"Milly" (1957)
Updated: 10 hours ago

The objective truth as such, is by no means adequate to determine that whoever utters it is sane; on the contrary, it may even betray the fact that he is mad, although what he says may be entirely true, and especially objectively true. I shall here permit myself to tell a story, which without any sort of adaptation on my part comes direct from an asylum.² — Søren Kierkegaard, Concluding Unscientific Postscript (1846)
Like a handful of other Lafferty stories, “Milly” is not included in the most recent The Man Who Talled Tales. That is a shame. It is a very fun story. In 2013, Andrew Ferguson wrote about it and pointed out the alliterative names. He also noted that Virginia Kidd once remarked on this habit in Lafferty’s work. After that, Lafferty seems to have toned it down.³ I am thankful for Kidd’s comment. It probably pushed Lafferty to become even more creative with the names he gave his characters. His character naming is one of the best tools we have for understanding his work.
“Milly” uses the murder mystery format to examine perception, causality, and the friction between logical systems and human experience. It has excellent dialogue. It's a satire of the “whodunit.”
It all begins with a strange greeting card verse about a “happy appendectomy.” From there, Lafferty puts a deeply detached anthropologist at the center of the crime, armed with essentials like Guelf’s Cephalic Tables and Sweet’s Slang Dictionary. This anthropologist is not interested in murder, but in the kind of young woman who writes greeting cards and thinks like his ancient and capricious Aunt Agatha Asquith.⁴ The typical, lurid, and trashy parts of a normal mystery story get short-circuited because “Milly” is a mystery story that refuses to get in line.
Take an uninspired interrogation scene from an average piece of Alfred Hitchcock Presents or Ellery Queen. The detective asks smart questions. The suspect gives slippery answers. Clues fall into place. In “Milly,” it does not work that way. The following interrogation shows what kind of game Lafferty is playing.
“Did you kill the girl?” “Of course I didn’t. I never kill people.” “Do you know who did?” “I believe so. Since she could hardly have done it herself I believe it must have been a third person.” “Would it be asking too much if you know the name of the third person?” “No. I have no way of knowing that.” “She was dead when you arrived?” “Yes. Recently but conclusively so.” “Then why didn’t you do something about it?” “I am a scientist, in my opinion a very clever one. But resurrecting the dead doesn’t come within my field. When it is infrequently done it is more likely to be done by a religious or a mystic than by a scientist of any sort. I didn’t do anything about it because there was nothing I could do about it.”⁵
The story’s driving force is the man being questioned, the anthropologist Dugglesby Dunham, whose déformation professionnelle blinds him to normal social and ethical standards. When he finds Milly’s body, he shows no horror and no sense of civic responsibility. He follows only the methods of his research. He treats her body as a set of data, using calipers to measure her head and recording a “cephalic index of seventy-eight.” The narrator observes that “there is something very contrary about a dead girl when you try to stand her up to weigh her and measure her.”⁶ His detachment reaches a high point during the police interrogation and starts to weaken slightly afterwards.
His opponent is a crude lieutenant named Eric Spoormand (the real killer), who eats peanuts while questioning him. Earlier, Dugglesby justifies his research to Willy Wrackman with an analogy: “How often will a policeman phone an anthropologist when he sees an interesting type in the course of his day’s work? You would be surprised how seldom.”⁷
Dugglesby is one of Lafferty’s caricatures of the person who sees the world only as a collection of facts. The binding normative force that guides most people does not move Dugglesby Dunham.
The story concerns flawed perception, with a group of characters who have names like Clandestine Carney and Shoo-Shoo Schoengeist. A typical mystery moves forward by uncovering facts. This story moves forward by building up mistakes. The “handle” needed to solve the case is eventually pieced together from three conflicting descriptions of Dugglesby: to Clandestine, he is a “sweet little red-headed man”; to Shoo-Shoo, a “crude little greaser”; and to the greeting card printer, an old Phoenician, he is a “big buff man, sort of a cowboy type.”⁸
Even Dugglesby, the trained observer, joins in this confusion. He misreads the girls’ screams of terror as a cultural ritual and writes in his report that women of their “vagrant type” “greet each other with loud screaming.”⁹ In this early and light story, there is already a trace of Lafferty’s interest in consensus reality, where what people accept as real is often made up of shared misunderstandings. Solutions come from both secrets and anti-secrets, from seeing the mixed-up and hidden patterns inside these collective mistakes.
