“For All Poor Folks at Picketwire” (1975)
Updated: 10 hours ago

But for to speke of vertuous beautee, Thanne was she oon the faireste under sonne; For povreliche yfostred up was she, No likerous lust was thurgh hire herte yronne. Wel ofter of the welle than of the tonne She drank, and for she wolde vertu plese, She knew wel labour but noon ydel ese. — Geoffrey Chaucer, “The Clerk’s Tale”¹
Somehow Griselda had remained one of the really good-lookers. — R. A. Lafferty, “For All Poor Folks at Picketwire”²
Picking up from “Dorg,” I want to look at Lafferty's “For All Poor Folks at Picketwire.” The two stories have a connection: the weird notion of eating rocks and how that might hurt or help humanity. But “Picketwire” is the harder of the two.
Its plot goes as follows. Lemuel Windfall could be a great inventor, yet he holds back. He knows his inventions will become obsolete, which demotivates him. Furthermore, he wants primordial working conditions, which are impossible. He wants to invent outside of time and space. His wife, Griselda, just wants him to make some money for their family and give her a trip to Paris.
The years go on. The number of kids in the family grows. For some service rendered, Jasher Halfhogan gives Lem a land deed to a remote spot on Picketwire Creek, Colorado. Years later, as an old man, Lem strikes a deal with Jasher to make earthy materials that weren’t possible before, things like edible sediment. He then goes away.
When edible earth begins to appear for free, Lem's former financial backers come to see his wife, Griselda. She immediately sees the value in what Lem is doing. The businessmen want Lem to make the food require a second treatment, which will let them charge for it. She visits a sibyl to learn more about where Lem is, and then goes to see him at Picketwire. At first she does not recognize him. He has become so bent and gnome-like. After they talk, he gives her a patent for a new substance he is teaching the poor folks at Picketwire to make: orichalcum. The story ends with Lem telling Grissie that all she has to do is think of Paris and she will be there. She emerges in the Rue de Purgatoire in Paris and sells the patent for a fortune.
What’s going on in this story? Over a decade ago, MPorcius wrote a response to it that gets at the main hurdle. Here is his take, a useful way in.
“A few days ago I was very pleased to find the anthology Epoch in a Missouri flea market. Edited by Roger Elwood and Robert Silverberg and published in 1975, Epoch, which contains 24 original stories, purports to be a sample of 'the state of the art in science fiction' and 'the definitive SF book of this decade.' The front and back covers are full of such charming declarations ('the culmination of centuries of imagination'?!) Anyway, the first story I have read in Epoch is R. A. Lafferty’s ‘For All the Poor Folks at Picketwire.’ This is another folksy downhome tall tale adorned with jokes that didn’t make me laugh. I don’t really care for this sort of thing, but I try to keep an open mind and give writers a chance to grow on me. (I always have in the back of my mind the knowledge that I was unimpressed by the first books I read by Gene Wolfe and Jack Vance, both of whom I now consider among my very favorite writers.) This story is about a backwoods inventor, a super genius who doesn’t care about money. All his life he has dreamed of being able to develop and manufacture items in a perfectly neutral environment, one without gravity, temperature, UV rays, etc. If I am interpreting the clues correctly, the inventor makes a deal with the Devil (or maybe some demon or angel) who allows him to start inventing and manufacturing in Purgatory, with a legion of kobolds and goblins as workmen – these kobolds and goblins are, in fact, the souls of the dead who are working off their sins. The inventor’s big new invention is edible rocks and clay, which is perhaps some Christian symbolism which is escaping me. Before the inventor got to Purgatory the kobolds and goblins were creating coal and petroleum. The story includes allusions to Virgil and Dante; there is a Sibyl, for example, and Purgatory is accessible through caves on the Earth’s surface. Immediately after reading ‘For All the Poor Folks at Picketwire,’ I thought it deserved to be ranked as merely average, but the more I think about it, the more I like it. The story is a sort of puzzle that I am still trying to figure out, which is a good sign that it was a worthwhile read. So I’ll have to give ‘For All the Poor Folks at Picketwire’ a thumbs up and continue scrounging the libraries, used bookstores and flea markets of the Middle West for the stories of R. A. Lafferty.”³
MPorcius is right to describe “Picketwire” as puzzle-like. A recent post explored two modes in Lafferty’s work, why it’s useful for readers to notice them, and how each creates a different kind of defamiliarization. One mode is didactic. It asks to be decoded. The other mode is palimphanic. It moves by association and asks to be reconstructed. That argument centered on “Puddle on the Floor” because it is dramatically palimphanic. This contrasts with “Picketwire,” which is didactic primarily, though both modes are, as usual, in play.
In approaching the puzzle, three pieces seem especially important.
1. Two medieval notions shape the story and must be held in equipoise. Yes, this is a Purgatory story, but it is a purgatory story within a Patient Griselda tale, which makes it a marriage trial story. Patient Griselda comes from medieval folklore and is best known from Giovanni Boccaccio’s Decameron (c. 1353) and Geoffrey Chaucer’s “Clerk’s Tale” in The Canterbury Tales (c. 1387–1400). She is remembered for her inhuman patience and obedience under terrible pressure, including losing her children and being cast out by her husband, the Marquis of Saluzzo, all because he wants to test her loyalty. She endures. Without complaint.
In Lafferty's story, the patience/impatience theme is explicit in lines such as
“Lem, everything that you've ever sold, you've already had it on the shelf for at least fifteen years,” Griselda would say with weary patience.
“She had always been an impatient woman.”
and perhaps more subtly in
“The changes are all made without surgery. They are made, in fact, without the . . . ah . . . patient being touched in any way.”
Patient Griselda stories are slippery. Often, they are made to divide readers. That is part of why they are slippery and part of what makes them appealing. In the 14th century, this took the form of the writer deciding how far to press the allegory. The more Griselda becomes a symbol for the soul, the less Griselda looks like a human victim of domestic abuse. Endurance of needless cruelty becomes virtuous longanimity. In the late Middle Ages, European writers played variations on this.
Boccaccio (1313–1375) is characteristically wry about Griselda's suffering. Petrarch (1304–1374), writing shortly after Boccaccio, emphasizes the allegorical Griselda who stands in for the soul’s steadfastness toward God. Chaucer (c. 1340s–1400) complicates Griselda by placing her tale in The Canterbury Tales (c. 1387–1400), which also has the Wife of Bath. Then he complicates it further by making the teller a scrupulous clerk, slightly impatient but still respectful toward Petrarch’s high-mindedness. The result is a tale that leaves open where allegory ends and literality begins. What does Lafferty do?⁴
This is the first piece of the puzzle. It can easily wrongfoot the reader because of how tempting it is to see Lem as the main character. His role is extraordinary. MPorcius reads the story that way, not mentioning Griselda. But this is to focus on the Marquis of Saluzzo only.
Lafferty does not hide the Griselda story structure, nor does he front-load it. The story begins with a massive emphasis on Lem's eccentricity and his Gnostic wish to evade the material constraints of nature to invent new material wonders, but each of the story’s three sections ends with Griselda. By the end, it's her story. She goes to Paris, still affectionate toward Lem but largely free of him. Getting the shape of the story right in one’s mind means taking this into account.
2. The story also plays with the concept of suffrages for the dead. Its title might look like a dedication, but it is a suffrage. One might ask: What is for those poor folks at Picketwire? The answer is, "A suffrage is. It's for the poor souls in Purgatory." So, unsurprisingly, Lafferty does a lot with Purgatory in the story.
Take the name Picketwire. This is the real-world Picketwire River, also known as the Purgatoire River, which flows through southeastern Colorado. The older Spanish name, Río de las Ánimas Perdidas en Purgatorio (“River of Lost Souls in Purgatory”), was shortened in French to Purgatoire. English speakers turned that name into “Picketwire.” In Lafferty, Picketwire is one of the gates to Purgatory. This is quite Irish of him, the best-known earthly passage to Purgatory being the legendary cave portal said to have been opened by St. Patrick on what is now called Station Island. ⁵

Here, it is worth slowing down.
