Iron Tongue of Midnight (1975)
Updated: 6 days ago

The iron tongue of midnight hath told twelve; lovers, to bed; 'tis almost fairy time. I fear we shall outsleep the coming morn as much as we this night have overwatch'd. — William Shakespeare, A Midsummer Night’s Dream, 5.1.380–383 (Theseus)
“... the sun really is darkened and the moon really does not give its light. The time has almost all run out. The iron tongue of midnight is already swinging, and soon it will clash and sound. The angular velocity of psychic accumulation is seen to gather to a breaking point after three million years of ... and it breaks...” — R. A. Lafferty, Iron Tongue of Midnight, manuscript p. 61.
Lafferty thought The Elliptical Grave was his least publishable book (and he was right), but there is one close contender, the unpublished half-mad novel Iron Tongue of Midnight. It is one of his hardest novels to follow, even for readers accustomed to his experiments. My theory is that he tried some of its ideas again, in a more accessible form, in East of Laughter (1988).
On a first reading, the clock offers the clearest guide: the novel follows the hours of a single day and night. Its scenes overlap, and their relations become clearer only late in the book.
This post considers how the novel works and two ideas that reach beyond it into Lafferty’s other fiction: the Prime World and the Schauergeschichtenbaum, the problem tree whose seed comes last.
Taking its title from A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Iron Tongue can be read as a world-dream (“these visions did appear,” says Puck), with Lafferty himself in Puck’s role. On Woomago, incompatible perceptions seem about to destroy the world. The closing confessions and calls to repentance bring the distinction between paranoia and metanoia into focus.
Iron Tongue is also a found-document novel. Its outer frame presents the narrative as an alien junior high school student’s investigation of planetary psychosis.
The day’s events lead toward the midnight bell at Pan-Tribal Hall. As the hour approaches, the characters fear that it will announce the end of the world.
The opening storm brings an apparent visitation of the angel of death. Firstborn victims are reported in seven families, recalling the plague of Egypt. These firstborn are often middle-aged or older, and their identities will become part of the murder mystery.
Social disintegration ensues among the groups at the center of the set pieces: the conservative Ornates, the Pentecostal and vile Hot Tongues, the moronic Green Gangers, and the decadent Baronial Poor.
Along the way, self-styled saints darken the sun by thought, prophets preach to mobs of liars, homunculi harvest human tongues for experiments (one of my favorite moments in all of Lafferty). A half-dead patriarch speaks from deep freeze in a scene that feels out of Philip K. Dick; fiction is weaponized as the three Scenarists (writers of reality, like the scribbling giants in East of Laughter) are confronted by their own creation, whose moral collapse is just a plot element to them.
The skylark expeditions take the characters to Venus-Noga, where they fight dragons. At midnight, people from the different factions gather, confess, and call for repentance. The world turns toward a precarious sanity. Jonah has been waiting a long time for another Nineveh:
“I sure have had a run of bad luck since. I haven’t done it since that day a way back then, and it isn’t that I haven’t tried. Now I am an old man remembering past glories. But I will hit again. I will call other great cities to repentance also. Believe me, when a man goes out to it faithfully every morning for more than twenty-five hundred years and works hard at it all the day and most of the night, he is going to hit again.”
It’s a wild novel, Lafferty’s wildest.
So how does it work?
Kolimar’s report describes the antagonistic groups of Woomago. The Ornate Squares are the tradition-bound majority and the source of the other groups’ members.
In opposition to the Ornates are the Hot Tongues, a self-designated spiritual elite; the Baronial Poor, a parasitic class; the Green Gangers, a primitive and violent underclass; and the Unassigneds, who are essentially countercultural, from both the right and the left.
Three local Scenarists write the world’s continuing scenario. How much their writing causes its events remains a question within the novel.
The opening storm leaves seven supposed firstborn victims of what become known as the Egyptian Plague Murders. Later that day, the Hot Tongues announce the end of a three-million-year period and claim that their election requires the destruction of the non-elect. The Ornates must contend with both the murders and the Hot Tongues’ attacks.
Kolimar, the Boy Giant, lectures among the Unassigneds. He announces that everything he says is a lie, then argues that a counterfeit points to a corresponding truth.
Scottsdale Boland seeks vengeance for his brother Wallace. Cletus Shatwell, meanwhile, leaves the Ornates and attempts to raise his father from death after a subjective dart strikes his father. These events draw the family disputes into the larger struggle over reality.
The characters experience double vision: living people appear superimposed on images of their deaths. Their perceptions can alter what happens, but the novel also holds them responsible for the consensuses they choose to inhabit.
