top of page
Search

“Once on Aranea” (1961/1972)

Nov 11, 2025
7 min read

Updated: 4 minutes ago


Extreme close-up of a spider’s face with large reflective green eyes.

Lafferty finished the original draft of “Once on Aranea” in October 1961 and revised it in December 1961, January 1965, and February 1966.¹ It first appeared in his short story collection Strange Doings (1972).² What began as a story of personal horror became a piece of cosmic horror and one of my favorite Lafferty stories.


The story opens with Scarble bound in silk, then flashes back a week to a survey team exploring the asteroids of the Cercyon Belt. They have an odd and funny procedure of leaving one man behind to test for latent threats. On Aranea, the Spider Asteroid, Bernheim reports that the dominant emotion of the native dodecapods is “mother-love, lately reoriented by an intrusion and intensified many-fold.” The intensifying intrusion? It’s them. “Oh, those mother-loving spiders!” becomes the men’s byword. They leave the wiry, spider-like Scarble behind to conduct the solitary test with only his dog, Cyon, for company.³


At first, Scarble thinks it will all be a picnic. He notes the spiders’ complex life cycle. They capture their wild, bipedal young and put a freshly killed scutter into the hood of each cocoon. As it decays, it feeds the young spider during its metamorphosis. The idyllic experience ends when the spiders invite him to drink from a drugged pool. He awakens to a warm snow of gossamer and silk, finding himself completely bound and helpless.⁴


In the original version of the story, Lafferty alludes to Gulliver’s Travels when Scarble mutters about Gulliver come to judgment.⁵ Lafferty wisely cut the joke when he darkened the piece. As Scarble struggles in the final version, he calls out, “You’re covering me too deep with that damned sand. Fun’s fun, but that’s enough.”⁶


Scarble’s horror gets amped up in one of the most memorably grotesque scenes in Lafferty, a scene right up there with the grinding up of an entire family in Not to Mention Camels (1976).⁷ The spiders bring Scarble the cocooned and putrescent, nearly liquefied body of his dog, sealing the stenchy carcass against his face. He knows what is happening. The spiders believe he is an unfinished larva, and Cyon is the food for his transformation into their prophesied Emperor Spider. After days of torment from hunger and thirst, with the spiders’ “Resurrection Song” rising around him, he shouts, “You think I’m going to eat Cyon and then turn into a spider. You’re wrong, I tell you!”⁸


But he is driven past madness, and he succumbs. He eats his dog’s remains and begins his transformation, growing eight new leg-notches to saw his way out of the cocoon. Discharged from active service, Scarble jokes, “Cyon was a good dog, but only after he had become very bad.” Back on Earth he is kept under observation, the four strange growths on each side of his body hidden under his flowing robes. He begs his doctor to leave them alone. “They saved my life. I couldn’t have gotten out of my cocoon without them.”⁹


In the final scene, Scarble visits his second doctor, Mosca. He is surrounded by floating silk stuff and explains that he is the Emperor of the Dodecapod Spiders of Aranea and that their operation on Earth is nearly complete. Doctor Mosca dismisses this, but Scarble says, “The time is at hand. I give the word now!” Mosca cries out, “I’m bitten badly! Another spider bite.” The spiders cover Mosca in silk. Unable to move his head, he still thinks Scarble demented.¹⁰


Andrew Ferguson identifies the Resurrection Song in the early ending, reads the eating of Cyon as a parody of the Eucharist, and traces the invasion of Earth to the added scenes.¹¹ The comparison here follows how the revision carries Scarble’s transformation to Earth, while the cuts sharpen the bodily horror.


“Once on Aranea” became much more powerful after the rewrite. The original had ended with Scarble breaking down and beginning to eat the putrefied mass of Cyon and to change. But because he had gone mad, it is unclear whether he is really changing, though the spiders’ Hallelujah chorus rises over Aranea.¹² Is the change just his madness? A comparison between the draft and the rewrite shows Lafferty, fully grown into his powers, trimming and adding, improving the prose, dialogue, and pacing.


For example, in the draft, Scarble’s opening monologue is longer, and his dialogue is different, while the survey team’s discussion about the spiders’ emotions is presented as a lengthy, hesitant conversation. What Lafferty cut was pretty limp stuff. The draft also included several extended sections that are absent from the final version. There was a longer philosophical passage on the nature of courage that dilated on the pseudo-squids of Okeanos Mikros. The theme of laughter on Aranea was more diffuse, and the additional stanzas of Scarble’s song deflated the bio-horror.¹³


Throughout the first half of the story, Lafferty’s final version smartly removes or shortens narrative asides, tightens dialogue exchanges, condenses internal monologues, and brings out what is so terrible about all that happens.


The most substantial change is the story’s conclusion. Instead of ending with Scarble breaking down and eating Cyon, the published version continues, adding a final act that mirrors the structure of the first part of the story. Lafferty skips from Scarble’s escape to his discharge from active service. Back on Earth, Scarble passes from one doctor to the next.¹⁴ We witness his physical transformation continuing as new limbs grow. What had been a story about a man going insane in order to survive becomes a story about a man being rewritten into the agent of a global invasion.


