“Cliffs That Laughed” (1966/1969)
Updated: 3 hours ago

In any case the Apollonius story is not just a series of “and thens”: it drives us on toward a conclusion which restates the theme of the opening. At the beginning Apollonius encounters a king who is living in incest with his daughter, so that his daughter is also his wife: at the end Apollonius himself is a prince united with his lost wife and daughter. The story proceeds toward an end which echoes the beginning, but echoes it in a different world. The beginning is the demonic parody of the end, and the action takes place on two levels of experience. This principle of action on two levels, neither of them corresponding very closely to the ordinary world of experience, is essential to romance, and shows us that romance presents a vertical perspective which realism, left to itself, would find it very difficult to achieve.¹
Tragedy, or threatening tragic complications in romance, often involve stresses within families, such as a father’s overbearing will or the threat of incestuous relationship. . . . A comic resolution, in fact, could almost be defined as an action that breaks out of the Oedipus ring, the destruction of a family or other close-knit social group by the tensions and jealousies of its members.²
Behind various incest and Oedipal taboos is the suggestion that the hunter is seeking a false identity which is the same thing as his own destruction.³ —Northrop Frye, The Secular Scripture
Advanced Lafferty.
A few thoughts on one of Lafferty’s more intricately constructed stories, “Cliffs That Laughed.” A summary would be less helpful than a sequence of events, so you will find a timeline at the end of this post, along with my notes on tracking its narration. The story uses variants of the first person over 130 times.⁴ It is a tour de force of indexical play, with Lafferty showing how slippery the I-index can be as he piles up pragmatic markers that make his fiction seem so oral.
That play with the first person may be one reason Lafferty made Willy Jones Island a part of Argo. With so much I-indexical mayhem, it was a lock for dramatizing dissociation in The Devil Is Dead, especially since the two works share some geography.
What interests me here is sexual transgression in Lafferty. First, a word about the schizo-gash. Lafferty does something similar in “Junkyard Thoughts.”⁵
The frame narrator speaks of the “fellow in the bar.”⁶ I read the two as one man who has split. The narrator learned about Willy Jones Island from Galli at the end of the war, perhaps around the time Finnegan had his fugue in Archipelago. The island turns up again in The Devil Is Dead, where Don Lewis dates the disappearance to 1944.
“On the morning of October 1, 1944, between ten and ten thirty in the morning, on an island that is sometimes called Pulau Petir and sometimes Willy Jones Island, three American soldiers disappeared, and have not been officially seen since. The three soldiers were Sergeant Charles Santee of Orange, Texas; Corporal Robert Casper of Gobey (Morgan County), Tennessee; and PFC Timothy Lorrigan of Boston. I was one of these three men, for my name is no more Don Lewis than the names of some others here are their real names. These three disappeared from a routine patrol. One of these boys was a coward; two were not; for this reason I do not say which one was myself. “I have heard that one of these soldiers got out of the thing alive, that he has told the main part of the story in an unlikely version, and that that soldier is not me. So perhaps I am not of the living; I have felt like a dweller of the middle world since that time. Besides, I do not tell the main part of the story, but only the outré little introduction.”⁷
Don Lewis gives us the background. My bet is that he’s a further split from Lorrigan. Don says, “I lagged behind.” When Marie questions him, he says it was Lorrigan who lagged behind.⁸

In the short story, the soldiers disappear on Pulau Petir in 1945. That’s where I think the split begins. At the Red Rooster, the soldier says he was lost for more than twenty years. He sometimes thinks a blow to the head could explain the middle land, though other things convince him it was real. His wandering recalls Finnegan’s fugues. Only after we hear “I was one of those three soldiers” does the narrator tell us the fellow in the bar said it. The two accounts keep running into each other, and the barman calls both men “nutty.”⁹ I hear the split in the interruptions of what I call the “Editorial Voice.” Legend, history, and biography merge into a fractured consciousness.

