top of page
Search

Fourth Mansions Thoughts

Jan 31
3 min read

Updated: Nov 14

Black-and-white photograph of long rows of beds in a large institutional ward.

Short post. Quickly sketched thoughts. Bernard Clairvaux has posted an essay on Fourth Mansions. Vastly stronger than his first one. The current essay uses the Alumbrados as a typology. I’m unconvinced that this is the strongest account of the Harvesters, though the direction it points toward is sound.


Part of the reluctance is that the Pythons need to be integrated into the Fourth Mansion. The essay acknowledges other spiritual powers, but I don’t see how its governing contrast accounts for that integration. Each of the four factions has reserves of spiritual power.


If the Alumbrados are to be understood as loosely gnostic and loosely antinomian (already a muddy historical question, given that figures like St. John of the Cross and St. Teresa of Ávila came under ecclesiastical suspicion), they can be treated as cousins of the Harvesters. The essay does not mention it, but Andrew W. Keitt’s Inventing the Sacred is useful for thinking through the problems of discernment raised by Fourth Mansions. I spent my Saturday afternoon reading it.


The essay’s argument raises several questions:


  1. Alumbradismo is a difficult historical category. It covers different groups and different practices, as the essay acknowledges. It was a prosecutorial label during the Spanish Inquisition. What did Lafferty know about this? I've read the entry in the Catholic Encyclopedia and looked at the sources I know he consulted. What justifies treating it as a coherent spiritual type for the Harvesters? Does knowing it teach us something about Lafferty's novel, or is it projecting a category onto a messy early-modern phenomenon to make a point about the novel, one that might obscure its immediate concerns? I worked through probable Lafferty sources, but I lean toward the second.

  2. A more useful key to the Harvesters lies, I think, in Jung’s Aion and in the popular subcultural spiritualities circulating at the time the novel was written. The Harvesters’ defining features include a seven-person critical mass, measurable physical effects, “brain-weaving” as a technique, and a rhetoric borrowed from engineering. These fit naturally into the mid-twentieth-century language of psionics and parapsychology. Given that context, why bootstrap a sixteenth-century heresy over the milieu Lafferty was writing in? I know the answer: the title of the book. Still, the nearer sources seem more likely, given that the novel does not deeply track The Interior Castle but uses it as a launching pad. The Harvesters are aimed at the contemporary world.

  3. The essay traces resemblances in illumination, elitism, and apocalyptic ambition. What accounts for the Weave’s behavior? Why is group work its signature feature? It is a quasi-magical group working that Bauer later strengthens by recruiting the demon Baubo. Why does the working have to take a coven-like form? In occult terms, what the Weave produces resembles an egregore, a collective thought-form. A Jungian account that builds on a known source quoted by Lafferty in Fourth Mansions, Aion, points to ego inflation, projection, collectivized archetypal power, the serpent as collective. What does the Alumbrado comparison explain about these particular features?

  4. Fourth Mansions gives us the Harvesters as a group that treats spirituality as spiritual technology (for them, it is all about expertise, instrumentation, power, collective technique, curiositas, summoning, parapsychology). What evidence shows that Spanish illuminism is doing more explanatory work than other available ideas (the spiritualist tradition, fantasy and sf-style psionics, technocracy, Jungian psychology, de Chardin, pop tropes) that we know Lafferty is drawing on?


Freddy Foley is a holy fool, as the essay argues. The current essay presents his descent as an analogy to Christ’s unique kenosis. I find Christianized katabasis the better description of his experience in the Bug. I catch a trace of von Balthasar in this reading of Lafferty. For a von Balthasarian, nearly every Christian katabasis can look like a kenosis.


What makes Freddy hard to interpret is that he really is a fool-fool. I don’t take him to be a Christ figure. There is no Freddy at Gethsemane. It would be interesting to know what Lafferty himself thought of Erasmus. I suspect Lafferty's view was complicated.



bottom of page