"Aloys" (1957/1961)
Updated: 18 hours ago

If present mathematics does not fit black holes, then present mathematics must be extended a trifle. That's better than smashing and exploding all the worlds. The fictions based on all this are unoriginal, yes. And the science that stutters around it is likewise unoriginal.¹ — “Something New Under the Black Suns” (1979)
Lafferty wrote “Aloys” in the fall of 1957 when he started his serious bid to be a professional writer.² It is one of the strongest of the early Lafferty stories just in terms of speed of Lafferty invention and sheer compact Lafferty voice. Lafferty is always surprising, but this story pushes surprises from one sentence to the next with brilliant aggressiveness. Take, for example, the following short paragraph from it, on which so much of its plot turns:
Professor Aloys had become great in spite of—or because of?—his poverty. He had worked out his finest theory, a series of nineteen interlocked equations of cosmic shapeliness and simplicity. He had worked it out on a great piece of butchers’ paper soaked with lamb’s blood, and had so given it to the world.³
It could hardly move faster. We learn that Aloys's scientific eminence is tied to extreme destitution. It outlines the conceptual scale of his nineteen interlocked cosmic equations. It contrasts the abstract intellectualism with the biological, low reality of the lamb's-blood-soaked butcher paper upon which the theory was documented and disseminated, the last being one of the story’s many comic drops.
Comic drops are what the story is built on. Ticking off drops that undercut high-concept setups with absurd realities, there is the memorable image of Halley’s Comet drinking beer in a dive bar while denying its celestial nature. There is the wonderfully absurd account of Aloys, a scholar revered by an elite few, surviving a transoceanic journey on food and offal from a bucket. There is a dry-cleaning visit and the account of the hand-me-down, ragged greatcoat that barks at the workers.⁴ We get the paralyzing linguistic crisis in which the genius can only recall words like "apple" and "fish." Lafferty writes:
“I remember bread and butter, but I don’t know which one goes on top. I know pencil and penknife and bed, but I have entirely forgotten the word for maternal uncle. I remember plow, but what in the world will I say to all those great men about a plow? I pray that this cup may pass from me.”⁵
The life-changing check for something like the Nobel Prize (when Bertie Smyllie told Yeats he had won, Yeats asked how much)⁶ was used as scrap paper for a stray formula. Then there is maybe the biggest one: the paradigm-shifting scientific lecture turns out to be a repurposed snake-oil pitch Willy McGilly used on yokels in New Mexico.⁷
My sense is that “Aloys” is a Lafferty story that Lafferty readers remember, even if it doesn’t get talked about much, since it is one of Willy McGilly’s finest moments. It was one of the first Lafferty stories I read, and it lodged McGilly forever in my mind.
McGilly doesn’t come into the story until late. Instead, we start with Professor Aloys Foulcault-Oeg. Oeg is brilliant and impoverished, but he does win recognition among a small, elite group of academics for creating a unifying theory based on nineteen interlocked cosmic equations. Living in extreme poverty and wearing that multi-generational, rag-stuffed greatcoat, he finds himself invited to accept a prestigious award. With it comes the monetary check he fails to recognize and uses absentmindedly as scratch paper.⁸
Because he is so impoverished, Oeg opts for a grueling journey as a hidden, starving stowaway on a riverboat and an ocean tramp to reach the host city.⁹ He has remarkably little ego for a great scientist. I half suspect his last name is “ego” scrambled.
As expected, he isn’t going to be up for the big night. Aloys arrives at the venue, and Aloys is overwhelmed by crippling social anxiety. One thinks of the Nobel Prize ceremonies and the tuxedos, and one can understand Aloys’s sense of class inferiority. He is even unable to remember basic English vocabulary.¹⁰
But his luck is about to change because right before the event begins, he is intercepted by a man introducing himself as Graf-Doktor Hercule Bienville-Stravroguine. It is, of course, Willy McGilly. Willy takes the panicked professor into a back room, then he leaves him bound and gagged on the floor.¹¹ The story then moves to McGilly as an imposter coming forth:
But when he emerged from that room he was a different man entirely. Erect, alive, intense, queerly handsome, and now in formal attire, he mounted with the sure grace of a panther to the speaker’s platform.¹²
This "new" Aloys is brimming with confidence, ready to deliver a three-and-a-half-hour lecture that will hold the highly educated crowd spellbound.
