"Symposium" (1965/1970)
Updated: 18 hours ago

Philosophical, unloved Lafferty this time.
“Symposium” is not reader-friendly, so it is no surprise few readers talk about it.¹ As with the demanding “Buckets Full of Brains,” Lafferty is more interested in his ideas than in charming the reader. Summary without commentary is also unhelpful here.
Here is a metaphysical story about mechanical, chattering alphabet blocks in a child’s toy box. The blocks do not know the most important fact about their story-world, that they were designed, and that their teloi are to be toys. Everything in “Symposium” branches from this ignorance. If you don’t buy into the premise, this one is going to leave you cold. Lafferty also puts his thumb on the scale in a way that would look outrageous to a Lafferty reader like the philosopher-linguist Paul Saka.² He stacks the deck, then lets the philosophical speculation of the chattering blocks begin.
Lafferty dramatizes Aquinas’s arguments for the existence of God as comedy. The five ways may have been part of his education at Cascia Hall, the Augustinian school in Tulsa.³ One flaw in “Symposium” is that the five ways won’t be a fun reading experience for most readers. This just isn’t what people want from their cotton candy Okie. It is very Chestertonian in that Chesterton is usually more fun than his fiction, and his fiction is fun because it is Chesterton.
As created beings, the alphabet blocks debate the cosmological argument from Aquinas’s quinque viae. The story itself serves as an ironic, indirect proof of a Creator’s existence, because the reader knows what the characters do not: they are toys and were made. We are not like men and women weighing Aquinas’s arguments from natural reason while reading the Summa Theologica or like undergrads reading an extract from it in an introduction to philosophy course. We are more like angelic intelligences who already know Aquinas is right because of how Lafferty has constructed the story world. We see more of the blocks than the blocks see of themselves. We can see teloi. They are toys.
I read the opening tumble alongside Aquinas’s argument from contingency.⁴
The cosmos is contingent. It did not have to exist, and it cannot create itself. There must be a Necessary Being (God) who caused it to be. “Symposium” begins with the Primordial Tumble (the Big Bang/Creation Point), whatever we want to call it. The narrator describes a world-box disgorging its contents. The blocks remember the tumble and wonder whether they have been through it before.⁵ They can, as it were, perceive the cosmic red shift.
This is the child playing with the blocks, dumping them into the play space. In Catholic terms, this suggests an analogy with creation ex nihilo. The analogy has a limit: the box already contains the blocks, whereas creation from nothing presupposes no matter. The tumble begins the game. The blocks already exist. Heidegger would not like this. It is sheer ontotheology.⁶

The argument from motion, also known as the argument from the First Mover, goes back to Aristotle. Whatever changes is brought from potentiality to actuality by something already actual. A series of movers deriving their power from one another requires a first, unmoved mover.⁷ Kant would later say that it is antinomy territory, the place where reason seeks the unconditioned, and any object of experiential knowledge must be experienced through both the senses and the concepts of understanding.
The non-Kantian might think everything needs a cause, but the first cause has no cause, and experience aporia. It is as if we are trying to see the back of our heads. When pure concepts do not have experience to process, they are like the jogger who has had his shoelaces tied to each other. For Kant, reason has carried the categories beyond the limits of possible experience.⁸ Lafferty would have none of that. He is no Kantian but a philosophical realist.
Gee (G) wants to keep the conversation inside the frame. Zed (Z) wants to keep the frame moving. His frame includes space, motion, mass, and the vivifying principle.⁹ Their motion depends on a world beyond the frame they describe. The Child, here playing the role of the Prime Mover, governs the beginning and end of their play. I read their exchange in light of the Aristotelian and Thomistic distinction between the first mover and the movers that depend on it.
The teleological argument is also known as the argument from design. This argument has some popular recognition because of how often it shows up in the embarrassing intelligent design arguments of well-meaning Protestants and because of how hard the New Atheists went after them over a decade ago. When I used to teach historical geology, I would occasionally get pushback from fundamentalists about deep time and the necessity of design.
In this version, distinct from Aquinas’s argument from things acting toward ends, the complexity of the universe implies a designer, from trilobites to nephrons in one’s kidney. Its best-known form is the watchmaker analogy published in 1802 by the Anglican William Paley (1743–1805).¹⁰ A complex mechanism cannot arise from random chance. If you found an iPhone on the beach, you would know it was designed by someone and had been either lost or abandoned.

