“McGonigal’s Worm” (1959/1960)
Updated: 2 hours ago

Top, Spartobranchus tenuis in its tube, reconstructed by Marianne Collins (© 2012). Bottom, the living acorn worm Harrimania planktophilus, photographed by C. B. Cameron.¹
Since acorn worms and the human lineage diverged 570 million years ago, pharyngeal slits for filtering food evolved into gills for extracting oxygen, and later into today’s human upper and lower jaw and pharynx, which encompasses the thyroid gland, tongue, larynx (voice box) and various glands and muscles between the mouth and the throat. Humans and other terrestrial vertebrates actually initiate vestigial gills while embryos, though they disappear quickly and rarely persist in infants.² — Robert Sanders, “Acorn Worm Genome Reveals Gill Origins of Human Pharynx”
Anyone who reads this blog knows that I think important aspects of Lafferty are poorly understood. “McGonigal’s Worm” seems not to be understood at all. It is an interesting example of what happens when people read Lafferty and then stop. This is the earliest science-fiction satire of evolution I’ve found in Lafferty. I read it with the rise of modern birth control in mind. He is being very cagey, as he usually is when dealing with these topics, because he is distinctly countercultural on them.
What fascinates me is that readers can enjoy “McGonigal’s Worm” and still come away wondering what happened. It is as if the story simply happens and says nothing to the readers.³
Its characters are cut off from the enlivening principle of reproduction, a severance Lafferty calls adynatogenesis, and then, thirty-five years later, fertility returns. Words in the story that are theologically radioactive are skirted. Lafferty distinguishes adynatogenesis, the loss of the power to conceive, from adynatotokos, the inability to give birth.⁴ Its ending, -tokos, means childbirth or offspring. Then there’s his Palingenesia Institute. The Greek word palingenesia occurs twice in the New Testament.⁵
Victoria Silverwolf calls it “a shaggy dog story,” though she finds it charming.⁶ When a Lafferty story keeps its secrets, it is usually because the reader has not entered into the shape he has built. I may, of course, be guilty of pareidolia, of seeing too many shapes. But in the absence of a reading that accounts for these words, I can only offer the reading that seems most satisfying to me. A walk through the plot will introduce what I take to be the key knowledge for understanding it as a fable about the place of procreation in human life, one that slyly resignifies an old exhibit in arguments about vertebrate ancestry: the biological class Enteropneusta.
One Saturday, the power to conceive fails throughout what the story calls the chordata, with the sole exception of a species of acorn worm called McGonigal’s Worm. A hobbyist first notices something amiss. A laboratory worker’s complaint about sterile mice brings the pattern to light. When the news reaches the public, people laugh. Ten months on, Director Concord of the Palingenesia Institute and his assistant find the world absorbed in a betting pool, a sure sign that we are looking at one of Lafferty’s indictment stories.⁷
“We have, for ten months, tested nearly everything in the world and we have found no answer. Yet, oddly enough, there is no panic.” “Except among ourselves,” said Appleby, his assistant, “whose province is its study. But the people have accepted it so completely that their main interest now is in the world sweepstakes, with the total sums wagered now in the billions.”⁸
The title of last child born is improbably awarded to an Algerian claimant after a reported gestation of 388 days. Thirteen years after the catastrophe, one hope has faded. The children born after it show no sign of fertility. About thirty institutes are at work. Later we hear of the Capsule Institute, which preserves human knowledge, and the Bare Chance Transmission Society, which looks for a creature that can inherit it. If humans have reached their end, perhaps they can pass on their species knowledge to other animals.⁹
