top of page
Search

The Carnivalesque

Oct 12, 2025
14 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

William Blake illustration of a long-bearded figure seated beneath a stone arch.

“The answer to the Mystery of Matter (why should there even be so cumbersome a thing as matter? Why did the Word have to be made Flesh? Was not the Making of Matter rather a cheap, and also difficult, trick for a Spirit to indulge in?) — the answer to this contains the answer to the question ‘How Did God Get to be God?’” — “In the Turpentine Trees” (1983)

"Snuffles" on my mind. I reread the edited transcript of the LaffCon3 panel on the story. The panel underestimates the story’s Catholic parody. Andrew Ferguson has addressed the metafictional aspects elsewhere. After so many words, the panel still left the violence in "Snuffles" unclear. Bakhtin on Rabelais got in the way.


Consider one of my favorite Rabelais characters, the very funny Friar Jean. The following passage is from the linguistically wild 17th-century Urquhart edition (the edition Lafferty knew):


So great was the cry of the wounded, that the prior of the abbey with all his monks came forth, who, when they saw these poor wretches so slain amongst the vines, and wounded to death, confessed some of them. But whilst the priests were busied in confessing them, the little monkies ran all to the place where Friar John was, and asked him wherein he would be pleased to require their assistance. To which he answered that they should cut the throats of those he had thrown down upon the ground. They presently, leaving their outer habits and cowls upon the rails, began to throttle and make an end of those whom he had already crushed. Can you tell with what instruments they did it? With fair gullies, which are little hulchbacked demi-knives, the iron tool whereof is two inches long, and the wooden handle one inch thick, and three inches in length, wherewith the little boys in our country cut ripe walnuts in two while they are yet in the shell, and pick out the kernel, and they found them very fit for the expediting of that weasand-slitting exploit. In the meantime Friar John, with his formidable baton of the cross, got to the breach which the enemies had made, and there stood to snatch up those that endeavoured to escape. Some of the monkitos carried the standards, banners, ensigns, guidons, and colours into their cells and chambers to make garters of them. But when those that had been shriven would have gone out at the gap of the said breach, the sturdy monk quashed and felled them down with blows, saying, These men have had confession and are penitent souls; they have got their absolution and gained the pardons; they go into paradise as straight as a sickle, or as the way is to Faye (like Crooked-Lane at Eastcheap). — Gargantua and Pantagruel, Book I, Chapter 27 (1534)

The prose texture helps explain why Lafferty is closer to Urquhart's version of Rabelais than to Bakhtin’s version of Rabelais. Reading Rabelais closely teaches us more about Lafferty than reading Bakhtin. People are now more familiar with Bakhtin and the carnivalesque than with Rabelais himself.


C. L. Barber’s Shakespeare’s Festive Comedy (1959) appeared just before Bakhtin’s work was translated into English. It makes a superficially similar point to Bakhtin’s about the carnivalesque, though it does not use the term. Barber says that festive comedy loosens social decorum, renewing it. It doesn’t overturn order; it restores it. Festivity is cyclical, not revolutionary.


Bakhtin also discusses repetition, renewal, and the temporary suspension of hierarchies. His utopianism separates him from Barber and Lafferty.


Bakhtin believed carnival has a liberating, utopian quality. The utopian side of the carnivalesque breaks down hierarchical distance. Through it, people glimpse a freer, more equal world. It dethrones the weight of medieval moral seriousness. That’s why critics like Eagleton, as well as Stallybrass and White, argued that Bakhtin blurs ritual renewal and political revolution in an unhelpful way.


This is relevant to Snuffles" because Lafferty hates utopia, and there is nothing utopian, redemptive, or emancipatory about “Snuffles.” A reader may find something utopian in Lafferty’s exuberance. The real Bakhtinian here is the reader who projects onto the writer.


“Snuffles” is far from the precincts of Bakhtinian carnival. It is closer to Barber’s festive comedy: dark, conservative, and order-affirming. In “Snuffles,” Lafferty uses festivity inside a Gnostic pocket cosmos to wake up modern readers and remind them that Gnosticism has been one of the most dangerous enemies of his faith, second only to Arianism.


The appeal to Bakhtin sounds vacuumed out of a handbook on lit-crit terminology. The argument runs: Lafferty loved Rabelais and was clearly influenced by him (true); Bakhtin wrote smart stuff about Rabelais (true); and Lafferty’s work has a carnival feel (yes, but let’s pause), so maybe Bakhtin can help us understand Lafferty (false). The argument treats influence as a transitive property.


Much in Rabelais doesn’t line up with Bakhtin. Just ask a Rabelais scholar what Bakhtin misses.