And it does. Afterwards, Willy McGilly cashes Aloys's forgotten check with the event's wealthy patron. There is a great callback joke that Aloys endorsed it with a newly invented mathematical formula when Aloys just didn’t recognize what a check was. The other scientists frantically copy it down. Then McGilly disappears with the cash and the gold trophy. The real Aloys frees himself from his restraints and is taken by another man to a secret location, Wreckville.¹³ There, Aloys reunites with Willy, who casually confesses the grifting:
“Only once in my life did I give a better speech,” said Willy. “It was the same speech, but it was newer then. That was in Little Dogie, New Mexico, and I was selling a snake-oil derivative whose secret I yet cannot reveal. But I was good tonight and some of them cried.”¹⁴
Recognizing them for what they are, Aloys identifies the group as a syndicate of professional con men. He is recruited into their ranks. Now his talents won’t remain uncontrolled in the wider world.¹⁵
This time through “Aloys,” I started thinking about one of Lafferty’s whole approaches to scientific knowledge and how his extreme openness to reality shows up in strange little moments of closure. A great example of this is his non-fiction essay “More Worlds Than One?” in which he questions the assumption that a planet capable of supporting life must be inhabited.¹⁶ What makes Lafferty a puzzle, perhaps, is that he was so scientifically literate yet so paradoxical in his literacy. My sense is that he was more willing to entertain the idea of prochronic time than Darwinism.¹⁷
Another instance of Lafferty in this mode is the book review “Something New Under the Black Suns.” It plays out the game of exploring the potential of novel science fiction concepts by examining the theoretical physics of black holes through two themed books. Lafferty pretends that they were given to him by a mechanical Oracle. In surveying Jerry Pournelle’s anthology Black Holes and Other Marvels, Lafferty outlines astrophysical concepts (dimensionless singularities, event horizons, and Stephen Hawking’s theory of random matter emission), and then he says the accompanying speculative fiction is stale and unrefined.¹⁸
So he goes back to the oracle, and the oracle points him toward John G. Taylor’s book Black Holes: The End of the Universe? Lafferty finds radical propositions about time travel and space-time inversion in Taylor. The cosmic cornucopia of numberless closed universes is Lafferty’s own comment.¹⁹
And he shuts the book. It is all too inelegant and silly. The paradoxes seem to require abandoning established science, but he says theological faith survives. The route forward, he says, is that present mathematics just needs a slight extension. Lafferty calls elegance a test of mathematical truth, writing:
The fictions based on all this are unoriginal, yes. And the science that stutters around it is likewise unoriginal. . . . And is elegance a test of mathematical truth? Yes it is, absolutely. We observe all the stuff being generated by the black holes and we ask “How do we know that any of this is so?” One does not ask such things of really elegant ideas.²⁰
One could read it and take away from it that Lafferty is just being cranky, but there is the issue that he was probably right. Classical general relativity predicts singularities in black-hole collapse. They mark boundaries of space-time, often associated with infinite curvature. But whether they physically exist remains uncertain. They may mark a breakdown of current theory that might require quantum gravity to resolve.²¹ Or such is my understanding of it.
All this led me to think a little harder about McGilly’s 19-point speech. Ferguson hears a snake-oil pitch in Willy’s performance, though he also sees Lafferty’s command of science fiction in the nineteen points.²² But maybe one should read the outline with a little more attention. If one does, one sees a lot of the real Lafferty in it. It is, of course, a trick first. McGilly anchors the talk in real terms. He mixes in obscurity and invention. He crosses disciplines wantonly. He forgoes proof and goes with a metaphor. A glance at just a few of the points from Aloys’s outline demonstrates this synthesis:
3. Cerebrum and Cortex—The Mathematics of Melancholia. 4. Microphysics and Megacyclic Polyneums. 5. Ego, No, Hemeis—The Personality of the Subconscious. . . . 11. Diencephalon and Di-Gamma—Unconscionable Thoughts About Consciousness.²³
Aloys’s outline ends with the Invisible Quadratic, possibly an allusion to Einstein’s E=mc². The narrator then praises the beauty of the outline, much as Lafferty praises elegance in the black-hole review.²⁴ If one looks at what McGilly seems to be saying, what the scientists forget, it can be reconstructed. It goes something like this. Reality is one connected system. Measurement is unstable. Mind and matter obey related patterns. History and language are full of hidden errors. Machines can inherit thought. The universe has shape, memory, and an ending. And underneath all of it, there is one simple, elegant law.²⁵ How much of that would the real R. A. Lafferty have disagreed with?

