"Oh Whatta You Do When the Well Runs Dry?" (1974/1984) & "Fall of Pebble-Stones" (1974/1977)
Updated: Nov 9

"Fall, at Pel-et-Der (L'Aube), France, June 6, 1890, of limestone pebbles. Identified with limestone at Château-Landon—or up and down in a whirlwind. But they fell with hail—which, in June, could not very well be identified with ice from Château-Landon. Coincidence, perhaps." — Charles Fort, The Book of the Damned (1919), citing La Nature, 1890-2-127
Forteans today.
In “Oh Whatta You Do When the Well Runs Dry?” the world is thrown into chaos when the well of all human creativity, wit, and inspiration suddenly runs dry on November 7, 1999. Society begins to collapse into a witless stupor, and a group of the world's most brilliant leaders convenes. And is stumped. They are powerless, cut off from the source of the kind of ingenuity needed to solve the crisis, but the solution eventually comes from a group of Forteans, who explain that humanity had merely depleted its own small, isolated compartment of a much larger cosmic well.
By breaking down the barriers and merging humanity's dry basin with another potent, wild, raunchy source, they restore creativity to the world. There is a cost: humanity is transformed, now permanently drawing from a shared, chaotic wellspring that, a final note in the story reveals, dictates the nature of our own consciousness.
This belongs among Lafferty’s Fortean tales, alongside "Sky," "Fall of Pebble-Stones," "When All the Lands Pour Out Again," "Bequest of Wings," "Symposium," "Scorner’s Seat," and the novella Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis? Charles Fort’s Super Sargasso Sea, introduced in The Book of the Damned, provides a useful comparison for their stores of lost or excluded things. “Fall of Pebble-Stones” never names Fort, but its unexplained falls make the connection especially close.
In “Pebble-Stones,” Bill Sorel is a feature writer with a reputation for stirring things up. He has just won what he calls “the big red plum,” the chance to compile The Child’s Big What and Why Book. He just has to provide simple but true answers to children’s most puzzling questions, such as “Why does a baseball curve?” and “How do the pebbles get under the eaves?” This is quite unlike the old definition of philosophy: asking questions like a child but giving answers like a lawyer.
Sorel throws pebbles from his nineteenth-floor window while trading theories with his neighbor Etta Mae. She’s full of imaginative, non-scientific, non-philosophical explanations, like lightning-fused sand and even somebody who makes pebbles appear so Sorel can keep throwing them. Sorel dismisses her story about Mrs. Justex, but the narration treats some accepted scientific explanations as equally “kind of doubty.” This is all very Fortean.
Sorel visits George “Cow-Path” Daylight, a small-town pitcher, and his granddaughter Susie “Corn-Flower.” Using an onion, Cow-Path offers a gyroscopic explanation of a baseball’s curve, which Sorel accepts. Susie supplies the answer to his other question: “The pebble angel puts the pebbles directly into the eaves-drop ditch.” A week later, Sorel chooses her explanation for his book and mails it in the rain. His ledge then yields pebbles faster than he can throw them. The neighborhood cop joins him, and Sorel says, “The pebble angel is showing that he likes the mention.”
Over the weekend, I read a very fun and appropriately untrustworthy book on Fort that I would recommend, Colin Bennett’s Politics of the Imagination: The Life, Work and Ideas of Charles Fort (2010). Fort, an early 20th-century writer—let’s be generous and call him a researcher—devoted his life to gathering lists of these anomalies, mocking science for its rejection of outliers and disconfirming data. In The Book of the Damned, Fort fills page after page with wonders, poking and picking at the libido dominandi of the scientists.
"I do not say that the data of the damned should have the same rights as the data of the saved. That would be justice. That would be of the Positive Absolute, and, though the ideal of, a violation of, the very essence of quasi-existence, wherein only to have the appearance of being is to express a preponderance of force one way or another—or inequilibrium, or inconsistency, or injustice. Our acceptance is that the passing away of exclusionism is a phenomenon of the twentieth century: that gods of the twentieth century will sustain our notions be they ever so unwashed and frowsy. But, in our own expressions, we are limited, by the oneness of quasiness, to the very same methods by which orthodoxy established and maintains its now sleek, suave preposterousnesses. At any rate, though we are inspired by an especial subtle essence—or imponderable, I think—that pervades the twentieth century, we have not the superstition that we are offering anything as a positive fact. Rather often we have not the delusion that we're any less superstitious and credulous than any logician, savage, curator, or rustic."