Lafferty inserts a subplot in the center of the story that dates it badly, largely because his ethnocentrism is crude. The Possibility Searcher Institute develops a test for potential fertility. It discovers only two positive human subjects among the three billion tested: a middle-aged Black Arabian named Musha ibn Scmuel and a wealthy spinster of thirty-five named Cecilia Clutt. Diplomat Carmody Overlark (yes, that Carmody Overlark) is dispatched to persuade Cecilia to do her part in repopulating the Earth. When she refuses, he tells her the law allows compulsion. Meanwhile, Musha is on the Atlantic when he asks to see a photo of Cecilia.¹⁰ Lafferty’s joke:
[Musha] screamed like a dying camel. And he jumped overboard. He was a determined swimmer and he was heading for home. A boat was put out and it gained on him. But, as it came up to him, he sounded. How deep he dived is not known, but he was never seen again.¹¹
After this, society resigns itself to the situation. Most primary schools close. New construction almost ceases.¹² Lafferty is clear as day that with infertility comes a cultural disaster; morality craters:
There had been a definite let-down in morals. Morals have declined in every generation since the first one, which itself left something to be desired. But this new generation was different. It was a tree that could not bear fruit, a hard-barked, selfish tree. Yet what good to look at it and shudder for the future? The future had already been disposed of. Now there [w]as a new hobby, a mania that swept the world, the Last Man Clubs, millions of them. Who would be the last person alive on Earth?¹³
It looks as if it is all over, but scientific efforts come together at the M.W. Institute. It focuses entirely on McGonigal’s Worm. Georgina Hickle, a married woman in her thirties and nearly the youngest woman on Earth, takes a job teaching the worms. She dislikes them. When she and other women at the laboratory begin to show the same symptoms, the young doctors call it “Hickle’s Disease.” An older psychiatrist tells them it is neither new nor a disease. Yes, it’s just the return of pregnancy.¹⁴
At the end of the story, the narrator looks back on what he calls an ancient generation. Official scientific explanation now attributes the thirty-five-year period of global sterility to the solar system temporarily passing through an area of cosmic radiation, though some superstitious people still believe McGonigal’s Worm had something to do with it.¹⁵
I wouldn’t count “McGonigal’s Worm” among Lafferty’s better stories. The squishy middle with Musha and Cecilia, in my view, mars the story. My deeper criticism is that the elements don’t come together, though I think we can see what they’re doing with enough clarity to infer what Lafferty is up to in the story.
I read the infertility in this story as a punishment imagined at a time when Americans were already using condoms and diaphragms.¹⁶ Lafferty wrote it in 1959. The FDA had approved Enovid for menstrual disorders in 1957. Approval for contraception came in 1960.¹⁷
Even before the second approval, doctors could prescribe Enovid for contraception.¹⁸ The pill became a high-profile controversy in the American Catholic Church. Dr. John Rock, a Catholic physician who helped develop it, argued publicly for its acceptance in his 1963 book The Time Has Come.¹⁹ In September 1958, Pius XII had condemned taking the pill to prevent conception. He distinguished that use from medically necessary treatment whose unintended effect was infertility.²⁰ This is the first context that I think should be kept in mind when reading the story. It becomes important when an older woman sees the pregnant Georgina Hickle on her way to work and responds with religious awe:
“Glory be,” said the old lady, “a miracle.” And she crossed herself.²¹
The second major context is how evolution was taught in the first half of the twentieth century and the importance of the acorn worm in that story. In Dennis Hird’s account the acorn worm was something of an emblem of what a primitive version of us in the phylogenetic tree might look like. Today acorn worms are classed as hemichordates.²²
In A Picture Book of Evolution (1906), Hird points to three features of the acorn worm (Balanoglossus): its gill slits, what he took for a short notochord projecting into the proboscis, and a short nerve tube in the collar. On these grounds he places this “marvellous worm” at the bottom of the vertebrate class.²³