What if the parts of Rabelais that are closest to Lafferty are the parts about which Bakhtin was weakest? Reading Lafferty through Bakhtin can obscure Lafferty’s anti-utopianism and repeat the distortions of reading Rabelais through Bakhtin. See The Last Laugh.


Bakhtin treats carnival as subversive of medieval order. Lafferty loved and was nostalgic for the order of the Middle Ages. Think of “Among the Hairy Earthmen.” The alien juvenile delinquents in that story play at some kind of carnival-like funny business, and he condemns it. A useful account of carnival must distinguish the forms Lafferty celebrates from those he condemns. A Bakhtinian reading is likely to go wrong without being made to stand on its head like a clowning Snuffles.


Back to LaffCon3. Montejo has just said a bit about Bakhtin, and then added, "while I think the violence here in ‘Snuffles’ may have those kinds of elements as well, I think we need to see that there’s also a carnival-type violence at play." He adds:


But I tend to think that there’s also this aspect to Lafferty regarding the place of violence within the Catholic imagination. And by that, I mean that there is from earliest Christianity up through the Reformation and beyond this focus on martyrdom accounts, literary and artistic depictions of the deaths of the martyrs, which are incredibly gruesome at times. This is where we get the stories of people being ripped apart by wild lions in the arena and so forth. Some of these descriptions are lovingly detailed, but they are not done in a prurient way—because of the cheap thrills that the depiction of violence might give us—but rather because of an underlying understanding that there’s a kind of redemptive quality, a soteriological dimension to violence. Because the violence suffered by the martyrs ultimately points to the redemptive death of the Savior on the Cross. So, the idea here is that the depiction of such violence is integral to our understanding of the order of the universe, salvation history, and the place of humanity within both societal and cosmic structures.

Martyrdom provides a contrast to “Snuffles.” For Lafferty, suffering through violence can be redemptive only when the suffering is merited through the treasury of Christ’s passion. In “Snuffles,” though, violence means moral negation, not redemption. We are nowhere near the soteriological imagery that Montejo points to.


The story world of "Snuffles" excludes redemptive suffering from its parodic thought experiment about Gnosticism. It is a fierce critique of modernity, targeting SF genre conventions (the metafictional) and the SF person, which is why it also includes coded attacks on evolution and open attacks on positivism.


What connects this to Bakhtin? Is the claim that Lafferty’s carnivalesque is somehow redemptive because it is violent, and that this violence links to the utopian potential Bakhtin sees in carnival, because Lafferty, as a Catholic, connects both merited and unmerited suffering in some way, and this way is relevant to salvation? Also, something about playacting? Is it that Catholics roleplay at martyrdom the way the girl does in Flannery O’Connor’s “A Temple of the Holy Ghost”? The logic isn’t clear.


Juvenalian satire provides a closer precedent. Both Rabelais and Lafferty laugh at violence because they are Juvenalian, not Horatian, satirists. They are rowdy and mordant. If you aren’t careful, both men can look a little wicked because they are trickster satirists like Swift. The Whiggish Horace Walpole wrote, “Swift was a good writer, but had a bad heart.” The Juvenalian impulse makes the Whiggish squirm because it is far more at home in a high-church conservative sensibility than in a low-church, theologically latitudinarian one, to extend the Swift-Walpole analogy.


The Christian Juvenalian doesn’t wring hands over the fact that some people are going to hell after being torn apart. Providence governs this too: God uses both ministering angels and scourges. Judith beheaded Holofernes, and the guy had it coming.


In another register, Snuffles doesn’t crucify martyrs. He shreds fools. Juvenal shreds them. Rabelais shreds them. Swift shreds them. Lafferty shreds them. Snuffles is a fool, but Snuffles is a scourge. In Christian art, martyrdom is a means of redemption, as the person accepts suffering through the gift of faith. In "Snuffles," the explorers’ deaths mean nothing. Phelan “died like a craven.” Margie dies softly, pathetically in the modern sense, after trying to cajole her killer. Billy Cross, ever the balladeer, dies with a quip on his lips, puffing his pipe: “I hate to go like this, Snuff, old boy.”


These bloody deaths happen in a Gnostic parody world where grace doesn’t exist. In a Gnostic cosmos, you are in trouble. The suffering won’t mean anything. There’s no redemption, just misery without purpose. The meaning of the bloodsmell comes from outside the frame. To put it in frame is to miss the point.


