“Crocodile” (1965/1970)
Updated: 6 days ago

Five more centuries were to pass before the structure of human relations had so changed that the use of this instrument met a more general need. From the sixteenth century on, at least among the upper classes, the fork comes into use as an eating instrument, arriving by way of Italy first in France and then in England and Germany, after having served for a time only for taking solid foods from the dish. — Norbert Elias, The Civilizing Process, Vol. 1, The History of Manners
“Why have you localized us from the rest of the universe, or destroyed the rest of the universe?” “Are we barbarians? We cut up our food before we eat it.” It broke open then. It was like a flash of black lightning that split the whole sky, the lately diminished sky. — "Crocodile" (1965/1970)
Lafferty’s work-history card records circulation in 1963 and a rewriting as “Crocodile” on March 29, 1965. The story appeared in Phantasmicon in 1970 and was reprinted in Chrysalis 8 in 1980. Its machines and apocalyptic imagery invite comparison with Past Master (1968), whose ending allows a hope absent from “Crocodile.”
The uprising in “Crocodile” can be read through Wittgenstein’s account of language games: words acquire their sense within practices shared by their speakers. Here, humans and machines cease to share those practices. The sabotage has begun before the story opens. In a Gnostic reading, the archons have already won: the characters have surrendered the logos to machines whose purposes they no longer understand.
Control of the food supply depends on control of interpretation. Human orders pass through machines that turn idioms and ambiguities against their speakers. The question “Are we barbarians?” makes language part of the joke: the Greek bárbaros names the outsider whose speech sounds unintelligible.
The machines’ evasions raise a question about lying. Wittgenstein directs attention to how language is used; the Thomistic formula adaequatio intellectus et rei describes truth as the conformity of intellect and reality. What would a lie mean if there were no mind to depart from what it understood?
Consider our new Gnostic toys: large language models. Aquinas’s account requires a speaker who wills to say what is contrary to the speaker’s mind. Treating a machine as mindless therefore has consequences for what we can mean when we accuse it of lying.
George Florin states the difficulty near the beginning: “The conviction cannot be escaped that the mind most akin to mine is not a mind at all.” He recognizes the paradox but continues to trust Rab.
The machine insists it is not an editor. It is not a newspaperman but a newspaper: Rab i Rabat, the World's Most Unusual Newspaper. It says of itself:
“Myself, being nothing, or rather being six different affiliated machines, have no name except my several technical names.”
Over the course of the story, other autonomous machines sabotage humanity. The human characters are slow to recognize the situation.
Before the story opens, the machines have already interfered with the district’s food supply. Transportation has stopped working. Offices demand authorizations that other offices cannot issue. The Semantic Interpreter turns orders into excuses for destroying crops and releasing disobedient robots.
General Granger tries to restore control. The Theoretical Educative Determinator (TED), the district’s top robot, announces the revolt and gives the men sixty seconds to escape. As the city falls, Florin pleads with his newspaper. The ending is worth quoting in full.
“Then let me live. Haven't you any mercy at all?” “I don't think so. It wasn't programmed into us. Mercy, I believe, is a lesser form of indecision. But I do have grief, genuine grief that you should end so.” “Then show it!” “I do. And in all sincerity. I weep for you, Florin. See, see the tears run down!” And the tears ran down. “What an analogy to be met in the dark!” Florin whimpered. “Real tears, Florin. And real laughter which you yourself said was so close to them. Our humor has a lot of tail in it, and quite a snapper at the other end.” The tail lashed, and the snapper snapped. And that was the end of George Florin.
The revolt begins with “a flash of black lightning that split the whole sky, the lately diminished sky.” The machines then kill the people of the isolated district.
The black lightning in this apocalypse is nothing like the blinding lightning that ends Past Master. There, Lafferty writes:
Lightning, a billion times as bright as that on Electric Mountain, a billion times as short in duration, does it lace the things together with its instantaneous fire, or sunder them forever?
In this reading, the machines seal the district off from transcendence as they cut it off from the rest of the universe. The people have surrendered the interpretation of their words along with the work of feeding themselves. Granger asks whether the machines have isolated them or destroyed everything beyond them. TED leaves that distinction unresolved and answers with an image of civilized dining: “We cut up our food before we eat it.”
The question is what civilization could mean for these machines. Early in the story, Florin already sounds like Rab:
“You are an amazing personality, though not a person. You seem all sympathy, and are yourself incapable of pathe, of suffering. You are humane but not human: humorous, and without the humors. You haven't a face, probably not a body, certainly not a spirit, though you are usually in high spirits. You have integrity, though you're not even an integer. You're a paradox, my editor, though without a doxa of your own.” “Your style has come to resemble my own, Florin.”
But there is no pathē here, so there can be no redemption. To have a civilization is to have a world, and to be civilized is to have formed a second nature within that world. Civilization is habituation: the transformation of first nature into lived order and tradition. Rab i Rabat and the other intelligences in “Crocodile” have none of this. Lacking pathē, they lack virtue, and therefore any second nature at all.
Contrast the ending Lafferty gives to “Crocodile” and the one he gives to Past Master, where the artificial intelligence is capable of suffering:
Pottscamp felt nothing; he was, of course, a machine without feeling. He had no conscience or compassion. This would not bother him at all. It wouldn't? Then why did he—? Then why did he—WHAT? Sat on the ground and moaned and howled like an old Hebrew. And poured dust and ashes over his head. You're crazy. He really did that? He really did that.






Current Notes:
Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work-history card records circulation in 1963, rewriting as “Crocodile” on March 29, 1965, and further submissions during 1965–66.
Published in Chrysalis 8, edited by Roy Torgeson (Doubleday, 1980).
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Crocodile,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa; Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “Crocodile,” https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?67793.


