top of page
Search

“Narrow Valley” (1966/1966)

Mar 27
19 min read

Updated: 2 hours ago

Rocky valley with scattered trees and shrubs beneath a clear blue sky.
A view through a rocky valley.

“I am like that hard-luck guy in the funny-paper or Job in the Bible.”¹ — Clarence Little-Saddle in R. A. Lafferty’s “Narrow Valley”

Advanced Lafferty today. The plot comes first, so that those who want only that can stop.


“Narrow Valley” has about three-quarters of a century in it. In Lafferty’s account of 1893, Clarence Big-Saddle, a Pawnee man, chooses a 160-acre valley for his allotment. The narrator says he will have to pay taxes on it.² Big-Saddle performs a makeshift spell using substituted ingredients and a word he doubts. The half-mile-wide valley appears to outsiders as a five-foot-wide ditch, under a spoken condition:


So he burned leaves and bark and made a speech:
“That my valley be always wide and flourish and green and such stuff as that!” he orated in Pawnee chant style. “But that it be narrow if an intruder come.”³

On the inside it is a lush, full-sized homestead. Clarence lives there for half a century without paying taxes. The land is sold for taxes three times, but none of the buyers can find it. The homesteaders who file on it cannot meet the residence requirement. Clarence leaves the valley to his son, Clarence Little-Saddle.⁴


Years later Robert Rampart finds the tract listed as open and files a homestead claim. He brings his wife, Nina, and their five children to occupy it. With some help, the family finds the ditch. The children and then Nina plunge into it. They shrink to match the valley’s hidden internal scale.⁵


Robert summons local authorities and three scientists. The photographs show a half-mile valley. The scientists differ over what the photographs mean. Nina drives the camper down by herself, then comes back for Robert and bundles him into it. After she takes him down, the valley is visible at its full width.⁶


This is, of course, a disaster for Little-Saddle. Distraught, he confides in one of the visiting scientists, our old friend Willy McGilly. Willy suggests giving the spell a booster shot. They throw dog-elm bark on the fire, and the far side of the valley draws closer. They add black locust leaves, and it narrows again. Only then does Clarence speak his wish. He shouts another doubtful word, and lightning answers. The Ramparts’ camper emerges with the whole family flattened like paper. It widens as they drive off. Clarence expects them all to be back to normal by the main road.⁷


“Narrow Valley” is highly regarded, and it should be. It is one of Lafferty’s best. It is funny, strange, theologically powerful, and politically pointed. Anyone who wants to understand it now will need to work through Daniel Otto Jack Petersen’s 2020 University of Glasgow dissertation on ecomonstrous poetics and weird bioregionalism in Lafferty’s fiction.⁸ My aim is mainly to clarify my own ideas about it.


Petersen reads “Narrow Valley” through a concept he originated, which he calls ecomonstrous poetics. If you look under the ecomonstrous hood, you find it is a concept cluster assembled from Monster Studies, New Materialism (NM), and Object-Oriented Ontology (OOO).⁹


My understanding of his argument about “Narrow Valley” can be put fairly plainly: I take him to make the valley itself the story’s active subject. It is a nonhuman agent that withdraws from human perception and entangles those who encounter it in its weird dimensionality. The first half of that is OOO; the second half, NM.


The reading is serious and smart. I believe it is also wrong, and the nature of its wrongness tells us something important about the limits of the Nonhuman Turn as a critical methodology when applied to fiction whose metaphysics are not, in fact, nonhuman. This won’t surprise anyone who reads this blog because the metaphysics that most illuminates Lafferty is Catholic metaphysics. It is often adventurous Catholic metaphysics, and I read it as the metaphysics he built into his fiction.


To see what Petersen is doing, one does need to know a little about contemporary debates in theory. He stakes out a contested area within contemporary ecophilosophy. The outline follows Petersen’s arguments.


New Materialism, as represented by Serenella Iovino, Serpil Oppermann, and Donna Haraway, emphasizes the agentive vitality of matter. This is to make a philosophical case that the world is not a passive backdrop to human action but a storied field of more-than-human relations.¹⁰ Petersen turns to Haraway’s Chthulucene for a world in which humans and nonhumans make their lives together. Haraway calls that making-with sympoiesis.¹¹


Object-Oriented Ontology, on the other hand, particularly in Graham Harman’s formulation, states that objects are never fully present to any relation; they are always withholding an interior that exceeds any encounter.¹² Timothy Morton’s “strange strangers,” entities simultaneously intimate and uncanny,¹³ are, to my mind, OOO’s most suggestive figure for the nonhuman.


