"And You Did Not Wail" (1974/1983)
Updated: Nov 9

But the spider meant to bite her. It glittered with the meanest eyes ever seen, and there was a noise right at the lower level of sound — malevolent spider laughter.
In "And You Did Not Wail," Basil Cubic confronts a world overtaken by emotional excess and collective hysteria. He is basically square, as his name suggests, but not unsympathetic. He expects the problem to yield to engineering.
Nosebleeds, lost individuality, and collapsed inhibitions mark The Thing, a sickness that spreads through society and the arts. Basil’s friend Andrew Giro recognizes the damage: “It’s the sniveling madness returned,” he says, “and it’s the enemy of quality.”
So Basil turns to O’Malley’s Agency to bring out some leased engineers. Instead of helping, all but one of the six whose reports we read celebrate The Thing. Finally, with nowhere else to turn, Basil calls Brain McClain. McClain offers the solution: start over from lemurs. In eighty million years, a new humanity may rise. Basil had believed the world could be repaired. Now he wails with the rest.


On December 15, 1974, Lafferty completed “And You Did Not Wail.” December 15th is a day that, depending on the year, falls in either the second or the third week of Advent. In 1974, when Lafferty was sixty, it fell on Gaudete Sunday.
A little liturgical context will help. Gaudete comes from the Latin gaudete, meaning “rejoice”; and Gaudete Sunday comes halfway through the season, a sign that Christ is near. On Gaudete Sunday, the rose candle is lit, rose vestments may replace the purple ones of penance, and the heavy penitential mood of Advent lifts for a moment of gladness. This is why there is a pink candle in the Advent wreath among the purple ones. The center white candle in the wreath is usually called the Christ Candle and is lit on Christmas Eve or Christmas Day.