When thinking about this story, I realized that something at work in much of Lafferty’s writing is what we might call the principle of disproportionate causality, where huge and deadly results come from small and unimportant causes. He enjoys this kind of setup. The motive for the murder comes down to the greeting card verses Milly sends. Spoormand says he thought he was “in trouble with her.” One of the verses she sends him is:
I’m sure we’ll be happy, And don’t say it’s not done, Cause I’ve got a pappy, And he’s got a shot gun.¹⁰
Spoormand, who wanted to marry someone with money, found the greeting card verses unbearably irritating (“there ought to be a law against writing verses like that with a needle in them”). One of the better moments in the story comes after the girls send Dugglesby a fan letter in verse (“We never met a murderer before”) and Clandestine asks for tickets to his execution. In the final lines, Clandestine reveals that the “Happy Appendectomy” verse—which had so fascinated Dugglesby and led him to research Milly—was actually hers, not Milly’s. She ends by saying, “You come with me, Dugs, you have your girls mixed. That was one of mine I traded to her. Milly couldn’t write an iamb to save her life.”¹¹
“Milly” uses a reversed mystery structure to mock misplaced logic in a world where illogical things happen because people themselves are illogical—something anthropologist Dugglesby Dunham seems to have overlooked in his studies. Dunham helps solve the crime by questioning how Spoormand traced him from three incompatible descriptions. A mix of mistaken perceptions and Dugglesby’s memory of the smell of peanuts ends up solving the crime.¹² Mostly unread, yellowed, and boxed up in Tulsa, “Milly” is another Lafferty story that deserves to be printed.





Bibliographical Note
Unpublished. Written in fall 1957, according to Lafferty’s work card.¹⁸
The card records submission to Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine on December 13, 1957, and return on January 7, 1958. Subsequent entries document submissions to other mystery and general-interest magazines through 1960.¹⁹
Notes
1. R. A. Lafferty, “Milly,” unpublished typescript, fall 1957, 1, series 2, box 17, folder 8, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Page numbers refer to the typescript. Back to text
2. Søren Kierkegaard, Kierkegaard’s Concluding Unscientific Postscript, trans. David F. Swenson, completed by Walter Lowrie (Princeton University Press for the American-Scandinavian Foundation, 1941), 174. The Danish original appeared under the name Johannes Climacus in 1846. Back to text
3. Andrew Ferguson, “10. Milly,” Continued on Next Rock, March 17, 2013, para. 2 (Kidd on alliteration) and para. 3 (Dugglesby as a “kind (if oblivious) soul”). Back to text
4. Lafferty, “Milly,” 1–3. Back to text
5. 7. Back to text
6. 4. Back to text
7. 9 (Spoormand and the peanuts), 18 (his confession), 7 (Wrackman and Dugglesby’s analogy). Back to text
8. 12 (Clandestine), 11 (Shoo-Shoo), 16 (the printer), 17 (Dugglesby compares their accounts). Back to text
9. 5. Back to text
10. 13–14 (Clandestine’s account of the three verses), 18 (Spoormand’s confession). Back to text
11. 18 (Spoormand’s remark), 11 (the fan letter), 12, 14, 17 (the request for tickets, its repetition, and its withdrawal), 19 (Clandestine’s closing speech). Back to text
12. 16–18. Plunkett offers the peanuts. Dugglesby remembers their smell in Milly’s room. Spoormand admits he copied Dugglesby’s name and address from one of his notebooks. Back to text
13. 11–12, 15–18. The descriptions come from Shoo-Shoo, Clandestine, and the printer. Spoormand admits copying the name and address from one of Dugglesby’s notebooks. Back to text
14. 15–17. The printer says the visitor he described to the lieutenant was the professor. Dugglesby connects the smell with the presence he sensed in the room. Back to text
15. 13–14, 18. Clandestine recounts the exchange of verses. Spoormand gives his account after Dugglesby and Plunkett identify him. Back to text
16. 1–3, 19. Back to text
17. 19. Back to text
18. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “Milly,” series 2, box 25, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text
19. Work card and handwritten submission record, “Milly,” box 17, folder 8. For the submission to Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine, the handwritten record gives February 14, 1958, and the card gives February 24. Back to text
Bibliography
Ferguson, Andrew. “10. Milly.” Continued on Next Rock, March 17, 2013.
Kierkegaard, Søren. Afsluttende uvidenskabelig Efterskrift til de philosophiske Smuler. Published under the name Johannes Climacus. C. A. Reitzel, 1846.
Kierkegaard, Søren. Kierkegaard’s Concluding Unscientific Postscript. Translated by David F. Swenson, completed with an introduction and notes by Walter Lowrie. Princeton University Press for the American-Scandinavian Foundation, 1941.
Lafferty, R. A. “Milly.” Unpublished typescript, fall 1957. 19 numbered pages and a separate handwritten submission record. Series 2, box 17, folder 8. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lafferty, R. A. Work card, “Milly.” Series 2, box 25. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