Those are the pieces.


Petersen notes that these two theories are generally understood as opposed. The opposition is between entanglement and withdrawal, or between a flat relational ontology and object autonomy. Petersen’s primary theoretical claim is that Lafferty’s fiction somehow squares the circle here. It holds the withdrawal and the entanglement together.¹⁴ More specifically, “Narrow Valley” demonstrates how Lafferty does this with greater clarity than perhaps other Lafferty works.


The valley draws people in and diminishes them. As Lafferty’s narrator puts it, “it ate them alive.”¹⁵ For Petersen, this entanglement coexists with withdrawal. The half-mile interior is hidden from people standing at the rim. The narrow valley in the story’s title is an instance of a nonhuman being that is monstrously present and monstrously opaque:


‘Narrow Valley’ is thus ecomonstrous both in its inscription of the exorbitant weirdness of a nonhuman (the valley) and its violently metaphored entanglement of others (human and nonhuman) into this singular weirdness.¹⁶

As I read him, this makes the valley the story’s protagonist, not just its novum.


From this, there follow further arguments. The first is political, turning on the valley’s action against Robert Rampart. Rampart is flattened to one dimension. He fails to hold the land. Petersen reads this as the story’s critique of settler-colonial modes.¹⁷ Robert calls on the Land Office, local authorities, scientists, and newsmen, the full apparatus of colonial possession, and it doesn’t work for him. He hesitates at the rim. I would put the point this way. The valley shows him to be cardboard because he was already, in some ontological sense, flat. Petersen reads this lack of dimensionality as an indictment of colonial entitlement:


Settler culture lacks the dimensions (monstrous inner depth and monstrous outer enmeshment) that McCarthy’s Delawares displayed above in the face of ursine and topographical devourment. Without such full dimensionality, it is impossible to sustainably dwell in the land’s shining yet withdrawing fullness.¹⁸

This makes sense, and Lafferty drives this thematic conclusion home in Willy and Clarence’s exchange as the Ramparts drive away:


“Did we overdo it, Clarence?” Willy McGilly asked. “What did one flat-lander say to the other?”
“Dimension of us never got around,” Clarence said. “No, I don’t think we overdid it, Willy. That car must be eighteen inches wide already, and they all ought to be normal by the time they reach the main road.”¹⁹

The second argument concerns the phenomenology of appropriate response to the ecomonstrous. This is an ethical argument. Petersen uses the idea of adduction, a leap of co-participation in the monster’s logic, to argue for a form of normativity that is neither simple cognitive recognition nor passive submission. It is more like an embodied willingness to enter the situation on its own terms. Petersen takes Nina Rampart’s leap as an example.²⁰ She does not explain or wait on the rim like her husband; instead, she yields to the environment:


Robert Rampart was roaring his alarm, and his wife Nina was screaming. Then she stopped. “What am I carrying on so loud about?” she asked herself. “It looks like fun. I’ll do it too.”
She plunged into the gully, diminished in size as the children had done, and ran at a pace to carry her a hundred yards away across a gully only five feet wide.²¹

Petersen contrasts her reaction with her husband’s to illustrate the theoretical ideal of adduction:


Hence, a leap of adduction is her response to the valley’s monstration. . . . Robert Rampart, on the other hand, declines enmeshment and instead complains to the authorities that a ‘ditch had stolen his wife and five children’ and ‘maybe had killed them’ (190). He sees only one aspect of the valley’s monstrosity, but note how even in this he is forced to ascribe agency to the inhuman.²²

The Rampart children are also little, if flawed, adducters. They run in before anyone can stop them. Robert does not adduct. He explains, talks, demands, waits on the rim.


Petersen discusses Little-Saddle’s argument with the children about the war bonnet and the Iron Crown. He connects the valley to resistance to allotment, credits Clarence and Willy with restoring the magic, and later develops a Catholic sacramental ontology.²³ My disagreement is over which act explains the narrow valley. I give Big-Saddle’s choice to conceal it more weight than Petersen does.


