Pulling the Hole in After You
Updated: Nov 8

I love to sail the ocean quaint,
I love the waves that rush-o.
I love to paint with sightless paint,
I love to whack my brush-o.
Lafferty’s image of pulling the hole in after yourself often connects with the mouth. It can describe something as harmless as a closing burrow, but several of its uses threaten the erasure of a person, a memory, or a world.
I read these holes as wounds in postlapsarian creation: absences that seem to consume being without ever reaching complete negation. That differs from the passive emptiness of the Lucretian void.
Lafferty shows us what this looks like at the end of Arrive at Easterwine (1971):
The universe, new seen, grew in power and clarity, and ghastliness.
“It’s still a sphere,” Gregory growled stubbornly. “A little bit rough, but a sphere.” But Gregory had slipped and shrunken. For the moment he was no giant. He had reached his limit, and perhaps his minutes as director were numbered.
“It’s still a rotten apple?” Glasser gasped with a passion unusual to him. “Oh, oh, why have apples been the symbol both of the loss and the search? Oh, God of the gutted glob! The holes in it, the holes in it, the unfathomable abysses, the searing absences. What thing cries out of its absences? How will it be fulfilled?”
“It’s a sponge,” said Cogsworth through closed teeth. “How sponges must suffer!”
"It’s a cheese,” Valery offered hysterically, “rotted cheese and full of holes. A whole cosmos of maggotty cheese, turned green in its taint and rot.”
Food. Holes. Mouths.
If you ask me, the most frightening “nothingness” villain in Lafferty’s novels is not the well-known one, Ouden. It is Invisible Alfred in Serpent's Egg (1987). Ouden is an idol, but Invisible Alfred is something far more insidious.
Invisible Alfred was not born invisible. He claims to have spent nine thousand years in an emptied one-hundred-gallon drum, drawing near-invisibility from the residue of its paint. This links him with other imprisoned devils in Lafferty’s fiction who are eventually released:
“The Earth had had endemic devils for many millennia and had built up a certain resistance to them. But the devil-invasions would be epidemics as they came to the worlds that did not have the devil experience.”
It is also a Law of Lafferty that we should not trust what devils tell us about themselves.
Like Pottscamp in Past Master (1968), Invisible Alfred can initially be mistaken for a friend. His story about the barrel invites sympathy before his actions disclose the danger. I read his invisibility beside the Catholic account of evil as privation.
Unlike Ouden, Alfred’s arrival doesn’t begin with big, booming postures—though he builds up to them, eventually claiming to be a prophet. The important part is that he does not announce himself as a terror. Real terrors in Lafferty usually don't. And unlike Ouden, you cannot laugh Invisible Alfred away. “We laugh you off the scene,” says Paul-Thomas to Ouden.
Of Invisible Alfred, Lafferty writes,
“[he] made three more numinous and prophetic speeches to three other multitudes of people that day, but they weren't successes. More and more people were laughing at him, and he was completely discredited. He didn't seem discouraged though. He just closed his eyes and mouth and went away. Or else he did not go away.”
Only Invisible Alfred’s eyes and the inside of his mouth are visible. Closing them conceals him completely. The narration’s “Or else he did not go away” keeps concealment distinct from departure.
I think he can’t. He isn’t Ouden, because Ouden is pure nothingness, and pure nothingness cannot exist. Invisible Alfred’s mouth does exist.
At first, the reader might think Alfred is just another of Lafferty’s grotesques, but it turns out that he is the Supreme Head of Lafferty’s most chilling Gnostic secret society, The Kangaroo. He will slaughter the children whom Lafferty has positioned the reader to care about. They are a version of the Dulanty children from The Reefs of Earth (1968) who will not get to remake the world—"And opposed to them, only the defenseless World!"—because they will be dead and because the world of Serpent’s Egg is on the offense.
Lafferty often puts exuberance beside violent death. Here the word joy makes the murders of Axel and Lord Randal worse:
“Axel woke up in total joy and sprung to his feet. He had nearly a second of happy realization, and he opened his mouth to shout. But no shout came from his mouth. One of those short, sharp-bladed Dolophonoi knives, seeming to move by itself, buried itself in Axel's throat, and the ten-year-old Golden Ape fell dead.
But the short knife, still seeming to move by itself, withdrew from the red-running throat of Axel and hovered in the air seeking further prey.
"I know you now, I'll have you now!" Lord Randal cried and went fearlessly after the dancing knife. Lord Randal's own knife had flicked out and stabbed at an unseen something. But the dancing knife found Lord Randal's throat just as it had found Axel's. And Lord Randal fell dead.”
Alfred’s survival of ridicule gives the image its terror for me: the absence still has a mouth and a knife.
From a Catholic eschatological perspective, the image is troubling. Catholic teaching envisions an eschatological fulfillment in which creation is renewed in the resurrection—a reordering, not an erasure, of existence. The destiny of the world is transformation and reconciliation with God, not dissolution into absolute nothingness. And yet, here is Invisible Alfred in full mania, speaking with the devilish voice of Pottscamp, who I think ventriloquizes Ouden:
“. . . all voices on Earth and in the Ocean praise me whenever they sound, whether they intend it or not. All of them rebound to my glory.”
I hear the same threat in Alfred’s ballad: “I love to paint with sightless paint, I love to whack my brush-o.” The final “o” in brush-o suggests Ouden to me. The association brings the painter’s brush beside the consuming mouth.
Returning to Arrive at Easterwine, it is perhaps surprising that—of all the members of the Institute for Impure Science—it is Glasser, the man without genius, who delivers the novel’s most profound line:
"What thing cries out of its absences? How will it be fulfilled?”
These are the examples of the phrase I have found:




