top of page
Search

“Goldfish” (1960/1996)

Oct 26, 2025
9 min read

Updated: 22 hours ago

Three goldfish varieties with anatomical details on plate XCIV of Marcus Elieser Bloch’s natural history of German fishes.
Goldfish varieties, plate XCIV in Marcus Elieser Bloch’s Oeconomische Naturgeschichte der Fische Deutschlands. Drawn by Krüger the younger and engraved by Bodenehr.¹

And once more it was like a high dive that Leo was afraid to take, like a leap across an abyss — but he must get it off to however unlikely a goal was left him. So he achieved separation. Then Fang struck and broke the body of Cuthbert in half, and there was no life left in it at all.² —“Goldfish”

“His brain is now emitting impulses in the delta pattern. . . . Tisman is sending, he’s probing, he’s getting ready for a leap. He’s gauging the footholds and handholds on the other side before he makes the grand jump out over the chasm.”³ —Not to Mention Camels (1976)

Andrew Ferguson reads “Goldfish” first as a mind-transfer story written in 1960, then in light of Lafferty’s illness by the time it appeared in 1996. In that later reading, what moves him is Leo’s struggle to get a message out of the bowl.⁴ The question here is what changed when the story became a poem. On November 27, 1993, Lafferty wrote to his publisher Dan Knight, “As to the story ‘Goldfish’ it was very short and very slight, and I finally turned it into verse.”⁵


The story “Goldfish” tells is simple. Its most intriguing element, perhaps, lies in how a scientist’s effort to survive his own murder pushes him lower on the chain of being. The murder of the goldfish by the brutal Fang is memorably succinct and gory.


Our main character is Leo Skatterly. His extraordinary predicament begins with a dim awareness. Lafferty opens, “He didn’t know how long he had been a goldfish. Probably not long.” Leo, the world’s greatest scientist in his own opinion and that of four to six others, now inhabits the body of Cuthbert, a goldfish he had named himself in a moment of cuteness. Lafferty has some fun with the bogusly scholastic, telling the reader that Leo is “only goldfish per eventa and not per essentia.”⁶


In his pre-goldfish life, Leo had been trying to prove that thought is a detachable thing, something that could exist apart from the body. According to his wife, his obsessive work on the subject led him to neglect her.⁷


Lafferty imagines an absurdist thriller told through a flashback that reveals what happened to Leo. His fat assistant, Gorden Gaster, confronts him one day, revealing that he and Mathilde have been conspiring. Gorden has mined Leo’s research for profit and cuckolded him. He says, “We have decided that there is no point in your living another hour. We believe that life bores you.”⁸


Faced with a loaded gun, Leo’s detachment starts to evaporate. “Where is your detachment?” Gorden says. “Buried under my terror,” Leo says. Begging for ten seconds for one last experiment with death itself, Leo separates from his body before Gorden fires the shot. Leo then achieves identity transference, making “a leap across an abyss” into the fishbowl.⁹


Here, Leo starts to recognize some limits. He experiences “frustration in having the finest mind in the world and not being able to implement it.” His powerlessness is amplified as he watches Mathilde discover his body. He thinks she may be humming “You Rascal You” over his corpse, though he admits he has no ear for music. She ruffles her hair with a studied carelessness and belts out a scream for effect. Convinced he must reveal his survival, Leo abandons a long-winded explanation and decides to spell his name with the thirteen pebbles in his bowl. After a night spent nosing the stones into place, he finishes his crude LEO by the early light.¹⁰


His message backfires. When Gorden and Mathilde return to the room, Leo tries to scatter the pebbles. Gwendoline rolls them back into place as fast as he scrambles them. Gorden comes to the bowl and sees the name. “Ah, Leo,” he says softly. “There you are.” Recognizing that a spelling goldfish is dangerous, Gorden decides to eliminate Leo. He tells him about his pet Fang, who is part Burmese fighting fish. Gorden mocks Leo one last time: “We will see what taking thought will do for you now. Cheers.”¹¹


Gorden brings Fang back in an ice cream box and pours him into the bowl. Fang waits until the humans have left before he attacks. As Fang tears at Cuthbert’s body (Cuthbert himself is dormant in a corner of his own brain), Leo makes a desperate, last-second transference. Lafferty writes,


Imagine a shark four inches long if you are only three inches. Imagine a lightning-killer and you in a goldfish bowl with him and no escape. Gorden had given Leo ten seconds (less two) before he killed him. How do you ask a killer fish to give you ten seconds? How do you practice detachment under the circumstances? And where in the room was there another living creature to which Leo could transfer? Yet it had to be done. Leo-Cuthbert achieved a detachment of a sort while certain slices of his underbelly were detached from himself. And he almost achieved separation, as lengths of viscera were separated from himself. Then the introductions were over, and Fang came in for the kill; there was no doubt of it.¹²

Poor Cuthbert! Leo, though, leaps, foreshadowing the plot that would become Lafferty’s Not to Mention Camels. The story ends as it began. A slow, dawning consciousness. A new and fragile form. Leo is now a fly, clinging to a curtain.¹³


Lafferty later took apart the story and turned it into light verse. It went from being a comically tense, science-fiction-y thriller about a murderous conspiracy into a whimsical, darkly comic fable called “All in the Boundless Ocean.”¹⁴ Lafferty scraps the murder plot. Gorden is gone, and Roy’s wife has a different part to play.