The character who prays, “O Lord . . . however it ends, don't let it have a pat ending. That I couldn't stand,” ends up as kibble: a joke about teleology. But who is he praying to? He isn’t praying. It’s not even an idiom in his mouth. It’s a non-cognitivist grunt, just a modern way of showing frustration. Look up how many times in his millions of words Lafferty has a character say O Lord. This is withering satire.


As a demiurge, Snuffles cannot create from the inside out. He isn’t like God, whose act of creation gives things purpose through the gift of essence and real ends, as Lafferty held. There is only existence. There are no entelechies, no teloi. Snuffles is a bad craftsbear, shaping things without meaning. He’s a funny scary bungler who admits his own failures: “I would be the last to deny that I miscalculated the gravity, a simple mathematical error that anyone could make . . . You may wonder why my birds have hair. I will confess it, I did not know how to make feathers.”


In most forms of Gnosticism, the demiurge fails to create a universe that is coherent, good, or purposeful. The resulting cosmos is flawed, corrupt, and material, populated by hostile forces (the archons) that obstruct spiritual ascent. The koine kosmos, in effect, backfires. If you ever meet a demiurge on the street and want to know whether it is Gnostic or Platonic, ask if it can do teleology. If it cannot give its creations final causes, it’s a Gnostic demiurge.


In heretical Gnosticism, the only “purpose” lies not in the cosmos itself but in what the cosmos vainly tries to contain: the spark, the pneuma, bits of the idios kosmos, exogenous traces of the originary struggling to escape a material prison. It is non-sacramental. Blood is just blood.


Comparison of Bakhtin’s view of carnival with interpretations emphasizing ritual continuity and social order.

Bellota:


  • There is no Grace.

  • There is no Redemption.

  • Suffering is pointless, not soteriological.

  • Creation has no ultimate purpose or telos.


"Snuffles" has much more in common with C. L. Barber’s idea of festive comedy than with Mikhail Bakhtin’s concept of the carnivalesque. As a critical term, the carnivalesque imagines a liberating utopia beyond hierarchy, with revolutionary potential. Nothing in "Snuffles" is utopian or revolutionary. The story is festively violent. The irony is restorative, mean, and Juvenalian.


We get a bear on a throne, a reminder of why order, purpose, and hierarchy matter. “Never does nature say one thing but wisdom another,” wrote Juvenal. “I did not know how to make feathers,” saith Snuffles. Georgina recalls a Lord of Misrule from a parade float in Nola, but that resemblance does not make Snuffles Bakhtinian. He is a nasty demiurge, and she is a fool. Lafferty’s carnival serves a different purpose from Bakhtin’s.


Two Readings of “Snuffles”


Question

Montejo’s reading

My reading

Purpose

A “metaphysical puzzle” about reality, knowledge, and a flawed creator. (pp. 191–192, 196, 204)

A Catholic parody of Gnosticism and modernity: a world without divine grace or redemptive meaning.

Festivity

A Bakhtinian inversion of cosmic order. Temporary chaos restores order and leaves life “hopefully rejuvenated.” (pp. 197–198)

Festivity becomes a grotesque trap in a world without purpose or joy.

Violence

Violence has a “redemptive quality” and “soteriological dimension.” The explorers’ suffering echoes Catholic martyrdom; their deaths “restore a balance to society and the cosmos.” (pp. 200, 202)

The explorers’ suffering serves no redemptive purpose. They are fools, not martyrs.

Conclusion

The explorers die before “that ultimate leap into knowledge.” The metaphysical puzzle remains unresolved. (pp. 204–205)

The story condemns a Gnostic cosmos without grace, salvation, or transcendent meaning, and satirizes modernity.

---


Reception of Bakhtin’s Carnivalesque in Anglophone Academia


  • 1967 – Julia Kristeva introduces Bakhtin’s ideas: Bulgarian-French theorist Julia Kristeva publishes an essay (in French) explaining Bakhtin’s concepts of dialogism and carnival, bringing the “carnivalesque” to the attention of Western theorists.


  • 1968 – First English translation of Bakhtin’s Rabelais study: Mikhail Bakhtin’s Rabelais and His World (original Russian 1965) appears in English, translated by Hélène Iswolsky (MIT Press). Bakhtin presents carnival as the subversive comic folk culture he finds in Rabelais.


  • 1973 – Bakhtin’s Dostoevsky book in English: Ardis Publishers releases Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics (trans. R. W. Rotsel). The book examines polyphony and carnivalization in Dostoevsky’s novels, including their inversions and free dialogue.


  • 1981 – Bakhtin’s essays in English: The Dialogic Imagination, a collection of Bakhtin’s essays (Univ. of Texas Press), is published in English. In the introduction, Michael Holquist calls Bakhtin “one of the leading thinkers of the twentieth century.”


