Beautiful Dreamer.” Shock, September 1960, 90–96.
Lafferty, R. A. “Cabrito.” In Funnyfingers & Cabrito, 33–45. Pendragon Press, 1976.
Lafferty, R. A. “Dig a Crooked Hole.” Unpublished story, July 1, 1976.
Lafferty, R. A. “Dorg.” In Orbit 10, edited by Damon Knight, 173–84. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1972.
Lafferty, R. A. “Episodes of the Argo.” In Episodes of the Argo, 7–43. United Mythologies Press, 1990.
Lafferty, R. A. “Eurema’s Dam.” In New Dimensions II, edited by Robert Silverberg, 67–81. Doubleday, 1972.
Lafferty, R. A. “Fall of Pebble-Stones.” In Orbit 19, edited by Damon Knight, 82–94. Harper & Row, 1977.
Lafferty, R. A. “The Forty-Seventh Island.” In Basilisk, edited by Ellen Kushner, 65–95. Ace Books, 1980.
Lafferty, R. A. “Hog-Belly Honey.” The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, September 1965, 95–102.
Lafferty, R. A. “The Hole on the Corner.” In Orbit 2, edited by Damon Knight, 212–27. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1967.
Lafferty, R. A. “I Don’t Like You.” Unpublished story, fall 1957. Transcription in my research files.
Lafferty, R. A. “In Outraged Stone.” In Frontiers 1: Tomorrow’s Alternatives, edited by Roger Elwood, 169–89. Collier Books, 1973.
Lafferty, R. A. “In the Turpentine Trees.” In Four Stories, 9–18. Drumm Booklet no. 7. Chris Drumm, 1983.
Lafferty, R. A. “Interurban Queen.” In Orbit 8, edited by Damon Knight, 184–94. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1970.
Lafferty, R. A. “Johnny Crookedhouse.” Unpublished story, fall 1957.
Lafferty, R. A. Lafferty in Orbit. Broken Mirrors Press, 1991.
Lafferty, R. A. “Make Sure the Eyes Are Big Enough.” In Golden Gate and Other Stories, 167–80. Corroboree Press, 1982.
Lafferty, R. A. “McGonigal’s Worm.” If, November 1960, 54–61.
Lafferty, R. A. “Milly.” Unpublished typescript, fall 1957. Series 2, box 17, folder 8. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lafferty, R. A. “Mud Violet.” In Demon Kind, edited by Roger Elwood, 17–41. Avon, 1973.
Lafferty, R. A. Past Master. Garland, 1975.
Lafferty, R. A. “Splinters.” In Shadows, edited by Charles L. Grant, 63–75. Doubleday, 1978.
Lafferty, R. A. Work card, “I Don’t Like You.” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Series 2, box 25. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Martial. Epigrams. Edited and translated by D. R. Shackleton Bailey. Vol. 1. Harvard University Press, 1993.
Simpson, Phillip L. “Serial Killing and Representation.” In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice. Oxford University Press, 2017.
Stevenson, Robert Louis. Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. Longmans, Green, 1886.
Watson, Lindsay C. “Bassa’s Borborysms: On Martial and Catullus.” Antichthon 37 (2003): 1–12.
Watson, Patricia. “‘I do not love thee Dr Fell’: Tom Brown’s Reception of Martial.” International Journal of the Classical Tradition 25, no. 4 (2018): 355–61.


