top of page
Search

“The End of Outward” (1979/1983)

Oct 21, 2025
13 min read

Updated: 2 hours ago

Philip Shelton Sears’s bronze Pumunangwet (He Who Shoots the Stars) at Fruitlands Museum. The archer aims upward from a rock.

Philip Shelton Sears, Pumunangwet (He Who Shoots the Stars), bronze, Fruitlands Museum, Harvard, Massachusetts.¹


Lord Randal had invented the bow-and-arrow. But Axel could shoot the arrows farther and faster. And higher. And when he was six years old, Axel did what many persons have dreamed of doing: he made his mark on the sky. He dipped the heads of his arrows in mud, and he shot them up with uncanny accuracy and made mud marks on that transparent sky-cover which was twenty meters above them. He made about a hundred mud marks that conveyed a message in the written form of ‘code Chaldee’ that the three had independently reinvented. The message was “If there is anybody up above that sky, let him give us a sign.” And the sign came at once, quick lightning and a water shower on the top side of the sky. The Three were pleased to see that their message was not washed away by the rain shower. There was someone else out there, someone more important than the overly-silent care-takers who sometimes came into the area to make major or minor adjustments, trying to look invisible when they came.² — Serpent’s Egg

What would the perfect Lafferty atlas look like? Some exhilarating combo of historical atlas and dictionary of imaginary places, most likely. Somewhere on its maps, you would find your own life, The Bank and Shoal of Time, and it would not be a bad idea to place near it another of Lafferty’s quasi-oceanic metaphysical hazards, that depressing thing he called The Great Doldrum Reef. The Reef can be found in “The End of Outward,” one of Lafferty’s metaphysical black comedies. Its name is informal shorthand. In the story’s science, it is our current era of stagnation, our “end-of-outward” period, as it were, when great human projects stall before breakthrough and nothing fructifies.³


The connection between The Bank and Shoal and The Great Doldrum Reef may seem tenuous, but Lafferty submitted “Bank and Shoal of Time” on October 25, 1978, and finished “The End of Outward” on October 30, 1979.⁴ I like to imagine that the five time-attempters of “Bank and Shoal” appear here in spirit.


In the Arpad Arutinov headnote that opens section 2 of “The End of Outward,” we find the following: “Five others were compelled to other sorts of symbolism to express the reversed flow of history.”⁵ Why should these five not be Kemp, Roaring, MacBean, Farquharson, and Charteris?⁶ Is that an unwarranted inference?


It must be a frustrating short story for some readers. Its architecture is self-denyingly frugal: dialogue followed by speechifying, two locations, with an in-between arrival and withdrawal of horse-drawn carriages with names from the Age of Gasoline. Beyond that, it is all theater of ideas. Can you rise to enjoying it?


It starts with Ike Casad and Fausto Barra, two scientists, shooting arrows straight into the air as they discuss progress and decline. “An arrow should hang at its high point for at least a moment before it falls back,” Ike says, setting up the story’s central metaphor. Ike calls the arrow’s turn a “turn-around flop.” Fausto calls it a “turn-over flop” and says that the world itself now lives in “flop-over time.” To prove a point about a returning Age of Trickery in the current flop-over, Ike performs an illusion. He makes the arrow he shoots hang impossibly at its apex in the sky.⁷


But the trick effect doesn’t last. A weird duality is created when Fausto shifts his footing and accidentally breaks the arrow. “You’ve broke it!” Ike cries, and for a moment the illusory arrow is suspended above them while the real, broken one lies at their feet (“the broken arrow on the grass was the real arrow”). With that, the two men walk toward Ike’s ornate gazebo, a hybrid of “band-stand, summer-house, gazebo and belvedere,” to join a meeting of scientists.⁸


Not just scientists, but fringe scientists. They are people of “high style, elite exuberance, and magnetic personalities.” They arrive in magnificent, custom-built vehicles, and Lafferty has fun with their names. One by one, the figures give updates on projects that have been stalled for over a decade in the Great Doldrum Reef. Charles Cogsworth talks about the manned Mars landing; Diogenes Pontifex discusses the creation of artificial life.⁹


Characters’ roles, views, choices, and fates, with Fausto, Dorner, Alice, and the half-dozen who stay at the End of Outward.

