top of page
Search

"Seven Story Dream" (1961/1973)

Jan 15
15 min read

Updated: Nov 11


Facade of a brick apartment building in Tulsa, with rows of windows and a Now Leasing sign above the entrance.
Pre-War Apartments, Tulsa, OK
Q: Do you believe in the perfectibility of man, or is he a constant fool at odds with the gods of the universe, to be forever rebuffed at his attempt to rise above the madness which surrounds him? RAL: The perfectibility of “man”? I believe in the perfectibility of people—some people, possibly most people. I do not believe in the perfectibility of society, or of the world, or of “man” in the abstract. Maybe it is a madness that surrounds and rebuffs abstract man. But each person can select his own ambient, because it is subjective to such a large degree. The madness is optional, both for one’s self and for the surroundings. You can send it back to be cooked right. But you don’t have to accept the raw madness. Sure, the individual is perfectible (though there’s probably a less pompous word for it somewhere). Perfection (the real meaning of the word is “completion,” not “faultlessness”) is always there for the taking. A person will finally come to it unless he refuses it. You’re making me sound pompous the way you put these questions—“constant fool at odds with the gods of the universe.” That’s not a real phrase; that’s one of the consensus impositions that somebody stuck in your pocket when you weren’t looking. Throw it away. —R. A. Lafferty, interview with R. J. Whitaker, “Maybe They Needed Killing & the Importance of Happiness,” in Cranky Old Man from Tulsa (1990), pp. 57–58; spelling and punctuation normalized.
“Why did you kill the girl, Gadberry?” “Jealousy, frustration, curiosity . . . ” “I can understand the jealousy. She was an attractive girl. What was the frustration?” “She was almost perfect, but not quite, and it is that which is just short of a masterpiece that infuriates. It is so near—yet it misses. I'm always in anger to destroy a near-masterpiece.” “So you destroyed her. And the third element was your curiosity, like when you said, ‘The girl was somehow completed in death.’ You had to see how she would look dead.”

In making a mostly aesthetic decision to carry out a murder, Gadberry reflects also on the morality of the author as artist, even to the point of staging the opening scene for maximum sensory effect (in the process ‘savagely striking down’ a lone white flower—again, subtlety not really the point of this piece). He cites as his motives ‘jealousy, frustration, curiosity,’ but the first two are clearly deprecated to the third, which he shares with any author who creates a character for the sole purpose of killing them off. —Andrew Ferguson

Again, we come to perfection. Lafferty approached it from multiple angles in his work, creating strange shapes from it. The story that develops this theme most fully is the minor “I’ll See It Done and Then I’ll Die,” in which the plot hinges on fantasies and misunderstandings of completion and perfection. That story was written after The Ghost Story was well underway. However, an earlier, prenucleation story from 1961 addresses the idea of perfection with remarkable intensity: the metafictional detective tale “Seven Story Dream.” It is metafictional in part because Lafferty never wrote mysteries that were not, in one way or another, self-reflexive.


In what follows, I want to think about how “Seven Story Dream” has been read and propose a counterreading of Andrew Ferguson’s interpretation. The only other time I have discussed Ferguson’s readings in depth was in relation to mimesis—an issue essential to understanding what worlds mean in Lafferty. Ferguson identified the manuscript revision. I dispute the moral consequence he draws from it. A brief summary comes first, followed by the revision and an analysis that develops the limitations of Ferguson’s reading.


“Seven Story Dream” is filled with fine and amusing detail. It piles on characters. Much of its pleasure lies in the fact that iterative pile-up is a clutter of odd personalities and red herrings. This summary strips them away to foreground the development of the murder plot.


The story begins with Gilford Gadberry, a pompous, second-rate artist, a man who often finds nature aesthetically displeasing and might best be described as a would-be perfectionist. One morning, Gadberry, still awake from the night before, examines the body of his neighbor, Minnie Jo Merry, on the lawn of their apartment building. He surveys the elements of the scene, running them through his mind to determine what is off. The offending detail is a white aster among the hollyhocks, which he savagely strikes down. Only then does he report the murder to the police.


Close-up of a white aster with a yellow center against green foliage.
Tall hollyhocks with pink, red and white flowers in a garden.

