"Old Halloweens on the Guna Slopes" (1975, rev. 1984)
Updated: 5 days ago

Forza [force] and froda [fraud] being the two essential elements of sin, it follows that they must be the two cardinal virtues of human life as such. Machiavelli personified them as the lion and the fox, the force and cunning which together make up the strong prince. So it is not surprising that European literature should begin with the celebration of these two mighty powers of humanity, of forza in the Iliad, the story of the wrath (menis) of Achilles, of froda in the Odyssey, the story of the guile (dolos) of Ulysses. The Secular Scripture
Consider the revisions Lafferty made to “Old Halloweens on the Guna Slopes,” changes that rendered the short story significantly less dark than in its original publication in Fantastic (August 1975). The revised version, which appears in the collection Ringing Changes (1984), is, in my view, inferior. But setting that kind of assessment aside, the shift in plot and tone, in three instances, sharpens our view of two of Lafferty’s recurring themes: violence and fraud. I’ve elsewhere called attention to the bloodsmell that permeates his work. Alongside this runs his inexhaustible fund of conmen and fraudsters. One cannot fail to recognize the centrality of violence and fraud in almost everything the man wrote.
The table compares the principal changes:
Major Plot Differences: Original vs. Revised



To get at this, a small detour. In the mid-1950s, Canadian literary critic Northrop Frye published Anatomy of Criticism (1957). The book imagined literature as an “order of words” and presented all literary works as part of a single grand structure. It’s a remarkable book—if you haven’t read it, I highly recommend it. Even someone as radical as my old methods teacher, Cary Wolfe, a major critical voice in posthumanism and animal studies, praised it effusively, as did his PhD advisor, the Marxist critic Fredric Jameson. This is just to say that while there’s much to argue with in Anatomy of Criticism, even readers one might expect to be oppositional have found it compelling in innumerable ways.
The problem was that in writing Anatomy, Frye had also written himself into a corner. The book became one of the most cited works of literary criticism of its time, but it locked Frye into a brand. He was the guy who thought of literature as a system of cyclical modes and genres, with literary history as a static order. For the rest of his critical career, Frye tried to find something dialectical, something in motion, within what he called the order of words. It was the thing that he needed to exclude to write the Anatomy.
His most successful early attempt at this became The Secular Scripture (1976). The book was drawn from his Norton Lectures at Harvard in the mid-1970s, a series on romance. By this time, however, the taste in literary criticism had shifted. Frye's intellectual stock was about to decline with the rise of high theory. For the rest of his life, he would increasingly be dismissed as either a naïve structuralist or a dogmatic schematizer. As a result, The Secular Scripture has not received the attention it deserves.
In 1996, the University of Toronto Press began publishing The Collected Works of Northrop Frye, a thirty-volume project that culminated with an index. One of the real treasures of that series is the inclusion of Frye’s notebooks, where he worked out his ideas, often in strangely coded or abbreviated forms. Volume 15, Notebooks on Romance (2004), shows the workshop where he developed the Norton Lectures. Among the many ideas that appear there, some in embryonic form, others more fully worked out, is a concept that appears less fully in The Secular Scripture but is useful for reading Lafferty: the distinction between forza and froda, and their centrality in romance, whether we’re speaking of the Greek second-century romances, the medieval chivalric tales, or the modern genres of the western and science fiction.
Michael Dolzani summarizes Frye’s dialectical idea like this:
In the notebooks and typed notes towards The Secular Scripture, we see Frye constructing a whole new history for romance, one that is dialectical and progressive rather than cyclical. There are two human impulses, forza and froda, violence and fraud, and two types of literature that result from them. The literature of forza is tragic and ironic; its violence is that of humanity hurling itself against the limitations of the fallen world, which ultimately destroy it. The literature of froda is comic and romantic; its fraud is the inventive imagination that outwits those limitations. The Secular Scripture argues for an evolution of Western literature from forza increasingly towards froda. It may be useful to suggest, however, that this is not a simple, straightforward progress but a dialectical one. In each of the five historical modes in the Anatomy, romance is born anew; but in each mode it struggles with its opposite, which is also reborn: forza and froda are contraries, versions of Wallace Stevens’s reality and imagination. This would explain the epic-romance tension in the second mode, and also cast light on The Secular Scripture’s description of the tension between modern popular romance and the “great tradition.” We seem to be led towards an ultimate yin-yang conception of genre, whereby a mode of literature wrestles with some categorical other that is at the same time contained within it.
The two versions of “Old Halloweens on the Guna Slopes” present Lafferty working through the dialectic of forza and froda.