At the meeting, the unstylish Jorden Dorner prompts the company to sing his greeting back to him: “Aw dinosaur droppings, is he here?” Dorner will argue that all the science projects are failing because the time for them has passed. “We cannot go onward,” he insists. “We cannot even stay where we are. We go backwards.” Alice Oast reports that Hereford cattle are “becoming tall and lean and wild-looking.” Where she sees a chance to breed new species, Dorner sees the bonds of species tightening.¹⁰ In his own speech he argues that the universe has stopped expanding and begun to contract. The moon landing thirty years earlier may have marked the end of outward, the peak of their civilization, “the turning of the tide.”¹¹


Table of scientific projects, promised breakthroughs, and signs of stagnation in The End of Outward.

Most of the scientists dismiss Dorner’s ideas, but Fausto Barra says that he intends to outflank the slide. “I’m not going to take the return trip,” he says. With tightrope mathematics (I hear an echo of Matthew 7:14), he thinks he and a few others have calculated the quantum interval closely enough to stay in the “approximate present.” Karns finds Fausto slightly transparent, and Fausto sees the same thing in Karns.¹² Fausto invites Alice Oast to stay. She agrees. Dorner says that he too will stay. After a final round of booze, the meeting breaks up. All but six ride away, some on horseback and others in horse-drawn buggies and carriages, full of “high amusement at the idea of Dorner that their civilization had begun to regress.”¹³


In the last section, the six are still at “The End of Outward.” A mini-event-horizon separates the group from the rest of humanity. Rumor gives the six the best of everything and calls them “a race that once flew to the moon.” The narrator closes: “They are as far out as anybody ever went, and nobody can ever take that away from them.”¹⁴


“The End of Outward” is pretty deep-end Lafferty. It piggybacks on many of his more idiosyncratic techniques. Two aspects of the story deserve closer attention. One is how it separates evolution from progress. The other is its use of the Vernier scale as the story’s conceptual master idea, with what it means for works such as Fourth Mansions.


The world might be a minute old or still a minute away in Lafferty’s unpublished story “One Minute Before.”¹⁵ A famous systematic treatment of apparent age came from Philip Henry Gosse, a nineteenth-century English naturalist and Christian. In his 1857 book Omphalos: An Attempt to Untie the Geological Knot, Gosse developed the idea that God created the world with the appearance of age, complete with fossils, tree rings, and geology, the appearance of a prehistory that never occurred.¹⁶


Admit for a moment, as a hypothesis, that the Creator had before his mind a projection of the whole life-history of the globe, commencing with any point which the geologist may imagine to have been a fit commencing point, and ending with some unimaginable acme in the indefinitely distant future. He determines to call this idea into actual existence, not at the supposed commencing point, but at some stage or other of its course. It is clear, then, that at the selected stage it appears, exactly as it would have appeared at that moment of its history, if all the preceding eras of its history had been real.¹⁷

That Lafferty sometimes entertains this idea shows he saw deep time as a genuine philosophical problem. But one can always dissolve a philosophical problem by accepting a few auxiliary premises. In “The End of Outward,” he uses a changing rate of cosmic expansion to suggest that our estimates of the universe’s age are flawed, his version of the cosmic age problem. Answering Alice Oast, Dorner predicts that within three million years observers will see a violet shift in some of the closer galaxies. For now he has only indirect signs that contraction has begun.¹⁸


Within this cosmological picture, Lafferty offers an oblique critique of evolutionary progress. The story makes its case that human progress has stalled. At the same time, Lafferty refuses to equate evolution with lasting progress. Of course, biological evolution does not imply inevitable progress; it concerns change, not ascent.


