"The Man with the Aura" (1961/1974)
Updated: 18 hours ago

“The vulgar is always taken by appearances and the result of things; and the world consists only of the vulgar.”¹ — Niccolò Machiavelli
Castlereagh served on many committees and national forums. His heading-up of any body guaranteed its integrity and success. No president felt properly inaugurated unless Castlereagh stood by his side. His was the most sought-after endorsement in the country. He was Respectability.²
“The Man with the Aura” was first written in 1961, went through several iterations, and was first published in 1974. It is very much a political story of the early 1960s, yet one published after Watergate broke.³
Andrew Ferguson reads it as an inventor tale and a trial run for Lafferty’s later stories about media projection.⁴ That is not very interesting to me. I see it instead as one of Lafferty’s angriest early portrayals of societal decline, a theme always central to his work. It belongs to the period when his irritations were those found in the unpublished novel Civil Blood. In its pages, Professor Maurice Chapelle, the father of the novel’s Juliet character, puts it unvarnishedly in a public lecture:
“Now then, are you possibly wondering what in the blazes I am talking about? No, you are not. Even the dullest among you, and believe me you are dull, know exactly what I am talking about. I am talking about you. I am talking about the mask, foisted sometimes as Contemporary American Culture, of a certain contrived beauty and synthetic poetry, bloodshot with obscenity and corruption; and the face it covers, the face of him who fell like lightning, the liar and the father of lies, the old stony face that is older than the world. You know what I am talking about but you will not admit that you know it. You are the new Pharisees hungry for the blood of a prophet.”⁵
The main character in “The Man with the Aura” is interested in power, money, and himself. Unsurprisingly, the story turns on social appearance and reality, self-deceit, and failure of collective will. It is bookended by two snapshots of American society. It opens with dialogue, then points to a grand scale, moves back in to focus on Tom Shanty, or Thomas Castlereagh, and then widens out again.
It ends with Lafferty co-opting the reader’s perspective, one of his fourth-wall breaks, to introduce a bewildered “we.”⁶ This “we” speaks for us, a culpable public that fails to recognize moral wrongdoing or assign responsibility for it. The result is an accountability problem disguised as a locked-room mystery, with the obvious perpetrators being those who wield power and control narratives and those of us who inexplicably seem mesmerized into letting them do so. Much that would later become more interesting in Lafferty is already present in this early short story.
At the center is the schizo-gashed Tom Shanty/Thomas Castlereagh, a man celebrated throughout America as the pinnacle of respectability and integrity. One night, he hosts his dejected friend James Madigan, the Secretary of Crime Prevention, for an evening of brandy and conversation. While this might look like a kind gesture to boost a friend’s spirits, it is selfish. Madigan explains that the country has gone to hell. Crime is up. Moral fibre is gone. His office has withheld the revised crime index for the last six months. He doubts they will publish it again.⁷ Everything in the story, I think, should be read against Madigan’s attempt to manage this data.
During the visit, Madigan’s worries quickly move to the background. This will be about Thomas. Thomas starts talking about himself, and Madigan mistakes it for an attempt to cheer him up. America celebrates Thomas as all that is good about the country, and Thomas begins confessing that his “Face of America” is a total fabrication, and the more Thomas tells Madigan, the more Madigan refuses to take him seriously.
