top of page
Search

"Told as the Twilight Fails" (1976)

Oct 6, 2025
5 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

Painting of a monumental stone-like profile marked Sade before a burning fortress.

“That may well be,” I argue. “Sex may be implicit in everything. But I want it out of everything and right here in one piece where I can see it and smell it and taste it and feel it and watch it. When is the main act? When do the people do it? What is this run-around that you keep giving me?” — “Sex and Sorcery” (1973)

Among the unfinished manuscripts at Tulsa is “Told as the Twilight Fails.” It belongs to a small group of stories that Lafferty never quite got right. These are angry, combative, and more than a little crude stories. They mock by going low, and in that sense, they are closer to morally serious lampoons than to satire. The most finished example is “Sex and Sorcery,” with its grotesque pornographer protagonist. It has been called funny, but it makes me cringe. “Brain Fever Season” approaches the same territory more obliquely, though I find it unpleasant too.


These are works in which Lafferty explores the question of what went so wrong with sex in the 1970s, the period often called porn chic. “It is named Pit and Crotch and is just plain the latest thing in scents,” as the protagonist of "Sex and Sorcery" puts it. I think Lafferty was prescient about the pornification of America and what has happened to its culture. What has me thinking about it today is porn being spammed on his Facebook group.


“Told as the Twilight Fails” is one of the stories where he tried to attack the problem. For all his powers as an artist, this was not his strength. The story takes place in an enclosed society known as a “Life Park” or “Zoo.” In the Life Park, there are manicured lawns kept warm by underground heating grids. The culture is built on a central contradiction. It supports, by law, both “the people's right to comfort” and “the people's right to vandalism.” Daily life has two main aims: to protect a state of “blessed tedium,” and to engage in “meaningful [sexual] encounters.” These encounters are public sexual acts, often performed in groups on city lawns. Lafferty says they occur at a measured density of “2.7 meaningful encounters per square meter per twenty-four hour day.”

 

The story takes place in a world of deep intellectual decline and deathly pomposity. People group themselves into scholarly institutions, but these are becoming obsolete under a dominant ideology called the “Centrality” or “Central Validity.” There are groups like the Fringe Studies College, the Kinky Flexibility Foundation, and the Swinger-Dinger Institution of Packaged Life-Styles. These institutions are being shut down or are going out of business as society turns its focus to boredom and rutting.


As in a few other stories Lafferty wrote, the principle at work is anti-life, and here it is described as sniggering. In this case, the snigger is vast. It is the “Cosmic Snigger,” not a sound but an “exploding resonance frequency” that gives people confidence in their beliefs. The characters solemnly discuss the Cosmic Snigger, but it turns out to be exactly what it sounds like. It reduces life. It makes people smaller. Its spirit is captured in the Poetry Parnassus, a monument where the great works of the poets have been destroyed by sanctioned vandals. In their place are 24 rhyming words, described as a “distilled essence,” on three columns.

The Poetry Parnassus: three parallel columns of eight rhyming words, as transcribed in the post.

Aesthetically, this is Lafferty at his worst, so very on the nose it honks. The story remained unfinished and unpublished. Even so, the bars and watching faces stay with me.


That leads to the story’s most interesting part. The world it describes has vast, possibly hallucinatory boundaries. It is surrounded by bars or grates that some characters see as illusions, but the bars are spiritually solid enough to cause a moonflight to turn back. Where did the bars come from? They were first seen by the Marquis de Sade in 1812. The bars are now accepted as a comforting barrier that keeps the outside world out. Along with the bars are the “Great Faces,” huge observers who watch the people inside. These expressive faces appear just as the people themselves have lost their own expressions. Nearly every character is said to have a “blank face.”


This is the story I wish Lafferty had written. In general, I do not care much for the French theorists when they go double Dutch, but I think they were right about the importance of Sade in modernity. I think Lafferty was right.


Bataille’s Erotism: Death and Sensuality and Literature and Evil, both published in 1957, offer one comparison. His account of Sade connects transgression, violence, and the pursuit of sovereignty. Lafferty’s moral commitments are very different, but both writers ask what happens when sexual freedom is made an absolute.


I suspect Lafferty would have found Bataille’s treatment of eroticism and the sacred repellent. Yet The Flame Is Green joins eroticism, violence, and religious imagery, notably in the episodes involving Elena Prado and in Dana and Catherine’s bloody fencing match. They use rapiers, distinguished from buttoned foils.


Blanchot’s essay on Sade, in Lautréamont et Sade (1949), considers the pursuit of sovereignty through radical negation. God, nature, and other people become limits the Sadean individual seeks to overcome. That account offers another way to read the combination of sexual license and emotional emptiness in Lafferty’s Life Park.


Blanchot says that Sade’s characters try to reach a state of “apathy.” They suppress pity, attachment, and spontaneous passion to concentrate their destructive energy. It is how they try to reach total freedom. In this way, Sade shows something about the logic of middle modernity. It leads to the Sadean person: a self-governing individual stripped of all external limits.


Lacan’s “Kant with Sade” (1963) puts a Sadean maxim of enjoyment beside the universal form of Kant’s moral law. The comparison is not simply between reason and unrestrained appetite: it concerns the impersonal demand that can organize enjoyment as a duty. I hear an echo of that demand in the Life Park’s ritualized “meaningful encounters.”


Foucault places Sade within a longer history of the demand to put sex into words. That history precedes Sade, reaching back through Christian confession. The connection I see with Lafferty is the relentless classification and measurement of sexual life.


I read the Life Park alongside these accounts of Sade. Its measured “meaningful encounters” make pleasure an organized obligation, while the blank faces suggest apathy.


There is little plot, but Alphamale Fangsel gives the fragment a direction. Fangsel breaks from the Sadean system. At one point, his face unblanks itself as he blinks his way out of the numbness. The story pattern reminds me of the Astrobe Dream and Cathead in that Fangsel rejects the orgiastic parkways and travels to “junk-town.” I am not sure the story could ever have worked, but I find the image of the Marquis de Sade looking out from the Charenton Hospice, seeing the night sky bars, and welcoming them to be strangely powerful.


Character map linking Fringe Studies, Kinky Flexibility, the Swinger-Dinger Institution, and the zoo in Told as the Twilight Fails.
Outline of the typescript, alternate opening, and planning notes for Told as the Twilight Fails, distinguishing the written ending from the projected iron-door exit.
Diagram linking false centrality with cultural reduction, blank faces, institutional collapse, and entrapment.
Concentric-circle diagram of the cage’s psychological, perceptual, and existential layers in Told as the Twilight Fails.

Feedback loop connecting tedium, hunger for sensation, and sanctioned transgression in the zoo.
Timeline tracing the loss of true centrality through Sade’s sighting of bars to the diminished zoo-world.
Diagram showing three fringe institutions drawn into the central void in Told as the Twilight Fails.
Diagram tracing Alphamale Fangsel’s rejection of the zoo’s pleasures and the return of expression and questioning.



Bibliographical Note


Unpublished. An unfinished short-story project preserved among Lafferty’s manuscripts at Tulsa. The surviving material includes a six-page typescript whose opening is dated April 22, 1976, a different opening dated June 1, 1976, and handwritten planning notes.


Sources: R. A. Lafferty, “Told as the Twilight Fails,” unfinished manuscript, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.

bottom of page