top of page
Search

“Along the San Pennatus Fault” (1986)

Jan 20
14 min read

Updated: 16 hours ago

Close-up of a duck’s orange webbed feet.

“But we haven’t any wings, father,” Job Salto protested. “You have feathers, and feathers are certainly an intimation of wings. Some of you even have a few elbow-feathers. I will call them pinion-feathers, and perhaps your elbows will have turned into wing-pinions by tomorrow.”¹

But Darwinism and all the denials that make it up, does give silly and evil answers; and it is guilty of Mistakes of Interpretation against dozens of sciences as well as against the Word of God.² — R. A. Lafferty to the editor of The Wanderer, January 31, 1987

“Along the San Pennatus Fault” is another Lafferty satire of Charles Darwin and company. This time, he goes after the neo-Darwinian synthesis of natural selection and genetics. The story’s premise targets Richard Goldschmidt (1878–1958) and his famous phrase, “hopeful monsters.” A German-born geneticist, Goldschmidt argued that major evolutionary changes could occur in a single step. He introduced the phrase in a 1933 paper.³ Seven years later, in The Material Basis of Evolution, he gave Lafferty the ammunition:


I think that this idea of the hopeful monster has come into its own only recently. Only now is the exact basis for an appraisal of its evolutionary significance available. This basis is furnished by the existence of mutants producing monstrosities of the required type and the knowledge of embryonic determination, which permits a small rate change in early embryonic processes to produce a large effect embodying considerable parts of the organism.⁴

These macromutations are what Lafferty is out to ridicule. The “Stephen Stanley” whom Anselm Salto quotes is the paleontologist Steven M. Stanley.⁵ The satire also seems to reach Stephen Jay Gould (1941–2002), the American paleontologist, popularizer of science, and public adversary of Richard Dawkins. Gould advanced a different challenge to strict gradualism: punctuated equilibrium, the model he and Niles Eldredge proposed in 1972. The idea is that the fossil record often shows prolonged periods of relative stasis (little net change) punctuated by comparatively rapid change associated with the formation of new species.⁶


The difference between Goldschmidt and Gould is that Goldschmidt’s theory pinpoints discontinuous change driven by significant developmental shifts within individual organisms. Gould, by contrast, kept natural selection and population processes central. He and Eldredge argued that evolution can be geologically abrupt without requiring single-step “hopeful monster” transformations.⁷ Lafferty has a lot of fun with this kind of wrangling. He imagines neo-neo-Darwinians and the one outlier, a neo-neo-neo-Darwinian.⁸ I read Goldschmidt as the neo-neo and Gould as the neo-neo-neo.


The story is set around San Pennatus (loosely, “Holy Feathers”) Fault College.⁹ A group of biotechnical directors monitors the area for sudden evolutionary saltations, and everyone in charge is keen on spotting early anomalies. There is a flying turtle named Sydney and a talking anaconda with multicolored eyes. The directors have twelve children between them. When supplies disappear from the laboratory, Godwin Dropforge suspects the children. Anatole makes a substance called Euelpis Elixirion Papia Pedema. Irene offers her translation as a question, “Happy Hopping Duck Elixir, is that it?” The Modern Greek word for duck is papia.¹⁰


Eighteen-year-old Anatole Prorok spikes the local reservoir with the elixir. As a result, people who drink the water begin to display physical traits such as facial feathers, tail feathers, and duck feet.¹¹


Cast chart pairing the six directors with their children in ‘Along the San Pennatus Fault.’