Aloys’s journey ends at the Wreckville table, where Willy tells him he has given the same speech before.²⁶


In the 1961 magazine, topic 14 concerns skepticism. In the 1972 collection, it concerns cybernetics. The table follows the collection.²⁷
Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work card identifies the story as written in fall 1957. It records submission to Esquire on January 2, 1958, and return on January 25, followed by extensive circulation during 1958 and 1959.²⁸
First published in Galaxy, August 1961.²⁹
Notes
1. R. A. Lafferty, “Something New Under the Black Suns,” in It’s Down the Slippery Cellar Stairs, Drumm Booklet 14 (Chris Drumm, 1984), 10–12, closing paragraphs. The review is dated August 10, 1979. Back to text
2. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “Aloys,” series 2, Writings, box 25, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Lafferty entered 3,300 words and fall 1957 on the card. Back to text
3. R. A. Lafferty, “Aloys,” in Strange Doings (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1972), 195. Story page references are to this edition unless otherwise indicated. For the first printing, see Lafferty, “Aloys,” Galaxy 19, no. 6 (August 1961): 59–66. The nineteen equations and the butchers’ paper appear on 60. Back to text
4. 194 (the comet), 196 (the bucket), 197–98 (the cleaners). Galaxy, 61–62, omits the offal and the cleaners’ account of the barking coat. Back to text
5. 199. The book reads “all those great men,” the magazine “all these great men” (Galaxy, 63). Aloys’s prayer echoes Matthew 26:39 (King James Version). Back to text
6. R. F. Foster, W. B. Yeats: A Life, vol. 2, The Arch-Poet, 1915–1939 (Oxford University Press, 2003), 245. The anecdote comes from Bertie Smyllie, who telephoned Yeats with the news of the 1923 Nobel Prize. Back to text
7. Lafferty, “Aloys,” 196 (the formula), 202–3 (the endorsement and the earlier sales pitch). Back to text
8. 194–96. Back to text
9. 196–97. Back to text
10. 197–99. Back to text
11. 198–99, 202–3. Back to text
12. 199. The book prints “that room,” the magazine “the room” (Galaxy, 63). Back to text
13. 200–3. Back to text
14. 203. The magazine omits “said Willy” and reads “This was in Little Dogie” and “I still cannot reveal” (Galaxy, 66). Back to text
15. 203–4. Back to text
16. R. A. Lafferty, “More Worlds Than One?,” in It’s Down the Slippery Cellar Stairs (Chris Drumm, 1984), 13–15. Lafferty challenges the inference from conditions that could support life to the inevitability of inhabited worlds. Back to text
17. Philip Henry Gosse, Omphalos: An Attempt to Untie the Geological Knot (John Van Voorst, 1857), 125. For the closing scene of Lafferty’s story, see “‘One Minute Before’ (1960),” Arrive at Easterwine, February 19, 2026. Lafferty discusses Darwinism in “Notes from the Golden Age,” unpublished essay, 1974, section beginning “Consider three trash or pulp fields,” R. A. Lafferty papers, box 18, folder 20, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text
18. Lafferty, “Something New Under the Black Suns,” 10–12, the M9 Oracle’s first recommendation. Jerry Pournelle, ed., Black Holes and Other Marvels (Fawcett Crest Books, 1978). For the physics behind the discussion of emission, see S. W. Hawking, “Particle Creation by Black Holes,” Communications in Mathematical Physics 43 (1975): 199–220. Back to text
19. Lafferty, “Something New Under the Black Suns,” 10–12, the Oracle’s second recommendation. John Taylor, Black Holes: The End of the Universe? (Souvenir Press, 1973). Lafferty represents the book’s title with a hyphen and gives the author’s middle initial. Back to text
20. Lafferty, “Something New Under the Black Suns,” 10–12, closing paragraphs. Back to text