When Finnegan experiences the fugue state that sends him to Ward Fourteen in Archipelago, Ignatius Ti translates the parakeet Amoy’s story about his old master, Ali ben Taife. A boy named Ali, in turn, appears in a Willy Jones Island story told by the dissociated Don Lewis.¹⁰

Now to the real weirdness.
One figure who keeps turning up in the ghost story is the Parthen. In two places in Lafferty’s work, the Parthen becomes a question of incest, though the nature of that incest differs in each case. When the Parthen appears with her mother, the possibility of incest is often close at hand.
In “Cliffs That Laughed,” the incest taboo enrages the Welsh pirate Willy Jones, who cannot sleep with his wife Margaret because he cannot tell her apart from their daughter. In Lafferty’s “Parthen,” Helen’s three daughters also resemble their mother.¹¹
Let’s start with More Than Melchisedech. The biologically childless Melchisedech Duffey molests girls in his bookstore, including one of his talismanic creations and one of his quasi-creatures.¹² I read this as a violation of the incest taboo, and yet it also scrambles the question of physical genealogy.
The temptation is to psychologize Lafferty. In The Secular Scripture, Northrop Frye treats incest as an obsessive convention of romance.¹³
Frye places the threat of incest, especially between father and daughter, in the night world. It belongs to the descent in romance.
In Frye’s account of descent, a man can get caught in a false identity. The hunter pursues something that would destroy him if he found it. In the Apollonius story, the king who takes his daughter as his wife presides over a demonic parody of the family Apollonius recovers at the end.¹⁴
Frye’s approach to incest in romance is helpful for reading both “Cliffs That Laughed” and More Than Melchisedech. In the short story the descent has no answering ascent. More Than Melchisedech complicates the pattern. Willy knows he is both a husband and a father. What he cannot tell is which he is to the woman standing in front of him. Melchisedech Duffey moves past it in a way many readers will find implausible or offensive. Confronted with the photographs, Duffey says he has confessed the few acts he considers sinful and expects his wife to forgive him.¹⁵
Galli says it takes at least twenty years to walk home from the middle land. The soldier says, “I wasn’t trying to get home. I was trying to get back to those girls even if it killed me.”¹⁶ He wants to go back to Willy’s Island and its Margarets.