Skylarking extends these powers into travel. The Green Gangers are especially good at it, although the accounts of their expeditions can disagree about where they went and what they did.
On Midsummer Night, a mixed group gathers at the park to consult an oracle. Several speakers give incompatible confessions to the murders. Rondelay asks to revise the Wrong Prophet’s explanation before putting it into the previous night’s continuity.
The midnight bell sounds “as for a celebration.” The world survives, reaching a “barely, barely, barely workable level of sanity.”
This summary makes the novel seem far less disorienting than it is. Like The Three Armageddons of Enniscorthy Sweeny (1977) and East of Laughter (1988), it examines consensus reality. Its image of a shattered plate applies to both persons and factions. Following who is speaking, and which group’s account is being offered, helps. The guide below follows the set pieces in order.
Patrick Shatwell’s double vision gives one example of this superimposition:
And also, in a reverse fashion, this ‘double vision phenomenon’ had completely engulfed Patrick Shatwell more than one time that morning, and it still hovered over him, faintly to the eyes of some of them, and with an immediate and horrible intensity to the eyes of others. This doubled or superimposed vision was that of Shatwell himself lying stricken and contorted and dead. The red-eyed and dazed, but living and vital, Shatwell who talked to the others there, was at the same time wrapped in a death cloud of another way of seeing him. This cloud showed Shatwell killed with an iron dart of gigantic size, a dart three meters long and half a meter thick, that went through his chest and body and absolutely destroyed his chest with the very size and power of it. It showed Shatwell surprised by the sudden death but still tortured with the pain that did not cease with the death.
On the social scale, each consensus reality is a consent-based subjective reality, and the factions defend different understandings of reality (the Ornates, Hot Tongues, Green Gangers, and the Baronial Poor), while some, the “unassigneds,” remain outside any camp, having themselves come out of the Ornates’ “potting shed”.
An example of the social dimension of this projected reality business can be seen in the following passage, which depicts a massive Ornate car crash created by the Hot Tongues, who are using a small set of Ornates as sacrificial lambs:
“Nor did everyone notice it now. In the streets of the city, about a third of the automobile lights came on, and the rest of them did not. Two-thirds of the drivers did not know that it had gotten dark, that they were driving in the darkness, for it had not gotten dark to them. This was something that the Hot Tongues themselves did not know. They had decreed darkness, and they had seen the darkness come. It was below their comprehension that there might be people so gross and blind that they could not see this imposed darkness when it came.”
Each group treats its own perception as authoritative, even when another group sees the same event differently.
Savant Ben challenges these competing claims late in the novel. His speech offers a way to read what has preceded it. A former scientist, he refused the government’s demand that science submit to astrology, including a requirement to cast horoscopes free for the poor.
In a secret meeting of fellow outcasts, Ben lays out what I take to be the book's central thesis: that Prime matters. He describes a universe of multiple "Woomago-type worlds," subjective realities that can be entered and experienced, but he says they are all measured against a single, foundational "Prime World." As he puts it, “On the flesh-reality of the world. On the incarnational reality. It’s the only one: for reality is singular.”
Ben compares these choices to wagers on horses. He urges his listeners to bet on incarnational reality, even while they share a room with people who inhabit different consensus realities:
“Ragland itself is stuffed with the shirts of those who lost them in thinking that it didn’t matter what color of horse they bet on. Do not bet on the bay horses, or the grays, or the tans, or the reds, friends. Bet only on the black horses to win, and then the only way your horse can lose is to another black horse. Ideational ragland is stuffed with the shirts of those who lost them in thinking that it didn’t matter what sort of reality they bet on. Do not bet on the existential reality, or on the phenomenal reality, friends. Do not bet on process reality, or on situational reality. Do not bet on pragmatic reality, nor on hypostatic reality. Do not bet on empirical or axial or dialectic or naturalistic or positival or ontological or autonomous reality. Those horses won’t run!”
Ben’s speech gives me my bearings in the novel.
I read the madness chiefly as a flight from incarnational reality into self-enclosed subjective worlds. Yet Lafferty also values imaginative powers. The question is how they remain answerable to the flesh-and-blood world, rather than becoming an escape from its demands.
Savant Ben comes late in the book, so it takes the reader a long while to reach the philosophical bedrock. This is typical of Lafferty’s novels, where fog becomes glass late when the narrative is tied off. His short stories work this way, but the novels lose readers. To know Lafferty’s novels, one should reread their last quarters.