The murder investigation quickly zeroes in on the building’s eccentric tenants. Detectives Keil and Gold suspect a resident, because no one appears to have left the building after the dew fell except Gadberry—a very Lafferty-ish clue. They question the off-puttingly devout landlady Mrs. Raffel, a timid dishwasher named Lamprey, a merchant named Izzard, and George Handle, a gullible man who uses sleep-learning recordings to “educate” himself. As they dig in, they learn Minnie Jo was "friendly" with everyone. Most of the story takes place here, with the detectives interviewing everyone until something unexpected happens. When asked who killed Minnie Jo, the simple-minded George Handle offers a repetitive admission, saying he strangled Minnie Jo Merry and threw her out the window.


The detectives find the confession suspicious because it sounds robotic and because Handle believes he committed the act within a dream. The detectives return to the apartment complex and learn from the guard that Gadberry has been trying to enter Handle’s newly locked room; they then bring him along to find the incriminating recording. The twist in the story is that Gadberry has used Handle’s sleep-learning machine night after night to condition him to confess on cue. Gadberry admits he killed Minnie Jo out of artistic frustration, because she was a near-masterpiece that “needed” to be destroyed. Those are the broad contours of "Seven Story Dream."


What is the revision? In the 1961 manuscript, as transcribed by Ferguson, the recording repeats a confession (“I killed Minnie Jo Merry . . .”) until George Handle learns it; in the published version, it instead trains George Handle to answer on cue to the question “Who killed Minnie Jo Merry?”, and it adds Gadberry’s line about “uninspired questioners” and the “cliché”.


I agree with Ferguson that the revision is significant. The disagreement over reading the story centers on why it is significant. He argues that “Seven Story Dream” is a meta-mystery about how murder mysteries work: the plot’s hypnopædia frame-up and the story’s clutter of “tapes, wires, records” pull attention away from the killer’s identity (never really in doubt) to the mechanisms and motives that make a corpse “necessary” in a piece of detective fiction. In Ferguson's reading, the murder is an aesthetic problem—Minnie Jo Merry is made “more aesthetically pleasing dead than alive.” Ferguson takes this outward into a critique of the genre itself, which often requires a body to satisfy what Ferguson calls its own ironic, even sadistic, aesthetic.


At a meta level, culpability raises questions about the authorial impulse to invent a character to kill another. Ferguson calls this a “grim promontory” to find oneself on, and he wonders whether it might be why Lafferty sat on the story for a decade.


He sees Gilford Gadberry as a true Decadent who elevates aesthetic experience above ordinary morality, then says Virginia Kidd’s addition to the story is important because it reintroduces the competing moral/rational framework of detective fiction: Gadberry knowingly panders to “uninspired questioners." This pandering betrays his aesthetic absolutism and pulls the story back from pure decadence into a serviceable detective story that critiques the genre’s clichés without letting its amorality swallow the narrative. The view is that an artist avoids clichés. The final story is said to be more in line with the Chestertonian Father Brown stories. Finally, Kidd's addition made the story more marketable.


First, points of agreement. There are three. Lafferty is metafictional. The killer was never in doubt. Virginia Kidd made the story more marketable.


Now to the points of disagreement. There is a great deal in Ferguson’s argument with which I disagree, and it would be easy to get lost in the weeds. My first impulse is to address, at some length, how his reading deploys Northrop Frye and Chesterton, both of whom illuminate Lafferty. Because the Frye point largely subsumes the Chesterton one, Chesterton receives only brief treatment here. Readers uninterested in Frye, or in how he bears on Ferguson’s argument, may wish to skip ahead.


In Anatomy of Criticism, Frye places detective fiction within ironic comedy. That classification leaves room for moralized melodrama and the reintegration of an existing order. Ferguson’s either/or excludes possibilities that Frye explicitly allows.


In The Secular Scripture, Frye writes that “the detective story operates, for the most part, in a deeply conservative social area, where the emphasis is on reintegrating the existing order” (138). Frye distinguishes this reintegration from complete justice. Detection can restore the social order while leaving its moral failures exposed.


Ferguson, by contrast, claims that Frye assigns the genre “not to the realm of moralism or any romantic restoration of society, but to the realm of sadism and ironic comedy.” Frye discusses punitive pleasure and moralized violence, but also the play that separates art from actual savagery. See the relevant passages at the end of this post from the Anatomy.


Frye can also call the detective story a romance while treating its ironic effects. In The Secular Scripture, he writes: "In the general area of romance we find highly stylized patterns like the detective story, which are so conventionalized as to resemble games" (44). This permits a combination of irony and social reintegration that Ferguson’s formulation excludes.