Thomas reveals that he is really Tom Shanty, a former “fox-faced sneak” and unsuccessful petty criminal. He says his success in the country is due to his invention of an “aura machine,” a series of electronic components surgically implanted in his head and throat. This device projects magnetic and electrical fields that cause others to perceive him as a man of charisma and rectitude, regardless of his real actions or appearance.⁸
“A duck-call is a simple device, and a duck is a complex one. Yet a duck will be fooled by a duck-call sounded by a man. A duck will even come to the artificial call in preference to the real, if the artificial is made with sufficient care. . . . “It didn’t take much: a subcutaneous device which I inserted myself; a selenium plate set into my head by a quack butcher; an apparatus embedded in my throat to give my voice what I wanted; a power pack; a harmonic booster.”⁹
It turns out that Thomas’s doctor, who has discovered the truth, has threatened to kill him. It doesn't help that Thomas has been carrying on with the doctor’s wife. Thomas gives his life history, one full of unpunished atrocities performed under the protection of this machine. It includes the murder of two previous wives for financial gain and the staging of massive, profitable arson frauds. He stood on public trial for nationwide fraud, where he was acquitted after turning the device to full power. His acquittal led the Chief Justice to embrace him in tears. ¹⁰
Throughout the confession, Madigan is simply unable to see that Thomas is a truly evil man. He interprets every admission of murder and theft as a display of piquant humor and deep drollery. He is under the irresistible influence of the aura machine. Of course, Thomas could turn down the machine while he tells Madigan his life story, but he doesn’t: he apparently keeps it on as he moves through the entire thing, knowing how he plans to end the evening:
“Dying, I tell you. Dammit, man, can’t you get it through your head that you’re dying before you die? I want you to believe me! It’s less fun when you don’t believe me. James, I kill you! Act like a man being killed!” “You are such a wonderful man, Castlereagh. If I am somehow called away, and it seems that I am, I’ll miss you woefully.” “Believe me that I kill you, Madigan! It’s no fun if you don’t believe.”¹¹
Madigan dead, Thomas resolves to kill Dr. Forester. We next see Thomas in the public account, holding the weapon that killed the doctor. The story ends with the public regarding the two high-profile murders as a baffling mystery and a personal tragedy for Thomas Castlereagh. One commentator, Lafferty says, “encapsuled the feelings of all of us”:
“The sympathy of the nation and the whole world goes out to Thomas Castlereagh. So great and good a man, and he has suffered such sorrows in the past! And now to be deprived of his two closest friends in a single night! The heart groans.”¹²
When Lafferty wrote the story, his critique of society was not yet aimed at the corruption of youth culture, which would preoccupy him later in the decade and through the early 1970s. It was aimed instead at what he saw as betrayals during his own youth and young adulthood. He wrote the story during the early Kennedy administration. I see JFK as another figure with an aura.
But he traced the deeper source of social decline further back, to FDR, another man with an aura.¹³
For much of his early life, Lafferty remained at least nominally a Democrat, as he once joked, out of sympathy for his father, who was one, while his siblings all became Republicans. After the war, he said, he, too, became a Republican, disappointed above all by Yalta and especially Potsdam. He believed that those compromises set the stage for the Cold War.¹⁴ Americans were sold on them through relentless ideological messaging. I take this to be the immediate background of the story: an America that, as Lafferty saw it in the early 1960s, had already lost its national narrative.
I don’t like the mesmeric theory of media in “The Man with the Aura,” but it is shorthand for what I take to be a Cold War paranoia about the enemy within. I like it as a time-stamped allegory of political disillusionment. In the final scenes, we discover that the locked room is the public’s mind. All evidence is powerless against the aura. Lafferty’s shift to a collective “we,” observing Thomas Castlereagh’s “august hands,”¹⁵ gives us a society conditioned to prefer the Face of America to the exposed fox-faced sneak. Sixty years later, America itself seems to me long, long gone, its civil religion as poisoned as James Madigan.
One question has bothered me about the story since I first read it. Why can Doctor Forester see through the aura? Is it because he sees the rash? Is his name a pun on seeing the forest for the trees? Is it because Forester just is somehow uniquely capable of thinking, or uniquely wronged by the cheating wife? Forester has studied emanations himself. That helps explain how he recognized the device.¹⁶ But Madigan, too, hears what the machine does. So why does the hypnosis field fail to entrap Doctor Forester?