The twelve children are the first to be transformed. At the press gathering, their fathers present them as evidence of an evolutionary breakthrough.¹²


A cheer went up from the crowd in the big banquet-hall-lecture-room when the twelve young persons duck-walked in. “Behold!” cried Anselm Salto, “the final vindication of saltatory evolution! And it’s come about just as we predicted that it would, by quantum speciation. As the immortal Stephen Stanley wrote, ‘It is generally agreed that quantum speciation takes place within very small populations — some would say populations involving fewer than ten individuals.’ Well, twelve individuals comes very close to being less than ten.”¹³

At one point, the miserable misanthrope Titus Chesty leads a mob intent on killing the transformed children. The townspeople later undergo the same transformation. As the directors and members of the media sprout feathers and discover how terribly hard it is to sit down, they debate the scientific merits of the changes. Anatole offers the reader a characteristic Lafferty epistemology, suggesting that the change may depend on what its observers believe. He admits making up his example about the hyena and allows that the children’s condition may be real.¹⁴


The elixir wears off for the twelve children first. I see Providence in what follows. A heavy rainstorm flushes out the reservoir, and the general population recovers over the next three days. Following the hopeful-monster episode, Anatole thinks he’ll give up biotechnics for a more erudite field. The directors mourn the loss of a potential new species.¹⁵


Near the end comes a standoff at Titus Chesty’s shack. His duck-like mutation persists: his elbows might be on their way to becoming wing pinions. Government lawyers now want to seize him as a World Resource under the Biotechnic Act of 2012. But Chesty is barricaded in his home, shooting the ends off the security guards’ noses. The girls’ ballad follows.¹⁶


I don’t particularly enjoy this story. Readers who do enjoy it will likely take it as Lafferty being silly. California satire? Check. Governmental regulation satire? Check. Of course, Lafferty does not argue directly in his fiction. Because I know how dead serious he is about Charles Darwin, I find it depressing to see his satirical powers working at low wattage.


This judgment has nothing to do with Lafferty’s writing at the level of the line or with his verbal wit throughout the story. Nor does it have to do with his genius for lateral leaps and conceptual caricature. There, he often succeeds. Instead, it has to do with how little Lafferty does with the idea of the hopeful monster beyond one obvious joke I think he expects the reader to catch. Dickinson calls hope “the thing with feathers.”¹⁷


“But we haven’t any wings, father,” Job Salto protested. “You have feathers, and feathers are certainly an intimation of wings. Some of you even have a few elbow-feathers. I will call them pinion-feathers, and perhaps your elbows will have turned into wing-pinions by tomorrow.”¹⁸

That is why Lafferty begins with hopeful monsters, why he mentions the word feathers an extraordinary twenty-three times in the story proper,¹⁹ and why he ends with the Titus Chesty set piece that includes this line:


“It’s a hope, it’s a hope!” Masterman Jordan spoke fervently.²⁰

Lafferty’s fervid irritation with Darwinian evolution motivates the story, not any new idea about the subject. He builds the story along the palimphanic associations of hope, but he does not become palimphanic or oceanic. The critique is negative, not visionary. What he says is what he had been saying for a long time—and here he says it worse, and with less ingenuity. Lafferty rejected all forms of evolution, including theistic evolution, as peak symptoms of modern credulity.²¹ I take the same objection to extend to abiogenesis.


He told Ed Babinski:


Etymologically every “species” is “special,” and so it will remain. A child of two years old will know that a dog is a dog whether it is a St. Bernard or a Chihuahua. And he will know that a cat is a completely different sort of creature, even though it is the same size and color of his dog. And a child of two years old would know immediately that a Neanderthal Man or a Cro-Magnon Man and a Grimaldi Man were men indeed; and that a Java Man or an Australopithecus were not men, that the difference between them and men was wider than the world. “What can a man receive in exchange for his soul?” Christ asks somewhere. If a person trades his immortal soul for Evolution then he trades it for circular-reasoning drivel. Biology and zoology and cosmology and geology and astronomy have all been turned into circular-reasoning monstrosities to accommodate evolution. Or such was the case for a hundred years or so. Science has now pretty well cleaned itself from the pseudo-sciences that owed their being to evolution. But the popular mind lags fifty or more years behind the facts, and sadly the popular mind still is likely to believe that there is some substance in evolution. But it is so goofy to be unhorsed by gnats! You are wasting your talent, Ed.²²

Did someone think this was about ducks and a light ribbing of scientists?


