top of page
Search

Reading Lafferty Through Motifs

Feb 18, 2025
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago


Shelf of Arabian Nights volumes beside The Thousand and One Nights.

“It was like in an old Puca comedy, one person falls into the quicksand, and then drags a second one in after him, and then a third and a fourth, till they all disappear to their deaths. Who could help laughing at a thing like that, especially when the actors were of another people than the Puca and had been given parts in the play which were real?” The Reefs of Earth (1968), chapter 9.


Reading large chunks of Lafferty is anything but straightforward. It’s not just that his thinking is wildly inventive, sharp, and lateral—it’s that his stories and novels demand intense rereading, and there’s never enough time to do them full justice. The threat of a Puca comedy is never far away.


When I want to understand a writer, I start at both the beginning and the end of the career, then work toward the middle with surgical strikes at key points. This method has served me well in studying Lafferty, though it has led to some unexpected consequences—chief among them being that Sindbad: The Thirteenth Voyage (1989), one of his least-read works, became a crow’s nest from which to survey the full sweep of his ideas and artistry. To those unfamiliar with the novel, this might seem odd, but it helped me recognize how Serpent’s Egg (1987), East of Laughter (1988), and Sindbad are Lafferty’s late meditation on the nature of fiction.


Beginning with Sindbad was also a lot of fun. I’ve long admired The Arabian Nights, particularly in Richard Burton’s translation, and agree with G. K. Chesterton that “the most enduring pleasure is a full leisure” (“The Everlasting Nights”).


As I worked through Sindbad, I relied on a remarkable scholarly tool: H. M. El-Shamy’s A Motif Index of The Thousand and One Nights. Keyed to various translations, it’s a dream for anyone who loves The Nights—and a double delight for those who enjoy the madness of Stith Thompson’s motif indexes, which are both rigorous and more than half-mad in their relentless pursuit of classification.


The dogged passion for cataloging narrative elements is what makes Thompson (1885–1976) such a fascinating figure. He was an American folklorist now mainly remembered for his Motif-Index of Folk-Literature, an ambitious attempt to classify recurring narrative elements in folktales, myths, and legends. Influenced by the Finnish method of comparative folklore study, he aimed to catalogue recurring narrative elements in a comprehensive reference. First published between 1932 and 1936 and later revised, his index became the foundational tool for folklore research. It allowed scholars to trace the transmission and evolution of motifs across cultures. (Below is a copy of the revised Index if you want to check it out.)



Using an Arabian Nights folklore index while reading Lafferty's Sindbad sparked a question: what if there were a Lafferty motif index? I experimented with building a retrieval-augmented generation system to construct one, but I was never satisfied with the results, though I went ahead and created a motif set for all the short stories. Still, I’d love to see a proper Lafferty motif index—and I might try again.


Here’s what my partially finished motif list for "Days of Grass, Days of Straw" (1973) looks like. Some entries are direct matches; others are analogies with Thompson’s categories:


A0–A99. The prophets wrestle God directly, highlighting an act of creation shared with the deity.

A900. The floating mountain and grass-choked main street emphasize mythically altered geography.

A1172.1. The story’s sun dance brings out the sun: a ritual regulation of sunshine.

B. Buffalo, dogs, and eagles appear in surreal roles.

D. All aspects of existence (coins, telephones, daily life) operate under a pervasive magical logic.

X. The buckskin “telephone bag” is a comic pretext for collecting a badger coin; Helen answers the call herself.

V. Death, blood blessings, and dismemberment have spiritual significance.

F. Marvels include leather-built cities and spontaneous cosmic battles.

F110. Christopher’s shift from the normal city day to the “grass day” world constitutes a terrestrial otherworld journey.

F160. The unfamiliar realm has a dizzying vitality.

F170. Out-of-count intervals and mountain wrestling are miscellaneous otherworld motifs.

F171.0.1. The floating mountain is an enigma of another domain, later explained through the prophets’ wrestling with God.

F440.1. By analogy with the green vegetation spirit, the “days of grass” can suggest a spirit animating the land.

F710. The roaring river on higher ground alters its “tune,” signifying an extraordinary body of water.

F750. A hovering mountain temporarily raised above the earth: an extraordinary landform.

F760. An extraordinary city built of buckskin and filled with grass.

F770. Architectural marvels: buildings of painted hides and walls that roll up at will.

F790. Extraordinary weather and sky phenomena: the shimmering day and thunderous mountain clashes.


H (General). The prophets’ contests with God are daunting ritual trials.

H1200. The quest for ascension and cosmic knowledge involves mortal risk.

H1225. Wrestling the divine is a pursuit of the strongest possible adversary.

H1250. Entering the “days of grass” can be viewed as a quest to another world.

H1376. The question “which day is this?” becomes an allegory for the search for meaning.

L. Ascending to prophet-status or collapsing into “straw-man” form reflects abrupt reversals of fortune.

M. Wrestling God to extract new days effectively ordains the future’s shape.

N (General). Betting on buffalo battles brings chance into the grass days.

N100. The winners and losers on the mountain face radically different fates.

N770. Surreal encounters and revelations set off unexpected adventures.

N770.0.1. Gathering at the roast dog stall becomes the feast that triggers Christopher’s deeper involvement.

P. The buckskin economy, communal hunts, and pipe-smoke “change” reveal an alternate social system.

Q. Success earns cosmic potency on the mountain; failure leads to brutal ejection or straw transformation.

T. Christopher and Helen’s passionate union enacts the fertility integral to grass days.

U (General). Juxtaposing dull straw days with vibrant grass days questions the essence of being fully alive.

U100–U299. The contrast between grass days and straw days expresses opposed ways of being.

U110. Seemingly mundane spaces turn out to be surreal.

V. Wrestling God makes the religious or theurgical element explicit.

W. The strength or frailty of a character’s spirit (courage versus collapse) is central to identity.

W121. Buford’s cowardice leads him to become a mere scarecrow of straw.


X. Incongruities like a bale-of-rags telephone and buffalo coinage inject continuous surreal humor.

Z. The repeated ballad lines and references to holy skins create a formulaic ritual framework.

Z0. Repeated phrases and stylized naming of days constitute a formulistic pattern.

Seasonal pattern. Seasonal references (Indian Summer, Blue-Goose Autumn) give recurring names to days out of count.

 

bottom of page