The ambitious, manipulative female goldfish gets quite the promotion. In the story, Gwen puts the pebbles back in place and gives Leo away. In the poem, she gets the two of them out of the bowl by putting it into Roy’s wife’s head to flush them.¹⁵


The domestic struggle gives way to a man willing to leave his fate to a fish. Leo in the story becomes Roy (both names with royal associations), but Roy, unlike Leo, is ready to roll with it.¹⁶


More interesting to me is what comes of Leo’s second jump. Leo prefigures the ontological slide we find in Not to Mention Camels, because Leo eventually becomes an insect (per eventa). It is as if a metafictional identity transfer took place. One part of the short story “Goldfish” was transferred to the poem, and the other part, the jumping to avoid death, to the novel. Ontological descent just isn’t very relevant to the finished poem with the exigency of death removed.


On the other hand, the descent angle matters for understanding the protagonist of Camels and his noetic darkening. Cyrus Evenhand says of Pilgrim Dusmano, “I believe he is a giant insect in the form of a man, one veined with green scum and inelegant instincts. Ah, I’d like to know what color blood that fellow bleeds.”¹⁷ And there is more insect imagery associated with the character. In both the short story and the novel, we get a related idea: that the death jump is really a fall, akin to what happens in “Fog in My Throat,” with its own ironic take on noetic darkening.¹⁸


“A long-term fly isn’t afraid of falling, and does not cling in terror to the mesh of a curtain.”¹⁹

“All in the Boundless Ocean,” with the illustration “A Goldfish” from Paul Bert’s Primer of Scientific Knowledge.²⁰

Character map connecting Leo Skatterly’s transferred mind with the fish and the conspirators in Goldfish.
Leo, the other occupants of the bowl, and the two conspirators.²¹
Numbered plot outline of Goldfish, tracing Leo’s murder, transfer to a fish, and escape into a fly.
Leo’s two transfers, from his laboratory to the fishbowl and from the bowl to the curtain.²²
Funnel diagram showing how Goldfish’s complex plot is condensed into All in the Boundless Ocean.
From “Goldfish” to “All in the Boundless Ocean.”²³
Table mapping Goldfish’s characters to merged or transformed roles in All in the Boundless Ocean.
The parts played by the scientist, his wife, and the goldfish in prose and verse.²⁴
Table comparing the genre, conflict, and tone of Goldfish and All in the Boundless Ocean.
How the tone changes when the murder plot drops out.²⁵
Circular diagram of Leo’s recurring awareness, memory, attempted action, danger, and mind transfer.
Leo’s dawning awareness in the bowl and on the curtain.²⁶
Character motivation map linking Leo Skatterly with the conspiracy between Gorden Gaster and Mathilde.
What Leo, Gorden, and Mathilde stand to gain or lose.²⁷
Table contrasting Leo’s ideal of mental freedom with the limitations of bodily existence.
What Leo can think and what he can do from the bowl.²⁸
Table tracing Leo’s successive human, goldfish, and fly embodiments, environments, abilities, and antagonists.
Three bodies in succession: scientist, goldfish, and fly.²⁹



Bibliographical Note


Lafferty’s work card records completion on January 23, 1960, followed by extensive circulation. He entered a sale to Marvel Comics on April 3, 1973, for $110 less 10 percent.³⁰ Four days later he told Sheryl Smith that The Haunt of Horror had the story. A later entry marks it “unsold again” on the evidence of a February 6, 1976, letter from Virginia Kidd.³¹


The August 1973 issue of The Haunt of Horror announced “Goldfish” for October. The magazine ceased publication after the August issue.³² “Goldfish” first appeared in Crank!, no. 7 (summer 1996), pages 68–75.³³


Notes


1. Marcus Elieser Bloch, Oeconomische Naturgeschichte der Fische Deutschlands, part 3 (Berlin, 1784), 132, plates XCIII–XCIV. Plate XCIV, “Der Goldkarpfen,” is signed by Krüger the younger as draughtsman and Bodenehr as engraver. Back to text


2. R. A. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” Crank!, no. 7 (summer 1996): 75. Back to text


3. R. A. Lafferty, Not to Mention Camels (Gollancz, 2016), chap. 1, paragraph beginning “It never happens that way, Salvatore.” The coroner is speaking to the brigadier of police about the dying Pilger Tisman. The novel first appeared in 1976. Back to text


4. Andrew Ferguson, “52. Goldfish,” Continued on Next Rock, August 1, 2013, paragraphs beginning “Read in 1960,” “However, by the time it was published,” and “Regardless.” Back to text