In “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” Lafferty burlesques his old enemy, but it is less interesting than elsewhere in his fiction. Why ducks? Ducks are one of Lafferty’s private symbols for being a real know-nothing. Why a flying turtle? Galápagos. Why Chardin Dropforge? The Omega Point is a forgery.²³ Why a serpent that is having a great time? Indeed.


The satire turns on the Darwinian directors being fooled by their own children, who are fooling around. The neo-Darwinians reject design (the teleological argument), so they can’t see that the kids’ experiment is behind the apparent macromutation. Those darned kids had a telos. The smartest of the next-gen kids realizes that the evolutionary science racket amounts to being a form of disciplinary underachievement. Note how species identity snaps back like a rubber band. He thinks he might find a better field of study.


There are, to be sure, small Lafferty touches, such as the children breaking the clay cups they drink from, a gesture that recalls Jeremiah 18–19 and 2 Corinthians 4:7, with the children enfiguring the rejection of humanity as earthen vessels to become “hopeful monsters” (read Lafferty’s “The Hand of the Potter: An Idyll”):²⁴


All of them drank off their brimming cups with slurping gulps. Then all of them smashed their ritual clay cups on a rock. This is a technique that is not in the repertoire of every biotechnician.²⁵

I hear a pun on the Penates, the pantry gods, here a household of Darwinian luminaries.²⁶ There is a worthwhile critique of institutional authority and shortsightedness. There is an interesting wrinkle around the midpoint, with implications for how consensus reality falls short of foundational features of Prime; the falsity of Darwinian evolution is one such feature for Lafferty. That implies epistemological access to some foundation beyond consensus reality, even though (let’s just use Lafferty’s language) any single person’s chosen ambient is highly subjective. This is Lafferty’s least imaginative anti-evolution allegory.


Fantasy illustration of two young people, a robed figure and a large flying turtle.

Stephen Fabian’s illustration for “Along the San Pennatus Fault.”²⁷

Character network connecting the college directors, their offspring, the townspeople and the elixir.
Plot outline of ‘Along the San Pennatus Fault,’ from the altered animals to Titus Chesty’s final resistance.
Rebus showing SAN PENNATUS divided by a fault line with arrows pointing in opposite directions.
Chronology of the elixir experiment, the town’s transformations and the rain that flushes the reservoir.
Diagram contrasting the characters’ belief in sudden evolution with the elixir’s effects and their reversal.
Interpretive notes, part 1 of 5. Ethical critique: Persons as World Resources.
Interpretive notes, part 2 of 5. Institutional critique: The Research Establishment as Echo Chamber.
Interpretive notes, part 3 of 5. Theoretical critique: Evolutionary Doctrine as Absurdity.
Interpretive notes, part 4 of 5. Ontological critique: Reality as Metaphor-Choice.
Interpretive notes, part 5 of 5. Theological foundation: Rejection of Design.
Reference table explaining character names, scientific references and literary allusions in ‘Along the San Pennatus Fault.’

The epigraphs,²⁸ the scientists,²⁹ the names of the families,³⁰ and the literary comparisons in the table.³¹




Bibliographical Note


Lafferty’s work card records completion on May 10, 1983, and submission to Virginia Kidd the same day. It records an undated sale to Amazing.³²


“Along the San Pennatus Fault” first appeared in the July 1986 issue of Amazing Stories. Stephen Fabian illustrated it.³³


Notes

1. R. A. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” Amazing Stories 61, no. 2 (July 1986), 94–95. Job addresses his father, Anselm Salto. Back to text


2. R. A. Lafferty to the editor of The Wanderer, January 31, 1987, 1, correspondence, series 1, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Lafferty replies to Fr. Robert D. Smith’s “Mistakes of Interpretation,” which he identifies as appearing in the January 22 issue. Back to text


3. Richard Goldschmidt, “Some Aspects of Evolution,” Science 78, no. 2033 (December 15, 1933): 547. He introduces the expression in the plural at the close of the paper. Back to text