A conflict arises between En (N) and Ex (X) over the electric motor in an appliance on the sideboard. En is our theist. En argues that a four-pole electric motor is too complex to appear in a swamp by accident. It cannot exist without a designer. Ex is our materialist, our atheist, a figure that runs from the Epicurean philosopher Lucretius to the evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins. Ex offers to try his hand at fiction and irony. Give a swamp “all the time in the world,” he says, and copper and iron just happen to fall into the shape of a motor.¹¹
Lafferty here mocks abiogenesis and materialist evolution.¹² If the reader has not fallen asleep, they know En is right. Ex and En are toy blocks discussing a manufactured appliance. Lafferty’s gambit is simple: show how ridiculous Ex sounds (“two rocks rubbing together”) and validate the teleological argument: intricate systems (life/cosmos) index a creator. There is also a rather obvious pun on being outside truth (Ex) and inside it (En).
Then there is the argument from degree, sometimes called the argument from perfection and hierarchy. We notice degrees of goodness, truth, and nobility in things. Aquinas traces these perfections to God as their highest instance and cause.¹³ This belongs to the hierarchical metaphysics of the Great Chain of Being, which is in all Lafferty and a key to understanding Past Master (1968).
Are (R) asks whether size runs in a circle. Could a creature looking through a microscope see distant galaxies? Later Thorn (Þ) says that everything has shrunk, including the measuring stick. The old dispute about recurring worlds comes to mind here, Augustine and Origen.¹⁴ This is all a little funny because the characters are confused about their place in the hierarchy. Eff says they are born “adult and intelligent,” but the reader knows they are at the bottom of the play hierarchy (toys). This reflects the Catholic view of humility: man is not the measure of all things; God is.
Thorn is the Anglo-Saxon letter that represented the consonant sounds now written th, which is why Ye Olde Shoppe should be pronounced “The Old Shop,” even if one can forgive the coyness of “shoppe.”¹⁵

For Lafferty, God is actus purus, pure actuality. Prime matter is pure potency. Created things cannot exist without God sustaining them in being.¹⁶ Lafferty is a Thomist on these points, and without such knowledge, a story like “Symposium” will not make sense, and one will not be in a position to understand how he treats characters such as Ouden.
You (U) argues about the vivifying principle. He asks whether life and matter might have been both simultaneous and identical. The blocks have little coils inside them and react to one another. Their animation gives the vivifying principle a mechanical counterpart, while also suggesting the Holy Spirit animating Adam’s clay.¹⁷

The synteleia is one of the more Christian elements in the story because it comes not from natural reason but from revelation. Catholicism is always focused on eschatology: the four final things. The universe is linear in one sense, not circular. It has a beginning (Alpha) and an end (Omega). Synteleia is the Greek term used several times in the Gospel of Matthew for the consummation of the age or the end of the world.¹⁸
And as he sat upon the mount of Olives, the disciples came unto him privately, saying, Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world?¹⁹
Pea (P) announces the synteleia: “the kid with the box.” This is a little confusing, but not overly so. For Lafferty, the end of the world is not a random heat death; it is the person’s return (Christ). In “Symposium,” the God figure (the Child) returns to gather the blocks and reject the one that does not fit. The end of play becomes an image of judgment. The child tells the blocks to jump into the box if they want to come out again tomorrow.²⁰

And that leaves us with the scandal of tradition: Thorn. The deposit of faith. Roman Catholics are quick to point out that Catholicism is a historical faith rooted in tradition. Modernity often tries to smooth over the awkward or "shaggy" parts of the past (parts like Thorn, the miracles, ancient dogmas) to make faith fit modern science.
But Lafferty is saying that Thorn (Þ) isn’t going anywhere. It’s the old letter that doesn’t fit the modern box. Thorn remembers a larger cosmos. His old crony says atoms were as big as house cats. If there is a character in the toy box that is Lafferty, it is Thorn, the traditionalist Catholic view. He won’t be modernized or smoothed down. He is the “stone of stumbling” (a biblical metaphor). The modern world rejects Thorn because he doesn’t fit the current pattern, but he remembers the ancient truths. Pea leaves our old pal Thorn out of the count. Tea remembers his name and still insists he isn’t there.²¹

This will not be a Lafferty story that many people think about much, but it is one of his quirkier theological games.