Earlier scenes change on rereading: the skylarks, the conflicting accounts of the murders, and the Scenarists’ revisions can be considered in light of Ben’s distinction between Prime and the other worlds.
At a minimum, the main threads to follow are the following (a diagram at the end of this post suggests one possible way to do so):
a. The Alien Boy Giant's Notes
Kolimar calls his notes “An Entertainment”; his professor refuses the subtitle. I take their disagreement as a reading tip. The comedy belongs to the investigation, even if the professor cannot see its use.
b. A Post-Electronic Earth Gone Mad
Andrew Ferguson has described the novel in the following way:
Iron Tongue of Midnight (6/27/75) — Offworld novel, styled an “exercise in alien psychology.” Densely packed with symbolism, thoroughly metafictional, apocalyptic, mystic, and visionary. An investigation into other possible worlds that, like the best Lafferty tales, spills over into those worlds and into our own.
I don't interpret the novel as an inquiry into other possible worlds, except in the broadest sense that all narratives about the future are modal fictions, as, indeed, are all fictional representations of the past. I read Woomago as Earth under altered conditions. But the novel leaves the physical status of skylarking unsettled: Savant Ben argues that even its immaterial journeys may be physical.
The alien-psychology frame also makes a joke about self-alienation. I read these post-Electronic humans as people who have become strange to themselves. Krangdangula and Kolimar may be the book’s only visitors from elsewhere, though Kolimar’s lost coordinates leave the world’s identity unconfirmed.
Although there are alien-sounding words such as Woomago (again, a code name) and Venus-Noga, the setting strongly suggests a future or alternate Earth. The prophet Jonah appears and asserts his ties to our Earth's history. There are references to our Fall of Rome and to our Ireland, specifically Lafferty’s Knockmealdown Mountains known from Ishmael Into the Barrens, as well as to London, Illyria, Athens, the Atlantic Ocean, Covent Garden, Granada, and the Alpujarra range.
The Earth references matter to my reading of Jonah. His renewed preaching recalls Nineveh: the threatened destruction gives way to repentance, and the world survives, barely.
1 But it displeased Jonah exceedingly, and he was very angry. 2 And he prayed unto the Lord, and said, I pray thee, O Lord, was not this my saying, when I was yet in my country? Therefore I fled before unto Tarshish: for I knew that thou art a gracious God, and merciful, slow to anger, and of great kindness, and repentest thee of the evil. 3 Therefore now, O Lord, take, I beseech thee, my life from me; for it is better for me to die than to live. 4 Then said the Lord, Doest thou well to be angry?
As Jonah in the novel says,
“Now this was not the Tharsis that had been in Cilicia in more ancient times than mine. It was the colony Tharsis (in some places of Scripture it is called Tarshish) which is in Atlantic Spain. It was in the Atlantic that I was thrown into the sea, and the fish that swallowed me was a Right Whale which is sometimes called the Jonah Whale.”
The post-Electronic setting complicates the Earth references. “Projective cerebralism” has replaced electronic scatter-casting, allowing individuals and groups to inhabit their own subjective worlds. I read Iron Tongue alongside Not to Mention Camels (1976) as another account of the responsibilities owed to incarnational Prime.
c. The Madness of a Single Day
The main action runs from one midnight to the next, ending on Midsummer Night. The frame proposes a psychotic cloud as one possible cause of the crisis, but the professor cannot establish either its cause or its cure. The novel also gives the madness a history extending back to the congresses of the 1990s.
d. An Ethnography of Competing Factions
The planetary psychosis is embodied by the world's factions, each representing a different consensus reality:
The Ornates: These are the conservative, stuffy, and unimaginative majority who value family, tradition, and brick-and-mortar stability. They are the biological base from which all other, more progressive, groups defect.
The Hot Tongues: Spiritually insane fanatics who believe themselves to be vessels of pure spirit and wield immense subjective power, capable of killing with subjective darts and altering perception. They’re one of Lafferty’s most savage depictions of extreme Protestantism.
The Baronial Poor: An opulent class that has transformed poverty into a powerful, parasitic aesthetic of aggressive consumption. They are part of Lafferty’s satire of extreme distinctions in spiritual and material poverty, most memorably (to me at least) set out in “Calamities of the Last Pauper” (1982).
The Green Gangers: Primal, violent, and intellectually stunted, yet paradoxically the masters of "skylarking," a form of subjective space travel via daydreaming. The dragon fighting on Venus-Noga is one of the strangest pieces of writing in Lafferty. A Lafferty chrestomathy would include it.
