top of page
Search

“Maybe Jones and the City” (1964/1968)

Mar 21
12 min read

Updated: 7 hours ago

Lot sits with his daughters outside a cave as fire engulfs Sodom in the distance.
Circle of Herri met de Bles, Landscape with Lot and His Daughters in Front of the Burning Sodom, sixteenth century. National Museum in Warsaw.¹

And there was a small bureau set up for that small group of folks who may perhaps have slight flaws in their characters—the golden flaw, as Maybe Jones once called it. This small bureau was to plan the future for the good-time crowd who could not be reformed into the sanctioned mold.² — R. A. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones and the City”

My favorite work by Jonathan Swift is his 1704 A Tale of a Tub,³ a work about which readers disagree in fundamental ways and about which there will never be agreement. That readers arrive at different interpretations of texts is a platitude. “Maybe Jones and the City” and Lafferty’s ironies more broadly have me thinking about this. As Lafferty readers know, he is about as ironic a writer as one will find, far more ironic than genre fiction usually tolerates.


The SFE entry on him has a line that neatly indexes those ironies. John Clute writes that Lafferty “has been understood by some as essentially light-hearted and by others as a solitary, stringent moralist.”⁴ The irony is that Lafferty is both, and because his ironies are so demanding, most readers find it hard to keep both aspects in view at once.


A recurring argument on this blog is that Lafferty developed strategies that allow readers to engage those ironies, and one of the most important is counterfiguration. “Maybe Jones and the City” is a more traditionally satirical story than most of what Lafferty writes, and it is puzzling that it has not been recognized as such. As with Swift’s A Tale of a Tub, what looks to me like a plainly satirical strategy and a series of ironic moves may look to you like something else, perhaps something more ambivalent.


“Maybe Jones” was written in 1964 but published in 1968, the same year as Space Chantey. At the Sleepy Sailor, Jones pays Roadstrum for directions to the Perfect Place.⁵ But I would suggest reading the story as if it belonged to one of Lafferty’s parallel tracks of fictional reality rather than to the Space Chantey universe, because much of it does not match up.


In “Maybe Jones,” humanity has cured mortality and achieved physical immortality, so society begins organizing itself into bureaucratic committees to design and construct customized versions of the afterlife. After all, the afterlife is now here among us.⁶ Lafferty had already imagined interminable life in his unpublished “Panic Flight.”⁷ Here, however, most of the population plans peaceful, pastoral eternities through agencies such as the Bureau of Wonderful Islands and the Bureau of Wonderful Fields. One small bureau plans for the hedonistic nonconformists. It is the Bureau of Wonderful Cities.⁸ Lafferty writes,


And there was a small bureau set up for that small group of folks who may perhaps have slight flaws in their characters—the golden flaw, as Maybe Jones once called it. This small bureau was to plan the future for the good-time crowd who could not be reformed into the sanctioned mold.⁹

Among this group is Maybe Jones, the man who once discovered the Perfect Place. The Perfect Place is like Cockaigne: a consequence-free place of endless revelry.¹⁰ Unfortunately, Maybe Jones doesn’t know how to get back. After seeing the place, he went to New Shanghai, suffered a head injury in a fight, and forgot the city’s name and bearings. Now he has spent two decades following false directions across the galaxy to find it again.¹¹


Meet the planners at the Bureau of Wonderful Cities. They want Jones’s ideas for building the Perfect Place. Their “total recall” methods have already reconstructed the Seven Sin Cities of History, and they show him their work. Jones visits simulations of Sodom, Pompeii, Lisbon, Port Royal, Chicago, San Francisco, and Galveston. He samples the cities as the planners have reconstructed them before their respective catastrophes. As he tours these pleasure centers, Jones judges their offerings and largely finds them lacking, dismissing them as too crude, adolescent, antiquated, and so forth, to serve as a sustainable environment for immortal revelers.¹²


The final reconstruction is Galveston just before the hurricane of 1900. Jones finds a way to visit it in other years, too. By the time he returns, he can remember the Perfect Place.¹³ He brings back a piece of Galveston “history” along with it:


“It’s put me in the mood,” he cried. “I’m ready to go to work. Hey, that place has a touch of the eternal! I found a way to tune it and visited Galveston in earlier and later years. I picked up an interesting piece of history too. You know, they never did bury any of the dead people after the hurricanes and tidal waves. They just ground them up and sold them for crab-meat sandwiches. Well, let’s go to work. It’s brought the Perfect Place back clear to my mind, and I’m ready to get with it.”¹⁴

Jones’s crab-meat story is a tall tale.¹⁵ With the Perfect Place clear in his mind, he begins writing specifications for the new city under the title “The Empyrean According to Maybe Jones.” There won’t be hangovers. There will be two-mile-long bars and girls built like clepsydras. The story ends by asking readers to tear out a sheet, write their wishes in the margin, and mail it to the Bureau of Wonderful Cities on Old Earth.¹⁶ According to the editor’s headnote in the first printing, Lafferty’s covering letter invited readers to suggest details for the city.¹⁷


The first thing to note is that the appeal to the reader has already begun before we meet Jones. Usually, it’s Lafferty’s narrator using his pragmatic marker trick. This time, though, I hear a collective. Here is the opening:


Listen, you high-old-time people, make your wants known now. They’re building the place, and they’ll put in anything you suggest. Funds are available. Lots of those peace-and-benevolence folks have made perpetual donations for those persons less fortunate in their aspirations than themselves. Less fortunate than—from where we stand, that’s a joke, isn’t it?
There is time, but barely. Tell them what you want them to put in. Act now!¹⁸

I think one has to put some pressure on the “Less fortunate than—from where we stand, that’s a joke, isn’t it?” This is what readers of the story seem to miss. In my reading, this is a joke because the voice comes from some very unfortunate place. Lafferty keeps it ambiguous, but I hear one of his sets of devils talking to themselves. They break their pitch and accidentally let us overhear them.


The traditional four last things are death, judgment, hell, and heaven.¹⁹ High-Life Higgins replaces death with immortality and drops judgment altogether. In his scheme, hell is somebody else’s version of heaven:


“The pitch is this,” said High-Life Higgins, after they had eaten and drunk and made cheer to excess. “We have now arrived at the three ultimates: Immortality, Heaven, Hell. We have just achieved the first of them. We are now setting up projects to construct the other two, on the premise that one man’s Heaven is another man’s Hell. We must build final enclaves for people of every choice. We cannot sit idly by and ask what we would do with the after-life. This is the after-life.”²⁰

Let’s consider two of these clues: the nature of the cities and the story’s most important use of counterfiguration.


I read the seven cities in the story as versions of the notorious cities of the plain. What were they? Most people can rattle off two of them, but there were five cities named in Genesis 14:2: Sodom, Gomorrah, Admah, Zeboiim, and Bela (that is, Zoar). They were in the Jordan plain, as described in Genesis 13:10–12. In Genesis, Lot chooses the well-watered Jordan region and lives among those cities.²¹


Their destruction is narrated in Genesis 19:24–25, where the Lord destroys Sodom and Gomorrah and overturns the cities of the plain. Zoar is the exception: Lot asks to flee there, so it was spared for him in Genesis 19:20–23 (see also Genesis 19:30). The four cities named under judgment in Deuteronomy 29:23 are Sodom, Gomorrah, Admah, and Zeboiim.²²


Table listing the seven doomed cities visited by Maybe Jones, their disasters and his verdicts.
Higgins’s seven cities and Jones’s verdicts.²³

Jones has what we might call Lot’s wife’s problem. He can’t help but look back.²⁴ Jones visits each of the seven cities before its disaster, though he also tunes Galveston to other years. Higgins puts the biblical destruction of Sodom in the same list as fires, earthquakes, and a hurricane. High-Life Higgins describes the reconstructions:


“By our total recall methods we are able to reconstruct the Seven Sin Cities of History, Jones. They are the folk dreams that have also been raucous facts. . . . But they were such a hopping bunch of towns that (under the old recension) they had to be destroyed: by blast-from-Heaven, lava-flow, earthquake, sinking-in-the-sea, cow-fire, earthquake again and fire, hurricane and tidal wave. They were too hot to last.”²⁵

Higgins keeps our attention on prostitutes and high times. I am not saying that Galveston experienced divine judgment. I read Lafferty as using the tropology of the cities of the plain while his planners talk as if judgment were no longer a problem. Yet every city they show Jones has suffered a catastrophe. Why will the city that Jones builds not also be destroyed? The answer Lafferty invites is that it will absolutely be destroyed. The invitation to rebuild Sodom is about as smart as investing in the Tower of Babel Construction Company.²⁶


I think all this is enough to make one recognize the story’s satirical norm and to grow suspicious of the voice urging one to Act Now, but what seals it for me is the counterfiguration of fire. This is not a story about heaven or the earthly paradise.