Bibliographical Note
Lafferty finished “Symposium” on April 4, 1965, and sent it to Frederik Pohl that day. He sent it to Virginia Kidd on April 20, 1968, then rewrote it and resubmitted it on November 27. The work card names The Third Foundation and records no payment and a withdrawal. It later records a $125 sale to Roger Elwood on April 12, 1973, for Omega.²³
“Symposium” first appeared in The Third Foundation, no. 95 (1970), and later in Omega, edited by Roger Elwood (Walker & Co., 1973).²⁴
Notes
1. An early exception is Bruce Gillespie, “The Original Fiction Anthologies 1973–1975,” SF Commentary, nos. 48–50 (1976): 116. Gillespie singles out “Symposium” as Lafferty’s best story of 1973. Back to text
2. Compare Paul Saka, “Monkeying Around with Fact and Fiction: Radical Epistemology and Reactionary Metaphysics in the Work of R.A. Lafferty,” Textual Practice 40, no. 11 (2026): 1705–25. Saka’s essay concerns “Been a Long, Long Time.” The comparison with “Symposium” is mine. Back to text
3. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province, 2nd rev. ed. (Burns Oates & Washbourne, 1920), I, q. 2, a. 3. For Lafferty’s schooling, see the biographical chronology, entry for 1932, and Cascia Hall’s school history. Back to text
4. Aquinas, Summa Theologica, I, q. 2, a. 3 (third way), and I, q. 46, a. 2. Aquinas distinguishes the world’s dependence on God from the question of a beginning in time. Back to text
5. R. A. Lafferty, “Symposium,” The Third Foundation, no. 95 (1970): 4. The story occupies pp. 4–9. Back to text
6. Aquinas, Summa Theologica, I, q. 45, a. 1; Martin Heidegger, “The Onto-theo-logical Constitution of Metaphysics,” in Identity and Difference, trans. Joan Stambaugh (Harper & Row, 1969), 59–61. Back to text
7. Aristotle, Metaphysica, trans. W. D. Ross, 2nd ed., vol. 8 of The Works of Aristotle Translated into English (Clarendon Press, 1928), 12.7, 1072a24–b4; Aquinas, Summa Theologica, I, q. 2, a. 3 (first way). Back to text
8. Immanuel Kant, Critique of Pure Reason, trans. and ed. Paul Guyer and Allen W. Wood (Cambridge University Press, 1998), A51/B75, A426–27/B454–55 (the world’s beginning), A452–53/B480–81 (a necessary being). Back to text
9. Lafferty, “Symposium,” 4. Back to text
10. William Paley, Natural Theology; or, Evidences of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity, Collected from the Appearances of Nature (R. Faulder, 1802), chap. 1. Compare Aquinas, Summa Theologica, I, q. 2, a. 3 (fifth way). Back to text
11. Lafferty, “Symposium,” 6–7. Back to text
12. Lafferty, “Symposium,” 7 (the two rocks). For the comparison, see Lucretius, On the Nature of Things, trans. William Ellery Leonard (E. P. Dutton, 1916), 2.1048–66, and Richard Dawkins, The Blind Watchmaker (Longman Scientific & Technical, 1986), chap. 3. Dawkins distinguishes cumulative selection from the single lucky accident Ex imagines. Back to text
13. Aquinas, Summa Theologica, I, q. 2, a. 3 (fourth way). Back to text
14. Lafferty, “Symposium,” 4, 7–8. Eff speaks at the opening, Are discusses relative size on p. 7, and Thorn recalls his crony on p. 8. Augustine, The City of God, trans. Marcus Dods, 12.13, and Origen, On First Principles, trans. Frederick Crombie, 2.3.4. Origen considers successive worlds; both writers reject the exact recurrence of the same events. Back to text
15. National Records of Scotland, “Letter Thorn.” In early printing, a letter shaped like y could stand for thorn in the definite article. Back to text
16. Aquinas, Summa Theologica, I, q. 3, a. 2 (pure act); I, q. 66, a. 1, ad 3 (prime matter); I, q. 104, a. 1 (conservation in being). Back to text
17. Lafferty, “Symposium,” 5–6, 9. In Gen. 2:7 (King James Version), God forms man from dust and breathes life into him. Compare Ps. 104:30. Back to text