The Unassigneds: A group of dropouts and individualists who exist between the other factions, standing at the crossroads of one million signposts. In many ways, they are the most sympathetic characters in the book, as one would expect. But most of them are profoundly flawed.
e. The Egyptian Plague Murders
The Egyptian Plague Murders drive Scottsdale Boland’s search for vengeance. His pursuit of Lemuel Bang becomes a pursuit of his own divided identity, according to Catherine and the Wrong Prophet. Lemuel is demonic, but also pitiable.
Scottsdale wants a murderer to punish. The Scenarists tell him that a murder can be written before its murderer has been devised. Their account makes his search more uncertain without removing the question of his responsibility.
f. The Metanovel and the Scenarists
Harry Halfstopper, Rondelay Silbermann, and Sean McDonald write the local continuity. They can propose changes to events and even to the past, though the novel repeatedly questions the extent of their control.
Sean suggests undoing the murders. Later, Rondelay wants to work over the Wrong Prophet’s account before back-setting it into the previous night. Even the apparent explanation remains subject to revision:
"Just a minute," Rondelay Silbermann cut in. "That was all pretty rough. Will you let me work it over a little bit before we back-set it into the continuity of last night?" "You go ahead, lady," the wrong Prophet said. "You will know how to fix things up. Next question please."
g. A Series of "Busted" Set Pieces
Rondelay’s sleepwriting offers an explanation for the book’s “busted episodes.” She has no memory of writing them and wants to discard them, but cannot be sure that anything can be removed from the world’s scenario:
"What dangerous things are you writing in your sleep, Rondelay?" Sean McDonald asked her. "It has to do with the world named Woomago, possibly, and I think so. It isn’t one of those recurring dreams, for I no longer dream, and I have no memory of my sleep writing. And I notice that Woomago is entering the common vocabulary as a sometimes derisive and sometimes humorous name for world, so I guess that some of my impressions and night-writings are slopping over into the popular consciousness. These Woomago incidents are unreal excursions and they happen to someone else, but I chronicle them. It is a series of recurring busted episodes is what it is, and I have to discard them. But who can really discard anything from the world scenario? Oh, busted, busted, though!"
h. The Prophet Jonah and the Mercy of God
Jonah carries his sign, “Repent! Repent!” I read his call to metanoia alongside Savant Ben’s defense of incarnational reality. Together they suggest a return to obligations that the factions’ private worlds have allowed them to evade.
Rondelay’s Schauergeschichtenbaum gives a model of storytelling in which the question must grow before its answer can appear:
“Let me tell you about the tree whose seed appears the last thing of all,” Rondelay said. “This tree is named the Schauergeschichtenbaum. It is a conifer that grows only in Transylvania. This tree begins to grow from its great fork which will be about ten meters above the ground. It grows down from there and it grows up from there, and finally it will reach a great height up in the air, and finally it will reach all the way down to the ground and will enter even into the ground. Finally, when it is nine-score years old, it will have reached its greatest height above the Earth and its greatest depth within the Earth. Then it will produce its original seed, on the deepest tendril of the deepest root. And that is the end of the tree. It dies immediately, at its age of one hundred and eighty years. This is the Problem tree; and its solution, which is the seed, comes last. And that’s a common enough configuration among the murder mysteries. One cannot have answers until the question has grown to its extent.”
I take the problem tree as a guide to Iron Tongue. The murders occur before the novel supplies their possible explanations. Those explanations grow out of the consequences, but the final confessions still disagree.
The planetary psychosis likewise spreads through the factions before the closing turn toward sanity. The frame prevents us from treating that turn as a fully explained cure.
Scottsdale’s divided identity is another problem introduced before its explanation. Catherine’s account of the false face and the Wrong Prophet’s account of the killing give different approaches to it.
The delayed passage from Crickets to Meadow Larks joins these late resolutions. Rose-Revel announces it as the bell rings, connecting the day’s end with a change in the world’s condition.
For me, the problem tree belongs beside the ghost story as an image of Lafferty’s method. A work’s earlier parts acquire new meanings as it grows. I would extend that reading to the relations among his books, without supposing that he planned their full shape from the beginning.
The tree begins between heaven and earth, growing upward and downward until it takes root. That double movement gives me another way to think about Lafferty’s fiction and its relation to Prime.




Bibliographical Note
Lafferty’s work-history card records completion on June 27, 1975, and submission to Virginia Kidd the same day. It gives the manuscript’s length as 189 pages and approximately 60,000 words.
Unpublished.
Sources: R. A. Lafferty, work-history card for “Iron Tongue of Midnight,” R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