First, in the great Catholic debate over whether Purgatory is a condition or a place, or both, Lafferty splits the difference. He gives the reader just enough in this story to feel that it is a place, continuous with the material world, in the way that St. Patrick's cave is continuous with Station Island, but also a sense that it is somehow outside of space and time and therefore a condition. This matters because of the Communion of Saints: in Catholicism, the living can aid the dead through suffrages, a practice rejected by the Reformed tradition. ⁶
Unlike MPorcius, I do not see a connection to Dante beyond this one. Lafferty is firmly on Team Dante in making Purgatory feel intensely physical and continuous with the material world. In The Divine Comedy, Purgatory is on the other side of the world. It is a mountain. A real mountain. Made of rock. That physical sense of Purgatory belongs to a pre-Reformation and pre-Counter-Reformation imagination, and Lafferty keeps it alive in his way. You can beat a trail from your front door to Purgatory's entrance.
Ulysses sailed within sight of that mountain in canto 26 of Dante’s Inferno. Later, in canto 27 of Paradiso, Dante the pilgrim looks down from the heavens and sees the following:
I saw that, from the time when I looked down before, I had traversed all of the arc of the first clime, from its midpoint to end, so that, beyond Cadiz, I saw Ulysses’ mad course and, to the east, could almost see that shoreline where Europa was sweet burden.⁷
Lafferty recapitulates this in the last sight of Roadstrum at the end of Space Chantey:
Alas, we have the terminal report of him! The coded chatter gives the sighted mort of him, How out beyond the orb of Di Carissimus His sundered ship became a novanissimus.⁸

At least three aspects of Purgatory are significant in the story:
i. Purgatory is the antechamber of heaven because everyone in it will eventually arrive there. Once they do, Purgatory will be no more. That makes it an intermediate state, not a final destination. It's a half-hogan, a half-house. Everyone ends up going the whole hog eschatologically.
“No, not consciously I didn't invent him, Grissie. And yet I did invent him a little bit, I suppose. And he me. We are all formed by feedback and interaction. We see more than there is in other people, and we ourselves are seen for more than we are. And we grow to match our seeming. Don't you like Jasher [Halfhogan]?” “I've never met him, Lem. Every time I've seen him he was scurrying away like some night ghost that was afraid of being shone on by sunlight. Well, if he's a Halfhogan, what would a Wholehogan be?” “You really don't know, Griselda? Sometimes you astonish me,” Lemuel said.
ii. Thomas Aquinas considered it probable that Purgatory is in the earth and that its purifying fire is continuous with the torturing flames of hell below it. In Lafferty's story, this matters for what he draws from Plato: the red light of orichalcum.⁹
iii. Many of the story’s obscure jokes turn on the history of how Purgatory developed in sacred doctrine, from debates over whether one could earn merit while there (think of the value of Lem’s work) to the whole mini-history of Purgatory Lafferty gives the reader twice, doubling down on its significance for understanding the story.
“Jews, close your ears!” a prairie dog barked. “Greeks, harden your hearing!” a rattlesnake voiced. “Covenanters, avert your senses lest you be affronted by it!” a bull-bat spoke in a series of little booms.
These warnings recall disputes over the fate of the dead in Jewish, Greek Christian, and Reformed traditions. The rattlesnake points to the Greeks at the Council of Florence (1439), where Eastern and Western delegates debated the doctrine while seeking reunion. Most of the Greeks were not entirely against the idea of a post-life purgation, but they disputed the Latin account of purgatorial fire. ¹⁰
The bull-bat points to the Covenanters (whose doctrine of immediate purification at death excluded Purgatory) and the Council of Trent (1545 to 1563), which issued the decree that would shape the Church’s approach from that point on: teach the doctrine, but exclude unedifying speculation from popular sermons. Little booms. Or as the Tridentine Decree on Purgatory put it:
But let the more difficult and subtle questions which do not make for edification and, for the most part, are not conducive to an increase of piety (cf. I Tim. 1:4), be excluded from the popular sermons to uneducated people. Likewise they should not permit opinions that are doubtful and tainted with error to be spread and exposed. As for those things that belong to the realm of curiosity or superstition, or smack of dishonorable gain, they should forbid them as scandalous and injurious to the faithful.¹¹
It’s this restraint on speculation that, ironically, gives Lafferty license to let his imagination run wild with the details. Could Purgatory be an engine of matter-creation?
