Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis? (1977)
Updated: Nov 10

The ethos of this blog can be found in Lafferty’s Serpent’s Egg (1987). It’s something he has characters say about mysteries, my favorite genre:
"The trouble with mysteries is that the mystery-giver doesn't play fair," Inneall complained. "He doesn't give us all the clues." "Yes he does, Inneall. He gives all the clues."
That might be my favorite moment in Lafferty's work.
Although he experimented with mysteries, his great detective novel is Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?, one half of Apocalypses (1977). It’s a book made entirely of strange turns, and throughout, Lafferty plays a game with the reader unlike anything else in his work. This is a matter of degree. He’s relentless, scattering contradictions and concocting so many seemingly throwaway details that it can feel like he’s inventing wildly in an onslaught of manic exposition, without bothering to keep track.
But he is keeping track. Repeatedly, he draws the reader’s attention to contradictions long after most will have moved on. It’s these weird reminders that make Sandaliotis so different from anything else I have read.
Has anyone cracked how this book works? I haven’t seen it. It isn't discussed much. But I have a crazy theory, one that I haven't let go of after rereading it.
I think the book hints that Constantine Quiche is a Frenchman, a former foot policeman named Chataigneraie, and that he is in hell, having died earlier that day. The other agents in Sandaliotis are quite likely devils tormenting him, and his handler, Grishwell, is part of the plan.
Lafferty provides an essential piece of insetting in the first chapter:
Through the night, [Constantine] was interrupted only once, not into wakefulness, but into a dream. The rock pile seemed to have become an under-ocean rock pile, a grotto, a cave, a booming tidal cavern. A female dolphin visited him there with her springy fish-flesh and her cool ways. She smooched him in that slurpy way that female dolphins have, and there was an underwater echo to it. Then he felt the needle stabs that are so often a part of those strange-species kisses. . . . “We live in caves under the ocean and we have a dog that lives in the sky. Sometimes we come up. We whistle to our dog and we both gambol. “If you hear anything else of us, do not believe it. This is all that we do. “Will you not come and see me in my cave sometime, after this little ritualistic action that we are engaged in now is finished with?” But the best detective in the world is always receiving various sorts of communications.
The dolphin in the dream will be associated with Amelia Lilac, an enemy agent who gives Constantine the Judas kiss several times, the Judas kiss being a recurrent motif in Lafferty’s work. She later warns Constantine:
"Oh yes, I am of dolphin flesh, and quite a few other fleshes. Are you not finding that out with your investigations? But look out for us when we come up out of the ocean and whistle for our sky dog. We can blow you out like candles then."
By the end of the novel, the reader will have enough evidence to see that the agents are quite likely another set of Lafferty’s devils. Constantine gets a glimpse of what’s really happening:
These creatures (the odds teetered between their being human or unhuman) came through as calculatingly insane destroyers. The whole thing showed the unfocused destructiveness and the mad irresponsibility, and the absolutely direct aim at a staked-out and self-immobilized target—Earth.
The Dungeons of Tertullian and Hell as Spectacle
Some of the strongest evidence that Constantine is in hell is the central role the Dungeons of Tertullian play in the book.
Tertullian (c. 155–c. 220 AD) was an influential early Latin Christian writer. He was writing as a Christian by 197; Jerome later described him as a priest.
According to the traditional account, Tertullian later broke communion with the Church and embraced Montanism, an apocalyptic movement that anticipated Christ’s imminent return. His association with apocalyptic thought may help explain the place of Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis? in a volume called Apocalypses. Tertullian is traditionally said to have died outside the Church. Augustine records the reconciliation of his remaining followers at Carthage.
In De Spectaculis (written c. 200 AD), Tertullian condemns the bloodlust of pagan audiences, warning that those who revel in such brutal entertainments will one day become part of an eternal spectacle of suffering. He envisions rulers, philosophers, and entertainers groaning in hell, their punishments echoing their former activities.
Meanwhile, Tertullian imagines himself rejoicing at this suffering. On this, he writes:
But what a spectacle is that fast-approaching advent of our Lord, now owned by all, now highly exalted, now a triumphant One! What that exultation of the angelic hosts! What the glory of the rising saints! What the kingdom of the just thereafter! What the city New Jerusalem! Yes, and there are other sights: that last day of judgment, with its everlasting issues; that day unlooked for by the nations, the theme of their derision, when the world hoary with age, and all its many products, shall be consumed in one great flame! How vast a spectacle then bursts upon the eye! What there excites my admiration? What my derision? Which sight gives me joy? Which rouses me to exultation?—as I see so many illustrious monarchs, whose reception into the heavens was publicly announced, groaning now in the lowest darkness with great Jove himself, and those, too, who bore witness of their exultation; governors of provinces, too, who persecuted the Christian name, in fires more fierce than those with which in the days of their pride they raged against the followers of Christ. What world’s wise men besides, the very philosophers, in fact, who taught their followers that God had no concern in ought that is sublunary, and were wont to assure them that either they had no souls, or that they would never return to the bodies which at death they had left, now covered with shame before the poor deluded ones, as one fire consumes them! Poets also, trembling not before the judgment-seat of Rhadamanthus or Minos, but of the unexpected Christ! I shall have a better opportunity then of hearing the tragedians, louder-voiced in their own calamity; of viewing the play-actors, much more 'dissolute' in the dissolving flame; of looking upon the charioteer, all glowing in his chariot of fire; of beholding the wrestlers, not in their gymnasia, but tossing in the fiery billows; unless even then I shall not care to attend to such ministers of sin, in my eager wish rather to fix a gaze insatiable on those whose fury vented itself against the Lord.
In Sandaliotis, the director of the Dungeons of Tertullian puts it like this:
"When, for instance, I show thirteen men in the agony of death on the walls of the thirteen-sided room, I give the people something to feel important about; for they play at being God, looking through the God’s-eye of the panoramic camera in the ceiling of the room. There is the need of something to abuse, something to feel superior to, something to hate. All these things are satisfied by the writhing creatures stretched out on the dank walls where they babble out their brains in rambling words as they die. All my dramas are very therapeutic."
Lafferty’s detective novel is a Chestertonian nightmare built on Tertullian’s ideas, where suffering is staged, filmed, and consumed as entertainment. Its nightmare is distinct from its satire of Tertullian and the media. The Dungeons of Tertullian make Sandaliotis an exceptionally dark companion to Not to Mention Camels (1976), another of Lafferty’s critiques of media. Both the director in Sandaliotis and the protagonist of Not to Mention Camels have unusual eyes:
And his eyes appear like two glass eyes, even though they are moving enough and merry enough.
The eyes of this pan-morphic (he had jeweled eyes or cracked-glass eyes) established the field of battle and made it conform to their own vision.
The Final Descent
Grishwell, Constantine’s handler, tells him early on to wear a parachute. By the end, readers have the internal evidence to understand why. The Director has already described his filmmaking process:
"What I do is create and direct psychological thrillers with a heavy historic and folklore underlay. I am very good at this. I try to do these pictures as cheaply as possible: how cheap I can do them is one measure of how good I am in this business."
And at the climax, Constantine finds himself inside the thriller, parachuting into what seems to be salvation:
He tugged the lines to carry himself away from that central vortex. He refused to descend deep, deep below into the lilac depths of the ocean. There was the churning, hammering shoal water that would break up a ship or a man. And what else? Mighty steep odds against it. Oh, there was a little bit of solidity out there, about big enough to stand on. But it was a way, a chancy break-neck way where one might stay alive and sometime get to clear water or to help. If only— And the odds against it weren’t as steep as they had seemed at first. None of that hundred-to-one stuff. The odds were no more than ten to one against it now. “Just one chance,” Constantine said. “Just one way. Oh, Director, you said that you liked to cut it close. Director, you should be down here. This is really going to be close. You said that you wouldn’t have it any other way. I would, but I haven’t.”
If I am right, Constantine Quiche hasn’t escaped from anything. He has plunged deeper into hell. And the show goes on.





