More Than Human Harvesters
Updated: Nov 8

I was thinking again about Monego's essay, mentioned a few days ago, and it occurred to me that one possible source for the Harvesters in Fourth Mansions is Theodore Sturgeon’s More Than Human (1953). This must have occurred to others, though I haven't seen it discussed. I don't have evidence that Lafferty was responding directly to Sturgeon, but the comparison seems worth pursuing.
Sturgeon imagines evolution acting on a communal mind: people with different psychic gifts learn to blesh into Homo Gestalt, a being none of them could become alone. Power does not settle its moral problems. Gerry, for instance, has power without a conscience. Lafferty’s seven Harvesters also combine their gifts, then mistake their increased power for spiritual maturity. Fourth Mansions can be read as a warning about that mistake.
Both novels give an important place to a simpleton: Lone in Sturgeon, Freddy Foley in Lafferty. Freddy becomes the meeting point of four contending kinds of creature. The Harvesters use their collective power to bully and kill, but Lafferty does not condemn the weave outright. Hondo and the others cleanse it and give it to Freddy. The question is who can bear these powers without being mastered by them. Teresa of Ávila’s Interior Castle supplies the terms of the final question: will the world repeat its destruction, or move on to the next Mansions? That Catholic setting gives Lafferty’s treatment of the group mind its particular character.
A guide to the Harvesters, with comparisons to Jung’s Aion, which Lafferty quotes in the epigraph to chapter XIII:


