Scrivener, Maxwell, and Ouden
Updated: 2 days ago

“The light from the sky turned ordinary light black, and there were big empty grinning faces in the sky like high cliffs that had been there always. Big faces that had always been there, but never seen except by the most intense flash of the insane lightning.” Past Master, Chapter 7
I continue to work through another pass at Past Master. In my reading, Ouden is not a being but a failure of vision—the result of political and spiritual manipulation, the lie that allows utopia on Astrobe to reach critical mass. The passage above is one of Past Master’s most astonishing moments. The faces in the sky were always there, we are told, unseen until the right—or wrong—kind of light made them visible. Lafferty tells us we are in a place where people hallucinate, but I will take the other fork in the road—one I find far more compelling.
It reminds me of Wittgenstein’s aspect-seeing, discussed in Philosophical Investigations (Part II, Section XI), where he examines how an unchanged figure can be seen differently—illustrated by the famous duck-rabbit image, which can be seen as either a duck or a rabbit.
Just as the image does not change but the way of seeing it does, so too do the faces in the sky in Past Master—present but revealed under certain conditions. This would mean that the cliff revelation in Past Master is not of something new but of something seen differently, something that had been ignored, dismissed, or beyond ordinary apprehension.

But here the duck-rabbit analogy breaks down. In Wittgenstein's drawing, both duck and rabbit are available aspects of the same figure. In Past Master, as in the New Testament, there is a particular identity to recognize. The disciples on the road to Emmaus were not seeing an ambiguous figure that could be either Christ or not, depending on their interpretation. This was no duck or rabbit. They were looking at Christ Himself and failed to recognize Him. The failure was not in the thing perceived but in the perceivers.
But their eyes were held, that they should not know him. Luke 24:16
Their inability to recognize Christ was not an optical failure, but a moment of spiritual blindness, one permitted for a time so that they might come to full understanding. Only when He blessed and broke bread was their vision restored:
And their eyes were opened, and they knew him: and he vanished out of their sight. Luke 24:31
The same is true of the faces in the sky—whether or not they should be seen, and what they truly signify, is not a matter of arbitrary interpretation but of the right or wrong mode of perception. Scrivener has already rejected Ouden; by the time the faces appear, he has been killed. For Maxwell, it is a fantasy born of fear. The crisis in Past Master is a version of Emmaus: when the truth appears, will we know it for what it is?
Is Maxwell capable of perceiving rightly at this moment in the novel? Maxwell, in his panic, is where Christ’s followers found themselves. This is spiritual pareidolia. It is not seeing the lightning of Psalm 18:12-14 for what it is. The disciples had Christ before them and failed to see; the foolish virgins waited for the bridegroom but were unprepared for His arrival.
The faces of Ouden are not real, but they are real as a way of seeing. They are not real in the same way that the King’s presence is real, which remains real even when hidden from those without the right preparation, the right expectation, the right kind of light. Maxwell’s cry—"Where is the face of our King? Would we know it if we saw it?"—is true spiritual terror, one of the rawest moments in the novel.
It is the failure of Emmaus. Not that there is nothing, nor that there is something terrible, but that when the truth appears, we may not know it at all.