18. Matt. 13:39, 40, 49; 24:3; 28:20 in Michael W. Holmes, ed., The Greek New Testament: SBL Edition (Society of Biblical Literature and Logos Bible Software, 2010). For the four last things, see United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, United States Catholic Catechism for Adults (USCCB, 2006), 161. Back to text
19. Matt. 24:3 (King James Version). Back to text
20. Lafferty, “Symposium,” 8–9. Back to text
21. Lafferty, “Symposium,” 8–9. For the biblical image, see 1 Pet. 2:7–8 (King James Version). For the deposit of faith, see Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum, November 18, 1965, §10. Back to text
22. Detail of fig. 5 in Andrew West and Michael Everson, “Proposal to Add LATIN LETTER THORN WITH DIAGONAL STROKE to the UCS,” July 23, 2017, 9. The diagonal stroke distinguishes this abbreviation from plain thorn. Back to text
23. R. A. Lafferty, work card for “Symposium,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Back to text
24. Lafferty, “Symposium,” The Third Foundation, no. 95 (1970): 4–9. The contents page lists the story under Lafferty’s name; the issue bears a 1970 copyright. For the anthology appearance, see Lafferty, “Symposium,” in Omega, ed. Roger Elwood (Walker & Co., 1973), 63–74. Back to text
Bibliography
Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologica. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. 2nd rev. ed. Burns Oates & Washbourne, 1920.
Aristotle. Metaphysica. Translated by W. D. Ross. 2nd ed. Vol. 8 of The Works of Aristotle Translated into English. Clarendon Press, 1928.
Augustine. The City of God. Translated by Marcus Dods. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st ser., vol. 2. Edited by Philip Schaff. Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1887.
Cascia Hall Preparatory School. “History.”
Cool Vintage Finds. “Build Your Antique Alphabet Block Collection.” April 23, 2018. Photograph.
Dawkins, Richard. The Blind Watchmaker. Longman Scientific & Technical, 1986.
Gillespie, Bruce. “The Original Fiction Anthologies 1973–1975.” SF Commentary, nos. 48–50 (1976): 107–38.
Heidegger, Martin. “The Onto-theo-logical Constitution of Metaphysics.” In Identity and Difference, translated by Joan Stambaugh, 42–74. Harper & Row, 1969.
Holmes, Michael W., ed. The Greek New Testament: SBL Edition. Society of Biblical Literature and Logos Bible Software, 2010.
Kant, Immanuel. Critique of Pure Reason. Translated and edited by Paul Guyer and Allen W. Wood. Cambridge University Press, 1998.
Lafferty, R. A. “Symposium.” The Third Foundation, no. 95 (1970): 4–9.
Lafferty, R. A. “Symposium.” In Omega, edited by Roger Elwood, 63–74. Walker & Co., 1973.
Lafferty, R. A. Work card for “Symposium.” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.
Lucretius. On the Nature of Things. Translated by William Ellery Leonard. E. P. Dutton, 1916.
National Records of Scotland. “Letter Thorn.”
Origen. On First Principles. Translated by Frederick Crombie. In Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4. Edited by Alexander Roberts, James Donaldson, and A. Cleveland Coxe. Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1885.
Paley, William. Natural Theology; or, Evidences of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity, Collected from the Appearances of Nature. R. Faulder, 1802.
Saka, Paul. “Monkeying Around with Fact and Fiction: Radical Epistemology and Reactionary Metaphysics in the Work of R.A. Lafferty.” Textual Practice 40, no. 11 (2026): 1705–25.
Second Vatican Council. Dei Verbum. November 18, 1965.
“Timeline.” RALafferty.org.
United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. United States Catholic Catechism for Adults. USCCB, 2006.
West, Andrew, and Michael Everson. “Proposal to Add LATIN LETTER THORN WITH DIAGONAL STROKE to the UCS.” July 23, 2017.