21. Roger Penrose, “Gravitational Collapse and Space-Time Singularities,” Physical Review Letters 14 (1965): 57–59. The theorem establishes that, under its assumptions, some paths through space-time cannot be extended. NASA discusses the limits of general relativity at the center of a black hole in “Anatomy,” under “Singularity.” Back to text
22. Andrew Ferguson, “11. Aloys,” Continued on Next Rock, March 24, 2013, paras. 5–7. Back to text
23. Lafferty, “Aloys,” Strange Doings, 200, items 3–5 and 11. Scribner prints the whole phrase Ego, No, Hemeis in italics, with no accent on Hemeis. The ellipsis skips items 6–10. Back to text
24. 200, item 19 and the following sentence. For the proposed allusion, see Albert Einstein, “Ist die Trägheit eines Körpers von seinem Energieinhalt abhängig?,” Annalen der Physik, 4th ser., 18 (1905): 639–41. Back to text
25. Lafferty, “Aloys,” Strange Doings, 200, items 13–19. The reference to machines follows item 14, “Cybernetics—Or a Brain for Every Man.” The corresponding topic in Galaxy, 64, is skepticism. Back to text
26. Lafferty, “Aloys,” Strange Doings, 194–99, 201–4. Willy recalls his earlier speech on 203. Back to text
27. Lafferty, “Aloys,” Galaxy, 63–64, compared with Strange Doings, 199–200. Norbert Wiener, Cybernetics: Or Control and Communication in the Animal and the Machine (Technology Press and John Wiley & Sons, 1948). For the glossary’s scriptural parallels to the address, compare Isaiah 11:6 and Matthew 13:52 with Strange Doings, 201. Back to text
28. Lafferty, work card, “Aloys.” The first entry records Esquire on January 2, 1958, with January 25 as the return date. The card also names the Atlantic Monthly, Harper’s, the Yale Review, and the Sewanee Review. Back to text
29. Lafferty, “Aloys,” Galaxy, 59–66. The title page credits the illustrations to Walker. They appear on 62 and 65. See also Internet Speculative Fiction Database, “Aloys.” Back to text
Bibliography
Einstein, Albert. “Ist die Trägheit eines Körpers von seinem Energieinhalt abhängig?” Annalen der Physik, 4th ser., 18 (1905): 639–41.
Ferguson, Andrew. “11. Aloys.” Continued on Next Rock, March 24, 2013.
Foster, R. F. W. B. Yeats: A Life. Vol. 2, The Arch-Poet, 1915–1939. Oxford University Press, 2003.
Gosse, Philip Henry. Omphalos: An Attempt to Untie the Geological Knot. John Van Voorst, 1857.
Hawking, S. W. “Particle Creation by Black Holes.” Communications in Mathematical Physics 43 (1975): 199–220.
Internet Speculative Fiction Database. “Aloys.” Accessed November 19, 2026.
Lafferty, R. A. “Aloys.” Galaxy 19, no. 6 (August 1961): 59–66.
Lafferty, R. A. “Aloys.” In Strange Doings, 194–204. Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1972.
Lafferty, R. A. “Aloys.” Work card. Box 25, series 2, Writings. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lafferty, R. A. “More Worlds Than One?” In It’s Down the Slippery Cellar Stairs, 13–15. Drumm Booklet 14. Chris Drumm, 1984.
Lafferty, R. A. “Notes from the Golden Age.” Unpublished essay, 1974. Box 18, folder 20. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lafferty, R. A. “Something New Under the Black Suns.” In It’s Down the Slippery Cellar Stairs, 10–12. Drumm Booklet 14. Chris Drumm, 1984.
National Aeronautics and Space Administration. “Anatomy.” NASA Science. Section “Singularity.” Accessed November 19, 2026.
“‘One Minute Before’ (1960).” Arrive at Easterwine. February 19, 2026.
Penrose, Roger. “Gravitational Collapse and Space-Time Singularities.” Physical Review Letters 14 (1965): 57–59.
Pournelle, Jerry, ed. Black Holes and Other Marvels. Fawcett Crest Books, 1978.
Taylor, John. Black Holes: The End of the Universe? Souvenir Press, 1973.
Wiener, Norbert. Cybernetics: Or Control and Communication in the Animal and the Machine. Technology Press and John Wiley & Sons, 1948.