Petersen sets up the story’s conflict by focusing on the terrain:


When the settler family, the Ramparts, come to the land allotment they have filed on . . . it appears to be a mere ditch or gulley. . . . Knowing the trickster nature of the land, the neighbour suggests the Rampart kids throw rocks across the apparent ditch, which they happily do.²⁴

One problem with thinking of the narrow valley as a metaphysical protagonist and attributing a “trickster nature” to the land is the spell.


The valley is narrow because Clarence Big-Saddle made it narrow, which is to say that the narrow valley is not a person, and Lafferty’s metaphysics, on my view, is largely a metaphysics of personhood. Clarence, acting as a person, burned leaves and bark. He spoke in Pawnee chant style. He used the wrong ingredients, saying a word he wasn’t certain about, and lightning answered. His son Clarence Little-Saddle inherited the narrowness along with the land, maintained it for many years without apparent effort, and, with Willy McGilly’s assistance, restored it when the Ramparts briefly broke through.²⁵


For that reason, I do not think the valley is an independent agent expressing its own weird ontology. It is an instrument of persons in the story, responding to address, being instrumentalized within a relationship that was built, inherited, and kept up.


Is this a peripheral feature of the story? I think it is the story’s basic causal structure. For me, the difficulty with making the valley the active subject is accounting for Big-Saddle’s decision to narrow it in the first place.


Consider what the spell is in “Narrow Valley.” It is botched from the start: wrong bark, wrong leaves, wrong word, spoken with deliberate confidence that Clarence Big-Saddle doubts:


He didn’t have any balsam bark to burn. He threw on a little cedar bark instead. He didn’t have any elder leaves. He used a handful of jack-oak leaves. And he forgot the word. How you going to work it if you forget the word?
“Petahauerat!” he howled out with the confidence he hoped would fool the fates.
“That’s the same long of a word,” he said in a low aside to himself. But he was doubtful. “What am I, a White Man, a burr-tailed jack, a new kind of nut to think it will work?” he asked.²⁶

The booster at the end is botched, too. The valley starts to narrow while the bark and leaves are burning, before Clarence says a word. Both rites work.²⁷ What the story shows here is that the personal nature of the world answers the person who acts seriously on insufficient grounds, who commits to the address in full acknowledgment of its inadequacy and acts anyway. It is not quite sacramental theology in any orthodox sense, because it plays with myth. But it does suggest an analogy with sacramental signs and intention, though in Catholic teaching the sacraments derive their efficacy from Christ.²⁸ It imagines a universe that recognizes audacious good faith.


Before pressing the ideological implications of this, consider an obvious objection. Petersen could reply that his framework doesn’t downplay Clarence; it expands the category of agent to include nonhumans, which is a more generous ontology, not a less generous one. The decentering of the human subject is politically progressive precisely because it makes room for a wider range of agency. The problem, from my perspective, is that the metaphysics Petersen argues for does not extend the notion of person but does what New Materialism and OOO usually do: it looks to the radically non-personal, the non-human, as something that deconstructs the person.

One can see why this is appealing when reading “Narrow Valley.” The story’s political logic requires expanding the category of agent laterally, to persons whose agency has been historically denied and legally abused, specifically, Indigenous persons whose relationship to land was treated as ontologically invisible by the settler-colonial state. The Nonhuman Turn expands downward instead: to matter, to objects, to landscape. By combining these moves, we fill the available interpretive space with the valley’s nonhuman vitality and leave Clarence at the margins of his own story. Yet somehow we have made room for more agents but left less room for the specific agent the story is about, Clarence Little-Saddle.


The myth held that the American West was unoccupied, available, ontologically inert until settlers arrived to make it mean something. Petersen’s model does something genuinely different: it doesn’t make the land empty. But it makes it so agentively full of its own nonhuman vitality that the Pawnee person who has a claim to it becomes its occasion. The land was always already weird and withdrawn and entangling; Clarence just happened to be the person there.


That contrasts with Catholic metaphysics, where the world was made for persons.²⁹ Of course, this view will seem hopelessly naïve, humanistically centered, and Anthropocene to many readers. I just happen to think it was Lafferty’s view and that it makes the story most intelligible.


I want to test Petersen’s account against two features of the story. First, Petersen treats the valley’s spatial illusions as evidence for OOO withdrawal, where a nonhuman object fundamentally conceals its true dimensions:


In the wry ecomonstrous poetics of this weird scenario, a ‘resistant landscape’ (Buell 1995: 61) hides in plain sight, withdrawing from human occupancy, perception, and comprehension.³⁰

The photographs do register the full valley, according to the narrator.³¹ But the scientists disagree about what this means: the eminent scientist Arpad Arkabaranan contradicts Vonk about the cameras and the human eye:


“Of course it is meteorological! Everything including dreams is meteorological. It is the animals and cameras which are fooled, as lacking a true dimension; it is only humans who see the true duality.”³²

Harman’s withdrawal concerns what no relation exhausts, not simply what cameras or humans can see. Withdrawal is a universal ontological condition prior to any act of perception.³³ More importantly, the scientists’ competing explanations are really just comic performances of systematic incomprehension, confidence, and mutual exclusivity. Vonk explains the valley and relaxes. Arkabaranan explains the valley and relaxes. The joke is that the explanations contradict each other. For that reason, I do not think the camera detail by itself establishes OOO withdrawal; it is part of what I take to be the satire, one that parallels the story’s satire of land offices, sheriffs, and National Guard colonels.


The second concerns the withdrawal argument directly. In OOO, withdrawal is universal and constitutive; every object withdraws from every relation, all the time, as a condition of its being an object at all. The valley’s narrowness is none of these things. It is particular, contingent, reversible, and person-caused. It does not narrow for Clarence, because the spell was designed to narrow for intruders. Applying OOO withdrawal to a deliberately engineered magical concealment is a misfit between what Harman describes and what Lafferty depicts. The valley is not withholding itself from Robert Rampart. The valley doesn’t withdraw itself. The two Clarences withdraw it.


The entanglement argument fares better but fails at another point, I think. NM emphasizes how relations help constitute beings. In the final scene Clarence expects the Ramparts to “be normal by the time they reach the main road.”³⁴ The valley has temporarily deformed them and is expected to restore their ordinary physical dimensions, and the comedy of this is not a peripheral detail. What happens to the Ramparts is more like eviction than sympoiesis.


Again, the valley is narrow because Clarence Big-Saddle chose to make it so. He did that in response to a human injustice brought about by other persons, the allotment regime. In the story, this leaves each Pawnee with 160 acres and a tax bill.³⁵ The 1892 Pawnee agreement allowed adults to select their allotments. Henry E. Roberts, a Skidi chief, remembered allotments of 80, 120, and 160 acres.³⁶ Land held in federal trust was exempt from local property tax, and the 1893 opening excluded allotted lands.³⁷ The Big-Saddle spell is a tactic: make the land appear valueless to outsiders while remaining habitable for those who belong there. The spell is passed down as part of the inheritance, held through Clarence Little-Saddle’s continued habitation, and is restored when threatened. This is a story about human custodianship, the living, inherited, personal relationship to a particular place that constitutes genuine dwelling rather than legal possession.


This makes the contrast with Robert Rampart political rather than ontological. Robert gets the satirical treatment not because he lacks the right attitude toward nonhuman agents, but because he comes as a bureaucracy-parsing, rules-exploiting claimant rather than an inhabitant, and he tries to steamroll an inhabitant. He files his claim before he has ever seen the land.³⁸ He deploys all the instruments of the colonial apparatus (law, government, science, media) to stake a claim that has no relational basis. If the valley rejects him, it is because Clarence made it reject intruders, and Robert is an intruder. The fundamental relationship in the story is between persons.


Willy McGilly is an interesting test case. The story gives him no hereditary claim to the valley. Yet he participates in the booster shot, and it works. Why? Not because Willy has achieved some form of sympoietic entanglement with the valley as a nonhuman agent. Willy proposes the booster shot, and Clarence joins him in performing it with what they have at hand. Willy remembers a different recipe from childhood.³⁹ This, again, is a relation between persons.


And it is significant precisely because “Narrow Valley” gives the reader a universe of responsive persons and addressable places, one in which even a doubtful word, spoken by someone who means what he asks, is answered by lightning. This is closer to the universe of Lafferty’s Catholicism, in which Christ acts through sacramental signs celebrated with the intention of the Church.⁴⁰ Catholics believe the cosmos is created and sustained by a personal God, and so, I think, did Lafferty.