The completion date makes the story’s two candles suggestive: Lafferty finished it on Gaudete Sunday.
The first candle appears in the third engineer’s report:
"They still have the outlawed signature candle burning in their heads; they still have the 'Maker's Mark' statement, burning in their breasts."
The office girls supply the second, stuck in a small cake whose material they identify:
“Tongue scrapings,” they said. “We scrape the coatings from our tongues and save it all because we are a happy-holy-tongued people. And now if you will give us your own tongue scrapings, then you can begin to have meaningful relations with us.”
We have two candles. The first is a metaphor of the soul, the Imago Dei candle. The second is its negation, a profane parody that takes the candle literally. In the story, this becomes the candle of humanism and machine worship, man exalting not the divine image within himself but only the non-divine part of man.
We will reach out . . . into persons, and we will pull out (haireisthai, draw out, select out, heresy out) the special quality or statement, and we will destroy it with a blast of sound. Then that person, who had been sick, will be well . . . Now we will make everyone free of it. There will be no more special qualities, not anywhere, not ever.
Midway through the story, Lafferty devises an etiological myth to explain how this works. In "Article Number Four," the Leased Engineer Number Six presents the story of mechanical people manufactured by the great rationalist Eratosthenes. They are the "first really normal humans." This origin myth is another picture of the profane second candle.
These mechanical beings feel "great glory at being created in the human image." I read this as a parody of the Imago Dei. Article Three says that mechanical people lack the disturbing quality its author wants to remove from others; Article Four supplies a fantastic history in which their uninhibited behavior becomes the human ideal. Eratosthenes’ manufacture of ecstatic people joins rational construction to the disorder Basil encounters.
But like Eratosthenes before him, Basil is an engineer, which is one reason Lafferty's depiction of him is complicated. Basil is an intellectual cousin of Eratosthenes, that uber-rationalist. Basil sees the problem, but he is unequipped to solve it.
He turns to the kind of mechanical persons Eratosthenes produced, the Leased Engineers, which is to say he thinks mechanically. But he is not one of the mechanical persons. This is why his wailing at the end of the story is not like all the other wailing produced by The Thing.
In "And You Did Not Wail," the O'Malley Girls are Basil Cubic's new, mass-produced office staff who act as a unified, chattering chorus. They're pretty much the very anti-rational, emotionally incontinent "sickness" he is trying to cure. The O’Malley girls are the ones who eventually hand Basil Cubic the small candle “stuck in” a “little dirty white cake of something.” The image parodies the white baptismal and Paschal candles. The “something,” they say, is a lump of “Tongue scrapings,” the filth of the “happy-holy-tongued people.”
The story throws down an absolute choice. Guard the God-stamped light of the Maker’s Mark, or accept an anti-sacramental flame, the scum of your own mouth. Be a humanist. Be a lolling tongue, joy-be-goy-goy. There is no God: it’s all about the funnilingus.
They swooned for joy, they forewent bathing lest any of the blessed human unction might be washed away from their hides, they raised their howls of praise to themselves and to their kindred, they danced and pranced, they talked with their happy tongues, they indulged in gibberish (funnilingus), they clasped each other fervently and uttered incantation phrases which fortunately have not come down to us, they smelled each other about the crevasses and articulations of their bodies and they were impassioned by the smells. They just could not get enough of themselves and of the people-thing to which they belonged. They did new and great things in the arts (creatively destructive things). They continually made little cries and sighs, their noses bled a lot, and they wept and tittered. What is there like the titter to make all mankind akin? And when ecstasy reigns, can logorrhea be far behind? No, it could not. There was instant logorrhea. Tongues bloomed like scarlet flowers, as they are doing once more today.
So, unlike Gaudete Sunday, this story is not joyful. It is one of Lafferty’s unhappiest, which really is saying something. The grandfather of all Lafferty sites online, Mulle-Kybernetik, calls it “OK” and adds this: “Recurring theme of teenager behavior indicating or causing a cultural downfall.”
It’s not that simple, but Lafferty is gagging at the counterculture, and it does get the better of him here. He falls into the same excesses that weaken “Horns On Their Heads” (1971). I like “And You Did Not Wail.” It’s just minor and flawed, and the main reason is that there’s a lot of cane-waving at the neighborhood kids.
Lafferty sees antinomianism as spiritually corrupt—I agree with him there—but he doesn’t care that his critique isn't hitting his own generation's taste as hard as it hits the counterculture. That’s both fair and unfair. It’s fair because the decline of art can be a symptom of the decline of a culture, a point anyone with any sense has heard a hundred times and agrees with. But it’s also unfair, because some things are just a matter of taste. Not walking that line carefully can come off as a cheap shot.
Then again, maybe I’m not being fair to Lafferty. He knows the difference, and he is doing satire. He is being deliberately silly, aware that Basil and Giro initially treat earlier versions of The Thing as more manageable. Or maybe it is fair to knock Lafferty here, because he wants to make such a serious point at the end, and the satire should be expected to carry such weight better if it wants to be this profound. That’s always the issue for me when Lafferty misses. In the past, I’ve called the exact issue theotropic dissonance.
The engineers’ reports give the satire several distinct voices. Their jargon and repeated dismissals make language part of the problem Basil is trying to diagnose.
And yet, everyone should have known what was coming. The title tells us this will be a rebuke. It alludes to Luke 7:32, where Jesus compares His generation to children who won’t respond: “We played the flute for you, and you did not dance; we sang a dirge, and you did not wail.”
Lafferty returns to this verse again and again. It’s in the title. It’s in the epigraph because Lafferty really wants us to get it. It’s behind the story’s mockery of popular music such as “Joy To The World,” with digs at Three Dog Night (“Three-Eyed Dog”) and the Rolling Stones (“Lolling Tongues”).
In the end, it’s flung at Basil by the O’Malley girls, who shout at him through a “miasma of sound”: “Oh, you impossible man . . . Why don’t you wail? Everybody is wailing. That’s the Lolling Tongues doing ‘Wail All Night’, and you do not wail!” It’s important to hear, whatever the messenger, that these are sacred words.
The crowd refused to hear either John the Baptist or Jesus. “You did not wail” means: you did not repent. The warning didn’t move you. The invitation didn’t move you. Your heart stayed hard. Lafferty clearly says his target is the whole world, but it still feels like he is talking about younger generations more than his own. That's part of the miss, at least for me. The rebuke hasn't been fairly recapitulated.
Basil also complicates the criticism. He recognizes the problem, but his confidence in engineering proves inadequate.
While the story talks about mechanical people, built with the Imago Dei factored out, Basil is a little too mechanical himself (Lafferty is not); and, while the story mocks the youth culture—the lippies, the bippies, and the rest—it also mocks him. He is being rebuked for not wailing, just as the others are rebuked for cheapening both joy and sorrow.
They are sentimentalists of the soul, and Lafferty plays with this by giving the plague a cycle. “‘All the arts had become very tearful . . . And all of them had become happy-jappy,’” swinging back and forth between moods that, in the end, “‘were not really extremes or opposites; they were the same thing.’” Lafferty ties this to “‘sentimentality in fiction since the eighteenth century German and the nineteenth century Russian.’” For Lafferty, it is an artistic problem as well as a spiritual one; in a way, it just isn’t for Basil. Basil is one-sided and needs a Giro.
The Fifty-Day Wonder Sect brings speaking in tongues into the satire. A scriptural epigraph is answered by a bishop who urges gibberish around the altar:
“Oh Paul is wrongsy-bongsy! Gibberish is in like Quinn. Let’s all make a mighty gibberish around the altar. Gibb, gibb, gibber!”
The opening scene makes the damage to language audible in baby talk. One of the O’Malley girls sees a spider and cries out, “‘Oh what a horribly human reaction! How unhumanly human!’” Then she coos at it: “‘Here, let me take the mumms tumms goowoo dumms mumswums—’” Basil’s disgust is instant: “‘Baby-talk to a spider!’” The girl says—“‘spiders are better people than a lot of people are,’”—but the spider bites her, and she yelps, “‘Ow Wow Gow!’”
The baby talk, once cognitive, even if degraded, has become non-cognitive, a yelp of pain that can be written as words but does not truly amount to them. Back to St. Paul, speaking in tongues, and gibberish.
Thucydides, writing about the Peloponnesian War, noted that during civil strife, words were twisted—recklessness was called courage, caution was called cowardice. It’s a set piece in many classrooms. Lafferty’s story made me think of this because of how it plays with the corruption of language. In this light, it is fun that Engineer Sixteen—the so-called “sanitary engineer,” a textbook example of language as social lie—alone appreciates the story’s only genuine engineering idea: a governor.










Bibliographical Note
Completed December 15, 1974. First published in Heart of Stone, Dear and Other Stories, Drumm Booklet no. 12 (Chris Drumm, 1983), beginning on page 3.
Lafferty’s work-history card records submission to Virginia Kidd on December 15, 1974. A later annotation identifies Heart of Stone, Dear and Other Stories and its 1983 publication by Chris Drumm.
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “And You Did Not Wail,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. “And You Did Not Wail,” Internet Speculative Fiction Database, accessed October 24, 2026, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?69706. “Heart of Stone, Dear and Other Stories,” Internet Speculative Fiction Database, accessed October 24, 2026, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/pl.cgi?16635.


