top of page
Search

"One Minute Before" (1960)

Feb 19
7 min read

Updated: Nov 8

Philip Henry Gosse seated in a dark suit, with one hand resting on a book.
Philip Henry Gosse (1810-1888)

"Yes. The creator could save himself a lot of trouble by setting beginning very near the end. He could make it all its mementos and history and cosmic evidence whenever he chose, or as late as he chose." "Yes. He could make it all at the last moment, all complete, and who would know the difference? He could make it between the moment that he had Gabriel set lip to horn, and the moment that he sounded that last (and only) note." "And if he cut it fine enough?"
“What is going on with him? He is tampering with the flow of the world’s events and circumstances. That is what is going on with him. He is tampering with the nature of reality . . . ” — The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny

Philip Henry Gosse was one of the more interesting English natural scientists of the nineteenth century. As a name, he is probably best known for having fallen under his son’s patricidal pen, since Gosse, father and son, are the familial agonists of Edmund Gosse’s Father and Son: A Study of Two Temperaments (1907). Gosse the son was a liar with a bad memory, and Gosse the father was a colorful combination of naturalist of genius, prolific popularizer of science, and full-throated evangelical Christian.


Gosse’s widest-reaching legacy is no doubt his coinage of the word aquarium, which kicked off the whole hobby of keeping aquariums in the nineteenth century, but his relevance to Lafferty lies in his nutty 1857 book, Omphalos: An Attempt to Untie the Geological Knot. There, Gosse proposed a novel concept, which he called prochronism. He used the adjective prochronic to describe features that appear to be evidence of a long past, even if that past never occurred.


If God created a world ex nihilo, it would necessarily include built-in signs of history, Gosse reasoned. There would be fossils, growth rings, and geological strata, and Adam would have had a navel. This contrasts with another kind of time after the point of creation. Gosse called that diachronic time.


The notion of prochronic time is something Lafferty returns to fairly often. It appears in short stories. It is a major theme in the Argo legend. It is very useful to have a name for this part of his project. For example, the Armageddon Operas of Enniscorthy Sweeny are prochronic productions: new pasts come into prochronic existence, and diachronic inhabitants puzzle over the timeline. To give another example, Pilgrim's death jumps in Not To Mention Camels are jumps into prochronic timelines, and his adventures are diachronic time mishaps. In Arrive at Easterwine, we read about geology and the amnesia gash as well as the “stroke of searing white light.”


In the unpublished, prenucleation story “One Minute Before,” readers meet Bob Biedermann and Jim Healey. The two men have known each other for a long time—or they haven’t—for the story takes place outside of time in what Healey calls an interlude out of time.


Diagram of the instant in “One Minute Before,” separating uncreated from created, no time from time, and dinner’s end from the universe’s beginning.

The two men seem to be present at a 67th precinct committee dinner. Time has seemingly stopped. The narrator says that "nobody moved, nobody breathed," while other attendees are frozen in positions of rising from the table or manhandling chairs:


It had been a little dinner, a meeting of some sort. It must have been. And some of them were still sitting; some had their hands on the table's edge to rise; some were half risen; and some were actually standing and seeming at the business of manhandling their chairs out of the way. Yet nobody moved, nobody breathed; and it was as if they had never done so.

Biedermann and Healey converse in a way that does not involve physical speech ("not talk out of mouth"). Healey estimates the meeting has lasted ninety minutes through an "analysis of accumulation of cigar and cigarette ash."


Healey, the philosophically minded of the two men, says that their current state is an interlude out of time that will leave no memory once it concludes. He compares the creation of the world to an artist painting a woman: a subject is depicted with a history and a room with furniture that does not have a diachronic causal chain:


When an artist paints a picture he makes a beginning, but he makes the beginning in the middle, as it were. If the picture is of a beautiful woman (and it should be) he begins with her as she is; normally he does not go back to show her birth . . . If she is in a room and that nominally furnished, he does not go back and show the manufacture of the furniture . . . Yet the room and the person or persons in it are complete with history and memories.

The men consider the possibility that the universe was not created billions of years ago but was instead "made complete with its past history." That would include fossils and human memories. Biedermann even says that the Creator might save trouble by "setting beginning very near the end."


The men then speculate that the beginning of the universe might be tapped in by a small gavel rather than a trumpet blast. At 9:58 CST on a Tuesday evening, this happens. The gavel taps, and the universe is "created in full stride with all its memories and vestiges and appurtenances." The creation point merges with the continuum, making the built-in past the real past. At the same moment, the committee dinner ends, and we learn from the narrator that his companion has forgotten the entire experience.