At the end of the story, Lafferty sets an official explanation for the thirty-five-year sterility beside a folk belief about the return of fertility. The first is the official scientific account: the solar system passed through an area of cosmic radiation that temporarily suppressed fertility. The second comes from people who keep the worms in small mesh cages to ensure fertility. It was at the worm laboratory that pregnancy was first noticed.²⁴
I have called the kind of associative structure Lafferty uses here palimphanic, rather than the more straightforward didactic moves that are easier to track in his fiction. What he seems to be doing is torquing each explanation so that it is right about the other and wrong about itself. I read the cosmic radiation (a natural force passing through the world from outside) as an act of God, a chastisement visited upon a species that was already voluntarily choosing a measure of sterility. It is “cosmic” in the religious sense:
“The point,” said Hegner in one of his yearly summaries, “is not whether sterility could have been caused by cosmic forces. Of course it could have been. It could have been caused in twenty ways. The miracle is that fertility had ever been possible.” . . . “Who can say what cosmic forces are conscious? Or even what it means to be conscious?”²⁵
Meanwhile, the superstition about the worm is wrong in its fetishism—the worm is not a fertility charm—but basically right in its intuition. The acorn worm, which Hird places at the foundation of the vertebrate lineage, is, on my reading, a sacramental sign of God’s original gift of life through procreation and culminating in the palingenesis of Matthew 19:28.²⁶
The evolutionist sees the acorn worm as evidence of phylogenetic ascent; Lafferty sees it as a symbol of life as sacred. That acorn worms look so phallic is part of the story’s joke, with Georgina’s squeamishness.²⁷
The two explanations at the end are a bit difficult because they are true (within the story) when understood figuratively and false when understood positivistically (cosmic radiation) and then superstitiously (fertility fetish):
The official explanation is that the Earth and its solar system, for a period of thirty-five years, was in an area of mysterious cosmic radiation. And afterward it drifted out of that area. But there are many who still believe in the influence of McGonigal’s Worm.²⁸



Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work card is dated December 7, 1959. He sent the story to The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction on December 8 and received it back on December 30. He submitted it to Astounding Science Fiction in January 1960 and to Galaxy on February 13. The card records the sale to If for $30 on April 12, 1960.²⁹
First published in If: Worlds of Science Fiction, November 1960, 54–61.³⁰
Notes
1. Marianne Collins, reconstruction of Spartobranchus tenuis in its tube (© 2012), and C. B. Cameron, photograph of Harrimania planktophilus, reproduced in Stephanie Pappas, “Image Gallery: A Worm Missing Link,” Live Science, March 13, 2013, “Worm in Tube” and “Acorn Worm.” Back to text
2. Robert Sanders, “Acorn Worm Genome Reveals Gill Origins of Human Pharynx,” Berkeley News, November 19, 2015. On the human pharyngeal arches, clefts, and pouches, see J. M. Johnson et al., “Syndromes of the First and Second Branchial Arches, Part 1: Embryology and Characteristic Defects,” American Journal of Neuroradiology 32, no. 1 (2011): 15, figs. 1–2. These embryonic structures do not function as gills. Back to text
3. Stephanie, comment on Gideon Marcus, “[Oct. 2, 1960] Second-Rate Fun (November 1960 If Science Fiction),” Galactic Journey, October 3, 2015. Back to text
4. R. A. Lafferty, “McGonigal’s Worm,” If: Worlds of Science Fiction 10, no. 5 (November 1960): 54–55, 61. Back to text
5. G. Abbott-Smith, A Manual Greek Lexicon of the New Testament (T. & T. Clark, 1922), 335, 447, s.vv. “παλινγενεσία,” “τόκος.” See Matthew 19:28 and Titus 3:5 (KJV). Matthew uses the word for the renewal of the world, Titus for rebirth. Back to text
6. Victoria Silverwolf, comment on Marcus, “Second-Rate Fun,” October 7, 2015. Back to text
7. Lafferty, “McGonigal’s Worm,” 54–55. Back to text
8. 55. Back to text
9. 56, 58–59. Back to text
10. 56–58. For Carmody Overlark’s later appearance, see R. A. Lafferty, Fourth Mansions (Ace Books, 1969), 191–92. Back to text