To put it in a nutshell, I think the story’s causal chain is driven not by OOO withdrawal or NM entanglement, which would be grounded in the object’s own ontological nature, but by the spell Lafferty gives Clarence Big-Saddle. The magic produces something that exists, not in cognitively ungraspable dimensions rooted in its metaphysical nature, but at two scales, or two “dimensions.”


It is as if there were an injective function. We have a “wide valley” expression of an ontological object and a “narrow valley” expression of that selfsame object. The two expressions stand in a fixed relation to each other, being somehow the same valley at different scales. That fits with neither OOO nor NM, because it is too knowably present for the former and too discretely determinate and identarian for the latter.


Petersen’s is the most theoretically ambitious reading of Lafferty in the critical literature, and his instinct that “Narrow Valley” does something that standard readings cannot account for is right. We differ over what that something is. I read Lafferty as writing from within a tradition that holds Divine Personhood to be the ground of creation, with other persons as its images. For me, “Narrow Valley” is a story about what persons can do to land and to one another, and about what I have called audacious good faith.


The valley would not have agency if it were presented the way T. S. Eliot presents the yellow smoke that rubs its muzzle on the window-panes and licks its tongue into the corners of the evening.⁴¹ That is a great metaphor, but it doesn’t tell one anything about the agency of yellow smoke.


In short, I do not think the valley has agency, nor do I see evidence of such agency in the story. The Nonhuman Turn, by leveling the ontological hierarchy between persons and objects, strips out the ontological verticality that the Incarnation, the sacraments, and the entire Catholic drama of salvation require for even minimal coherence. So, in the end, it is the wrong tool for understanding a writer who believed that the universe was made for persons. Given the conversations that Petersen and I have had, my views won’t surprise him in the slightest.


Character network connecting the Pawnee family, the Ramparts, their neighbors and the three visiting investigators.
The two Clarences, the Ramparts, their neighbors, and the visiting investigators.⁴²
Long vertical plot timeline of “Narrow Valley.”
The events of “Narrow Valley” in the 1982 Ace printing.⁴³
Source notes on Pawnee allotment, homesteading, Pawnee names and ceremonial plant references in “Narrow Valley.”
Pawnee allotment, names, and the materials of the two spells.⁴⁴
Reference notes on Audifax, nighthawks, regalia, the Iron Crown and Oklahoma geography.
Audifax, the nighthawk, the war bonnet, and the Iron Crown.⁴⁵
Notes linking the story with the camel and needle, optical illusions, the noosphere, Charles Fort and Boudicca.
The camel and the needle, the noosphere, and the scientists’ explanations.⁴⁶
Reference notes on Job, Corsicana, Flatland and household idioms in “Narrow Valley.”
Job, Corsicana, and the flat-lander joke.⁴⁷
Unresolved-source notes concerning the reported marvels, comic-strip figure, televised president and scientists’ names.
Names and marvels whose sources are uncertain.⁴⁸
Notes on a possible narrow-gate allusion, Cecilia’s French and a numerical discrepancy in the valley’s dimensions.
Possible allusions and the dimensions reported in the story.⁴⁹
Rebus placing the word VALLEY inside a narrow gap between two blocks of earth.
“Narrow Valley” as a rebus.
Table comparing Vonk’s, Arkabaranan’s and McGilly’s explanations of the valley.
Vonk, Arkabaranan, and McGilly on the valley.⁵⁰
Diagram of Petersen’s account of withdrawal, Nina’s response, and Clarence’s resistance to settlement, with my objection about who conceals the valley.
Petersen’s account of the valley and my reading of its implications.⁵¹
Glossary of 37 legal, Pawnee, literary, and geographical references in “Narrow Valley,” with sources.
A glossary of the story’s names and allusions.⁵²



Bibliographical Note


Lafferty completed “Narrow Valley” on March 6, 1966, and sent it to Frederik Pohl. Pohl returned it on March 28. Lafferty revised the story in early April and sent it to The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction on April 3. The work card records its acceptance for $100 on May 31.⁵³


“Narrow Valley” first appeared in the September 1966 issue of The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction.⁵⁴ Ace collected it in Nine Hundred Grandmothers in 1970. The quotations here follow the January 1982 Ace printing.⁵⁵


Notes


1. R. A. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” in Nine Hundred Grandmothers (Ace Books, January 1982), 210. Back to text


