top of page
Search

Just How Old Is Dotty?

Oct 20
4 min read

Updated: 4 days ago


Dotty herself was never sentimental, and it would not be decent to get sentimental on her behalf. — Chapter 2, Dotty
Having just “reached her majority” at novel’s end, which by Texas law would have meant turning 18 years of age, 18 years into which she has packed several lives’ worth of incident and grief and loss . . . — Andrew Ferguson, on Dotty

This afternoon, I revised my Dotty resource and started thinking about the novel’s somewhat murky chronology. Dotty is young at the end of the book, but eighteen can’t be right.


At the beginning of Chapter XII, “Dotty was sixteen (seventeen in the fall).” The chapter follows her life after Joe Smith and ends with “And in such ways did a couple of years go by.” Charles enters the story in the next chapter. This puts Dotty at about eighteen before their courtship, marriage, and all the tragedy that follows.


Before Charles sails in Chapter XIII, Dotty tells him:


And I’ll set my watch. I haven’t set it for two years. It’s an hour and ten minutes slow and I haven’t even cared.

The neglected watch appears to mark the same two-year interval.


After Charles’s death, she tells God:


I begged You to give him to me for a year, and You gave him longer.

So if Dotty is eighteen when they meet, she is at least nineteen when Charles dies. Then another year passes. When the weekly letters stop arriving, Soft-Talk Susie tells her:


Well, you have had a year. There were fifty-two letters. He told you there would be, didn’t he?

Only then does Dotty start reading them.


A word here about Texas. Texas didn’t lower its general age of majority to eighteen until 1973. Under the law of Dotty’s time, marriage could end a woman’s legal minority before twenty-one. Since Dotty had already married Charles, the closing reference to her majority may be an age clue, pointing to her twenty-first birthday. The novel supports this reading: even while married, Dotty looks forward to registering to vote “as soon as she was of age.” The voting age in Texas was then twenty-one, and marriage wouldn’t have changed that.


But there is a complication. In Chapter XV, Lafferty dates the wedding:


They were married in 1950 probably, or a year very near to it, in the summer. July, as a month, would not be far wrong. It is all written down at the Church. You can go and see it in the records.

The year 1950 conflicts with the two years that pass after Dotty is sixteen. Following her stated age and those elapsed years puts her meeting with Charles around 1952, with the wedding following. That fits a little better, though it means reading “a year very near to it” too loosely for my taste.


That leaves a real loose end, but eighteen doesn’t work. Twenty-one fits the elapsed time and the closing formula that Dotty “had just reached her majority.” Since she was born on October 15, 1933, this reading places the ending shortly after her twenty-first birthday in 1954.


By the stated ages and intervals, Dotty is already about eighteen when Charles enters the story. Ferguson’s ending age leaves no room for the marriage and the year of letters after Charles’s death.


Ferguson describes Dotty as “tentatively back in the faith,” but later writes:


Having just “reached her majority” at novel’s end, which by Texas law would have meant turning 18 years of age . . . she has perhaps lost the Faith that is the only explicatory framework apart from sheer material chaos within which such losses can be made to fit, even if they never quite fit right.

Ferguson acknowledges Dotty’s return to faith, then suggests its loss. Lafferty distinguishes faith from consolation, and both from final salvation:


She had returned doggedly to her Faith, but the old sparkle of it had not returned. Whatever was built back would have to be close-grained and hard like a gnarled tree. A bone is broken in a second, but it takes longer to knit.     

Lafferty capitalizes “Faith”; in context, Dotty has returned to the Catholic Faith. In Catholic teaching, faith is a supernatural virtue infused by God, by which we believe what he has revealed on his authority, with intellect and will cooperating with grace. Faith does not depend on felt consolation, so her return to the Faith is compatible with the continued absence of its former “sparkle.” That is a tough Catholic ending for a tough book that gives Dotty mixed odds on making it to the finish and through the narrow gate.



The novel ends with the reader in the crosshairs:


Dotty is by no means saved. No more than you are. A practiced gambler like One-Chance Hardwich who owns the Chatterbox Club, and who will bet on anything, would give odds at no more than five to three in her favor. On yourself he would hardly go even money.

An old one. A Catholic sits in a half-empty hotel lobby. A Prot asks, “Is this chair saved?” “How would I know?” says the Catholic.


Finally, a minor curiosity about Lafferty’s other Dotty, Dotty Yekouris. In Archipelago, Finnegan is shot on a Wednesday afternoon, after his confession on July 15, then the feast of St. Henry the Emperor. The year is probably 1953: in More Than Melchisedech, he says in May 1946 that he will wander for seven years before being buried in Cuba. On that reading, Finnegan’s shooting and entombment precede Dotty Peisson’s twenty-first birthday, October 15, 1954.




bottom of page