The Ecomonstrous
Updated: 2 days ago

He welcomed them as one of the rarest and heartiest foods ever. They entered into him. Ah, the salt and the sulphur of them would stand him well in his crux hour when it came. By eating its brains, he would always have a certain mastery over this enemy. — R. A. Lafferty, Past Master
Advanced Lafferty today. Reading The Oxford Handbook of Biblical Monsters (2025) has me thinking again about Daniel Otto Petersen’s idea of the ecomonstrous, developed in his 2020 dissertation. Lafferty fans who want to think with Lafferty should read it closely. Some time ago I wrote about the devil-hydra in Past Master. My diagram at the end of this post outlines how Petersen approaches the question of the monstrous. My disagreement concerns the moral work done by monsters in the theological and Catholic folk imagination that Lafferty uses as his seedbed.
This comes out most clearly in the diagram in Section II (“Core Nature of the Monster”), especially in Petersen’s characterization of the ecomonstrous as “uncategorisable exorbitance” with no inherent moral valence. His definition does not assign moral character in advance: a monster may be evil, but its monstrosity lies in its excess (p. 66).
I agree that this kind of figure does appear in Lafferty. It is the sublimity of Leviathan in the Book of Job. What Petersen does well is identify a dialectical moment, but something essential is lost or becomes one-sided when the conceptual limit of the term is amoral weirdness. The ecomonstrous in Lafferty does not freeze itself as a concept once it is pushed into actual narrative functions, when we ask what the monstrous is doing.
The Feral Lands offer a good example of where Petersen’s ideas are illuminating. His videos on Past Master (1968) show how strong his close reading can be. We enter the Feral Lands as an ecomonstrous space, but soon the Feral Lands are defined by verticality: their mountain peaks and watery depths evoke the primordial waters of Genesis 1:2 and the heights of Genesis 8:4. If we think of the Feral Lands as they first appear to the characters, Petersen’s notion of the ecomonstrous has real power.
When we turn to the devil-hydra, however, the concept risks reinforcing what Lafferty so often critiques as modern cultural amnesia. Most of Lafferty’s monsters invite a clear binary moral judgment. Most of his real monsters are devils, with the consequence that the ecomonstrous is rarely free of the gravity well of the ethicomonstrous. It is within that moral field that Lafferty’s creatures take shape, their forms becoming legible through theological absolutes rather than through morally neutral environmental forces.
That moral field becomes legible to Thomas More in total darkness when the Nine tell him about the back of the tapestry, the conspiracy behind Astrobe’s politics. The book has two conspiracies: the false one of Proctor, Foreman, and Kingmaker, and the real one of the Nine. Lafferty uses ecomonstrous aporia apocalyptically, as a way of recovering a renewed ethicomonstrous perception, which takes place in Chapter 10.
I also question Section V (“Implications”), particularly Devourment and Sympoiesis. Petersen reads devourment as ecological world-making, distinguishing predation from human atrocity (pp. 152–53). That emphasis does not account for the moral differences between Lafferty’s meals. Ferguson’s Bakhtinian reading of “Snuffles” similarly treats devouring as an image of destruction and renewal.
Eating is one of Lafferty’s obsessive themes, and he wrote exceptionally well about it. On the moral side, we can imagine a y-axis. It ranges from the maw of Ouden (a little higher up are the threats made by Snuffles) to the Eucharistic meal that happens just offstage after the end of Arrive at Easterwine (1971). Aurelia (1982) is a novel of homilies organized around meals.
There is also a satirical x-axis. It can be farcical, as in the Big Breakfast of Space Chantey (1968). It can be biting, as in “Oh, Those Trepidatious Eyes!” It can be an acid bath, as in “Pleasures and Palaces.” The great example of consumption as something that is not transformative and only minimally satirical is Ouden, followed by the thieving bears. Their consumption is annihilative.
Alongside the consumption of the devil-hydra’s brains in Past Master and the idea of using Thomas More as “bait,” the attacks of Ouden and the thieving bears are instances of violent spiritual warfare and domination, not ecological aporia. The dialectic has moved beyond ecomonstrous aporia.
What has happened is allegory. Lafferty’s Thomas More belongs more to the Middle Ages than to the early Renaissance. The antagonist is the Henry VIII of Lafferty’s Cobbett, Chesterton, and Belloc. Past Master is as much an assault on Protestantism as it is on utopia, the two being connected for Lafferty. But the point of allegories is that they convey ethical information. They disclose, not withdraw. It is the medieval view that nature itself is a book to be read.
When Petersen looks at nature in Lafferty, he sees a sacramental ontology rooted in biodiversity and divine plenitude connected on one side to object-oriented ontology (OOO). I agree with him about plenitude, but then he freezes nature as vibrancy-tenebrity.
I also see something sacramental, but it looks a little different to me because it does not end there. It becomes a specific literary variation of the Eucharistic doctrine of transubstantiation, grotesque counterfiguration, used as a weapon to master the enemy. It is post-aporetic. Aporia is preliminary. Revelation is final.