4. Richard Goldschmidt, The Material Basis of Evolution (Yale University Press, 1940), 390–91, quotation on 391. Back to text


5. Steven M. Stanley, Macroevolution: Pattern and Process (W. H. Freeman, 1979). Anselm’s wording comes from Lafferty’s story in Amazing Stories, 94. The sentence concerns the size of a population in which a new species arises. Anselm applies it to twelve children who change overnight. Back to text


6. Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould, “Punctuated Equilibria: An Alternative to Phyletic Gradualism,” in Models in Paleobiology, ed. Thomas J. M. Schopf (Freeman, Cooper, 1972), 94–96, 98. They describe morphological change concentrated around the origin of a species in a geographically isolated population and relative stability after its establishment. Back to text


7. Gould later argued that small changes in the timing of development can produce marked differences in adult form. See Stephen Jay Gould, “Return of the Hopeful Monster,” in The Panda’s Thumb: More Reflections in Natural History (W. W. Norton, 1980), 191–92. This was a separate argument from his account of the fossil record with Eldredge. Back to text


8. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” 90. Merald Hilltop is the lone neo-neo-neo-Darwinian. Back to text


9. Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (Clarendon Press, 1879), s.v. “pennatus” (winged or feathered). Back to text


10. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” 90–93. For the wordplay, see Henry George Liddell and Robert Scott, A Greek-English Lexicon, rev. Henry Stuart Jones with Roderick McKenzie, 9th ed. (Clarendon Press, 1940), s.vv. “εὔελπις” (hopeful) and “πήδημα” (a leap). For “duck,” see Λεξικό της κοινής νεοελληνικής [Dictionary of Standard Modern Greek] (Institute of Modern Greek Studies, 1998), s.v. “πάπια.” Back to text


11. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” 91–93. Back to text







17. Emily Dickinson, The Poems of Emily Dickinson: Reading Edition, ed. R. W. Franklin (Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1999), no. 314, line 1 (Johnson no. 254). First printed as “Hope,” in Poems by Emily Dickinson, Second Series, ed. T. W. Higginson and Mabel Loomis Todd (Roberts Brothers, 1891), 27. Back to text


18. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” 94–95. Back to text


19. 87, 92–96. Fifteen occurrences stand alone and eight occur in hyphenated compounds. Including the epigraph attributed to Cato would give twenty-four. Back to text



21. Lafferty to the editor of The Wanderer, January 31, 1987, 1–2. In his 1985 letter to Ed Babinski, 1, 3, Lafferty expressly rejects theistic evolution. Back to text


22. R. A. Lafferty to Ed Babinski, “Re issues 1 & 2 of Theistic Evolutionist Forum and other aberrations,” Theistic Evolutionists’ Forum, nos. 3–4 (March–April 1985): 1–3, at 3. Compare Matt. 16:26 and Mark 8:37 (KJV). Lafferty recasts the question in his own words. Back to text


23. Charles Darwin, Journal of Researches into the Natural History and Geology of the Countries Visited during the Voyage of H.M.S. Beagle Round the World, 2nd ed. (John Murray, 1845), chap. 17, 394. Darwin records the islanders’ ability to tell the Galápagos tortoises apart and compares the shapes of their shells. Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, The Phenomenon of Man, trans. Bernard Wall (Collins, 1959), 262–63, esp. 263 n. 1. Teilhard uses “Omega Point” for the personal center toward which other centers converge. Back to text


24. Jer. 18:1–6 and 19:1, 10–11 (KJV). The potter reshapes the marred clay in chapter 18. In chapter 19 Jeremiah is told to break an earthen bottle as a sign of judgment on Jerusalem. Paul calls those who carry the treasure “earthen vessels” in 2 Cor. 4:7 (KJV). R. A. Lafferty, “The Hand of the Potter: An Idyll,” in Feast of Laughter: An Appreciation of R. A. Lafferty, vol. 5, ed. Kevin Cheek and Gregorio Montejo (Ktistec Press, 2020), 343–58. Back to text


25. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” 92. Back to text


26. Lewis and Short, A Latin Dictionary, s.v. “Penates.” The Roman Penates guarded the household and were associated with its provisions. Back to text


27. Stephen Fabian, illustration for R. A. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” Amazing Stories 61, no. 2 (July 1986), 89. The art credit appears on page 87. Back to text


28. The story credits its opening couplet to John Hookham Frere (87). In Charles Edmonds’s edition of Poetry of the Anti-Jacobin (Sampson Low, 1890), the contents (xxi) assign cantos 1–2 of “The Progress of Man” to George Canning. The couplet comes from canto 1, lines 34–35, 104. The note to line 14 also names William Godwin’s Enquirer and Erasmus Darwin’s Zoonomia (103). The second epigraph’s Cato attribution is part of Lafferty’s text. Back to text


29. For the scientific names proposed in the table, compare Theodosius Dobzhansky, Genetics and the Origin of Species (Columbia University Press, 1937), chaps. 1–3; Joel Cracraft, “Systematics and Evolution of the Gruiformes (Class, Aves). 1, The Eocene Family Geranoididae and the Early History of the Gruiformes,” American Museum Novitates, no. 2388 (1969): 1–41; and Hugo de Vries, Species and Varieties: Their Origin by Mutation, ed. Daniel Trembly MacDougal, 2nd ed. (Open Court, 1906), preface. The proposed connection between Davoreen Merriman and de Vries is conjectural. Back to text


30. The story lists the twelve children on 91. I read some of their names and their parents’ names against other books. Anselm of Canterbury explains his title “Faith Seeking Understanding” in the preface to the Proslogium. Compare Frederick Marryat’s Masterman Ready and Anatole France’s The Revolt of the Angels, chap. 35, 345–57. For the Brandywine echo, Tolkien names old Rory Brandybuck in book 1, chap. 1, and the Brandywine Bridge in chap. 5 of The Fellowship of the Ring. Lafferty says that Rory Brandywine does not drink water (96). Back to text


31. For the comparisons in the table, see Augustine, The City of God, trans. Marcus Dods, 14.28 (the two cities and their loves). Compare Plato, Republic, trans. Paul Shorey, 7.514a–517b (the cave). For the Apollonian and Dionysian, see Friedrich Nietzsche, The Birth of Tragedy; or, Hellenism and Pessimism, trans. Wm. A. Haussmann (T. N. Foulis, 1910), sec. 1, 21–22. For the projectors at the Academy of Lagado, see Jonathan Swift, Gulliver’s Travels, ed. David Womersley (Cambridge University Press, 2012), pt. 3, chap. 5, 259–74. Back to text


32. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. The card records completion and submission to Virginia Kidd on May 10, 1983, and an undated sale to Amazing. Back to text


33. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault,” 87–98. Whole no. 529. Back to text

Bibliography

Anselm of Canterbury. Proslogium. Translated by Sidney Norton Deane. Open Court, 1903. Preface and chap. 1.


Augustine. The City of God. Translated by Marcus Dods. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, first series, vol. 2, edited by Philip Schaff. Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1887. 14.28.


Canning, George. “The Progress of Man.” Canto 1. The Anti-Jacobin, no. 15 (February 19, 1798). In Poetry of the Anti-Jacobin, edited by Charles Edmonds. Sampson Low, 1890. xxi and 103–4.


Cracraft, Joel. “Systematics and Evolution of the Gruiformes (Class, Aves). 1, The Eocene Family Geranoididae and the Early History of the Gruiformes.” American Museum Novitates, no. 2388 (1969): 1–41. Biodiversity Heritage Library.


Darwin, Charles. Journal of Researches into the Natural History and Geology of the Countries Visited during the Voyage of H.M.S. Beagle Round the World. 2nd ed. John Murray, 1845. Chap. 17, 394.


