"Promontory Goats" (1975/1988)
Updated: Nov 8

V. Requiem aeternam dona eis, Domine. R. Et lux perpetua luceat eis. Fidelium animae, per misericordiam Dei, requiescant in pace. Amen.
“Promontory Goats” is a Lafferty piece that I don’t quite know what to do with. Its comedy and its interest in the Devil’s redemption trouble me. The assessments and fragments resist a single account of Casey, and the manuscript outline shows how carefully Lafferty arranged them. Like Three Armageddons, it puts pressure on the form it appears to use. Familiarity with the Argo books helps.
One difficulty is Casey’s light verse about gassing chambers and soap. His mother is Jewish, which makes these lines especially disturbing: “The gallows always smells of rope / I don’t know why it shouldn’t. / A gassing chamber smells of soap / Though I’d have bet it wouldn’t.”
The goat gives me a way into the story. “Promontory Goats” presents itself as an assessment-collection of the surviving works and personalities of Kasmir “Casey” Szymansky. Demetrio Glauch dates his introduction to All Souls’ Day. I read the collection chiefly through its treatment of Purgatory and redemption.
Near the end, Bascom Bagby describes Casey caring for the goats in Purgatory. In Bagby’s account, prayers from the living often send their burdens to the dead instead of relieving them. Glauch then returns for the final assessment:
"He has great concern for the goat caravans that arrive here every day. There has long been the cultus of praying for us Poor Souls in Purgatory; but the effect has not been so much the taking up of the burdens of the Souls here as the sending to us of further burdens to bear. People phrase their prayers for us very strangely. They pray mostly for themselves, that they be rid of their burdens. And they mention our names. And those burdens arrive here every day on caravans of laden scapegoats. Casey works with the beat-up and burden-weary goats pretty well. He is a good animal man, and he patches them up as well as can be done."
This sets up a contrast with Casey’s own grandiose fantasy of making himself a scapegoat for the Devil so that the Devil would be redeemed.
In Roman Catholicism, All Souls’ Day is observed on November 2 to remember and pray for the faithful departed. It is connected with prayers for souls believed to be in purgatory, and it comes right after All Saints’ Day on November 1. Whatever “Promontory Goats” is, it is a meditation on failure and mercy with a great deal of black comedy thrown in.
Casey is a Chicago polymath from the Argo books, obsessed with the Final Redemption of the Devil. He proposes to trade souls with Satan, take his place in Hell, and release him. The collection alternates other people’s assessments with Casey’s poems and prose fragments.
I follow four related questions through the collection.
First, what can the assessments tell us about Casey? Glauch dislikes him; Hilton and Stein say they like him; Finnegan defends his compassion while judging his commitment to the Devil disastrous. Their disagreements matter to the portrait. Glauch’s image of the empty crock gives the collection its form:
"The form of this attempt to find and assemble the essence of some fifty years of Casey's works and days... will be shaped by the container that was Casey himself. The surviving essence, which should obey the laws of all gasses, ought to conform to the shape of the empty container that Casey left by his going . . . There are still invisible configurations and promontories in that emptied crock, and the essence will shape itself to them even when we are not aware of them."
Second, when does compassion become presumption? Margaret Stone gives the sharpest challenge to Casey’s promised sacrifice. The man who offers an eternity in Hell was afraid to serve one hour in Purgatory as a child:
“This cultus and practice consists of a child taking the place, for one hour usually, of the most forgotten soul in Purgatory. It is very painful, but it is not desolating . . . I questioned Casey about this once, when I had heard that he was talking nonsense about trafficking with the Devil. He remembered the cultus from his childhood, but he had never entered into it. He had been afraid. He was afraid of one hour in Purgatory, but he big-mouths about an eternity in Hell. I think that Casey's mind has blown.”
Third, Casey’s account of false preludes makes his own role uncertain. He claims that false creations, redemptions, and endings precede the true ones, and wants a part in as many false preludes as possible:
"Before the true redemption there had to be a dozen false redemptions; and after the true, there had to be many more of the false, and they are still going on . . . Before the return of Christ, there must be a dozen returns of false Christs, and one of them will be larger and more conspicuous than the others. Before the end of the world, there must be very many false endings; and I suspect that some of them will be very well done and pretty convincing."
Fourth, how does the destruction of Casey’s art relate to his proposed self-sacrifice? I read the burning as a possible form of self-emptying, though the losses are also wasteful and leave his friends reconstructing what they can:
"In drawing and painting, in music, in verse and in prose, he cranked out a very lot of it. He destroyed most of it. The chimney of his house was called the Black Chimney of Hubbard Street because he burned so much of his stuff in the fireplace of his old house there . . . It is for this reason that even the scanty amount printed here is at least half reconstructed from the memories of those who heard it from him."
The title comes from George Meredith’s “Phoebus with Admetus.” In Lafferty’s story, the goats also recall the scapegoat of Leviticus 16, carrying the people’s sins into the wilderness. The rocky heights of the title make that burden precarious.
I read Lafferty as taking Casey’s compassion seriously while exposing his inability to bear what he has undertaken. The ending gives him work among the burdened goats, but leaves the stolen body and the possibility of an effigy unresolved. That uncertainty is part of what keeps me returning to the story.
Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work-history card records completion in March 1975 and submission to Virginia Kidd on March 27. It gives the manuscript’s length as seventy-three pages and approximately 24,000 words.
First published as Promontory Goats (United Mythologies Press, 1988).
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Promontory Goats,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa; Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “Promontory Goats,” https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?1457787.