3. Lafferty spins medieval folklore by way of Gnosticism and quantum physics. What Lem wants (his gnostic pride) is a workshop without gravity, temperature, or duration. I suspect the story also draws on ideas from quantum theory, such as quantum entanglement, seen in the connection between Jasher and Lem, and bilocation, as when we get the double location of the Picketwire. Lafferty maps it onto real rivers named for Purgatory. It is a classic Lafferty move.
Finally, there may be a joke on Einstein’s “spooky action at a distance” in Lem’s changing size:
It was a queer, refractory sort of place, but Griselda had adjusted to it in everything except her eyes and her mind. Her dinner date had been getting smaller, and the café-restaurant had been getting stranger and more intimate.
and in Grissie's line
"I hardly know how to say this, but there is something very spooky about the place."¹²
Those are the main puzzle pieces, as far as I can see, although a few smaller things stand out. For instance, the sibyl in the story comes straight out of Virgil’s Aeneid, but Lafferty probably also knew that the much less familiar Sibylline Oracles figured in disputes over Purgatory. His Catholic Encyclopedia discusses the early Christian use of these oracles under “Sibylline Oracles.” The names Jasher and Lemuel are drawn from the more mysterious parts of the Old Testament for the same reason: no one knows who King Lemuel was, and no one knows much about the lost Book of Jasher. ¹³
And the red sweater that Grissie says she will send to Lem is a variation on the red cap worn by kobolds in German folklore, as well as a twist on the fires of hell that once flamed up into Purgatory being turned down a little after the Council of Trent.¹⁴
So, where does this leave the reader? With permanent, and seemingly author-intended, options that remain provocatively irreconcilable. As a cultural symbol, Patient Griselda is overdetermined. She is many things: moral exemplar and moral ambiguity; the good wife and the ridiculous wife; victim of cruelty and paragon of second-order virtue; political allegory and spiritual allegory.
Some of that applies here. Allegorically, Lafferty’s Impatient Griselda may have died, moving from Purgatory into heaven, journeying after death from Lem’s quantum cave to her long-dreamed, heavenly Paris. Or she may still be alive, having left Purgatory to walk the Haussmann-planned streets of real Paris, now filthy rich, like the exploitative sharks who begged her to find Lem.
Lafferty keeps it wide open:
“I'll send it, Lem, I'll send it!” Griselda cried. She kissed him, or perhaps she missed him. She thought Paris. She rushed out of there. And she came out in Paris in the middle of… … the Rue de Purgatoire. And right around the corner was Le Conglomérat, where she traded the Conveyance of Patent for a few of those fortunes. And all around every corner was Paris.

Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work-history card records completion in December 1973, submission to Virginia Kidd that month, and a sale to Roger Elwood.¹⁵
First published in Epoch, edited by Roger Elwood and Robert Silverberg (Berkley/Putnam, 1975).
Notes
1. Geoffrey Chaucer, “The Clerk’s Tale,” in The Canterbury Tales, fragment IV, lines 211–17. Back to text
2. R. A. Lafferty, “For All Poor Folks at Picketwire,” in Epoch, ed. Roger Elwood and Robert Silverberg (Berkley/Putnam, 1975). The story begins on p. 89. Subsequent quotations from it appear in the text. Back to text
3. MPorcius, “‘For All the Poor Folks at Picketwire’ by R. A. Lafferty,” MPorcius Fiction Log, October 16, 2013. The extra “the” in the story title is MPorcius’s. Back to text
4. Giovanni Boccaccio, Decameron, day 10, tale 10, especially Dioneo’s closing judgment. For Petrarch’s interpretation, see his letter to Boccaccio, Letters of Old Age 17.3. Compare Chaucer, “Clerk’s Tale,” IV.1142–1212, including the envoy. Back to text
5. Purgatoire Watershed Partnership, Purgatoire River Watershed Plan (2014), 16. For the Irish pilgrimage site, see Lough Derg, “About Lough Derg.” Back to text
