05 Aurelia and Yin-Yang
Updated: Nov 8

“All these things are possible. If you will worry about them, then I will cease doing it. I hate duplication.” “I will worry about them,” the bodyguard said. “It is my job to worry about them. Are you also going on a peripateticus, as Rex calls it, when Aurelia goes?” “Yes. Today. And that is all the questions that I will answer, Mr. Bodyguard.” “But I would like to know—” “Black lightning of which you felt only a sample, man! Black lightning to burn you to a cinder!” Cousin Clootie the Dark Counterpart said. And then Cousin Clootie walked away with his awkward shamble.
Fifth thinking-aloud post. A post on antagonist mapping.
Aurelia is another of Lafferty's novels featuring devils and a demonic conspiracy. One would have to look closely at the Floating World and the “trolls” to make the case fully, and show how the materials that became Aurelia emerged from the German-set E. T. A. Hoffmann pastiche that had been the original draft.
What seems to have happened is this. Lafferty started working with Hoffmann in mind, and he wrote the riverboat scenario, which survived and became a part of the final novel. That material is dreamy and odd, partly because of the history of Aurelia's compositional process. It is obscure. What I can say is that Lafferty wrote the basis for the scenes and most of the material itself before he knew he was going to write a postfiguration of Christ. He started with a book about art and magic, and he worked himself into a corner. That was when Aurelia was still Aurelia McDermott. He needed a way to make Aurelia centripetal. Postfigure her through the Christian tradition.
One can see this by noting a few points.
First, there is the original German setting of “To Aurelia with Horns.” This is from the original abandoned manuscript:

Second, there is the very important reference to E. T. A. Hoffmann.

Third, there is the fact that Lafferty takes the description of Julio Cordovan straight from E. F. Bleiler. In the original MS, this is explicit inspiration:

This is Bleiler on Hoffmann, from page v of his introduction to the tales. Lafferty kipes Bleiler:

Finally, in the published version of Aurelia, Bleiler and Hoffmann have disappeared. Julio Cordovan sticks around:

The point matters because the devils in the book passed through a filter of Hoffmannian fantasy before becoming part of the published Aurelia. If you haven't read him, E. T. A. Hoffmann (1776–1822) was a German Romantic writer, composer, artist, and critic best known for difficult fantasies such as “The Sandman.” Wonderful and weird, Hoffmann is as tricky to read as Lafferty. Today in the U.S., he is best remembered for The Nutcracker and the Mouse King, which became the subject of Tchaikovsky's famous work.
What I call Hoffmannian fantasy makes ordinary life unstable through doubles, automata, madness, and uncertain supernatural events. The reader cannot always tell whether an event is magical or delusional. Lafferty’s use of Bleiler’s introduction gives us evidence for the comparison here.

Consider a small point. Why the gory blood-drinking scene in the novel? I suspect it is because of the mention of wine drinking in Bleiler and because Hoffmann wrote a novel called The Devil's Elixir.

In any case, the riverboat people are the powers and principalities, in my view. They show up in Sandaliotis in the Fortean intelligences. A devilish conspiracy in a Lafferty novel is about as surprising as a twist in an O. Henry story, so that isn't surprising. What is surprising in Aurelia is the presence of another set of antagonistic forces, all gathered under the sign of the yin-yang. This becomes the main set of antagonists outside the Floating World passages, though the Floating World people still play their role. Lafferty associates yin-yang with the New Age counterculture.
Before getting into the yin-yang and the “gusto-disgusto dynamic” (which I read as love-hate caught in the bad infinite), I think Aurelia becomes much easier once one appreciates how much doubling is going on. A few examples, from my notes on the categories of doubling in Lafferty:

By this point, Aurelia faces the people of the Floating World and the cult of the yin-yang. Within the novel, that cult treats light and darkness, good and evil, and life and death as opposites requiring compensation. I take this as Lafferty’s polemical version of the doctrine, rather than a complete account of yin-yang thought.
Lafferty writes from a different metaphysical world. For him, God is absolute light and goodness. Evil is a corruption to be defeated, not a partner to be accommodated. To the Christian imagination, the claim that good needs evil in order to be whole is not wisdom but a dangerous lie.
Lafferty gives the cult’s doctrine a physical form in the “yin-yang yo-yos,” the double-spiked darts that kill Aurelia and Cousin Clootie. The weapon is deadly and deliberately ridiculous. Its return to the thrower gives me an image of repetition that contrasts with Aurelia’s teaching on fulfillment in “Final Happiness.”
Here is how Lafferty describes the weapon:
“Those double-dart yo-yos could be sailed with a flick of the hand, and they would go straight to a selected target-tree and embed themselves in it to a ten centimeter depth. . . . And why were those darts double-spiked? So, they would go back and kill the thrower if he had any reservations about the yin-yang philosophy. There were many mysteries about these murderous toys.”
Aurelia recognizes the spiritual trap. We see this when a dowdy cultist approaches her and calls the yin-yang the “perfect balance” and the “celestial compensation by which the universe runs.” Aurelia rejects the premise at once. The universe does not require an equal measure of darkness to offset the light. Lafferty’s Augustinian formation shows here. Aurelia tells the woman:
“I am not at all disposed to deal with a yo-yo,” Aurelia said. “Begone with that damned thing, woman! I tell you that it is out of balance.”
Earlier, she had told the same woman:
“It is all a false compensation and a false balance. It is a little bit of evil that the enemy has devised to blur people. I do not believe that if I want to walk up stairs I must first dig a compensating hole in the ground for balance. I do not believe that every time we light a light we must also light a darkness for balance.”
Whatever Planet X's real name, many of its people have been so damaged by this specious doctrine of balance that they cannot endure Aurelia’s unmixed goodness. The citizens feel compelled to complete a “love-hate dialectic,” as though admiration must be balanced by violence.
Finally, Lafferty could have written the novel as if it focused on Cousin Clootie, because Clootie's high-school assignment runs in parallel with Aurelia's. The two of them, working together, form a counterimage to the black-and-white duality of the yo-yo that does not make a yin-yang mistake. Cousin Clootie is her dark counterpart, the stick to her carrot, but the horns they blow are in harmony and in time, not discordant with one another, opposed to one another, or in a dialectical relationship. She has her mechano-organo monkey (cyborg/AI), and he has his, the black tarsier.
These posts have approached Aurelia through biblical postfiguration, Thomistic ideas, and the figures who oppose her.

Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work-history card for Aurelia, also headed To Aurelia, with Horns, gives a manuscript extent of 194 pages and 70,000 words. It records submission to Virginia Kidd on October 20, 1976, followed by a note about retyping a lost manuscript and a further entry to Kidd on November 17, 1976.
First published as Aurelia by The Donning Company in its Starblaze Editions series in September 1982, with illustrations by Larry Todd. The first edition has 183 pages.
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for Aurelia / To Aurelia, with Horns, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa; Internet Speculative Fiction Database, Aurelia, title record, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?2397, and first-edition record, https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/pl.cgi?189529.