Lafferty uses the word anastasis in the early ending, where the spiders’ Resurrection Song accompanies Scarble’s change. The published story keeps the name and carries the parody to Earth.¹⁵


In the published version we see Scarble’s rebirth into a new, glorified state, at least from Aranea’s perspective. Scarble undergoes a symbolic death, a descent into the cocoon, and emerges as the messianic Emperor of the Dodecapod Spiders. In Byzantine art the Anastasis depicts the Resurrection through Christ’s descent into Hades to free the dead.¹⁶ Scarble’s actions on Earth, where he makes bodily metamorphosis stand in for metanoia (repentance), form a darkly ironic take on Christ’s role after the Resurrection. The last lines of the story perhaps echo Acts 17:30–31, where Paul calls everyone to repent and speaks of the man God raised from the dead.¹⁷ Scarble remakes mankind in his own new, alien image.


My musical setting of Scarble’s song. The lyrics below follow the performance.
The spaceman frolicked with his girl Though all his mates could not abide her. She was a pippin and a pearl, She was a comely twelve-legged spider. He sat upon her twelve-kneed lap And wished that it was even wider. Let all be silent who, mayhap, Have never loved a loving spider. He’d glad explore her every side, He’d get upon her back and ride her. Amazing motion to bestride A real dodeca-gated spider. Embracing her below, above, It seemed that he was quite inside her. None knows topography of love Who never loved a twelve-armed spider. With paler loves be they content Who never had the love of Spider.¹⁸

Character map linking the survey team, Cyon, Earth doctors, and the creatures of Aranea.
Table contrasting explorers’ accounts with what actually happened during their isolated planetary visits.
Parallel narrative analysis comparing human perceptions with Aranea’s biological processes.
Table tracing Scarble’s physical, psychological, and ontological transformation through four stages.
Flowchart of the Aranean life cycle, metamorphosis, and the role of subordinate creatures as nourishment.
Thematic diagram connecting perception, transformation, irony, and colonialism in Once on Aranea.
Table comparing explorers’ encounters, failures, evidence, and their foreshadowing of Scarble’s fate.
Parallel structure chart comparing Scarble’s experience on Aranea with Doctor Mosca’s experience on Earth.



Bibliographical Note


Lafferty’s work card records a rewrite on January 10, 1965, and submission to Analog the same day. He revised the story again on February 6, 1966. In December, Robert A. W. Lowndes accepted it, with payment due on publication. The story later came back to Lafferty.¹⁹


First published in Strange Doings (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1972).²⁰


Notes


1. Andrew Ferguson, “83. Once on Aranea,” Continued on Next Rock, November 16, 2020, closing chronology. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “Once on Aranea,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. The card dates the 1965 and 1966 revisions to the day. Back to text


2. R. A. Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” in Strange Doings (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1972), 63–76. For its first appearance, see Ferguson, “83. Once on Aranea,” publication history. Back to text


3. Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 63–66, especially 65 for Bernheim’s report and the crew’s byword. Back to text


4. 67–70. Back to text


5. The early manuscripts are catalogued under R. A. Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 19, folder 12, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. For the binding of Gulliver, see Jonathan Swift, Gulliver’s Travels, ed. Allan Ingram (Broadview Press, 2012), pt. 1, chap. 1, 66. Back to text


6. Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 69. Back to text


7. R. A. Lafferty, Not to Mention Camels (Bobbs-Merrill, 1976), chap. 4, the murder of Aubrey Pym’s family. Back to text


8. Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 70–72. Back to text


9. 72–74. Back to text


10. 74–76. Back to text


11. Ferguson, “83. Once on Aranea,” discussion of the Fierst version and the Earth coda. Back to text


12. Ferguson, “83. Once on Aranea,” account of the Fierst ending. For the published Hallelujah chorus and Scarble’s escape, see Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 72–73. Back to text


13. The Tulsa finding aid lists two fourteen-page carbons and a nine-page rewrite, box 19, folder 12. For the surviving song verses, see Ferguson, “83. Once on Aranea,” under “Scarble’s Song.” The published text gives one stanza before turning back to the story (67). Back to text


14. Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 73–76. Back to text


15. Ferguson, “83. Once on Aranea,” discussion of the early ending. For the song and its sequel in print, see Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 71–72, 75–76. Back to text


16. Walters Art Museum, Resurrection of Christ, ca. 1350–75, accession no. 37.751. Back to text


17. Acts 17:30–32 (King James Version). Paul commands repentance in verse 30, speaks of God raising the appointed judge in verse 31, and the hearers respond to the resurrection of the dead in verse 32. Back to text


18. For the longer song with its prose interludes, see Ferguson, “83. Once on Aranea,” under “Scarble’s Song.” The printed quatrain reads “friends” in the second line. The musical setting uses “mates.” Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 67. Back to text


19. Lafferty, work card, “Once on Aranea,” entries for January 10, 1965, February 6, 1966, and the submission to Lowndes. The acceptance entry is dated December 5, 1966. Back to text


20. Lafferty, “Once on Aranea,” 63–76. For the collection’s contents, see Indiana University Libraries, “Strange Doings,” IUCAT. Back to text


Bibliography


Ferguson, Andrew. “83. Once on Aranea.” Continued on Next Rock, November 16, 2020.


Indiana University Libraries. “Strange Doings.” IUCAT. Catalogue record for the 1972 Scribner edition.


Lafferty, R. A. Not to Mention Camels. Bobbs-Merrill, 1976.


Lafferty, R. A. “Once on Aranea.” In Strange Doings, 63–76. Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1972.


Lafferty, R. A. “Once on Aranea.” Typescript carbons and rewrite. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 19, folder 12. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. Work card, “Once on Aranea.” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Swift, Jonathan. Gulliver’s Travels. Edited by Allan Ingram. Broadview Press, 2012.


Walters Art Museum. Resurrection of Christ. Ca. 1350–75. Accession no. 37.751.

bottom of page