While Fort had quirky things to say about the real Sargasso Sea, one obsessive subject in his work was the Super Sargasso Sea, a hidden, cosmic reservoir where lost objects, creatures, and mysteries gathered before sometimes falling back into our world: frogs, fish, red dust, gelatinous matter, pebbles, and so on. As Fort put it, “I accept that, when there are storms, the damnedest of excluded, excommunicated things—things that are leprous to the faithful—are brought down—from the Super-Sargasso Sea—or from what for convenience we call the Super-Sargasso Sea—which by no means has been taken into full acceptance yet.”
And if by damned things, Fort meant all the observations cast out by science, an awful lot of it drew from the Super Sargasso Sea: rains of frogs, lights adrift in the sky, gelatinous objects falling from nowhere. The data of the damned. These are the pebbles Susie Corn-Flower’s angel drops into our world. In “Pebble-Stones,” Lafferty reverses the miracle: Fort’s damned is Lafferty’s blessed, holy gift.
“Fall of Pebble-Stones” gives Fort’s excluded phenomena a guardian angel. In the other tales, Lafferty extends the reservoir of strange objects into a source of thought itself.
I read that extension alongside Pierre Teilhard de Chardin’s noosphere: the sphere of human thought and shared mental life within his account of evolution. The comparison helps connect Lafferty’s physical reservoirs with his interest in collective consciousness.
Teilhard’s noosphere belongs to an evolution directed toward the Omega Point. Lafferty’s stories give shared thought a more unruly physical setting, sometimes placing its source in the sky. In “Well Runs Dry,” the explicit term is the Collective Unconscious.
We see the underlying logic in The Elliptical Grave (1977/1989), where the excavation takes place in the air; we see it in Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?, where the mirages of Fort's New Lands (1924) combine with the appearance of the land mass and the Fortean Object/weapon in the sky; and we see it strongly at work in "Oh, Whatta You Do When the Well Runs Dry?"
The story makes creativity depend on a shared supply that humanity has overdrawn while reducing its nonhuman contributors. The Forteans reveal that only one compartment has failed. They replenish it from a part of the well the human leaders had refused to share. The cure restores thought and changes its character.
Of course, Lafferty often has more up his sleeve, which makes this story even more fun. November 7 was Lafferty’s birthday. He liked to tell people—though not quite accurately—that he stopped writing on his seventieth, November 7, 1984, as if that day marked the well running dry. In other words, he made the image of the well’s exhaustion in the story, written over a decade earlier, part of his own biography. But the actual story’s "sky note" ending places its November 7 in the forgotten past, which means the source of all Lafferty’s wild imagination is a pre-birthday in an earlier cycle.
“We haven’t any particular wells or fountains of our own. We draw it all from the same unsanitary and common pool.”




Some notes on the non-footnote:

Bibliographical Note
Oh Whatta You Do When the Well Runs Dry?
Lafferty’s work-history card records completion on October 25, 1974, and submission to Virginia Kidd the same day. It records a sale in Dutch.
First published in Dutch in Dagen van gras, dagen van stro (1979); first published in English in Ringing Changes (Ace Books, 1984).
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Oh Whatta You Do When the Well Runs Dry?,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa; Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “Oh Whatta You Do When the Well Runs Dry?,” https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?58345.
Fall of Pebble-Stones
Lafferty’s work-history card records completion on June 19, 1974, and a sale to Damon Knight for Orbit.
First published in Orbit 19, edited by Damon Knight (Harper & Row, 1977).
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Fall of Pebble-Stones,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa; Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “Fall of Pebble-Stones,” https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?69689.