11. Lafferty, “McGonigal’s Worm,” 58. Back to text
12. 58. Back to text
13. 58. The magazine omits the w in “was.” Back to text
14. 59–61. Back to text
15. 61. Back to text
16. U.S. Bureau of the Census, Population of the United States: Trends and Prospects, 1950–1990, Current Population Reports, series P-23, no. 49 (U.S. Government Printing Office, 1974), 28. Back to text
17. Suzanne White Junod and Lara Marks, “Women’s Trials: The Approval of the First Oral Contraceptive Pill in the United States and Great Britain,” Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 57, no. 2 (2002): 117n1, 126–29, 133. Back to text
18. 128–29, 133. Back to text
19. John Rock, The Time Has Come: A Catholic Doctor’s Proposals to End the Battle over Birth Control (Alfred A. Knopf, 1963), 168–69, quoted in Alexander Pavuk, Respectably Catholic and Scientific: Evolution and Birth Control between the World Wars (Catholic University of America Press, 2021), 290n12. Back to text
20. Pius XII, address to the Seventh International Congress of Hematology, September 12, 1958, Acta Apostolicae Sedis 50 (1958): 734–35. Back to text
21. Lafferty, “McGonigal’s Worm,” 60. Back to text
22. Oleg Simakov et al., “Hemichordate Genomes and Deuterostome Origins,” Nature 527 (2015): 459. Acorn worms belong to the class Enteropneusta in the phylum Hemichordata. Back to text
23. Dennis Hird, A Picture Book of Evolution, pt. 1, Containing Lessons from Astronomy—Geology—Zoology (Watts & Co., 1906), 114–15, fig. 101. Back to text
24. Lafferty, “McGonigal’s Worm,” 61. Back to text
25. 56. An interlocutor asks whether an enemy could have caused the failure before Hegner raises the question of consciousness. Back to text
26. Matthew 19:28 (KJV). Abbott-Smith, Manual Greek Lexicon, 335. Back to text
27. Lafferty, “McGonigal’s Worm,” 59–60. Back to text
28. 61. Back to text
29. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “McGonigal’s Worm,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. The 11-page carbon typescript is in series 2, box 17, folder 3. Back to text
30. Lafferty, “McGonigal’s Worm,” 54–61. Back to text
Bibliography
Abbott-Smith, G. A Manual Greek Lexicon of the New Testament. T. & T. Clark, 1922.
Hird, Dennis. A Picture Book of Evolution. Part 1, Containing Lessons from Astronomy—Geology—Zoology. Watts & Co., 1906.
The Holy Bible. King James Version. Matthew 19:28 and Titus 3:5.
Johnson, J. M., G. Moonis, G. E. Green, R. Carmody, and H. N. Burbank. “Syndromes of the First and Second Branchial Arches, Part 1: Embryology and Characteristic Defects.” American Journal of Neuroradiology 32, no. 1 (2011): 14–19.
Junod, Suzanne White, and Lara Marks. “Women’s Trials: The Approval of the First Oral Contraceptive Pill in the United States and Great Britain.” Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 57, no. 2 (2002): 117–60.
Lafferty, R. A. Fourth Mansions. Ace Books, 1969.
Lafferty, R. A. “McGonigal’s Worm.” If: Worlds of Science Fiction 10, no. 5 (November 1960): 54–61.
Lafferty, R. A. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Marcus, Gideon. “[Oct. 2, 1960] Second-Rate Fun (November 1960 If Science Fiction).” Galactic Journey. October 3, 2015. Comments by Stephanie and Victoria Silverwolf, October 3 and 7, 2015.
Pappas, Stephanie. “Image Gallery: A Worm Missing Link.” Live Science. March 13, 2013. Illustration by Marianne Collins and photograph by C. B. Cameron.
Pavuk, Alexander. Respectably Catholic and Scientific: Evolution and Birth Control between the World Wars. Catholic University of America Press, 2021.
Pius XII. Address to the Seventh International Congress of Hematology. September 12, 1958. Acta Apostolicae Sedis 50 (1958): 732–40.
Rock, John. The Time Has Come: A Catholic Doctor’s Proposals to End the Battle over Birth Control. Alfred A. Knopf, 1963.
Sanders, Robert. “Acorn Worm Genome Reveals Gill Origins of Human Pharynx.” Berkeley News. November 19, 2015.
Simakov, Oleg, Takeshi Kawashima, Ferdinand Marlétaz, et al. “Hemichordate Genomes and Deuterostome Origins.” Nature 527 (2015): 459–65.
U.S. Bureau of the Census. Population of the United States: Trends and Prospects, 1950–1990. Current Population Reports, series P-23, no. 49. U.S. Government Printing Office, 1974.