Sources for the diagrams and the table of names and allusions.¹⁷
Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work card dates completion to July 15, 1966, under the title “Willy Jones Island.” He rewrote the story on August 20, 1966, and April 23, 1967. He sent it to Robert A. W. Lowndes on October 17, 1967, recorded its acceptance on November 30, and entered a $40 payment on December 16, 1968.¹⁸ Tulsa also holds a 13-page carbon, a one-page cover sheet recording the submission history, and a marked copy of the March 1969 printing.¹⁹
First published as “Cliffs That Laughed” in Magazine of Horror, March 1969. First collected in Strange Doings (1972). Reprinted in the October 1993 issue of Amazing Stories.²⁰
Notes
1. Northrop Frye, The Secular Scripture: A Study of the Structure of Romance (Harvard University Press, 1976), 49–50. Back to text
2. 137. Back to text
3. 105. Back to text
4. R. A. Lafferty, “Cliffs That Laughed,” Magazine of Horror 5, no. 2 (March 1969): 88–99. The 163 first-person singular forms comprise 118 instances of I (including contractions), 25 of me, 18 of my, and 2 of myself in narration and dialogue. The count excludes the editor’s introduction. Back to text
5. R. A. Lafferty, “The All-at-Once Man,” Galaxy 30, no. 4 (July 1970): 74. Lafferty calls Penandrew’s wound a “schizo-gash.” In “Junkyard Thoughts,” Isaac Asimov’s Science Fiction Magazine 10, no. 2 (February 1986): 95, Jack Cass and J. Palmer Cass speak out of the same mouth. Back to text
6. Lafferty, “Cliffs That Laughed,” 91. Back to text
7. R. A. Lafferty, The Devil Is Dead (Avon Books, 1971), 37–38. Back to text
8. 39. Back to text
9. Lafferty, “Cliffs That Laughed,” 88–89 (the soldier and the bar), 94 (the men knew each other on the island), 98–99 (the wound, the middle land, and the barman). Back to text
10. R. A. Lafferty, Archipelago: The First Book of the Devil Is Dead Trilogy (Manuscript Press, 1979), 72–75, 79–81. For the boy at the Big House, see Lafferty, Devil Is Dead, 41–42. Back to text
11. Lafferty, “Cliffs That Laughed,” 93–96. See also R. A. Lafferty, “Parthen,” Galaxy 33, no. 6 (May–June 1973): 88, 91. Back to text
12. R. A. Lafferty, Tales of Chicago, vol. 1 of More Than Melchisedech (United Mythologies Press, 1992), bk. 3, “Hog Butcher & Gadarene Swine,” sec. 5, and bk. 4, “Tales of Chicago,” secs. 1, 2, and 5. Book 3 identifies the talismans of Mary Catherine Carruthers and Mary Rattigan. The girls appear among those named in the photographs in book 4, section 5. Back to text
13. Frye, Secular Scripture, 44. Back to text
14. 137 (incest and the night world), 105 (the hunter), and 49–50 (Apollonius). Back to text
15. Lafferty, Tales of Chicago, bk. 4, sec. 5, the photograph and blackmail episode. Back to text
16. Lafferty, “Cliffs That Laughed,” 98. Back to text
17. For the diagrams, see the story, 88–99, along with Archipelago, 79–81, and The Devil Is Dead, 37–43. For Jilolo, see Collins English Dictionary, s.v. “Halmahera.” For the Malay terms, see Kamus Dewan, 4th ed. (Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka, 2005), s.vv. “berjumpa,” “esok,” “ru,” and “tuntung.” For Dutch pronunciation, see B. C. Donaldson, Dutch: A Linguistic History of Holland and Belgium (Martinus Nijhoff, 1983), 146. For Welsh cwbl, see Geiriadur Prifysgol Cymru, s.v. “cwbl.” For the galleon trade, see Johanna Hecht, “The Manila Galleon Trade (1565–1815),” in Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History (Metropolitan Museum of Art, October 2003). Back to text
18. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “Cliffs That Laughed” (originally “Willy Jones Island”), R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text
19. Catalogue entry for “Cliffs That Laughed,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 5, folder 19, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text
20. Lafferty, “Cliffs That Laughed,” 88–99. Reprinted in Strange Doings (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1972), 260–76. For the later reprint, see Amazing Stories 68, no. 7 (October 1993): 45–50. Back to text
Bibliography
Collins English Dictionary. S.v. “Halmahera.”
Donaldson, B. C. Dutch: A Linguistic History of Holland and Belgium. Martinus Nijhoff, 1983.
Frye, Northrop. The Secular Scripture: A Study of the Structure of Romance. Harvard University Press, 1976.
Geiriadur Prifysgol Cymru. S.v. “cwbl.”
Hecht, Johanna. “The Manila Galleon Trade (1565–1815).” In Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. Metropolitan Museum of Art, October 2003.
Kamus Dewan. 4th ed. Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka, 2005.
Lafferty, R. A. “The All-at-Once Man.” Galaxy 30, no. 4 (July 1970): 73–87.
Lafferty, R. A. Archipelago: The First Book of the Devil Is Dead Trilogy. Manuscript Press, 1979.
Lafferty, R. A. “Cliffs That Laughed.” Magazine of Horror 5, no. 2 (March 1969): 88–99.
Lafferty, R. A. “Cliffs That Laughed.” In Strange Doings, 260–76. Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1972.
Lafferty, R. A. “Cliffs That Laughed.” Amazing Stories 68, no. 7 (October 1993): 45–50.
Lafferty, R. A. “Cliffs That Laughed” (originally “Willy Jones Island”). Work card. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lafferty, R. A. The Devil Is Dead. Avon Books, 1971.
Lafferty, R. A. “Junkyard Thoughts.” Isaac Asimov’s Science Fiction Magazine 10, no. 2 (February 1986): 87–101.
Lafferty, R. A. “Parthen.” Galaxy 33, no. 6 (May–June 1973): 85–91.
Lafferty, R. A. Tales of Chicago. Vol. 1 of More Than Melchisedech. United Mythologies Press, 1992.
University of Tulsa. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library. Finding aid for the R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Series 2, box 5, folder 19.