The Empyrean, the highest heaven in Dante’s Paradiso, is the heaven of pure light.²⁷ The Bureau of Wonderful Cities would build its Empyrean out of places like Sodom. I take that for irony. High-Life Higgins says they hold “the Empyrean, the eternal fire-stuff,” and Maybe Jones calls his blueprint “The Empyrean According to Maybe Jones.”²⁸ I read the counterfiguration through fire’s double sense here: divine love or hellish torment, depending on one’s relation to God.²⁹


The planners celebrate cities remembered for their destruction. Sodom supplies the biblical example of divine judgment. Sodom becomes a pleasure destination, not a toponym for what God hates.


Then there is the golden flaw. All idolatry, of course, is a worship of the created rather than the Creator, and the great instance of this in the tradition is the Golden Calf of Exodus.³⁰ And for whom is the bureau established? For people with the golden flaw, “the good-time crowd who could not be reformed into the sanctioned mold.”³¹ I hear a pun on sanctioned and sanctified. The narrator gives us Maybe’s real name, Midas, and says his father gave him the touch.³² I hear the golden flaw in the name, too.


Network diagram connecting Maybe Jones, his cronies, the Bureau of Wonderful Cities and the seven doomed cities.
Jones, his cronies, and the bureau in the 1974 text.³³
Reference table explaining names, places and literary allusions in “Maybe Jones and the City.”
The bureau mottos and other allusions in the Scribner text.³⁴



Bibliographical Note


Lafferty’s work card dates the story to February 15, 1964, and records a rewrite on April 4, 1965. On December 17, 1967, he sent it without payment to The Third Foundation.³⁵ It first appeared in issue 80 (1968).³⁶


Charles Scribner’s Sons collected the story in Does Anyone Else Have Something Further to Add? in 1974. The collection adds Margaret the Houri to the bureau staff and gives her a speaking part.³⁷


Notes


1. Christine Göttler, “Landscape, Mutability, and the Unruly Earth: An Introduction,” in Landscape and Earth in Early Modernity: Picturing Unruly Nature, ed. Christine Göttler and Mia M. Mochizuki (Amsterdam University Press, 2023), 57–58, fig. 0.16. National Museum in Warsaw, M.Ob.600 MNW. Back to text


2. R. A. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones and the City,” in Does Anyone Else Have Something Further to Add? Stories About Secret Places and Mean Men (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1974), 184. Back to text


3. Jonathan Swift, A Tale of a Tub: Written for the Universal Improvement of Mankind (printed for John Nutt, 1704), title page. Back to text


4. John Clute, “Lafferty, R A,” The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, 4th ed., updated September 14, 2026, passage beginning “He has fairly been described.” Back to text


5. R. A. Lafferty, Space Chantey (Ace Books, 1968), 10–11. For the story’s composition and first printing, see the Bibliographical Note below. Back to text


6. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 183–84. Back to text


7. R. A. Lafferty, “Panic Flight,” unpublished story, opening conversation at the Earth Club, transcription in my research files. The University of Tulsa catalogues the six-page typescript and its carbon, completed April 22, 1958, in the R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 20, folder 3, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text


8. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 184–86. Back to text


9. 184. Back to text


10. “The Land of Cokaygne,” in Early English Poems and Lives of Saints, ed. Frederick J. Furnivall (A. Asher, 1862), 157, lines 25–56. Back to text


11. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 181–83. Back to text


12. 186–89. Back to text


13. 188–89. Back to text


14. 189. Back to text


15. Galveston County Health District, History Council Committee, Public Health in Galveston County: A Historical Recollection (Galveston County Health District, [2016]), 4. The account describes burial at sea and the cremation of bodies after the storm. Back to text


16. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 189–91. Back to text


17. Editorial headnote to R. A. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones and the City,” The Third Foundation, no. 80 (1968), [5]. The editor reports the suggestion in Lafferty’s accompanying letter. Back to text


18. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 181. Back to text


19. Andrew Donlevy, The Catechism, or, Christian Doctrine, by Way of Question and Answer, 3rd ed. (James Duffy, 1848), lesson 15, 175. Back to text


20. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 186. Back to text


21. Genesis 13:10–12 and 14:2 (King James Version). Biblical references follow this version. Back to text


22. Genesis 19:20–25, 30, and Deuteronomy 29:23. Back to text


23. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 187–89. The disasters are Higgins’s catalogue. Jones gives the verdicts. On the undetermined cause of the Chicago fire, see “The Fire: The Official Report on the Origin of the Fire,” Chicago Evening Post, December 12, 1871, under “Who Started It.” Back to text


