Lafferty and the Sliding Scale of Allegory
Updated: 4 days ago

Northrop Frye’s idea that allegory is a sliding scale helps in reading Lafferty. Angus Fletcher acknowledges Frye’s influence in Allegory: The Theory of a Symbolic Mode (1964).
In the “Second Essay” of Anatomy of Criticism (1957), p. 91, Frye writes:
Within the boundaries of literature we find a kind of sliding scale, ranging from the most explicitly allegorical, consistent with being literature at all, at one extreme, to the most elusive, anti-explicit and anti-allegorical at the other.
Frye’s sliding scale
Position | Character | Examples |
Continuous allegory | Sustained allegorical correspondences. | Bunyan; Spenser. |
Freistimmige (free-style) | Correspondences appear and disappear. | Ariosto; Goethe; Ibsen; Hawthorne. |
Doctrinal poetry | Narrative carries a strong doctrinal purpose. | Milton’s epics. |
Implicit imagery: the center | Images suggest ideas without prescribing correspondences. | Much of Shakespeare. |
Ironic and paradoxical imagery | Images complicate narrative and meaning. | Conceits; symbolisme; objective correlatives; heraldic symbols. |
Increasingly indirect imagery | Private associations, deliberate obscurity, and playful evasion. | Dadaism. |
Related terms
Term | Meaning |
Actual allegory | The writer indicates how images relate to examples or precepts. |
Naïve allegory | Images illustrate ideas. At its extreme, explanation displaces literary invention, as in Frye’s example of the eagle vision in II Esdras. |
Metaphysical conceit | A strained conjunction of disparate things. |
Symbolisme | Images evoke rather than name. |
Objective correlative | An image focuses emotion and substitutes for an idea. |
Heraldic symbol | A central emblem arrests narrative and perplexes meaning: the whale, scarlet letter, golden bowl, or lighthouse. |
Source: Northrop Frye, Anatomy of Criticism, “Second Essay,” pp. 90–92; Angus Fletcher, Allegory, acknowledgments and p. 8.
Evita in Past Master
Evita in Lafferty’s Past Master moves along this scale.
Allegorical forms
Reading | Textual evidence |
Actual allegory Thomas names her Eva/Lilith; she confirms both. Her brother is Adam. The passage dream names Succubus, Eve, Lilith, Judith, Mary, and Valkyrie. | |
Continuous allegory The mulier of Genesis 3:15: sustained enmity with the Devil across the novel. She hunts him, kills him, and eats his brains. The Marian layer is the most continuous allegory in the book. | |
Freistimmige (free-style) Allegory appears and disappears. Evita also argues politics on Replica, carries Devil-meat, breaks a door, and visits Thomas in his cell. | “left-handed eloquence” |
Naïve allegory The hydra hunt resembles a devotional pageant, with chants and ritual combat. Thomas calls it allegory while trying to deny its reality. Father Oddopter insists that the Devil has been killed. | |
Heraldic symbol Her appearance is uncertain and her nature contested; the narrator withholds a fixed description. | |
Ironic and anti-allegorical She ironizes her allegorical roles, shifting from possessed frenzy inside the hydra’s brain to a wink and laughter. | “My seduction of you is a little different from what I planned.” |
Scriptural and mythic identities
Reading | Textual evidence |
Judith typology Evita attacks Foreman; George, Maxwell, and Rimrock join her in killing and dismembering him. She hangs the largest remaining piece on the Judas Tree. The killing recalls Judith and Holofernes. | “Zehheeroot, is-Kerioth” … “Beware, Iscariot.” The carob tree is “sometimes called the Judas Tree.” |
Valkyrie function She helps determine the escape from Electric Mountain, knows the attempt to rescue Thomas will fail, and chooses Foreman as a sacrificial companion for Thomas. | “I am such a primitive. You are such a dog.” |
Succubus / Lilith Depravity marks her first appearance. She declares her intent to seduce a saint and becomes Thomas’s nominal mistress. She fulfills her Marian function through her fallenness. | |
Genesis 3:15 (mulier) Evita and her companions enter through the hydra-devil’s eye and cut into its brain. The destruction of the serpent’s head recalls Genesis 3:15. | “Evita had the head and most of her inside the big eye.” |
Movement along the scale
Evita shifts along the allegorical scale, sometimes within one scene. The deepest allegory, the protoevangelium, is less overt than the pageantry. The passage dream names the figures brought together in her.
“Succubus, Eve, Lilith, Judith, Mary, and Valkyrie.”