In the story, the universe no longer evolves outward but retracts, undoing its own elaboration, perhaps a better word than evolution to characterize its expansion. Dorner denies that new species can be produced by Alice Oast’s method while giving the reader images of what appears to be devolution, animals coming unbred, and outwardly expressive forms moving back toward their origins.¹⁹ In this way, the story separates ideas of progress from questions of creation and speciation, linking doubts about continued progress to doubts about cosmic chronology.


Scientific materialism and divine providence, joined by the Vernier-scale reading of human experience as signs of cosmic judgment.

The story’s major symbol of human progress (the moon landing) measures the culmination of the outward age on the instrument: a gesture made “at the turning of the tide.” It is revered as a permanent achievement precisely because it marks an apex. By contrast, the scientists’ current attempts at species leaps, such as creating new animals, are doomed, since they try to move forward after the turn. Dorner can therefore assert that the time for such efforts “has gone by,” attributing their failure to a change in natural law, a “tightening and not a loosening of the bonds of species.”²⁰


Illustrated guide to reading a vernier caliper, with a magnified scale and a measurement of 2.28 centimetres.

The most interesting part of “The End of Outward” to me is the Vernier scale image. It’s not quite, but almost a microcosm and a macrocosm. No hermeticism needed, not of the kind we get in Serpent’s Egg.


When I think of a Vernier scale, I picture a welder’s calipers: a smaller auxiliary scale with slightly different spacing (the microcosm analogue) sliding along a main scale (the macrocosm analogue) to register shifts the large scale alone cannot show. The analogy isn’t exact, which is what makes it so interesting. The microcosm isn’t measuring anything on its own. But it is registering something in the story: the end of outward. Lafferty makes human culture the sliding ruler on the cosmic dial. Dorner explains this clearly, saying, “Our own lives and our civilization and society form a very small Vernier scale that is counterpart of the cosmic scale,”²¹ meaning we can read the universe’s great turn by first noticing small misalignments in ourselves.


Pierre Vernier, a mathematician from Franche-Comté, described the vernier scale in 1631 to enhance the precision of scientific instruments. His instrument was a quadrant for astronomy and surveying. Its auxiliary scale allowed the observer to read fractions of the smallest division on the main scale.²² In Lafferty’s story, Vernier is restored to its original context of precision and discovery.


In effect, the story acts a bit like a Vernier scale. The scientists’ discourse is like a vernier reading of the misalignment between potential progress and actual regression, picking up on the shift long before astronomy can detect the larger fact. The narrative models the cosmic cycle (rise, apex, fall), while our world is the vernier’s minute offset: the arrow’s flop. This gets spelled out in Fausto’s claim that the arrow “has hung at its apex for about thirty thousand years.”²³ Because astronomical confirmation has to lag behind these cultural signs, Dorner names human culture the small weather vane that turns first.²⁴


This is where all the strange theories and phenomena come in. They are fine-grained indicators: breeds become unbred, undoing the work of selective breeding;²⁵ fashions and technologies slide backward. Etc. One imagines God’s hand on the universe like an irritated welder’s on a set of Vernier calipers, with the Moon landing recast as the furthest outward tick before the dial begins to slide back. The small scale (our biology, taste, tools, and milestones) shows that the main scale, the universe itself, has already reached maximum outward. Judgment has been passed.


There is something sad about this, especially in how it touches Fourth Mansions and Lafferty’s many other works about the leap forward. Kevin Cheek calls Fourth Mansions (1969) “an immensely hopeful book.”²⁶ “The End of Outward” stands about as far from being hopeful as one can get in Lafferty. I myself find Fourth Mansions less clear. On my reading, Freddy must have failed for Carmody to return again in Fair Hills of Ocean, Oh!²⁷ Not that the Overlarks share the same fictional universe, but that some part of Lafferty was not as hopeful as Cheek.