Dickinson, Emily. Poems by Emily Dickinson, Second Series. Edited by T. W. Higginson and Mabel Loomis Todd. Roberts Brothers, 1891. “Hope,” 27.


Dickinson, Emily. The Poems of Emily Dickinson: Reading Edition. Edited by R. W. Franklin. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1999. Poem no. 314, line 1.


Dobzhansky, Theodosius. Genetics and the Origin of Species. Columbia University Press, 1937. Publisher’s record for the first-edition reprint.


Eldredge, Niles, and Stephen Jay Gould. “Punctuated Equilibria: An Alternative to Phyletic Gradualism.” In Models in Paleobiology, edited by Thomas J. M. Schopf, 82–115. Freeman, Cooper, 1972. Chapter scan.


Fabian, Stephen. Illustration for R. A. Lafferty, “Along the San Pennatus Fault.” Amazing Stories 61, no. 2 (July 1986): 89.


France, Anatole. The Revolt of the Angels. Translated by Mrs. Wilfrid Jackson. John Lane, 1914. Chap. 35, 345–57.


Goldschmidt, Richard. “Some Aspects of Evolution.” Science 78, no. 2033 (December 15, 1933): 539–47. Journal scan.


Goldschmidt, Richard. The Material Basis of Evolution. Yale University Press, 1940. Book scan.


Gould, Stephen Jay. “Return of the Hopeful Monster.” In The Panda’s Thumb: More Reflections in Natural History, 186–93. W. W. Norton, 1980. Chapter scan.


The Holy Bible. King James Version. Jer. 18:1–6 and 19:1, 10–11 and 2 Cor. 4:7.


Institute of Modern Greek Studies. Λεξικό της κοινής νεοελληνικής [Dictionary of Standard Modern Greek]. Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 1998. S.v. “πάπια.”


Lafferty, R. A. “Along the San Pennatus Fault.” Amazing Stories 61, no. 2 (July 1986): 87–98.


Lafferty, R. A. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. “Re issues 1 & 2 of Theistic Evolutionist Forum and other aberrations.” Letter to Ed Babinski. Theistic Evolutionists’ Forum, nos. 3–4 (March–April 1985): 1–3.


Lafferty, R. A. “The Hand of the Potter: An Idyll.” In Feast of Laughter: An Appreciation of R. A. Lafferty, vol. 5, edited by Kevin Cheek and Gregorio Montejo, 343–58. Ktistec Press, 2020.


Lewis, Charlton T., and Charles Short. A Latin Dictionary. Clarendon Press, 1879. S.vv. “pennatus” and “Penates.”


Liddell, Henry George, and Robert Scott. A Greek-English Lexicon. Revised by Henry Stuart Jones with Roderick McKenzie. 9th ed. Clarendon Press, 1940. S.vv. “εὔελπις” and “πήδημα.”


Marryat, Frederick. Masterman Ready; or, The Wreck of the Pacific. 1841–42. Project Gutenberg.


Nietzsche, Friedrich. The Birth of Tragedy; or, Hellenism and Pessimism. Translated by Wm. A. Haussmann. T. N. Foulis, 1910. Sec. 1, 21–22.


Plato. Republic. Vol. 2. Translated by Paul Shorey. Harvard University Press, 1935. 7.514a–517b.


Stanley, Steven M. Macroevolution: Pattern and Process. W. H. Freeman, 1979. Internet Archive.


Swift, Jonathan. Gulliver’s Travels. Edited by David Womersley. Cambridge University Press, 2012. Pt. 3, chap. 5, 259–74.


Teilhard de Chardin, Pierre. The Phenomenon of Man. Translated by Bernard Wall. Collins, 1959.


Tolkien, J. R. R. The Fellowship of the Ring. George Allen & Unwin, 1954. Book 1, chap. 1 and chap. 5.


Vries, Hugo de. Species and Varieties: Their Origin by Mutation. Edited by Daniel Trembly MacDougal. 2nd ed. Open Court, 1906. Project Gutenberg.

bottom of page