top of page
Search

"Hands of the Man" (1957/1970)

Mar 18
8 min read

Updated: 19 hours ago


Black-and-white photograph of a man placing his hand in a spring-loaded measuring device.
“It is not my game. I am too guileless.” “The serpent in the garden said the same, but for all that he had a motive.”¹

“Hands of the Man” was written in 1957 as a con-game story with no science fiction elements,² and is interesting for at least three reasons. Andrew Ferguson has discussed the first two.³ First, it is a Wreckville story, so anyone interested in Lafferty’s heterotopia of brilliant confidence agents will want to know it. Aside from the early novel Antonino Vescovo and Lafferty’s extensive poetry translations,⁴ 1957 is also the year the archive comes to life. Lafferty sets up the series of pieces he will play with as he establishes himself as a published writer.


Second, as Ferguson suggests, it is a place to see Lafferty’s revision process, namely, how he takes a story in one genre and revises it for the science fiction market. The two best stories for watching him at work like this are “Hands of the Man” and “The Ultimate Creature.”⁵


The third reason concerns the names Lafferty changed.


The original “Hands of the Man” is about a seaman who bests two Jews. The Jews think they have an easy mark in the main character, but, unknown to them, they are the marks. The con requires no ethnic identification. Giving the cheated dealers Jewish names makes that identification part of the joke.⁶ It is an early example of the virtuous antisemitism one sees throughout Lafferty. Here one finds it at ground zero: 1957.


In the original “Hands of the Man,” a stocky seaman named Hodl Oskanian sits in a tavern boasting about his deeply lined palms. This chiromancy theme runs through Lafferty's career and finds its fullest expression in “This Boding Itch.”⁷ Hodl compares his intellect to that of historical figures: Leonardo, Aquinas, Aristotle, and one Willy McGilly:


“But now the right hand. Notice that, while still the second most fascinating hand in the world, it is not what it should be. Every line is a little fuzzy. It is now the hand of a compromised genius (I doubt if there is any other kind); something like the hand of a Leonardo or an Acquinas or an Aristotle or a Willy McGilly; the hand of a man capable of reaching the stars, but not knowing what to do when he has reached them.”⁸

A spotter named Henry Gottlieb sees Hodl’s diamond ring and introduces him to a diamond merchant named David Shapiro. Suspecting the stone is stolen, Shapiro negotiates a purchase and brings a wrapped bundle of cash, with armed guards already present, to complete the transaction.⁹


When Hodl says the ring is stuck on his finger, the real con begins. Hodl’s secret accomplice, Charley O’Malley, arrives disguised in a dirty apron to provide hot water and soap. This creates a brief distraction. Hodl and Charley execute a sleight-of-hand trick to swap David’s cash for a dummy bundle wrapped in matching brown paper and David Shapiro Jeweler tape. Hodl then escapes with the ring; Charley has the money. Lafferty ends with Hodl and Charley later that evening in a Wreckville bar, where Charley counts the real bills while Hodl continues to admire the allegedly virtuous lines on his hands.¹⁰


The version readers know, published in 1970 and later collected in a Centipede volume, moves the story from a contemporary setting into science fiction. Lafferty tacks on some of the planets we know from his other works. Hodl’s profession is changed from a “seaman” to a “skyman,” and the tavern’s regular beverage is replaced with a “green beer” recently introduced from Barathron, in a Romulan-ale move.¹¹ The dialogue about the diamond’s origins and Hodl’s pocket contents now includes references to extraterrestrial locations and currencies, which adds a kind of genre-sandwich sprinkle: Ganymede, Astrobe, Trader Planets, and Earth coin:¹²


“It isn’t from Earth,” said David. “I doubt that it’s of any trabant or asteroid. It hasn’t the orange cast of those of Ganymede, and I’d know a diamond from Hokey Planet anywhere. Is it from Astrobe? Pudibundia? Bellota?” “No, it isn’t from any of the Hundred Worlds, nor from any licensed planet. I didn’t pick it up in any such backyards. It’s from a distance.”¹³

The spotter Henry Gottlieb becomes Henry Hazelman, and the diamond merchant David Shapiro becomes David Daumier. The Jewish names disappear; the dealers’ roles and defeat remain. Finally, Charley O’Malley becomes Willy McGilly. Lafferty repaints David’s henchmen and adds some science-fiction chrome. He introduces a mind-reading mechanical man named Structo, or Penetrax Nine, who interacts with the characters and scans both the diamond and the protagonist’s mind.¹⁴