2. 196. Back to text


3. 196. Back to text


4. 197. Back to text


5. 197–202. Back to text


6. 202–3, 206–10. Back to text


7. 208–11. Back to text


8. Daniel Otto Jack Petersen, “‘You Are the Old Entrapped Dreams of the Coyote’s Brains Oozing Liquid Through the Broken Eye Socket’: Ecomonstrous Poetics and Weird Bioregionalism in the Fiction of R. A. Lafferty (with a Comparative Reading of Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian)” (PhD diss., University of Glasgow, 2020), 41–42, 89–90, 150–51. Back to text


9. 22–26, 96–106. Back to text


10. Serenella Iovino and Serpil Oppermann, “Introduction: Stories Come to Matter,” in Material Ecocriticism, ed. Iovino and Oppermann (Indiana University Press, 2014), 1–2. Back to text


11. Donna J. Haraway, Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene (Duke University Press, 2016), 2, 58. See also Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 101–4. Back to text


12. Graham Harman, Towards Speculative Realism: Essays and Lectures (Zero Books, 2010), 54, quoted in Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 105. Back to text


13. Timothy Morton, “Here Comes Everything: The Promise of Object-Oriented Ontology,” Qui Parle 19, no. 2 (2011): 165–66. See also Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 113–14. Back to text


14. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 104–6, 118–21. Back to text


15. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 202. Back to text


16. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 150. Back to text


17. 150–51. Back to text


18. 151. Back to text


19. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 211. Back to text


20. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 80–82, 150. Back to text


21. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 202. Back to text


22. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 150. Back to text


23. 41–42, 90n105, 150n185, 151, 211–15. Back to text


24. 89. Back to text


25. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 196–97, 209–11. Back to text


26. 196. Back to text


27. 196–97, 210–11. Back to text


28. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2000), pars. 1127–28, 1131. Back to text


29. pars. 293–94, 356–58. Back to text


30. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 89–90, quoting Lawrence Buell, The Environmental Imagination: Thoreau, Nature Writing, and the Formation of American Culture (Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1995), 61. Back to text


31. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 203. Back to text


32. 208. Back to text


33. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 104–6. Back to text


34. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 211. Back to text


35. 196–97. Back to text


36. Agreement with the Pawnee, November 23, 1892, art. II, ratified by Act of March 3, 1893, ch. 209, § 12, 27 Stat. 612, 644–45. Henry E. Roberts, “The Pawnee Tribe of Oklahoma,” September 6, 1971, in Oklahoma’s Indian People: Images of Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow, ed. Anita Chisholm (Oklahoma State Department of Education, 1983), 182. Back to text


37. General Allotment Act, ch. 119, § 5, 24 Stat. 388, 389 (1887). For a Pawnee trust patent and its tax status, see United States v. Board of County Commissioners of Pawnee County, 13 F. Supp. 641, 641–42 (N.D. Okla. 1936). Grover Cleveland, proclamation of August 19, 1893, 28 Stat. 1222, 1225–27. Back to text


38. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 198–99. Back to text


39. 208–11. Back to text


40. Catechism of the Catholic Church, pars. 1127–28. Back to text


41. T. S. Eliot, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock,” Poetry 6, no. 3 (June 1915): 130, lines 15–17. Back to text


42. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 196–211. Back to text


43. 196–211. Back to text


44. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 196–98, 208–11. For the terms of allotment, see the Agreement with the Pawnee, art. II. The commissioner of Indian affairs recorded 821 Pawnee trust patents in his Annual Report for 1894 (Government Printing Office, 1895), 20. For the names of the four bands, see Pawnee Nation of Oklahoma, Constitution of the Pawnee Nation of Oklahoma, revised June 14, 2008, preamble. Back to text


45. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 198–205. On the significance of the feathered headdress, see Leo Killsback, “Crowns of Honor: Sacred Laws of Eagle-Feather War Bonnets and Repatriating the Icon of the Great Plains,” Great Plains Quarterly 33, no. 1 (2013): 1–23. Back to text


46. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 205–9. For the camel and the eye of a needle, see Matthew 19:24 (King James Version). The comparison with Charles Fort concerns his method of collecting reports of strange events. See The Book of the Damned (Boni & Liveright, 1919), chap. 1. Back to text


47. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 210–11. For Job’s losses, see Job 1:13–22 and 2:7–10. Compare Edwin A. Abbott, Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions (Seeley, 1884), parts 1–2, especially §§ 1, 16–18. The 1936 José Antonio Navarro monument in Corsicana identifies Corsica as his father’s birthplace. Back to text


48. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 198–99, 203, 207–10. Back to text


49. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 196, 198–99, 207, 210. Compare Matthew 7:13–14 for the possible narrow-gate allusion. In the 1966 magazine, the estimate of 180 moons appears both times (85, 87). The Ace printing gives 180 in the scientist’s explanation and 108 when the narrator returns to the image. Back to text


50. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 207–9. Back to text


51. Petersen, “Ecomonstrous Poetics,” 41–42, 89–90, 150–51. Back to text


52. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” 196–211. The 821 allottees are recorded in the Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs for the Year 1908 (Government Printing Office, 1908), 158, Oklahoma table, Pawnee entry. Back to text


53. R. A. Lafferty, work card for “Narrow Valley,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, series 2, box 25, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. The revised carbon and reprint permissions are in series 2, box 18, folder 6. Back to text


54. R. A. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction 31, no. 3 (September 1966): 77–88. Back to text


55. Lafferty, “Narrow Valley,” in Nine Hundred Grandmothers (Ace Books, 1970), 196–211. The January 1982 printing has the same pagination. Back to text


Bibliography


Abbott, Edwin A. Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions. Seeley, 1884.


The Bible: Authorized King James Version with Apocrypha. Edited by Robert Carroll and Stephen Prickett. Oxford University Press, 1997.


Catholic Church. Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2000.


Cleveland, Grover. “Opening Cherokee Outlet to Settlement.” Proclamation of August 19, 1893. 28 Stat. 1222–39.


Eliot, T. S. “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock.” Poetry 6, no. 3 (June 1915): 130–35.


Fort, Charles. The Book of the Damned. Boni & Liveright, 1919.


Haraway, Donna J. Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Duke University Press, 2016.


Iovino, Serenella, and Serpil Oppermann. “Introduction: Stories Come to Matter.” In Material Ecocriticism, edited by Serenella Iovino and Serpil Oppermann. Indiana University Press, 2014.


Killsback, Leo. “Crowns of Honor: Sacred Laws of Eagle-Feather War Bonnets and Repatriating the Icon of the Great Plains.” Great Plains Quarterly 33, no. 1 (2013): 1–23.


Lafferty, R. A. “Narrow Valley.” The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction 31, no. 3 (September 1966): 77–88.


Lafferty, R. A. “Narrow Valley.” In Nine Hundred Grandmothers, 196–211. Ace Books, 1970. January 1982 printing.


Lafferty, R. A. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002. Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Morton, Timothy. “Here Comes Everything: The Promise of Object-Oriented Ontology.” Qui Parle 19, no. 2 (2011): 163–90.


Pawnee Nation of Oklahoma. Constitution of the Pawnee Nation of Oklahoma. Revised June 14, 2008.


Petersen, Daniel Otto Jack. “‘You Are the Old Entrapped Dreams of the Coyote’s Brains Oozing Liquid Through the Broken Eye Socket’: Ecomonstrous Poetics and Weird Bioregionalism in the Fiction of R. A. Lafferty (with a Comparative Reading of Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian).” PhD diss., University of Glasgow, 2020. University of Glasgow.


Roberts, Henry E. “The Pawnee Tribe of Oklahoma.” 1971. In Oklahoma’s Indian People: Images of Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow, edited by Anita Chisholm, 182–83. Oklahoma State Department of Education, 1983.


Texas. José Antonio Navarro monument. Navarro County Courthouse, Corsicana. 1936. Texas Historical Commission, marker 7237.


United States. Act of March 3, 1893, ch. 209, §§ 12–13, 27 Stat. 612, 644–45.


United States. General Allotment Act. February 8, 1887, ch. 119, 24 Stat. 388–91.


United States. Office of Indian Affairs. Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, 1894. Government Printing Office, 1895.


United States. Office of Indian Affairs. Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs for the Year 1908. Government Printing Office, 1908.


United States v. Board of County Commissioners of Pawnee County. 13 F. Supp. 641 (N.D. Okla. 1936).

bottom of page