"The Most Forgettable Story in the World" (1971/1974)
Updated: Nov 9

Mountains delectable they now ascend, Where Shepherds be, which to them do commend Alluring things, and things that cautious are, Pilgrims are steady kept by faith and fear. — John Bunyan, The Pilgrim's Progress (1678)
“By stumbling backwards over no road at all, down hill and through tangled brush, until we found ourselves in the bottom of a pit,” a dour old machine issued. “Then we noticed that the bottom of the pit was actually the top of the Delectable Mountain. If there is nothing lower, then also there is nothing higher. To be in the middle of a plain is the same as to be on the top of a mountain, if all the mountains are gone and forgotten. No, I don't believe that there are any roads, or have ever been. Why should there be roads to get to where we already are? And why should we leave when there is nowhere else to go? What need of roads?”
“The Most Forgettable Story in the World” opens at a meeting on “The Insufficiency of Mere Perfection.” Only a dozen people and half-a-dozen machines attend. They call their world perfect, but cannot explain how they reached it. As one character puts it, it is “a familiar syndrome, this worrying that there is something forgotten.”
They cannot recover the meanings of “hills,” “destination,” and “offspring.” The stories they half-remember offer incompatible accounts of who they are and where they came from.
A young machine recalls the Grimmsian story of “princes turned into frogs”; a young girl supplies the Darwinian story of “frogs turned into princes.” I read the first beside the Fall and the second beside evolution. Neither speaker can recover what a frog or a prince is.
A dour old machine offers another theory: there was no journey or purpose at all. He says they got here by accident, by “stumbling backwards over no road at all . . . until we found ourselves in the bottom of a pit.”
At the end, a young man says, “I remember what I have forgotten.” What he has lost is “My destination and my name.” He cannot recover either: “Oh no, no. I merely remember that they are what I have forgotten.” The narrator then asks how humanity’s story of its origin and destination became forgotten.
To appreciate this one, try playing the “What are the best stories to introduce someone to Lafferty" game. As far as the Lafferty fan community goes, this game is all but done. A few years ago, The Best of R. A. Lafferty (2021) tried to play the game well and screwed it up by not tapping into the fan community. The commentary was often lazy and self-involved, and the selection as unimaginative as “Best Of” collections usually are.
This game usually defaults to identifying the essentials, the ought-to-haves, the nice-to-haves, and so forth. What is an essential? Honking no-brainers. “Nine Hundred Grandmothers”? There are other ways to play the game.
So, a confession about "Nine Hundred Grandmothers." It’s not one of my favorites. I have ideas about it, including what the laughter is about, but I’m not sure the story even makes my top fifty. Of course, I see why "Nine Hundred Grandmothers" is considered one of Lafferty’s best and most memorable stories, and I see why he thought so himself. But if people asked me what to read to get to know Lafferty, they’d run up against my nasty case of not wanting to play the “Best of” version of the how-to-introduce-people-to-Lafferty game.
"The Most Forgettable Story in the World” may be the best example of another approach. It’s “best” not in the sense of "Nine Hundred Grandmothers." It’s best in the sense of being a shortcut to the RAL nerve center.
Its concentration of Lafferty’s preoccupations offers several routes into the less familiar stories and novels. “Nine Hundred Grandmothers” may be less helpful if its apparent absurdism becomes the model for everything else.
Now contrast it with "The Most Forgettable Story in the World," where we encounter the problems of the large cast of characters, most of whom invite no emotional investment as characters; of dialogue overriding action—or rather, of dialogue as intellectual action; and of resolution deferred or absent to put pressure on reader reception.
We see major themes and images pulled into synchronous orbit: amnesia; flatland and mountains; humans and machines in contrast with each other, and machines and humans in contrast with other humans and other machines; intergenerational disagreement; the felix culpa versus the phylogenetic tree; linguistic degradation as the coefficient of cultural decadence. Catholicism (Augustine) and Protestantism (the Delectable Mountain). One could go on.
I read its amnesia as a double loss: the loss associated with the Fall, and the cultural forgetting that accompanies the collapse of a world.
This makes it a short-story counterpart to “The Day After the World Ended,” and to the argument developed in In a Green Tree. The story’s inhabitants cannot account for their own condition. The essay addresses its readers directly and calls on them to create a new world:
"By every definition, this is Utopia. Of course some of us have always regarded Utopia as a calamity, but most of you have not. In its flexibility and in its wide-open opportunities, this is the total Utopia. Anything that you can conceive of, you can do in this non-world. Nothing can stop you except a total bankruptcy of creativity."
The comparison shows how much the short story leaves unresolved.
If I were assembling the short stories into a super-anthology sequenced by theme, I would be inclined to place "The Most Forgettable Story in the World" first, as a kind of prelude. The choice would be programmatic rather than commercial. After all, the double meaning of “The Most Forgettable Story in the World” is a joke about the second kind of thing.








Bibliographical Note
Written March 20, 1971. First published in Long Night of Waiting by Andre Norton and Other Stories, edited by Roger Elwood (Aurora Publishers, 1974).
Lafferty’s work-history card records submission to Virginia Kidd on March 20, 1971, and identifies Roger Elwood’s anthology as the story’s destination.
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “The Most Forgettable Story in the World,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. “The Most Forgettable Story in the World,” Internet Speculative Fiction Database, accessed October 24, 2026, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?68102=.