5. R. A. Lafferty to Dan Knight, November 27, 1993, p. 1, my research files, paragraph beginning “As to the story.” Lafferty identifies the poem and the booklet in the next sentence, then quotes a stanza. Back to text


6. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 68–69. Back to text








13. 75. Lafferty, Not to Mention Camels, chaps. 1–2. In the first chapter Doctor Funk describes how would-be world-jumpers experience death. The second chapter takes up the life of Pilgrim Dusmano. Back to text


14. R. A. Lafferty, “All in the Boundless Ocean,” in Laughing Kelly and Other Verses, Drumm Booklet 11 (Chris Drumm, 1983), the fifth poem, unpaginated. Chris Merrick, The R. A. Lafferty Glossary, version 2.0 (September 2024), s.v. “Goldfish,” connects the story with the poem. For my account of the escape, see “Laughing Kelly (1983),” Arrive at Easterwine, October 7, 2025. Back to text


15. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 73–74. Lafferty, “All in the Boundless Ocean,” the fish mate’s suggestion to Roy’s wife and the escape down the drain. Back to text


16. The prospect of life in the ocean. Lafferty quotes the stanza beginning “But we’ll have every arrant wish” in his letter to Knight, November 27, 1993, p. 1. Back to text


17. Lafferty, Not to Mention Camels, chap. 2. The next paragraph identifies the speaker as Cyrus Evenhand. Back to text


18. For my reading of the doctor’s last experiment, see Jon Nelson, “Fog in My Throat” (1974/1976), Arrive at Easterwine, October 25, 2025. Back to text


19. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 75. Back to text


20. Lafferty, “All in the Boundless Ocean,” the fifth poem, unpaginated. For the still image, see Paul Bert, Primer of Scientific Knowledge, trans. and adapted by T. W. Gilson (J. B. Lippincott, 1888), 85, fig. 127. Back to text


21. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 68–75. Back to text



23. 68–75. Lafferty, “All in the Boundless Ocean,” the fifth poem, unpaginated. Back to text


24. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 73–74. Lafferty, “All in the Boundless Ocean,” the fish mate’s plan to have Roy’s wife flush the bowl. Back to text


25. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 68–75. Lafferty, “All in the Boundless Ocean,” the fifth poem, unpaginated. Back to text


26. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 68–69 and 75. Back to text





30. R. A. Lafferty, work card, “Goldfish,” series 2, box 25, R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa. Tulsa also holds an undated twelve-page carbon typescript, series 2, box 10, folder 5. Back to text


31. R. A. Lafferty to Sheryl Smith, April 7, 1973, p. 2, my research files. For the later change in status, see Lafferty, work card, “Goldfish.” Back to text


32. “In the Wind,” The Haunt of Horror 1, no. 2 (August 1973), 94. The notice names Lafferty and the story. For the digest’s two-issue run, see “Haunt of Horror, The,” The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction. Back to text


33. Lafferty, “Goldfish,” 68–75. Tulsa also lists “Goldfish” among the contents of Lafferty’s Six Fingers of Time collection typescript, series 2, box 22, folder 9. Back to text


Bibliography


Bert, Paul. Primer of Scientific Knowledge. Translated and adapted by T. W. Gilson. J. B. Lippincott, 1888.


Bloch, Marcus Elieser. Oeconomische Naturgeschichte der Fische Deutschlands. Part 3. Berlin, 1784. Plate XCIV.


Ferguson, Andrew. “52. Goldfish.” Continued on Next Rock, August 1, 2013.


“Haunt of Horror, The.” The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction.


“In the Wind.” The Haunt of Horror 1, no. 2 (August 1973): 94.


Lafferty, R. A. “All in the Boundless Ocean.” In Laughing Kelly and Other Verses. Drumm Booklet 11. Chris Drumm, 1983. Unpaginated.


Lafferty, R. A. “Goldfish.” Crank!, no. 7 (summer 1996): 68–75.


Lafferty, R. A. “Goldfish.” Undated carbon typescript, 12 pp. Series 2, box 10, folder 5. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. Letter to Dan Knight. November 27, 1993. My research files.


Lafferty, R. A. Letter to Sheryl Smith. April 7, 1973. My research files.


Lafferty, R. A. Not to Mention Camels. Gollancz, 2016. E-book.


Lafferty, R. A. Six Fingers of Time. Collection typescript. Series 2, box 22, folder 9. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Lafferty, R. A. Work card, “Goldfish.” Series 2, box 25. R. A. Lafferty papers, 1979-002, Department of Special Collections and University Archives, McFarlin Library, University of Tulsa.


Merrick, Chris. The R. A. Lafferty Glossary. Unpublished typescript, version 2.0, September 2024.


Nelson, Jon. “Fog in My Throat” (1974/1976). Arrive at Easterwine, October 25, 2025.


Nelson, Jon. “Laughing Kelly (1983).” Arrive at Easterwine, October 7, 2025.

bottom of page