Bibliographical Note
Lafferty finished “The Man with the Aura” on May 10, 1961. His work card records a rewrite on January 3, 1965, and a revision sent to Damon Knight on February 4, 1967. He sent the story to Virginia Kidd on April 20, 1968. An entry dated September 25, 1971, names Gerry Page and Witchcraft & Sorcery, no. 10.¹⁹
First published in Witchcraft & Sorcery, no. 10 (1974), 25–28.²⁰
Notes
1. Niccolò Machiavelli, The Prince, trans. Luigi Ricci (Oxford University Press, 1921), chap. 18, 71. Back to text
2. R. A. Lafferty, “The Man with the Aura,” Witchcraft & Sorcery, no. 10 (1974): 25. Back to text
3. R. A. Lafferty, work card for “The Man with the Aura,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. For the Watergate arrests on June 17, 1972, see National Archives, “Watergate: A Chronology,” June 17 entry. Back to text
4. Andrew Ferguson, “78. Tom O’Shanty’s Aura,” Continued on Next Rock, November 16, 2013. Back to text
5. R. A. Lafferty, Civil Blood, typescript, chap. 1, 12–13, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text
6. Lafferty, “The Man with the Aura,” 28. Back to text
7. 25. Back to text
8. 25–28. Castlereagh identifies himself as Tom Shanty on p. 26. His account of the machine begins on p. 27. Back to text
9. 28. Back to text
10. 26–27. Back to text
11. 28. Back to text
12. 28. Back to text
13. R. A. Lafferty to Sheryl Smith, September 24, 1973, 1, copy in my research files. Lafferty calls Roosevelt “the first nauseous breath of the post-rational era.” Back to text
14. The source of the family recollection and the remarks on Yalta and Potsdam is untraced. In 1975 Lafferty described himself as “a political Independent, a personal Conservative.” R. A. Lafferty, “Oklahoma Authors: R. A. Lafferty,” Oklahoma Librarian 25, no. 4 (October 1975): 4. Back to text
15. Lafferty, “The Man with the Aura,” 28. Back to text
16. 27. Castlereagh tells Madigan about Forester’s earlier work and the rash that brought him to the doctor. Back to text
17. 25–28. The fraud trial and its thirty million investors appear on p. 27. Castlereagh’s bequest and the commentator’s sympathy appear on p. 28. Back to text
18. Lafferty, “The Man with the Aura,” 26–28. Castlereagh names seven exemplars on p. 27. For the “coals of fire,” see Prov. 25:21–22 and Rom. 12:20 (King James Version). The parallels with Mesmer, Arendt, and Kirlian photography are mine. See Franz Anton Mesmer, Mémoire sur la découverte du magnétisme animal (Didot le jeune, 1779); Hannah Arendt, Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil (Viking Press, 1963); and J. O. Pehek, H. J. Kyler, and D. L. Faust, “Image Modulation in Corona Discharge Photography,” Science 194, no. 4262 (1976): 263–70. Back to text
19. Lafferty, work card for “The Man with the Aura.” Back to text
20. Lafferty, “The Man with the Aura,” 25–28. Bob Maurus illustrated the story. Back to text
Bibliography
Arendt, Hannah. Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil. Viking Press, 1963.
Corbis. President Kennedy Gives His “Race for Space” Speech. Houston, September 12, 1962. Photograph. Getty Images, 615299944.
Ferguson, Andrew. “78. Tom O’Shanty’s Aura.” Continued on Next Rock. November 16, 2013.
Lafferty, R. A. Civil Blood. Typescript. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lafferty, R. A. Letter to Sheryl Smith, September 24, 1973. Copy in Jon Nelson’s research files.
Lafferty, R. A. “The Man with the Aura.” Witchcraft & Sorcery, no. 10 (1974): 25–28.
Lafferty, R. A. “Oklahoma Authors: R. A. Lafferty.” Oklahoma Librarian 25, no. 4 (October 1975): 4–5.
Lafferty, R. A. Work card for “The Man with the Aura.” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Machiavelli, Niccolò. The Prince. Translated by Luigi Ricci. Oxford University Press, 1921.
Mesmer, Franz Anton. Mémoire sur la découverte du magnétisme animal. Didot le jeune, 1779.
National Archives. “Watergate: A Chronology.” In “Watergate and the Constitution.”
Pehek, J. O., H. J. Kyler, and D. L. Faust. “Image Modulation in Corona Discharge Photography.” Science 194, no. 4262 (1976): 263–70.


