Lafferty's Monadology
Updated: Nov 8

I was lucky enough to come across Andrew Ferguson’s thoughts on Lafferty’s ghost story early on—Lafferty's idea that his fiction forms a single, ongoing work of art, with an underlay that occasionally flickers into view. It’s a fascinating idea, but hard to pin down. If you’ve read enough Lafferty, you recognize it when it happens.
I wanted a way to track these recurrences, so I tried an extended metaphor drawn from Leibniz’s Monadology. It is a reading aid, not a claim that Lafferty adopted Leibniz’s system.
Leibniz’s Monadology
Leibniz’s monads are simple substances without parts. Each expresses the universe from its own perspective; their agreement does not depend on physical influence passing between them. God grounds their pre-established harmony.
For this analogy, I distinguish three levels of created monads, then consider God as their source:
Bare monads: perception without the distinct awareness and memory associated with souls.
Souls: more distinct perception accompanied by memory; animal life belongs here.
Rational souls or minds: knowledge of necessary truths and reflective awareness, associated with human beings.
God: the necessary, original substance from which created monads derive, not simply one more member of their hierarchy.
Repurposing Monads as a Heuristic for Reading Lafferty
I borrow the image of a universe reflected in each monad to describe Lafferty’s recurring motifs. Each may disclose something of the underlay. The analogy has limits: Leibniz’s monads do not migrate between receptacles, while a literary motif can recur in different characters and scenes.
Bare monads: small details, settings, or figures whose recurrence gives a glimpse of the underlay.
Soul monads: developed figures and motifs. Glasser is my example: his childhood toy panda trails the balloons that Epikt does not find attached to Glasser himself.
Rational monads: figures or motifs that make a mystical or cosmic relation explicit. These are ranks within my reading analogy.
Two Illustrative Passages
These two passages pair a Dutch priest with an Irish or Irish-coded speaker. The exchanges begin with self-pity and end very differently.
Passage 1: From “Dotty”
Dotty had already achieved education and aplomb. She could read and understand. In mathematics she was the best girl in school, and she bested all the boys except one. She did write a bad hand. Still, it could always be read, and many fine and flourishing hands cannot always be.
She learned a lot from Father Van Heuvel whom she treated as an equal. You cannot treat people as interiors just because they are Dutch.
“There is a certain stability about your kind,” Dotty told him. “Oh, it’s true you Dutch are stodgy and prosaic, not brilliant and intransigent like us Irish.”
“In one thing you exceed: in feeling sorry for yourselves. The Irish have brought it to a fine art.”
“Perhaps if others were as good at it they would indulge it equally. But there has to be Dutch in the world. We cannot all be birds. Some are born to be rocks.”
“That is high praise from you, Dotty. On a rock the Church was founded.”
“I wouldn’t have picked Peter if it’d been me. I don’t mean to criticize, but do you know who I’d have picked? Thomas. There was a man with a mind of his own. If he’d have been picked, the Church would have had an easier time.”
“Much easier, Dotty. But it would have been Arian, or the modern word for the same thing, Episcopal. It would not have been Catholic.”
“Are you sure?”
“I am sure, Dotty.”
“Well, some are born to be rocks, and it may be a good thing for the rest of us that they are. We can’t all be Irish and talented. But I always thought it would have been a good thing if He’d picked one Irishman for an Apostle. I wonder why He overlooked that? He didn’t overlook much.”
“We do not know for certain the race of all of the Apostles. Only eight can absolutely be set down for Jewish. There is slight evidence that two are Greek, and we can only guess about the other two.”
“Then maybe one of them was a wandering Irishman after all? But what if it should turn out to be Judas? Maybe there was no oversight on His part. He may have picked one Irishman, and in kindness it is hidden from us.”
“There is something a little Irish about Judas, Dotty. And in legend he was red-headed.”
Passage 2: From The Reefs of Earth
A priest came to see Henry Dulanty in his cell. He was an old Holland Dutchman, not one of your new young priests who doesn’t know an Analect from the Anastasis.
He found Henry reading and was surprised at the book he had.
“It’s almost like a staged thing that I should find you with that,” the old priest said, “nearly a touch of the phony there. Where are you reading?”
“Maerens incedebam sine furore, consurgens in turba clamabam.”
“Og, from Job. It goes on ‘I was the brother of dragons and companion of ostriches. My skin is become black upon me. My harp is turned to mourning.’ I had a professor once who called him the Majestic Cry-Baby. You aren’t, are you?”
“Yes, a little. We luxuriate in our misfortunes more than do the people of—that is—more than”
“More than do the people of Earth, Dulanty? I guessed you as soon as I came in. In a long life, I believed I had encountered it twice before, but I wasn’t sure. With you I am. You’re from an alien world. But it’s odd that an alien should be reading Latin.”
“Father, our briefing was a few centuries out of date, I believe. Latin, and three American Indian tongues (which I cannot identify with any presently known), were the only Earth languages I learned before I came to Earth… Our own teaching is that the Anointed will be born on the meanest of worlds, hardly to be called a world. Some have sensed that it may be Earth, but this interpretation isn’t widely held…”
(...)
Henry Dulanty confessed to the old priest, and it did kill him. Not immediately, but it killed him… It was lost in a strangeness more frightful than any evil he had ever suspected. The talking creature was an almost-man, but he flicked his ears like an animal and showed green billowing flames behind his eyes…
Circulation and Transposition
In Dotty, the pairing produces affectionate argument and comedy. In The Reefs of Earth, it becomes an encounter between different kinds of person, with fatal consequences for the priest. In my terminology, Dotty can occupy the rational level while the two figures in Reefs belong to the soul level. The labels help me compare the scenes.
The ghostly connection, on this reading, lies in a recurring relation that changes as it passes from one scene to another. The underlay becomes visible through both the resemblance and the difference.
Paraphrasing Monadology §§56–57: each monad is a living mirror of the universe from its own point of view.
“Each type of story element in Lafferty is a living mirror of the underlay, according to its own point of view.”
This gives me a way to track other recurrences without assuming that they all mean the same thing.

* I read Pilgrim in Not to Mention Camels as a bare monad who mistakes himself for a rational one. That is a description within this analogy, not a literal denial of his personhood or a universal rule about how Lafferty treats his characters.