24. Genesis 19:17, 26. Back to text


25. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 187. Back to text


26. Genesis 11:1–9. Back to text


27. Dante Alighieri, The Divine Comedy, vol. 3, Paradiso, pt. 1, Italian Text and Translation, trans. Charles S. Singleton (Princeton University Press, 1975), 30.38–42, 336–37. Back to text


28. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 189–90. Back to text


29. Compare Isaac of Nineveh, Mystic Treatises, trans. A. J. Wensinck (Koninklijke Akademie van Wetenschappen, 1923), 136, on divine love as a source of suffering or delight. Back to text


30. Exodus 32:1–8. On worship of the creature, see Romans 1:25. Back to text


31. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 184. Back to text


32. 181. Compare Ovid, Metamorphoses 11.100–130, in Selections from Ovid: Chiefly the Metamorphoses, ed. J. H. Allen, W. F. Allen, and J. B. Greenough, rev. Harold N. Fowler (Ginn, 1890), 133–34. Back to text


33. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 182–86, 188–90. Back to text


34. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” 185. For the bureau mottos, see Hart Crane, “Voyages,” II, in White Buildings (Boni & Liveright, 1926), 50, and Hilaire Belloc, Sonnets and Verse (Duckworth, 1923), sonnet I, 3, lines 13–14. The third verse is credited in the story to Hiram Glotz. The first printing calls him Hiram Clutz. Back to text


35. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “Maybe Jones and the City,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. The card lists ten pages and 2,800 words. Tulsa catalogues the revised typescript and a separate explanation of the changes in series 2, box 17, folder 2. Back to text


36. R. A. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones and the City,” The Third Foundation, no. 80 (1968), [5–11]. Back to text


37. Lafferty, “Maybe Jones,” Does Anyone Else Have Something Further to Add?, 179–91, especially 184–86, 190. The title leaf is on 179, and the opening appeal is on 181. Back to text


Bibliography


Belloc, Hilaire. Sonnets and Verse. Duckworth, 1923.


The Bible: Authorized King James Version with Apocrypha. Edited by Robert Carroll and Stephen Prickett. Oxford University Press, 1997.


Clute, John. “Lafferty, R A.” The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction. 4th ed. Updated September 14, 2026.


Crane, Hart. White Buildings. Boni & Liveright, 1926.


Dante Alighieri. The Divine Comedy. Vol. 3, Paradiso. Part 1, Italian Text and Translation. Translated by Charles S. Singleton. Princeton University Press, 1975.


Donlevy, Andrew. The Catechism, or, Christian Doctrine, by Way of Question and Answer. 3rd ed. James Duffy, 1848.


“The Fire: The Official Report on the Origin of the Fire.” Chicago Evening Post, December 12, 1871.


Galveston County Health District, History Council Committee. Public Health in Galveston County: A Historical Recollection. Galveston County Health District, [2016].


Göttler, Christine. “Landscape, Mutability, and the Unruly Earth: An Introduction.” In Landscape and Earth in Early Modernity: Picturing Unruly Nature, edited by Christine Göttler and Mia M. Mochizuki. Amsterdam University Press, 2023.


Isaac of Nineveh. Mystic Treatises. Translated by A. J. Wensinck. Koninklijke Akademie van Wetenschappen, 1923.


Lafferty, R. A. “Maybe Jones and the City.” The Third Foundation, no. 80 (1968): [5–11].


Lafferty, R. A. “Maybe Jones and the City.” In Does Anyone Else Have Something Further to Add? Stories About Secret Places and Mean Men, 179–91. Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1974.


Lafferty, R. A. “Panic Flight.” Unpublished story, 1958. Transcription in my research files.


Lafferty, R. A. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. Space Chantey. Ace Books, 1968.


“The Land of Cokaygne.” In Early English Poems and Lives of Saints, edited by Frederick J. Furnivall, 156–61. A. Asher, 1862.


Ovid. Selections from Ovid: Chiefly the Metamorphoses. Edited by J. H. Allen, W. F. Allen, and J. B. Greenough. Revised by Harold N. Fowler. Ginn, 1890.


Swift, Jonathan. A Tale of a Tub: Written for the Universal Improvement of Mankind. Printed for John Nutt, 1704.

bottom of page