Despite this looking like a simple chestnut, or just the kind of thing boys in their first whiskerage, as Lafferty puts it, talk about, the metaphysical puzzles it creates are fairly deep (see the resource at the end of this post). Lafferty writes:


Well then, the great saurians need never have been; only the fossil memory of them need have been. Seven Troys did not rise and fall; only the record of them was made in the Earth when it was made. Ronsard never rimed; only his books were made all at one time when the world was made . . . and the mother who bore you was not born, nor were you. Debts never contracted for would still have to be paid, and the outcome of wars never fought would still determine the present and the future.

The prochronic possibility cannot be distinguished from an elapsed past by the evidence it supplies. Geology and cosmology work with that evidence; the hypothesis offers them no competing test. Bertrand Russell made the logical point with a world created five minutes ago, complete with memories. He called the hypothesis uninteresting for his purpose. Lafferty found a story in it.


The story brings creation and eschatology into the same conversation. These are questions Lafferty returns to throughout his fiction.


My preferred reading of the frozen interlude is through Origen. I see a connection with the later fiction’s treatment of aeons and eternity.


The distinction between eternity and temporal succession helps me describe the scene. The men converse outside the sequence of events that the gavel will set in motion.


This is where it gets a little weird. It picks up on Lafferty’s belief that the second coming and judgment occur at every person’s death, and it relates to his view that everyone is already dead and his rejection of non-eschatological finality. That is another way of saying that everyone is “already” (we break temporal language) in eternity.


Because our ultimate reality is an "always already there" participation in the heavenly court, as John Behr puts it in his reading of Origen, the characters’ suspension inside of but somehow beyond prochronic time can be thought of as a glitch from the "shadow" of earthly life to their true, "hidden" identity as rational beings. Quoting Lamentations in First Principles, Origen argues that our temporal existence is a shadow of eternal reality; Lafferty found this idea productive for many of the more complicated stories he wrote, all of which were written after this first dip in the water.


Lafferty’s trick is to depict the 67th precinct meeting as a static, bloodless tableau. In this state, the two men are momentarily existing in that non-temporal "interlude" where eternity, beyond "every idea of a sense of time," becomes almost accessible.


Imagine a fence post. On one side is the prochronic; on the other is the diachronic. The entire scene is supported by and bound by eternity. When a rational being falls into time, it is caught in causal chains not of the rational being’s own making, which is the problem of the prochronic. One might say that the problem with being born is not that sin, or the result of sin, brought one into the world, but that one had no say in the matter of being born. Now imagine you could have a conversation at that moment. That is “One Minute Before.”


At the story’s climax, the world is "created in full stride" at the strike of a gavel. This looks to me like it parallels Origen’s eschatological view of creation. Here, creation is eschatological because divine creation is not a past historical event. It is the realization of God's unimpeded will, which is complete only at the end of time, when all rational beings voluntarily submit to Christ and God becomes "all in all." By timing the birth of the story cosmos to the end of the precinct meeting, Lafferty makes the END of the meeting BEGINNING:


The gavel tapped. And the Universe was created in full stride with all its memories and vestiges and appurtenances; and at just the same time the 67th precinct committee dinner came to an end, never having begun. But the creation merged with its continuum, and its built-in past became its real past.

What would an Origenist reading of this look like? It literalizes the concept that “the end is always like the beginning.” The end of the meeting is the beginning of the world. The molded (what Origen calls plassein) elements of the world (the ninety minutes of cigar ash and the furniture of built-in memories) are temporal dust. Creation (ktizein in Origen, also the root of ktistec) is, in Rowan Williams’s words, the “unimpeded expression of God’s rational will” that only reaches completion when the eschatological “Amen” is sounded.


I hear the gavel tap as a strange “Amen”: the meeting is over, and the world begins. The people are already rising before the gavel sounds.


In hindsight, given where Lafferty went as a writer, this simple early story foreshadows what happens when we reach his great experiments with time in the fully nucleated works, culminating in his greatest and ethically flawed masterpiece More Than Melchisedech when taken with its pendant texts. As argued before, the main character in the Ghost Story is the person's relation to time.


Numbered plot outline of “One Minute Before,” from the frozen dinner through the gavel’s creation of the universe.
Timeline of “One Minute Before” contrasting conditions before creation with the universe and its newly created history.
Diagram of creation, eschaton, time, and eternity, progressing from election through the Passion to creation.



Bibliographical Note


Lafferty’s work-history card dates the writing to February 15, 1960, and gives the manuscript’s length as approximately 1,750 words. It records submissions to The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, Fantastic, and Fantastic Universe.


Unpublished.


Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “One Minute Before,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.

bottom of page