Ferguson uses his account of the genre to suggest a philosophical reason for the delay in publishing “Seven Story Dream”:


This is a grim promontory on which to find oneself, philosophically speaking, and I wonder if it isn’t that which led Lafferty to shelve the tale for so long. There’s a further inquiry to be had over the degree to which this tale deviates from the spirit of oft-cited inspiration G. K. Chesterton, whose Father Brown treats murder less as a crime against morality than as one against rationality: there is evil in the world, and no amount of detection will make that wholly right again, but so long as such crimes can be made comprehensible within the wider moral universe then the logical coherence of that universe remains unshaken.

Now something about Chesterton. The strangeness of Ferguson’s claim that “G. K. Chesterton, whose Father Brown treats murder less as a crime against morality than as one against rationality,” largely speaks for itself but bears thinking about. Across Chesterton's fifty-three Father Brown stories, murder is certainly not "less a crime against morality" than against rationality. In Chesterton, the problem with murder is the Judeo-Christian problem with murder: murder is, first and foremost, a moral crime. The Catholic formula is "mortal sin."


Chesterton never drives a wedge between moral judgment and rational intelligibility. Murder is no less a crime against morality than against rationality, because for Chesterton the two are mutually implicating: moral judgment is inseparable from intelligibility, so that evil can be recognized, named, and judged within an ordered moral universe. That is how the Father Brown stories work. My suspicion is that Chesterton would have laughed at "Father Brown treats murder less as a crime against morality than as one against rationality." It is something one would expect an antagonist, usually an intellectual or a businessman, in the Father Brown stories to say.


Ferguson’s “grim promontory” names the position in which the detective-story writer shares the murderer’s aesthetic interest in a corpse. He wonders whether Lafferty’s recognition of that position delayed publication.


I do not find this persuasive. Lafferty built the 1961 "Seven Story Dream" around the idea of perfection from the very beginning. The question is how the story’s judgment of Gadberry bears on Ferguson’s analogy between murderer and author.


Why not just reject Gadberry’s worldview as being overintellectualized and self-serving bunkum? Gadberry is what the story mocks. As we should expect, Lafferty has already constructed a mousetrap for Gadberry by turning Gadberry’s own melodramatic (Frye would say moralized) commitment to a false view of perfection against him. Ferguson’s argument gives Gadberry’s account of perfection more weight than the story’s judgment of it.


Examine how perfection works in the story. Crudely, Gadberry acts like God. He claims the authority to decide when something is perfect, setting its telos by determining when it is complete or incomplete. He chooses to “complete” Minnie Jo Merry through her murder because he imagines himself in competition with God. His outward aestheticist pose is that, by killing her, he can ontologize Minnie as an art object.


Ferguson argues that Gadberry’s primary motive for this is artistic curiosity. He writes:


In making a mostly aesthetic decision to carry out a murder, Gadberry reflects also on the morality of the author as artist, even to the point of staging the opening scene for maximum sensory effect (in the process “savagely striking down” a lone white flower—again, subtlety not really the point of this piece). He cites as his motives “jealousy, frustration, curiosity,” but the first two are clearly deprecated to the third, which he shares with any author who creates a character for the sole purpose of killing them off.

Yet the textual evidence points to something beyond this aestheticist reading. There are signs of jealousy and frustration—clues that the story is not only about an aesthete “perfecting” someone in the name of art, but that the murder is also, in part, sexual and bound up with possession and sinful destruction.


Lafferty’s opening scene is a brilliant piece of writing in several ways, but certainly brilliant in one word choice:


In spite of the elements that went into the composition the effect was near perfect — and yet there was one clashing entity in that aubade scene. Gadberry reviewed it in his mind, for the artist is satisfied with nothing but perfection. The firs, the hedges, the corpse, the mimosa, the garbage cans, the lawn, the hollyhocks with their lone aster — something was in that peaceful morning scene that simply did not belong there.

The critical word is aubade. An aubade is a literary genre, and it matters if the story is read metafictionally. Most well-known aubades rely on an implied sexual situation, simply because they are set at daybreak after lovers have spent the night together. Perhaps the most famous aubade in English—one Lafferty, as a devoted reader of poetry, would almost certainly have known—is "The Sun Rising" by John Donne. It is a classic inverted aubade, opening with the poet in bed with his lover and proceeding by scolding the sun for intruding on their privacy.


We see the same trope in Romeo and Juliet (Act III, Scene 5), where the newlyweds argue over whether the bird they hear is the nightingale or the lark. They want to prolong the night. Daylight means that Romeo must leave.


The aubade gives the opening scene a sexual association. That counts when weighing Gadberry’s motives, especially beside the possibility that Minnie Jo Merry was raped before being strangled and thrown from the window. The allusion to Jack the Ripper puts sexual murder in our imagination. Then Lafferty lets something drop in the very last lines of the story.


The machine went on to recount certain abominations that only the killer knew he would commit, but the voice of that most polished madman returned again and again to the command: “Say, ‘I killed Minnie Jo Merry. I killed Minnie Jo Merry. Strangled her and threw her out the window. I killed—’”

What are these “certain abominations,” beyond the murder itself? Are they just punching and kicking her? Is kicking or punching an abomination? Why are they called abominations when the murder itself isn't? Why were these certain abominations necessary for the composition of Gadberry's scene with Minnie Jo Merry’s body? To state the obvious, an abomination is a true horror. In a story shot through with sexual implications, the most plausible answer is that these abominations are indeed sexual.


“Minnie Jo was quite a good girl, but she was on the edge of becoming quite a bad girl. I have seen it happen to so many of the young ones who are loose in the world.”

“He can talk about music and funny paintings and the new dirty novels and psychology and things like that.”
"No, I never laid a hand on her, except sometimes in attempted affection.”
All of them always looking at the young girl.
Nor was she the only girl a third his age that he brought in. The sap was not all dead in him yet.

The sexual associations complicate Gadberry’s aesthetic explanation. Jealousy and frustration remain explicit motives that Ferguson’s emphasis on curiosity must account for.


The Virginia Kidd additions may have ensured publication, but they also divert attention from the story’s subtler aspects, which came not from Virginia Kidd but from R. A. Lafferty, which is why I think Gadberry is not a true aesthete but a hedonistic, self-absorbed, second-rate artist, whose aesthetic claims may disguise sexual jealousy and frustration. The needless certain abominations point to jealousy and sexual frustration as real components of his character and motives. The part of the confession that Lafferty wrote keeps Gadberry's scopophilia front and center:


“I lied. She had eyes, and she wasn’t conventional. She was near perfect, gentlemen. So near.”

In a 1989 letter, Lafferty returned to the distinction between perfection and faultlessness:


There has never been a perfect book . . . of all time and for all people except the one; and its author is far more human than we are. There has never been a perfect man but the one. To look for things which are truly excellent, one must look for things that are distant kin to these two; one must look for things that are flawed.

There is also something distinctly Lafferty-devilish about Gadberry’s desire to destroy beauty, to reject the flawed, and then to claim that one does so out of concern for perfection and completion. After all, it is the rhetoric of the devils in Past Master who know that complete means perfect:


“Suffice it to say that those single-minded men who invented us did break down the barrier between living and nonliving matter. And they discovered that the living was the illusion. Well then, they created us as dead men, and dead men we be. We are dead, and all is dead. But we believe that we are complete. We feel that there is no dimension beyond ourselves. In our beginning man made us. Then we made ourselves, a little more efficiently than man could do it. We reproduce almost in your own manner. We even cross with humans, with some curious results. We have become man. We have replaced man. Soon man will be nothing.”

The severe moral judgment Lafferty passes is present in the 1961 version of "Seven Story Dream." If anything, the 1973 version's Virginia Kidd revisions obscure Gadberry’s range of motives rather than clarify them. This is what happens when your agent fiddles with your story. Lafferty loved Virginia Kidd, but her revisions were a generic overlay of needless cuteness on the story, helping it more effortlessly sink into the genre slum. She knew how to sell a story.


With these considerations in mind, we are ready to turn to the unusual Mrs. Raffel, the apartment landlady. Lafferty gives her lines that will strike some readers as off-putting, for reasons akin to the discomfort many feel when confronting The Chronicles of Narnia, specifically the notorious train episode and Susan’s fate. What is at work in both cases is an uncompromisingly Christian moral vision, one that insists it is preferable to die young and saved than to live longer only to die damned. Raffel judges Minnie Jo’s death by the prospect of salvation. Gadberry claims the power to complete her himself. Their opposed accounts distinguish providence from the artist’s usurpation of it:


"Not necessarily, Captain. Minnie Jo was a very open person. If Jack the Ripper himself had come in, red from his trade, she'd have said, ‘Hi, honey, sit down and talk to me.’ But it was probably someone she knew.” “What are your feelings on hearing of the death of Miss Merry?” “Satisfaction—though I'll miss her—and relief and thankfulness that it has finally turned out all right.” “Turned out all right? Do you call it turning out all right that she was murdered?” he asked her. “Oh yes. There were many worse things that could have happened to her. How lucky that Minnie Jo was killed before they happened!” “You will have to explain that. Did you hate her?” “No, I loved her—and I will explain. Minnie Jo was quite a good girl, but she was on the edge of becoming quite a bad girl. I have seen it happen to so many of the young ones who are loose in the world. Every time I know one, and notice her nearing the change, I pray that something will intervene and prevent it. This is the first time my prayers have been answered, and I'm thankful.”

Finally, it looks to me as if Ferguson conflates the artist’s instrument with the artwork it produces. Ferguson treats the tape as if it were part of Gadberry’s art, as if it were an element in the composition. The recording serves Gadberry’s attempt to evade detection. Its calculated banality need not define his aesthetic ambitions. It is no more part of his art than the handle of Van Gogh’s brush is part of Starry Night. It is closer to being like the money Gadberry extracts from Handle: a means to an end. Gadberry says, "I often make use of fools."


Ferguson says he is puzzled by the name “Handle” and speculates about the composer. To me, it looks like Handle is a handle, a tool. The real artwork, as Gadberry himself conceives it, or says he conceives it, is the murdered body of Minnie Jo Merry:


Captains Keil and Gold were there quickly and in charge. Minnie Jo was bruised about the throat and dried blood framed her mouth, but her death may have been caused by a violent concussion.

Thomas De Quincey, one of my favorite writers, wrote a long essay with a famous title: On Murder Considered as One of the Fine Arts (1827). There is an important distinction between murder as a fine art and committing murder to create an art object. The former aestheticizes the entire process; the latter aestheticizes the victim. Lafferty’s story is concerned with the second, not the first. Lafferty's version of the murder-as-fine-art tale is his "Almost Perfect."


Ferguson’s conjecture about the publication delay rests on his interpretation of the story, not on anything he quotes from Lafferty. The Catholic account of perfection developed above gives us a different way to read the original version.


The learning-in-one’s-sleep conceit was already familiar. Ferguson’s connection with an episode of My Three Sons is a good catch; it helps explain the device’s banality.


“Seven Story Dream” turns on a weak, sitcom-grade twist, redeemed by Lafferty’s ingenuity elsewhere and by his brilliant verbal texture. The 1961 and 1973 versions rely on the same trite device. The story matters as an early, pre-nucleation probe of Lafferty’s perfectibility theme and as another trial run of a large cast in a small package, not as any grim philosophical promontory.


Character chart grouping the tenants, landlady and police in Seven Story Dream, with the tape that exposes Gadberry’s false confession scheme.
Nineteen-step plot outline of Seven Story Dream, from the dawn scene and tenant interviews to Handle's confession and the incriminating tape.
Rebus showing a seven-storey building with the word Dream on each floor.
Relationship diagram centering Minnie Jo Merry, with Gadberry marked as her killer and Handle as the conditioned confessor.
Flowchart of Gadberry's sleep-learning confession scheme and its discovery when police search Handle's recordings.
Interview sequence for the landlady and six surviving tenants, ending with Handle’s rehearsed confession and Gadberry locating the conditioning tape.
Diagram of Gadberry's dawn composition, accepting the corpse on the lawn while treating the lone white aster as a flaw.
Diagram linking the number seven to Handle's dreams, the witnesses and the interview structure of Seven Story Dream.
Illustrated opening of Seven Story Dream, with a landscape painting on an easel beside the first paragraphs.
Excerpt from Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism discussing detective fiction, irony, melodrama and scapegoating.



Bibliographical Note


First published in Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine, July 1973; collected in Does Anyone Else Have Something Further to Add? (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1974).


The work-history card records a return from Fierst on March 25, 1963. This is a return date, not a completion or revision date.


Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Seven Story Dream,” Card file box, Series 2: Writings, Box 25, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. “Seven Story Dream,” Internet Speculative Fiction Database, accessed October 24, 2026, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?69722=.


Manuscript location: “Seven Story Dream,” Series 2: Writings, Box 21, Folder 23, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.

bottom of page