Instead of the returnees, at the end of outward, we are given the Great Cosmic Verger, an incredibly memorable image of Lafferty’s creative imagination in a sour mood. Of him (Him, I think), Dorner asks: “Who is the verger who with his verge-staff allows some things to pass and denies others? It is a cosmic verger nowadays, and he moves us back from the verge.”²⁸


A verger, from the word for “staff,” is a church official who carries a staff before a bishop or other dignitary in procession.²⁹ It is as if the Argo, the ship of the Church, was told the waters end here. You blew it. The communion of the saints (the Elite) exists, but you’re going to need more grace than had those lucky pre-July 20, 1969 folks before the flop of time’s arrow. There are more than a few shades of this in Serpent’s Egg.


Lastly, the boundary-setting figure with the staff appears elsewhere in Lafferty, most vividly in the following passage: “In the bodies of Kings and their Ladies, they strode down a High Road in the Levant. They were wondering what last thing they could contrive, when they found their way blocked by a Pilgrim with a staff.”³⁰ The difference seems to be that the wicked children in “Hairy Earthmen” are now us.


If so, then in “The End of Outward,” the message is even more eristic. I hear Dorner’s judgment on Pontifex’s project as a judgment on us: there will be no fourth mansion. “It recedes from you. The time for it has pulled away and left the project stranded, as it has left so many others. Shelve it, shelve it!”³¹


Character map. Karns sees Fausto and Dorner turn slightly transparent. Fausto, Alice, Dorner, and three unnamed others stay behind. Rumor credits them with the best of everything.
The circular pattern of announcement, promised near-success, failure, and recommitment at the Great Doldrum Reef.
The curve of expansion and contraction, with the moon landing marked as Dorner’s possible turning point.
Parallel cosmic and civilizational scales, with biological, cultural, technological, and scientific signs of regression.
Spectrum of characters’ responses to cosmic reversal, from belief in perpetual progress to acceptance or escape.



Bibliographical Note


Completed October 30, 1979.³² First published in Heart of Stone, Dear and Other Stories, Drumm Booklet no. 12 (Chris Drumm, 1983), 21–28.³³


Lafferty’s work card records submission to Virginia Kidd on October 31, 1979. A later annotation identifies Heart of Stone, Dear and Other Stories and its 1983 publication by Chris Drumm.³⁴


Notes

1. Smithsonian Institution, “Pumunangwet,” Inventory of American Sculpture, MA000521. Back to text


2. R. A. Lafferty, Serpent’s Egg: A Fantasy (Morrigan Publications, 1987), 4. Back to text


3. R. A. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” in Heart of Stone, Dear and Other Stories, Drumm Booklet no. 12 (Chris Drumm, 1983), 21–28. The narrator and Ike Casad name the reef in section 1. Back to text


4. R. A. Lafferty, work cards, “Bank and Shoal of Time” and “The End of Outward,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text


5. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” sec. 2, Arpad Arutinov’s headnote. Back to text


6. R. A. Lafferty, “Bank and Shoal of Time,” in A Spadeful of Spacetime, ed. Fred Saberhagen (Ace Books, 1981), 187–88. My identification of the five is conjectural. Back to text


7. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” sec. 1, the archery crest. Back to text


8. Sec. 1, the broken arrow and the gazebo. Back to text


9. Sec. 1, the quarterly meeting. Back to text


10. Sec. 1, Dorner’s greeting, his reply to Karns, and his exchange with Alice Oast. Back to text


11. Sec. 2, Dorner’s stirrup-cup speech. For the date of the lunar landing, see NASA, “Apollo 11.” Back to text


12. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” secs. 1–2, Fausto’s account of the quantum interval. Compare Matthew 7:13–14 (KJV). Back to text


13. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” sec. 2, Alice’s answer, Dorner’s decision, and the departure. Back to text