Lafferty also expands the concluding Wreckville scene to suit the new setting. The money-counting confrontation, however, is already present in the draft: Hodl accuses David of trying to pay him with “funny money.” After drawing a weapon, he uses the accusation to break off the deal and leave with the ring, leaving the counterfeit bills behind.¹⁵


The final scene in the Wreckville tavern adds a new monologue by Willy McGilly.¹⁶ McGilly outlines the stages of the grift, the Setting, the Bait, the Warning, the Counter-Play, and the Innocent Disclaimer, while comparing their work to an ancient handicraft surviving in an automated universe:


“They have multiplied the Earth by billions and made all things intricate,” said Willy. “Men are not the same as their fathers were, and a man would need three brains to comprehend all the new devices. And yet in quiet places, like a Green Valley, some of the simple and wholesome things endure—old friends, old customs, old cons—sweet frauds that are ever young. We are like ancient handicrafters in an automated universe, but we do fine and careful work.”¹⁷

One feels that Lafferty had originally trusted the reader. Minor details are inserted throughout as well. David’s package now bears a “deformed Greek M” to indicate the amount. Eoin Dinneen is added to the list of historical geniuses because this is now a science fiction story. Piety is added to the virtues Hodl admires on his palm in the new ending.¹⁸


Ferguson suggests that Lafferty added the science fiction elements in revision. He does not mention the removal of the Jewish names.¹⁹ Those changes belong in an account of the revision.


Character map connecting Hodl Oskanian, David Daumier, Henry Hazelman, Willy McGilly, the guards, and the mechanical man.
Numbered plot outline of “Hands of the Man,” from Hodl’s palmistry display to the Wreckville meeting.

In the first printing, David marks the parcel with a capital M. Willy calls the fourth stage of the con the “Counter-Play.”²⁰

Willy’s five stages of the con, showing the visible action and the function of each stage.
The genuine diamond and cash, the counterfeit substitution, and the roles of Hodl, Willy, and the machine.
Textual comparison of Hodl’s two hands, with a separately labeled theological reading.
Comparison of the original typescript and the published story, identifying handwritten revisions and limits of the supplied scan.

The last table compares the original typing, Lafferty’s handwritten revisions, and the 1970 printing.²¹




Bibliographical Note


Lafferty’s work card dates the writing to fall 1957 and records circulation beginning with Scott Meredith on November 23, 1957. It records later rewriting, submission to Virginia Kidd in October 1968, and a sale to Infinity.²²


First published in Infinity One, edited by Robert Hoskins (Lancer Books, 1970).²³


Manuscript location: “Hands of the Man,” Series 2: Writings, Box 10, Folder 21, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Notes


1. R. A. Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” marked typescript, 4, box 10, folder 21, series 2, Writings, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. In the first printing David goes straight from Hodl’s claim to be guileless to his offer of five thousand. See Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” in Infinity One, ed. Robert Hoskins (Lancer Books, 1970), 157. Back to text


2. R. A. Lafferty, work card for “Hands of the Man,” box 25, series 2, Writings, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. The card dates composition to fall 1957. In the marked typescript, Hodl is a seaman (1) and the con ends in Wreckville (7). Back to text


3. Andrew Ferguson, “6. Hands of the Man,” Continued on Next Rock, March 10, 2013, opening two paragraphs. Back to text


4. Ferguson, “1. Antonino Vescovo,” Continued on Next Rock, March 2, 2013. Ferguson reports that Lafferty dated the novel to about 1935–37. For the poetry translations, see “Vogelsprachekund and Dotty (1957–58/1990),” Arrive at Easterwine, November 18, 2025. Back to text


5. “‘Teresa’ (1961) and ‘The Ultimate Creature’ (1966/1967),” Arrive at Easterwine, September 27, 2025. R. A. Lafferty, “The Ultimate Creature,” Magazine of Horror 3, no. 6 (November 1967): 42–49. Back to text


6. Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” marked typescript, 1–2. My reading of the dealers as Jewish rests on the names Gottlieb and Shapiro and the narrator’s canceled aside inviting the reader to guess Gottlieb’s name. Back to text