In the original version of “Old Halloweens,” forza dominates: the story ends in ironic tragedy, with the strong implication that the authorial stand-in is the victim. The romantic mode is dominated by the tragic mode. In the revised version, however, the story turns toward froda, ending with a birthday trick in which Austro is doused with chili. Froda becomes the dominant note. This time, romance and comedy contain the irony and tragedy.
To make the new ending work, Lafferty seems to have cut the elements of forza that the new ending could not accommodate. Chief among these is one of the most disturbing passages he ever wrote, which is entirely absent from the revised version:
It was a year ago tonight. Several of us got the feeling that the little boy was going to be killed. On this portal-night we are able to rescue one who has been unjustly handled. He will still be killed, yes: but when he is killed, he will go with us; he will not go where dead people go. It was at that little wading pool for kids down in Honey Locust Park. It was just at sundown. There were two middle-sized girls there (six or seven years old), and they had decided to drown the little boy. A lady was on duty there, and she watched it and pretended not to see it. She had been overtaken by that special evil that can enter only into homo saps. She didn’t want anyone to see it; she didn’t want anyone to know it; but she wanted those two middle-sized girls to drown that little boy, and she wanted him to suffer that black strangulation that is the worst suffering of all.
The black strangulation epitomizes forza at its darkest.
Also lost are three other elements: the “dumb cluck stuck” motif, Austro’s account of his selection and banishment as a sacrificial victim, and the encounter with the three familiars, who speak in riddles and threats:
They had a black cat with them. They had a white monkey. They had a Judas-goat. All just plain Halloween props. Chiara-Morgana blew on her fingers and they lighted up like blue candles. “Oh go duck for apples somewhere,” Mary Mondo said crossly. Mary was scared though. There was something about a sonder-effect ghost-trap in the sparks that came from the Morgana fingers. “Your symbiosis blows like rack—Your inside monkey’s on your back,” the white monkey simpered in that monkey-mouthed way they have of talking. . . . “We bet you wish that you were dead—You hole-in-mind and hole-in-head,” the black cat wauled in that gross way they have. . . . “For one of you, things to and fro—From this day on you will not know,” the Judas-goat bleated. What, no longer be one of the guys who knew everything? Judas-goat, the goat-butcher’s knife is hungry for your throat.
These deletions reverse the direction of the original version. What had been a descent from froda into forza becomes, in the revision, a movement from froda to froda, where force was trickery all along—the extent of the forza being only the wild pranks themselves.
Why did Lafferty make these changes? We can only speculate. Some possibilities:
An editor may have asked him to tone it down.
He may have felt uneasy about casting a day from the liturgical calendar in such a sinister light. Perhaps this is part of the meaning behind his choice to introduce “Heavenly Days McGee.”
He may have believed it was misleading to suggest that past Halloweens were truly so rough.
He may have worried the ending came off as self-pitying and wanted to avoid overemphasizing the Laff character.
He just changed his mind about what the story should be about.
One final note: when froda is neutralized, it often metaphorizes into the virtue of prudence, something Frye points out in his notebooks. When forza is overturned, it tends to metamorphose into the virtue of fortitude. Here is the original forza ending:
Roy and Chiara ran whooping down the street and left one of us there with a hole in his head (where the know-everything cortical had been), and with a ghost-monkey (wrenched from its interior and rightful den) on his back forever. No, they don’t make Halloweens like they used to. They make them a lot rougher.
In the revised version, forza has been metamorphosed. There is no black strangulation. Instead of malevolence, we are given an image of a birthday trick (froda) resulting in fortitude: Austro, chili on his head, endures the prank, keeping up with what really matters, the continuation of the Rocky McCrocky strip:
“Hammer and chisel ringing out the great epic of Rocky McCrocky on the comic-strip stone blocks. Chili still on his head, and his mouth full of snail cake. Sunshine shining there at midnight, and the rock dust flying!”
Lafferty usually works within romance, where forza and froda continually oppose each other. Their conflict helps explain his repeated pairing of violence and fraud.
This, to my mind, is what Dolzani means when he writes that Frye shows romance to be “a mode of literature [that] wrestles with some categorical other that is at the same time contained within it.” I’ll be watching for forza when I see froda in Lafferty, and for froda when I see forza.
Current notes:
See the interactive map of The Men Who Knew Everything stories.
Bibliographical Note
Completed March 12, 1974. First published in Fantastic, August 1975. Collected in Through Elegant Eyes (Corroboree Press, 1983). A revised version appeared in Ringing Changes (Ace Books, 1984).
Lafferty’s work-history card records submission to Virginia Kidd on March 13, 1974. A later entry names Sol Cohen and Fantastic as the story’s destination.
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Old Halloweens on the Guna Slopes,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. “Old Halloweens on the Guna Slopes,” Internet Speculative Fiction Database, accessed October 24, 2026, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?58347.


