Martin Heidegger and Past Master
Updated: 3 days ago

Over the Christmas break, I have been considering teaching Past Master next summer and posting the lecture recordings. I would probably begin with Heideggerian categories and work backward, letting the novel’s Thomistic and other Christian elements come into clearer focus by contrast. I would also likely assign Paul Kingsnorth’s recent Against the Machine: On the Unmaking of Humanity as a supplementary text, given how directly it speaks to the questions Past Master raises for a contemporary audience.
Past Master takes up questions that can be compared with Heidegger’s later thinking about Being and Gestell. Gestell, usually translated as “enframing,” names a way of revealing in which things appear as standing-reserve (Bestand), available for ordering and use. The comparison helps ask what Astrobe’s Dream permits its citizens to see, and what it conceals.
Heidegger’s vocabulary would be a shared set of terms for class discussion, allowing the novel’s problems to be examined without asking students to begin from the theological commitments within which Lafferty himself is thinking.
The Nine and Astrobe’s cities invite a reading through Gestell: people become available for inspection, adjustment, and disposal. Heidegger describes the danger that human beings may understand themselves chiefly as resources. He also insists that, because humans participate in revealing, they are never merely standing-reserve. That qualification matters to a novel in which even the Programmed can surprise us.
Heidegger’s lectures on Nietzsche place will to power within the completion of Western metaphysics.
The end of Past Master leaves open the possibility of another way of revealing and presencing (Anwesen) beyond Gestell, beyond late modernity, which in Lafferty takes the form of Christian eschatological hope:
The spirit came down once on water and clay. Could it not come down on gell-cells and flux-fix? The sterile wood, whether of human or programmed tree, shall it fruit after all? The Avid Nothingness, the diabolically empty Point-Big-0, is it cast away again? Is there then room for life? Shall there be return to real life?
In "The Question Concerning Technology" (1954), Heidegger writes about this problem outside Christian eschatology but with hope:
But where danger is, grows / The saving power also. Let us think carefully about these words of Hölderlin. What does it mean ‘to save’? . . . ‘To save’ is to fetch something home into its essence, in order to bring the essence for the first time into its genuine appearing.
Heidegger’s involvement with National Socialism cannot be set aside when reading his later account of technological ordering. Lafferty writes after the war, with work camps among his images of administered humanity. I have discussed this in relation to “Groaning Hinges of the World” and the totalitarian order concealed by Astrobe’s Dream.
The guide below uses Heidegger’s terms to ask questions of Past Master.