  • 1981 – Terry Eagleton’s Marxist critique: Literary critic Terry Eagleton questions the politics of the carnivalesque in his essay “Carnival and Comedy: Bakhtin and Brecht” (in Walter Benjamin, or Towards a Revolutionary Criticism). Eagleton argues that carnival is “a licensed affair in every sense, a permissible rupture of hegemony, a contained popular blow-off.” In other words, it is an authorized safety-valve rather than a true revolution.


  • 1980s – Scholarly debate on subversion vs. containment: Research on popular culture describes carnivals and feasts of fools as permitted temporary inversions after which the social order resumed unchanged. On this reading, temporary “ritual rebellion” can reinforce the existing order.


  • 1984 – New translations and Todorov: The University of Minnesota Press publishes a new English edition of Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics, edited and translated by Caryl Emerson (with intro by Wayne C. Booth). The same year, Bulgarian-French critic Tzvetan Todorov’s monograph Mikhail Bakhtin: The Dialogical Principle appears in English.


  • 1984 – Umberto Eco’s response: In a contribution to a 1984 symposium on carnival (published in Carnival!), novelist-semiotician Umberto Eco asserts the essential conservatism of carnival. He argues that historically, carnival was an instrument of social control (authorities “licensed” misrule to prevent real dissent) and warns that modern mass media enact a “continuous carnivalization of life” that substitutes mindless fun for genuine politics.


  • 1986 – Carnivalesque in cultural theory: Peter Stallybrass and Allon White’s book The Politics and Poetics of Transgression (Cornell University Press, 1986) uses Bakhtin’s carnivalesque to analyze literature and culture. They examine the class and bodily politics of carnival’s inversions of high and low, sacred and profane. Stallybrass and White conclude that “it actually makes little sense to fight out the issue of whether carnivals are intrinsically radical or conservative”, since carnival can both contest and tacitly uphold social hierarchies.


  • 1989 – Extension to film and media: Film scholar Robert Stam publishes Subversive Pleasures: Bakhtin, Cultural Criticism, and Film (1989), which applies Bakhtinian concepts – including the grotesque and carnivalesque – to cinema and popular media. This is “the first extended application” of Bakhtin’s carnival theory beyond literature into mass-media criticism.


  • 1990s – Russo, Rushdie, Carter, and Danow: Mary Russo’s “Female Grotesques: Carnival and Theory” (essay, 1986) and her book The Female Grotesque: Risk, Excess, and Modernity (1994) draw on Bakhtin’s grotesque-carnival to analyze the female body and subversive laughter. Critics read Salman Rushdie’s and Angela Carter’s combinations of magical realism and social satire through Bakhtin’s carnivalesque. David K. Danow’s The Spirit of Carnival: Magical Realism and the Grotesque (1995) links Bakhtin’s carnivalesque to Latin American magical realism and the grotesque in modern fiction.


  • 2000s – Organizational communication and digital culture: Studies of organizational communication and digital culture describe online forums and social media as “carnival” spaces of dissent and play. Debate continues over whether consumer carnival enables dissent or absorbs it. 


  • 2022 – Ed Simon on carnival: Ed Simon in “Who Still Needs the Carnivalesque?” (The Baffler, 2022) calls for reviving carnival’s radical, populist spirit in politics.


Statue of a winged, lion-headed figure with a serpent coiled around its body.

The Demiurge in Western Thought

(4th c. BCE → 19th c.)


c. 360 BCE — Plato introduces the Demiurge as benevolent craftsman.

In Timaeus 28a–29b, the dêmiourgos (“craftsman”) models the cosmos on eternal Forms, imposing mathematical order on recalcitrant pre-cosmic “chaos.” The maker is purposive and good; the account is offered as an eikôs muthos/logos (a likely story/reason). Key features: exemplarism, teleology, and a strict distinction between intelligible model and generated world.


1st c. BCE–1st c. CE — Hellenistic/early imperial receptions (Philo; proto–Middle Platonism).

Philo of Alexandria reworks Platonic cosmogony into biblical monotheism: God creates through his Logos—functionally occupying demiurgic roles but as divine Word/Wisdom rather than a subordinate artisan.


1st–2nd c. CE — Middle Platonists systematize: Alcinous, Plutarch, Numenius.

Handbooks/commentaries (e.g., Alcinous’ Didaskalikos) and essays by Plutarch and fragments of Numenius elaborate the hierarchy: the Good/First God, a second divine Intellect (often identified with the Demiurge), and the World-Soul as mediator. Numenius tends to split the demiurgic intellect in its encounter with matter.