Current notes:
I suspect that Charles Fort’s New Lands (1923) helped inspire the aerial landscape of Sandaliotis. The following tables summarize Fort’s arguments and the reports he cites; dates and descriptions follow his account.
Charles Fort on Mirages

Reports Discussed in New Lands






--
The director quotes one of Horace's odes (4.7) to Constantine. Here is Horace's poem in its entirety, in John Conington’s translation, with lines relevant to Sandaliotis bolded:
The snow is fled: the trees their leaves put on,
The fields their green:
Earth owns the change, and rivers lessening run
Their banks between.
Naked the Nymphs and Graces in the meads
The dance essay:
“No 'scaping death” proclaims the year, that speeds
This sweet spring day.
Frosts yield to zephyrs; Summer drives out Spring,
To vanish, when
Rich Autumn sheds his fruits; round wheels the ring,—
Winter again!
Yet the swift moons repair Heaven's detriment:
We, soon as thrust
Where good Aeneas, Tullus, Ancus went,
What are we? dust.
Can Hope assure you one more day to live
From powers above?
You rescue from your heir whate'er you give
The self you love.
When life is o'er, and Minos has rehearsed
The grand last doom,
Not birth, nor eloquence, nor worth, shall burst
Torquatus' tomb.
Not Dian's self can chaste Hippolytus
To life recall,
Nor Theseus free his loved Pirithous
From Lethe's thrall.

Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work-history card records completion on July 20, 1975, and submission to Virginia Kidd on July 22. It records a sale to Pinnacle on January 7, 1977, as part of Apocalypses.
First published in Apocalypses (Pinnacle Books, 1977).
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa; Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “Where Have You Been, Sandaliotis?,” https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?69726.