14. Sec. 3, the closing paragraph. Back to text


15. R. A. Lafferty, “One Minute Before,” unpublished story, 1960, transcription in my research files, 77–78, Biedermann and Healey at the precinct dinner. Back to text


16. Philip Henry Gosse, Omphalos: An Attempt to Untie the Geological Knot (John Van Voorst, 1857), 341–42, 351–53. Back to text


17. 351. Back to text


18. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” sec. 2, Dorner’s reply to Alice Oast on the violet shift and his exchange with Shalimar McGuire on the age of the universe. Back to text


19. Sec. 1, Oast and Dorner; sec. 2, Dorner on the return journey. Back to text


20. Secs. 1–2, Dorner’s reply to Oast and his account of the moon landing. Back to text


21. Sec. 2, Dorner’s reply to Drexel Bannock. Back to text


22. Pierre Vernier, La construction, l’usage, et les proprietez du quadrant nouveau de mathematique (François Vivien, 1631), 5, 8–12, and folding plate. Back to text


23. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” sec. 1, Fausto’s opening reply to Ike. Back to text


24. Sec. 2, Dorner on the violet shift and the weather vane. Back to text


25. Sec. 1, Oast on domestic breeds. On reversion and selective breeding, see Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species (John Murray, 1859), 14–15, 29–31. Back to text


26. Kevin Cheek, “Introduction to Fourth Mansions,” Yet Another Lafferty Blog, January 8, 2024. Back to text


27. R. A. Lafferty, Fourth Mansions (Ace Books, 1969), chap. 10, 191–92, and chap. 13, final paragraph; Lafferty, Fair Hills of Ocean, Oh!, unpublished typescript, November 28, 1979, chap. 6, 54–55, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 8, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text


28. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” sec. 1, Dorner’s reply to Shalimar McGuire. Back to text


29. Encyclopædia Britannica, 11th ed. (1911), 27:1022, s.v. “Verger.” Back to text


30. R. A. Lafferty, “Among the Hairy Earthmen,” Galaxy Magazine 24, no. 6 (August 1966): 96. Back to text


31. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” sec. 1, Dorner’s reply to Diogenes Pontifex. Back to text


32. Lafferty, work card, “The End of Outward.” See also the corrected carbon typescript, October 30, 1979, 14 pages, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 7, folder 15, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text


33. Lafferty, “The End of Outward,” 21–28. Back to text


34. Lafferty, work card, “The End of Outward.” Back to text

Bibliography

Cheek, Kevin. “Introduction to Fourth Mansions.” Yet Another Lafferty Blog. January 8, 2024.


Darwin, Charles. On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. John Murray, 1859.


Encyclopædia Britannica. 11th ed. 1911. Vol. 27, 1022. S.v. “Verger.”


Gosse, Philip Henry. Omphalos: An Attempt to Untie the Geological Knot. John Van Voorst, 1857.


The Holy Bible. King James Version. Matthew 7.


Lafferty, R. A. “Among the Hairy Earthmen.” Galaxy Magazine 24, no. 6 (August 1966): 88–98.


Lafferty, R. A. “Bank and Shoal of Time.” In A Spadeful of Spacetime, edited by Fred Saberhagen, 187–213. Ace Books, 1981.


Lafferty, R. A. “The End of Outward.” In Heart of Stone, Dear and Other Stories, 21–28. Drumm Booklet no. 12. Chris Drumm, 1983.


Lafferty, R. A. Fair Hills of Ocean, Oh! Unpublished typescript, 1979. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 8, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. Fourth Mansions. Ace Books, 1969.


Lafferty, R. A. “One Minute Before.” Unpublished story, 1960. Transcription in my research files.


Lafferty, R. A. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. Serpent’s Egg: A Fantasy. Morrigan Publications, 1987.


National Aeronautics and Space Administration. “Apollo 11.”


Smithsonian Institution. “Pumunangwet.” Inventory of American Sculpture. MA000521.


bottom of page