2nd century — Christian “Gnostic” transformations: the hostile/ignorant Demiurge.

Sethian and related materials (e.g., Apocryphon of John) polemically invert Plato: the world-maker (Yaldabaoth/Saklas/Samael) is an ignorant or arrogant ruler who falsely claims ultimate divinity; the material cosmos is a prison. (Survives in multiple Coptic witnesses at Nag Hammadi.)


Late 2nd–early 3rd c. — Patristic responses and heresiologies (Irenaeus, Tertullian).

Irenaeus (Adversus Haereses) catalogues and refutes demiurgic myths, reporting the Gnostic claim that the Demiurge “imagined he created” unaided; Tertullian (Adversus Marcionem) defends the OT Creator as the true good God, even while adopting “demiurge” as a neutral label for the biblical maker. These polemical accounts remain sources for the doctrines they attack.


3rd century — Origen’s Christian Platonism: subordinating demiurgy to creatio.

Origen’s On First Principles integrates Platonic cosmology into Christian doctrine: creation flows from the one God (not an inferior craftsman) via the Logos; the Platonic schema is re-interpreted within Trinitarian metaphysics.


3rd century — Plotinus’ Neoplatonism rejects the Gnostic demotion of the maker.

In Ennead II.9 (Against the Gnostics), Plotinus defends the goodness of the sensible cosmos and repudiates the idea of an ignorant/evil demiurge. In his own system, the “demiurgic” role belongs to Nous (Intellect) as the living Forms; creation is emanation, not temporal manufacture.


4th–5th centuries — Demiurgy in Iamblichus and Proclus.

Theurgic currents (Iamblichus) and systematic exegesis (Proclus’ Commentary on the Timaeus) interpret “Demiurge” within a hierarchy descending from the One through Intellect and Soul, often correlating the Demiurge with Zeus and assigning “demiurgic” causality to divine Intellect. Proclus becomes the medieval West’s most influential philosophical reader of Timaeus.


4th–5th centuries — Latin West: Chalcidius’ Latin Timaeus.

Chalcidius’ partial Latin translation and extended commentary on Timaeus (to 53c) becomes the central Platonic conduit for the Latin Middle Ages, combining Middle Platonic and Neoplatonic interpretations.


4th–6th centuries — Doctrinal consolidation of creation ex nihilo.

While Christian Platonists retain purpose and exemplarism, Christian theology teaches creatio ex nihilo, sharply distinguishing biblical creation from Platonic “crafting.” In medieval theology (e.g., Aquinas, ST I, q.45), God creates without pre-existent matter.


12th–13th centuries — Dualist heresies and a demiurgic “evil creator” motif in the Latin Middle Ages.

Bogomil and Cathar movements are portrayed (largely via hostile sources) as teaching a sinister world-maker (sometimes identified with Satan/Satanael), echoing late-antique dualisms. The degree of continuity with ancient Gnosis is disputed.


15th century — Renaissance Platonism and Ficino’s Timaeus revival.

Ficino’s translations and commentaries re-center Timaeus in humanist curricula and Christianize Platonic cosmology: the world-maker becomes the providential Christian God working teleologically through an ensouled cosmos.


Late 16th century — Hermetic/Neoplatonic cosmologies (Bruno and allies).

Renaissance Hermetism (which Ficino had popularized) sometimes invokes a demiurgic intellect mediating divine power; Bruno radicalizes the animated, infinite cosmos while drawing on Ficinian Platonism/Hermetism.


17th century — Cambridge Platonists (Cudworth) and “plastic nature.” Seeking an alternative to occasionalism and mechanism, Cudworth posits a “Plastick Nature,” an unconscious, lawlike, purposive agency executing divine ideas—comparable to an impersonal demiurge within nature. His True Intellectual System describes purposive action in nature without positing a lesser god.


17th–18th centuries — Early modern uses of the craftsman metaphor.

Leibniz’s architect/engineer God and (more programmatically) Kant’s Critique of Judgment (Part II) relocate “craftsman” language into regulative teleology: nature must be judged “as if” purposively organized, but no literal cosmic artisan is affirmed by theoretical reason. The demiurge becomes a heuristic rather than a metaphysical agent.


19th century — German Idealism and Naturphilosophie treat creation as an immanent process.

In Schelling’s Naturphilosophie and related works, nature is a living, self-articulating power; “demiurgy” diffuses into the identity of nature and spirit. Hegel treats ancient Gnosticism within the history of religion, but the system’s absolute idealism leaves no room for a subordinate world-maker.

 

bottom of page