6. Catechism of the Catholic Church, pars. 1030–32, especially par. 1032 on suffrages for the dead. For the Reformed position, see the Westminster Confession of Faith, 21.4 and 32.1. Back to text
7. Dante Alighieri, Paradiso, trans. Allen Mandelbaum, 27.79–84, Digital Dante, Columbia University. For Ulysses’ sighting of the mountain, see Inferno 26.133–42. Back to text
8. R. A. Lafferty, Space Chantey (Ace Books, 1968), closing poem, first four lines. Back to text
9. Thomas Aquinas, Summa theologiae, Supplement, appendix 2, art. 2, response. Aquinas calls the location probable and allows for exceptions. For the orichalcum on the wall of Atlantis, see Plato, Critias 116b–c. Back to text
10. Council of Florence, Laetentur caeli, July 6, 1439, Decree for the Greeks. The decree affirms purification after death without specifying fire. Back to text
11. Council of Trent, “Decree Concerning Purgatory,” session 25, December 1563. The English wording quoted here appears in Brett David Salkeld, “A Creation Refined by Love: The Value of Purgatory for Ecumenical Dialogue” (MA thesis, University of St. Michael’s College, 2007), passage at n. 125. Back to text
12. Albert Einstein to Max Born, March 3, 1947, in The Born–Einstein Letters, trans. Irene Born (Macmillan, 1971), 158. Back to text
13. Virgil, Aeneid 6.35–155, on the Cumaean Sibyl. For the Christian reception of the oracles, see Patrick Healy, “Sibylline Oracles,” in The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 13 (Robert Appleton, 1912). David Blondel takes up the dispute over Purgatory in A Treatise of the Sibyls (1661), bk. 2. For Lemuel and Jasher, see Prov. 31:1, Josh. 10:13, and 2 Sam. 1:18. Back to text
14. Friedrich Ranke, Die deutschen Volkssagen (Beck, 1924), discussion of the kobold. Ranke describes its red jacket and pointed red cap. Back to text
15. R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “For All Poor Folks at Picketwire,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. For the publication record, see the Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “For All Poor Folks at Picketwire.” Back to text
Bibliography
Aquinas, Thomas. Summa theologiae. Supplement, appendix 2, “Purgatory.”
Blondel, David. A Treatise of the Sibyls. 1661.
Boccaccio, Giovanni. Decameron. Edited by Maurizio Fiorilla. Day 10, tale 10.
Catholic Church. Catechism of the Catholic Church. Paragraphs 1030–32.
Chaucer, Geoffrey. “The Clerk’s Tale.” In The Canterbury Tales, fragment IV. Harvard’s Geoffrey Chaucer Website.
Council of Florence. Laetentur caeli. July 6, 1439. Decree for the Greeks.
Council of Trent. “Decree Concerning Purgatory.” Session 25, December 1563. Text of the decree.
Dante Alighieri. The Divine Comedy. Translated by Allen Mandelbaum. Digital Dante, Columbia University. Paradiso 27.
Einstein, Albert, and Max Born. The Born–Einstein Letters. Translated by Irene Born. Macmillan, 1971.
Healy, Patrick. “Sibylline Oracles.” In The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 13. Robert Appleton, 1912.
Lafferty, R. A. “For All Poor Folks at Picketwire.” In Epoch, edited by Roger Elwood and Robert Silverberg. Berkley/Putnam, 1975.
Lafferty, R. A. R. A. Lafferty papers. 1979-002. McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lafferty, R. A. Space Chantey. Ace Books, 1968.
MPorcius. “‘For All the Poor Folks at Picketwire’ by R. A. Lafferty.” MPorcius Fiction Log, October 16, 2013.
Petrarch, Francesco. Letter to Giovanni Boccaccio on Griselda. Letters of Old Age 17.3.
Plato. Critias. 116b–c.
Purgatoire Watershed Partnership. Purgatoire River Watershed Plan. 2014. Section 2.1, “Watershed History.”
Ranke, Friedrich. Die deutschen Volkssagen. Beck, 1924. Discussion of the kobold.
Salkeld, Brett David. “A Creation Refined by Love: The Value of Purgatory for Ecumenical Dialogue.” MA thesis, University of St. Michael’s College, 2007.
Virgil. Aeneid. Book 6.
Westminster Assembly. Westminster Confession of Faith. Chapters 21 and 32.