7. R. A. Lafferty, “This Boding Itch,” in Golden Gate and Other Stories (Corroboree Press, 1982), 47–56. The 7:31 news bulletin describes the treatment that erases the lines on people’s palms. Back to text


8. Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” marked typescript, 2. The original typing has “Acquinas” and includes Willy McGilly. The first printing has “Aquinas” and adds Eoin Dinneen (Infinity One, 154). Back to text


9. Marked typescript, 1–5. David sends Henry for his men before he goes for the money. Back to text


10. 5, 7. On page 7, Charley counts the bills, Hodl explains the matching paper and tape, and Lafferty writes Willy McGilly’s name over Charley O’Malley’s. Both names occur in “Adam Had Three Brothers,” New Mexico Quarterly 30, no. 3 (Autumn 1960): 280 (Willy McGilley), 281 (Charley among the uncles). Back to text


11. Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” Infinity One, 153–55. For the Romulan ale, see Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, directed by Nicholas Meyer (Paramount Pictures, 1982), McCoy’s birthday visit to Kirk. Back to text


12. Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” Infinity One, 156–57, 161. Astrobe is also the setting of Past Master (Ace Books, 1968). Back to text


13. Infinity One, 156. Back to text


14. Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” marked typescript, 1–2, 7. For the revised names and the machine, see Infinity One, 153–55, 157–60, 162. Hodl calls it Structo. David calls it Penetrax Nine. Back to text


15. Marked typescript, 5–7. David’s protest and the canceled deal are legible through the reverse of 6. The words “funny money” are from Infinity One, 161. Back to text


16. Marked typescript, 7, and Infinity One, 162. Willy names the five stages immediately after the handicrafters speech. Back to text



18. Marked typescript, 2, 5, 7. In Infinity One, see 154 (Eoin Dinneen), 159 (the parcel mark), and 163 (Piety). Back to text


19. Ferguson, “6. Hands of the Man,” opening two paragraphs. The handwritten substitutions are on pages 1–2 and 7 of the marked typescript. Back to text


20. Infinity One, 159 (the mark) and 162 (Willy’s fourth stage). Back to text


21. Marked typescript, 1–5, reverse of 6, and 7. The addition on the reverse of 6 distinguishes burglary from taking a taker in honest combat. See Infinity One, 162–63. Back to text


22. Work card for “Hands of the Man,” November 23, 1957 (Scott Meredith), October 12, 1968 (Virginia Kidd), and October 9, 1969 (sale to Infinity). Back to text


23. Lafferty, “Hands of the Man,” Infinity One, 153–63. Reprinted in The Man Who Walked Through Cracks, ed. John Pelan, vol. 5 of The Collected Short Fiction (Centipede Press, issued 2019), opening on 59. See the ISFDB publication record. Back to text


Bibliography


Ferguson, Andrew. “1. Antonino Vescovo.” Continued on Next Rock. March 2, 2013.


Ferguson, Andrew. “6. Hands of the Man.” Continued on Next Rock. March 10, 2013.


Internet Speculative Fiction Database. “Hands of the Man.” Accessed November 19, 2026.


Lafferty, R. A. “Adam Had Three Brothers.” New Mexico Quarterly 30, no. 3 (Autumn 1960): 280–88.


Lafferty, R. A. “Hands of the Man.” In Infinity One, edited by Robert Hoskins, 153–63. Lancer Books, 1970.


Lafferty, R. A. “Hands of the Man.” Marked typescript. Box 10, folder 21, series 2, Writings. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. “Hands of the Man.” Work card. Box 25, series 2, Writings. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. The Man Who Walked Through Cracks. Edited by John Pelan. Vol. 5 of The Collected Short Fiction. Centipede Press, issued 2019.


Lafferty, R. A. Past Master. Ace Books, 1968.


Lafferty, R. A. “This Boding Itch.” In Golden Gate and Other Stories, 47–56. Corroboree Press, 1982.


Lafferty, R. A. “The Ultimate Creature.” Magazine of Horror 3, no. 6 (November 1967): 42–49.


Meyer, Nicholas, dir. Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. Paramount Pictures, 1982.



“Vogelsprachekund and Dotty (1957–58/1990).” Arrive at Easterwine. November 18, 2025.

bottom of page